does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Heat flows from hot to cold and the WAI steel temperatures require very high gas temperatures to be maintained during the heat transfer. The other problem is thermal conductivity, which is quite low for the fire insulation, so the high temperature heat will not have the time needed to transfer through to the steel. This is why steel fire insulation is rated in hours. They know the fire will cool down significantly before the high temperature gas can transfer its heat sufficiently to the steel.

If the gas temperature goes down to 600 C and the steel was at 700 C guess what would be happening? The heat would be transferring from the steel to the gas. In other words, the steel would be cooling.

The WAI steel temperatures could only be achieved in a closed furnace with an excessive amount of fuel and no fire insulation on the steel.

The gas temperatures are irrelevant Tony.

Carbon black can oxidize at 1400C if in direct contact with 600C steel in the presence of oxygen.

Carbon black is an easily transportable fuel in fire, it only needs oxygen and an ignition sourse.
 
The gas temperatures are irrelevant Tony.

Carbon black can oxidize at 1400C if in direct contact with 600C steel in the presence of oxygen.

Carbon black is an easily transportable fuel in fire, it only needs oxygen and an ignition sourse.

I would suggest it is your ability to understand what could and couldn't have happened that is irrelevant.
 
YAY. I got mail from Tony.

BOO. It has no content.

I sent you the files in reply to your e-mail, even though I posted them on the 911 free forum and gave everyone here (including you) the links before e-mailing you.

In the first e-mail I sent you I asked what "type" engineer you are and you didn't tell me in your reply. You said you mentioned it here, but I looked at all of your posts on this thread and nowhere do you say what “type” of engineer you are. Are you holding that back for some reason or did you actually think you provided that information?

The files on the 911 free forum are downloadable pdfs, so that would be no different than getting them by e-mail. You sound like you just want to complain whether there is a reason to or not. Is that your normal disposition?
 
Last edited:
Why is it appropriate to model fires as if they only appear magically at maximum intensity for 25 min and then suddenly disappear? Can you cite a single other serious engineer who has used that approach except for Korol? Korol himself does not cite anyone who does. None of the NIST authors used that approach, nor did ARUP, nor did Bailey, nor did Mohwer, nor did Beyler. The Cardington study that you cited as an authority does not at all support that approach, and nor do the actual model fire studies of wtc 1 & 2 floors and cubicles.

So why are you citing it as if it even deserves consideration? Whether or not Beyler's approach is the best one, the alternative you are suggesting is garbage.

Remember heat transfers from hot to cold, so the only time that should be considered is when the object transferring the heat to another object is actually hotter than it.

How many minutes are the Cardington gas temperatures above the temperature that the WAI report claims the steel on floors 9 and 10 got to?
 
Last edited:
I would suggest it is your ability to understand what could and couldn't have happened that is irrelevant.

Oh really http://www.uicinc.com/review-of-combustion-coulometric-co2-detection-method/

They use that method in the Lab, every day.

There are about a thousand links on the combustion of carbon on heated metal surfaces, would you like for me to post all of them?

Any surface over 600C can ignite carbon which can burn at up to 1400C in air.

I even discovered Tony that free carbon would ignite during the collapses do to increased oxidation induced by air compression, during the collapse.

Since combusting carbon produces no viewable flame in sunlight, that might not have been observed.
 
Oh really http://www.uicinc.com/review-of-combustion-coulometric-co2-detection-method/

They use that method in the Lab, every day.

There are about a thousand links on the combustion of carbon on heated metal surfaces, would you like for me to post all of them?

Any surface over 600C can ignite carbon which can burn at up to 1400C in air.

I even discovered Tony that free carbon would ignite during the collapses do to increased oxidation induced by air compression, during the collapse.

Since combusting carbon produces no viewable flame in sunlight, that might not have been observed.

I don't think I have ever seen anyone come up with as many tortured explanations as you seem capable of. Of course, the probability of their actual occurrence is near zero, but that doesn't seem to matter to you. You just keep pumping out different scenarios as though repeating an actual probable situation is what you want to stay away from.
 
I sent you the files in reply to your e-mail, even though I posted them on the 911 free forum and gave everyone here (including you) the links before e-mailing you.

In the first e-mail I sent you I asked what "type" engineer you are and you didn't tell me in your reply. You said you mentioned it here, but I looked at all of your posts on this thread and nowhere do you say what “type” of engineer you are. Are you holding that back for some reason or did you actually think you provided that information?

The files on the 911 free forum are downloadable pdfs, so that would be no different than getting them by e-mail. You sound like you just want to complain whether there is a reason to or not. Is that your normal disposition?
Post 886

Sloppy. Very sloppy.
 
I don't think I have ever seen anyone come up with as many tortured explanations as you seem capable of. Of course, the probability of their actual occurrence is near zero, but that doesn't seem to matter to you. You just keep pumping out different scenarios as though repeating an actual probable situation is what you want to stay away from.

It can be experimentally proven Tony, if you or any of the others At AE/911 Truth could actually do a credible experiment that was not designed to fail.
I can heat a piece of steel to 600C with a torch and directly oxidize carbon black on it's surface!
The governing facter is Oxidation!
Your Ideas like many truther Ideas are way to oversimplified!
 
It can be experimentally proven Tony, if you or any of the others At AE/911 Truth could actually do a credible experiment that was not designed to fail.
I can heat a piece of steel to 600C with a torch and directly oxidize carbon black on it's surface!
The governing facter is Oxidation!
Your Ideas like many truther Ideas are way to oversimplified!

And your ideas don't even make sense.
 
And your ideas don't even make sense.

Seeing they are experimentally proven in experiments going back to before the writing of the US constitution even, and founding of the Roman Empire,

Do you think you could be wrong?

Your talking stuff that has been known since copper was first smelted, when will your engineering knowledge progress to be able to Accurately comment on bronze age technology?:D

You are talking about knowledge discovered in pre BC, Greece and Ancient China.:rolleyes:

I would post some of the scientific studies but given Tony's level of Technology this is probably more appropriate.

http://cavemanchemistry.com/oldcave/projects/smelt/index.html
 
Last edited:
Omg omg omg it's Tony Szamboti!

Edited by Agatha: 
Do not alter usernames to insult. Also removed breach of rule 12. Please review your Membership Agreement to which you agreed on joining the site.

Are you still focused on building 7 column 49 or wat?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Seeing they are experimentally proven in experiments going back to before the writing of the US constitution even, and founding of the Roman Empire,

Do you think you could be wrong?

Your talking stuff that has been known since copper was first smelted, when will your engineering knowledge progress to be able to Accurately comment on bronze age technology?:D

You are talking about knowledge discovered in pre BC, Greece and Ancient China.:rolleyes:

I would post some of the scientific studies but given Tony's level of Technology this is probably more appropriate.

http://cavemanchemistry.com/oldcave/projects/smelt/index.html

Edited by Agatha: 
Removed breach of rule 12
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Omg omg omg it's Tony Szamboti!

Edited by Agatha: 
Removed previously moderated content


Are you still focused on building 7 column 49 or wat?

It is column 79 there
Edited by Agatha: 
Removed breach of rule 12
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Every single comprehensive report promoting structural failure of WTC 7 promotes a sudden onset of collapse.

Meanwhile, demolition theorists have been saying for years that WTC 7 may have been gradually weakened before the final collapse event, using witnesses and recordings of loud explosions from the area as evidence.

I don't know why the building moved a little 90 seconds or 6 seconds before the East Penthouse fell. Why don't you explain it? Either you admit all of the mainstream materials are incomplete or you are forced to say that was a coincidence not related to the actual collapse.
There are a number of possible causes. To me, the most likely cause is the pushing of a column. That's exactly what the NIST report says happened.

It might be also a partial internal collapse of some floors causing some rocking in the building. Like the WAI report says happened.

Again, it's not like that movement can't be reconciled with the existing reports.

Got any video showing the loud bangs that pre-weakened the structure the way you say, while that movement was happening?
 
Wow, putting noahfence, abaddon, open, and crazy chainsaw on ignore makes the forum readable for now.

I am sure there are more nastys out there who will have to be added.

Good then We can all laugh at you, I may have evidence on a new scientific study done by a real scientist that you don't have any knowledge of.

I can't wait now till the results are in, from it.

Please when the results are in no one tell Tony, he doesn't need to know!
 
Last edited:
Does everyone here believe that lances were used to cut columns during clean up?
I can show you pictures of columns standing and then cut, if you wish.

What tool do you suggest they used for doing that, other than a thermal lance?
 
Most people would understand why I generally don't feel a need to answer nincompoop questions like "how many planes crashed on 911?" or nincompoop comments like "if you can't give a complete alternative scenario you can't criticize the official story".
Well, you can, but not without looking like a fool.

See, refuting every current and future report on WTC7 wouldn't get you any closer to refuting the whereabouts of the 19 hijackers, the fact that they hijacked the planes and crashed them against three buildings and a field, that some of them received pilot training, that they were filmed at the airport and photographed at an ATM, that there are passenger manifests provided by the private airlines that include all 19, that they left behind a car with some clues in it that pointed to them, that there's a CVR recording with the voices of the hijackers of flight 93, and so on and on and on.
 
There are a number of possible causes. To me, the most likely cause is the pushing of a column. That's exactly what the NIST report says happened.

It might be also a partial internal collapse of some floors causing some rocking in the building. Like the WAI report says happened.

Again, it's not like that movement can't be reconciled with the existing reports.

Got any video showing the loud bangs that pre-weakened the structure the way you say, while that movement was happening?

Tony's FEA has a fatal flaw it relies on bolt shear without tearing of the Seat or girder,
Tony has in fact contradicted earlier statements he made to present an FEA that shows his incompetence!
 
Remember heat transfers from hot to cold, so the only time that should be considered is when the object transferring the heat to another object is actually hotter than it.

How many minutes are the Cardington gas temperatures above the temperature that the WAI report claims the steel on floors 9 and 10 got to?

Tony, thay doesn't address the question. To properly model the heat transfer, the environment needs to be modeled to what it actually is as closely as possible, in the meantime you let the heat transfer equations do the work of determining the amount of heat applied. The transfer will appropriately apply the flow, into the affected metal frame or out as the case may be.

You don't properly model the heat applied to an object in a kiln by having the heat in the kiln appear as a step function, sometimes 0, sometimes 1.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom