does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

How long did the fires in the Cardington study heat given elements in that structure, Tony? Was it for 25 min?

If you look at the Cardington atmosphere data you will notice that peak gas temperatures above 900 degrees C only lasted for about 22 to 25 minutes. Could it be Dr. Korol and his colleagues know something you don't?
 
Last edited:
As a mechanical engineer I was schooled in heat transfer and thermodynamics as well as strength of materials, stress analysis, and mechanics in general.

I have done a significant amount of both structural and thermal design and analysis in my career.

Did you read the article published by Dr. Robert Korol et al on what the likely temperatures were that WTC 7 steel in fire affected areas would have reached? They are far below what the WAI report claims.

The article is titled Performance-based fire protection of office buildings: A case study based on the collapse of WTC 7 and can be found on-line.

I too had heat transfer and thermodynamics courses in my physics course. I transfered to college and got a diploma that would get me a job, electronic technology, which again had courses in physics. I would not be so bold however, as to compare my ability in this area to that of a renowned expert in fire sciences.
Do you believe that your abilities in fire sciences is enough for you to challenge Beyler's paper even though you have never seen it and never even tried to obtain it?
Do you believe you would be taken seriously enough to be granted the full paper?
AND AGAIN...
Is there a fire sciences engineer within the ranks of those 2000+ in AE911T?
 
I too had heat transfer and thermodynamics courses in my physics course. I transfered to college and got a diploma that would get me a job, electronic technology, which again had courses in physics. I would not be so bold however, as to compare my ability in this area to that of a renowned expert in fire sciences.
Do you believe that your abilities in fire sciences is enough for you to challenge Beyler's paper even though you have never seen it and never even tried to obtain it?
Do you believe you would be taken seriously enough to be granted the full paper?
AND AGAIN...
Is there a fire sciences engineer within the ranks of those 2000+ in AE911T?

I would have to say your training within physics courses is probably not as rigorous as full courses on specific topics like those given in a mechanical engineering curriculum.

It isn't a hard thing to see that the extreme steel temperature claims in the WAI report are not possible. You can see that would also be the conclusion from the discussion in the paper by Dr. Korol et al.

If I said the grass in front of your house got to 500 degrees C due to sunlight would it be hard to say that is nonsense? That is about the same level we are dealing with here.
 
Last edited:
The WAI report extreme steel temperature claim is obviously a result of a need due to reverse engineering what it would take to break through the next floor down. It won't stand up to scrutiny and that is why no specifics about Beyler's analysis were given in the WAI report and why it isn't available publicly.

Do you ever tire of ascribing malfeasence in others who do not agree with you?
 
I would have to say your training within physics courses is probably not as rigorous as full courses on specific topics like those given in a mechanical engineering curriculum.

It isn't a hard thing to see that the extreme temperature claims in the WAI report are not possible. You can see that would also be the conclusion from the discussion in the paper by Dr. Korol et al.

Korol, like you, is a mechanical engineer. Beyler's career is fire scienced, he has won awards in the field. I will take his training and experience over yours and Korol's until such time as he is proven to be in error.
AGAIN, is there or is there not a fire science engineer in the 2000+?
Have you even contacted ANY fire sciences specialist?
 
Last edited:
Korol, like you, is a mechanical engineer. Beyler's career is fire scienced, he has won awards in the field. I will take his training and experience over yours and Korol's until such time as he is proven to be in error.
AGAIN, is there or is there not a fire science engineer in the 2000+?
Have you even contacted ANY fire sciences specialist?

No, Korol is a civil engineer and has had to be concerned about fires in buildings most of his career.

Abboud won an award for the WAI WTC 7 report and it was never entered in the court record and is not even valid as an explanation for the collapse. Awards can be given to non-credible reports for political purposes and unfortunately, that is what I think we have here.

None of the fire science engineers who have signed AE911Truth's petition agree with the NIST fire simulation and heat transfer analysis and the steel there doesn't get nearly as hot as that claimed by the WAI report.
 
Last edited:
If you look at the Cardington atmosphere data you will notice that peak gas temperatures above 900 degrees C only lasted for about 22 to 25 minutes. Could it be Dr. Korol and his colleagues know something you don't?

How about the total heating time, Tony? Do you suppose the fires in wtc 7 suddenly appeared at maximum intensity and then just as suddenly disappeared after 25 min? I know Korol's methodology is ridiculous and so do you.
 
How about the total heating time, Tony? Do you suppose the fires in wtc 7 suddenly appeared at maximum intensity and then just as suddenly disappeared after 25 min? I know Korol's methodology is ridiculous and so do you.

Heat flows from hot to cold and the WAI steel temperatures require very high gas temperatures to be maintained during the heat transfer. The other problem is thermal conductivity, which is quite low for the fire insulation, so the high temperature heat will not have the time needed to transfer through to the steel. This is why steel fire insulation is rated in hours. They know the fire will cool down significantly before the high temperature gas can transfer its heat sufficiently to the steel.

If the gas temperature goes down to 600 C and the steel was at 700 C guess what would be happening? The heat would be transferring from the steel to the gas. In other words, the steel would be cooling.

The WAI steel temperatures could only be achieved in a closed furnace with an excessive amount of fuel and no fire insulation on the steel.
 
Last edited:
No, Korol is a civil engineer and has had to be concerned about fires in buildings most of his career.
but is not a fire science engineer, neither are you.
Abboud won an award for the WAI WTC 7 report
So his peers who granted the award were simply aiding in the cover up of his and Beyler's "ridiculous" paper. Beyler has won his own accolades.
and it was never entered in the court record and is not even valid as an explanation for the collapse. Awards can be given to non-credible reports for political purposes and unfortunately, that is what I think we have here.
You have no standing to make these accusations.

None of the fire science engineers who have signed AE911Truth's petition agree with the NIST fire simulation and heat transfer analysis and the steel there doesn't get nearly as hot as that claimed by the WAI report.
So there are fire science engineers in the group?
Pray tell then, why are they not publically aiding you and AE911T in declaring error and malfeasence in the Beyler report? Why are they leaving it to a mechanical engineer and a civil engineer?
Why are they not requesting the Beyler report?
 
but is not a fire science engineer, neither are you.
So his peers who granted the award were simply aiding in the cover up of his and Beyler's "ridiculous" paper. Beyler has won his own accolades.

You have no standing to make these accusations.


So there are fire science engineers in the group?
Pray tell then, why are they not publically aiding you and AE911T in declaring error and malfeasence in the Beyler report? Why are they leaving it to a mechanical engineer and a civil engineer?
Why are they not requesting the Beyler report?

They have spoken out about the problems with the NIST WTC and WTC 7 reports. They just don't clown around with the amateur believers in the present official story here like I do.

I don't think you are in a position to judge what Dr. Korol and I know about fire and heat transfer.

I don't know that Beyler won accolades for his work referenced in the WAI report. I know Abboud did.

I just got started on the WAI report and raised the glaring issue it has. Most don't even know about it.
 
Last edited:
Heat flows from hot to cold and the WAI steel temperatures require very high gas temperatures to be maintained during the heat transfer. The other problem is thermal conductivity, which is quite low for the fire insulation, so the high temperature heat will not have the time needed to transfer through to the steel. This is why steel fire insulation is rated in hours. They know the fire will cool down significantly before the high temperature gas can transfer its heat sufficiently to the steel.

If the gas temperature goes down to 600 C and the steel was at 700 C guess what would be happening? The heat would be transferring from the steel to the gas. In other words, the steel would be cooling.

The WAI steel temperatures could only be achieved in a closed furnace with an excessive amount of fuel and no fire insulation on the steel.

Why don't you defend the 25 min heating time? You're the one who cited it. Why cite something so obviously and utterly incorrect?
 
Last edited:
Why don't you defend the 25 min heating time? You're the one who cited it. Why cite something so obviously and utterly incorrect?

That is an appropriate amount of time for the WAI situation, as that is the duration for temperatures above that claimed for the steel. The problem they have is that it can't transfer enough heat through the insulation in that short a period of time.

Those high gas temperatures would have had to last 120 minutes or more to heat the steel to what WAI claims, and Cardington and other sources show those peak temperatures don't last longer than 25 minutes.
 
They have spoken out about the problems with the NIST WTC and WTC 7 reports. They just don't clown around with the amateur believers in the present official story here like I do.
Really? What do they do then?
Have they contacted the SFPE, have they written rebuttals for "Fire Engineering", have they gone to ANY professional organization, as opposed to the amateurs clown circles you choose to haunt?
I don't think you are in a position to judge what Dr. Korol and I know about fire and heat transfer.
I am in a position to judge relative training and experience between he, and you, versus Abboud and Beyler. You aren't in the same league.

I don't know that Beyler won accolades for his work referenced in the WAI report. I know Abboud did.
I don't think I said Beyler won an award for this work. However, yes, ok, Abboud did. You minimize it based solely on your personal incredulity. What else you got, perhaps a written rebuttal from a fire sciences engineer?

I just got started on the WAI report and raised the glaring issue it has. Most don't even know about it.
I agree, and so what? Obviously Abboud's peers did, and found it particularly good. That alone suggests it's not the big hidden secret study you claim it is, and that it certainly is not the obvious and "ridiculous" study you accusie it of being.

What are your qualifications to disagree? You know, besides your baseless accusation of politics or malfeasance?
 
Last edited:
That is an appropriate amount of time for the WAI situation, as that is the duration for temperatures above that claimed for the steel. The problem they have is that it can't transfer enough heat through the insulation in that short a period of time.

Those high gas temperatures would have had to last 120 minutes or more to heat the steel to what WAI claims, and Cardington and other sources show those peak temperatures don't last longer than 25 minutes.

Why is it appropriate to model fires as if they only appear magically at maximum intensity for 25 min and then suddenly disappear? Can you cite a single other serious engineer who has used that approach except for Korol? Korol himself does not cite anyone who does. None of the NIST authors used that approach, nor did ARUP, nor did Bailey, nor did Mohwer, nor did Beyler. The Cardington study that you cited as an authority does not at all support that approach, and nor do the actual model fire studies of wtc 1 & 2 floors and cubicles.

So why are you citing it as if it even deserves consideration? Whether or not Beyler's approach is the best one, the alternative you are suggesting is garbage.
 
Last edited:
Why is it appropriate to model fires as if they only appear magically at maximum intensity for 25 min and then suddenly disappear? Can you cite a single other serious engineer who has used that approach except for Korol? Korol himself does not cite anyone who does. None of the NIST authors used that approach, nor did ARUP, nor did Bailey, nor did Mohwer, nor did Beyler. The Cardington study that you cited as an authority does not at all support that approach, and nor do the actual model fire studies of wtc 1 & 2 floors and cubicles.

.

Nor does, on my quick read, the SFPE Handbook.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom