does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Debates are what we use to move past opinions into what withstands scrutiny as reality based fact.


Odd, I never realized that the scientific method relied on debates.

Edit: I guess I will have to go review some Evolution vs. Creationism debates to determine how the various species came to be!
 
Last edited:
It goes back further than that to Tony's mentor, Steven E. Jones

Does anyone think such worthless experiments as this Molten Aluminum Experiment: Molten Aluminum Experiment: http://youtu.be/SQdkyaO56OY could ever duplicate a large molt of Aluminum reacting with nitrogen fire retardants in plastics?

You see I can point to the actual fraudulent behavior of all the experimenters, and show how and why they are frauds all the way back to Jones.

As I see it this is nothing more than a distraction, a bit of minutia. It is AE911T's continuing odd choice to pick on such minutia in the attempt to do nothing more than "prove NIST wrong". It does nothing whatsoever to further AE911T's own claims, although they seem to believe it does.

Would this be one of the major items that TSz would introduce in a debate?
 
Odd, I never realized that the scientific method relied on debates.

Edit: I guess I will have to go review some Evolution vs. Creationism debates to determine how the various species came to be!

Perhaps Tony can provide examples of when such debates have been used in the past on other scientific and engineering issues to determine facts from opinions.

The evolution versus creationism debates are religious and politically driven. They certainly NEVER influenced what science considered as true.

How does science determine "what withstands scrutiny as reality based fact"? Generally it is peer review of hypotheses and experiment. At least in hard sciences like physics, chemistry and applied sciences such as structural engineering.
 
Last edited:
I have some time right now...

So instead of wasting your time with a pointless debate that you already know what the outcome will be (both sides claiming victory) and accomplishing exactly two things...Jack and Squat. Why not spend that free time doing something productive? There's probably an elderly person in your neighborhood who could use some leaves raked. Grab a trash bag and pick up litter in your area. Volunteer at the local homeless shelter. Hell, start a new hobby...build a bird house...learn to play the piano or take up painting.

There are million better and more productive uses of your time than debating some faceless person on the internet about an event that happened 15 years ago...especially when you know the end result...agreeing to disagree.:rolleyes:
 
As I see it this is nothing more than a distraction, a bit of minutia. It is AE911T's continuing odd choice to pick on such minutia in the attempt to do nothing more than "prove NIST wrong". It does nothing whatsoever to further AE911T's own claims, although they seem to believe it does.

Would this be one of the major items that TSz would introduce in a debate?

No I would introduce it and for the first time show the video I shot of molten Aluminum,
Steel dust and And nitrated plastics reacted in the appropriate environment.
I had hoped these clowns got a hearing in court as part of a new investigation, so I could show the video there.
I posted photos of a similar experiment here years ago, AlN does not float off with the oxide, it oxidizes when exposed to air with steel dust not Iron oxide.
When finely divided steel oxidized in the presence of AlN, it triggers a thermite like reaction in the molt.
The material continues to react, even after pouring into a pan, which is why my photo of poured aluminum into a cold pan, sitting on wood was possible.
Plastics use Nitrate fire retardants and a large molt is great at creating an oxygen shielded environment for reactions to take place under it.
That is the problem in most of these experiments using small amounts of materials, and not recreating the appropriate environment for the reactions to occur.

They were always hoaxes and Tony fell for it and it ruined his professional representation.
I feel in a way sorry for him, but no one's real fault but his!
 
You forgot, no mushroomed steel, from thermite-thermate cutting.
You're quite right. Lets add that to the list.

Beyond "It looks like CD", "mumble, mumble freefall mumble" and "ITS OWN FOOTPRINT!!!!!", has this ever actually been done?
After 15 years, AFAIK, we have
  • No trace of explosives in the debris.
  • No sound of explosives.
  • No witnesses who saw the buildings being prepped for demolition.
  • No whistleblowers who were involved, and who have now come forward.
  • No coherent explanation of how both thermite and explosives were used.
  • No explanation of how the thermite, explosives and all the associated fuses etc. survived 7 hours of being in an uncontrolled fire.
  • No mushrooming of steel, from thermite/ thermate cutting.
Tony, did I miss something? What evidence do you have for CD? I'm serious: I'd really like to know.

Tony: the obvious lack of evidence for CD is growing. Do you have any positive evidence for demolition?
 
Huh? That makes Tony's post make even less sense. He made a thread, now in AAH, about when tfk was coming back to post here and he got responses.
 
I have some time right now...

Write a scholarly paper on your central thesis, get it successfully peer-reviewed by structural and forensic engineers, then get it published in one of the premier journals of structural and/or forensic engineering. That use of your free time should get you started on your goal of setting the record straight far more effectively than challenging anonymous laymen to debates in a backwater internet forum.
 
They're designed to have Tony "win". Its totally dishonest and transparent, and really the last gasping breaths of the terminally clueless.

Indeed such ground rules inevitably favor the fringe claimant. The claimant can spew all manner of unsubstantiated rubbish, reverse the burden of proof, and rest assured that all the corrections that would have to ensue won't fit the ground rules.
 
Write a scholarly paper on your central thesis, get it successfully peer-reviewed by structural and forensic engineers, then get it published in one of the premier journals of structural and/or forensic engineering. That use of your free time should get you started on your goal of setting the record straight far more effectively than challenging anonymous laymen to debates in a backwater internet forum.

Much more eloquently said than how I put it in post 24.

15 years after the fact and not a single peer reviewed structural engineering paper, nor any swaying of the ASCE or any professional engineering organization to their opinion of the destruction of the three WTC structures which collapsed fully (out of a dozen destroyed structures).
 
Last edited:
I have some time right now and am wondering if anyone here who supports the conclusions of the NIST reports, for the three high-rise collapses in NYC on Sept. 11, 2001, would want to debate me one-on-one as I contend that these NIST reports have been shown to be non-explanatory and incorrect.

The debate would take place on the 911 free forum, like the one I did with tfk, and the rules would be the same as those for that debate shown below.

1. The debate is restricted to the collapses of WTC 1, 2 & 7 in NYC on September 11, 2001, the NIST reports on these events, and any additional objectively verifiable information and analyses in the public domain about them.

<snip details made irrelevant by item 1's fundamental misunderstanding of what debate is and what it's for>


Those are not terms for a debate. They are terms for an argument.

Debate is for weighing plans of action, such as new or altered project plans, organizational policies, or public policies (i.e. new laws or amendments to or repeals of existing laws). It is not necessary that the debaters or anyone else have the intention to take the actions being debated, but it is necessary that they be plausible plans to be volitionally acted upon in the future. (So, e.g. "the universal gravitational constant shall be reduced by 10% on Sundays" or "Japanese military forces should not have bombed Pearl Harbor in 1941" don't qualify.) This is why parliamentary procedures used by legislative bodies in the U.S. at all levels of government encompasses debate about bills that are eligible for a future vote, rather than about bills that were passed or rejected last week.

I would be willing to debate you on any such premise that you wish to propose, based wholly or partly on the events of 9/11. I could suggest some examples, but I prefer that you demonstrate that you understand the point in the previous paragraph by coming up on your own with a suitable premise to debate about. I also have significant time restrictions on when such a debate can begin and at what pace it proceeds, which we can discuss once a premise is agreed upon.
 
Last edited:
1. The debate is restricted to the collapses of WTC 1, 2 & 7 in NYC on September 11, 2001, the NIST reports on these events, and any additional objectively verifiable information and analyses in the public domain about them.


Why this?
Here's some of what would be excluded:
- No comparison of the designs of WTC3,4,5&6 to the designs of 1,2&7
- No mention of the total destruction wrought by the collapses of WTC1 & 2, ie. not only the destruction of all other WTC structures but several other buildings nearby and heavy damage to yet more.

Why does AE911T always want to completely ignore the total destruction in the WTC complex? After the fires in WTC 5 & 6, in which the entire structure was absolutely and completely gutted, any objects in that structure would have been utterly destroyed. What was left of WTC 4 most likely also had similar fires, though there just aren't photos or videos of it in the immediate aftermath of WTC 1's collapse.
Most certainly, contents of these structures would be more completely destroyed than the contents of WTC 7. Yet we are supposed to believe that not the fires in WTC 7, but its collapse was likely engineered to destroy something in the building. Why are the fires in these other structures not supposedly suspicious?

Oh look.... look who were the tenants of WTC6, which was completely gutted by massive fires in the aftermath of the collapses of WTC 1 & 2, especially those I have in red:

United States Customs Service
United States Department of Commerce
Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms
United States Department of Agriculture – Administrator, Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (AAPHIS)
United States Department of Labor
The Peace Corps (New York Regional Office)
Export-Import Bank of the United States
Eastco Building Services (building management)
 
Last edited:
Those are not terms for a debate. They are terms for an argument.

Debate is for weighing plans of action, such as new or altered project plans, organizational policies, or public policies (i.e. new laws or amendments to or repeals of existing laws). It is not necessary that the debaters or anyone else have the intention to take the actions being debated, but it is necessary that they be plausible plans to be volitionally acted upon in the future. (So, e.g. "the universal gravitational constant shall be reduced by 10% on Sundays" or "Japanese military forces should not have bombed Pearl Harbor in 1941" don't qualify.) This is why parliamentary procedures used by legislative bodies in the U.S. at all levels of government encompasses debate about bills that are eligible for a future vote, rather than about bills that were passed or rejected last week.

I would be willing to debate you on any such premise that you wish to propose, based wholly or partly on the events of 9/11. I could suggest some examples, but I prefer that you demonstrate that you understand the point in the previous paragraph by coming up on your own with a suitable premise to debate about. I also have significant time restrictions on when such a debate can begin and at what pace it proceeds, which we can discuss once a premise is agreed upon.

I don't know if you are right on the semantics, but you can call it whatever you like. It would be a discussion between two individuals with opposing points of view on the NIST WTC reports (those involving WTC 1, 2, and 7) and what the public domain evidence points to as the reason for the collapses of these buildings.

If you don't like the ground rules tfk and I used why don't you eliminate what you don't like, add what you want, and post it here. I will then review it and accept it as is or make a counter proposal.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom