does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

”Why are the fires in these other structures [~WTC 5 & 6] not supposedly suspicious?”

WTC 5 & 6 stood between WTC 7 and the Twin Towers.

Though suffering far more impact damage than WTC7, as well as suffering from long lasting major fires, WTC 5 & 6 did not collapse.
 
mumble mumble - its own footprint

Beyond "It looks like CD", "mumble, mumble freefall mumble" and "ITS OWN FOOTPRINT!!!!!", has this ever actually been done?
The topic "In or on its footprint for the three towers -wtc1 wtc2 wtc7-" was illuminated in threads five and a half years ago.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7378798#post7378798
After 15 years, AFAIK, we have
  • No trace of explosives in the debris.
NIST FAQ
Q. Was the WTC debris tested for traces of explosive residues ?
A. No

Cosmic Yak : Tony Did I miss something ? I really want to know
Fonebone < Now you know
 
Last edited:
I was wondering if anyone wanted to debate the existence of oxygen with me in a one-on-one exchange. Anyone failing to answer within 97 minutes will forfeit and oxygen will no longer be an element.

Because this is how science is done, isn't it?
 
Funny how he left out the reason why NIST ruled out explosives. And it's the same 'reason' that Truthers never have a good answer for...

Exactly Twoofers wanted every speck of dust tested for explosives, that were not indicated for by the physical evidence.
Dr. Jones tried to pull a fast one with the thermite fantasy he knew, residue of thermal lances with Aluminum and steel wire would leave similar evidence to thermite.
What he forgot is that Columns cut while loaded with thermite are mushroomed by Gravity.
Physics has to be violated for CD, to be real.
 
What would you have tested for explosive residues?

There was no evidence of explosives at all.

Flapdoodle ! You got a minute ?

exhibit A
http://themindrenewed.com/in-the-media/713-news156
documented accounts of explosions

exhibit B
An ABC television reporter N.J. Burkett was standing on west street
broadcasting LIVE with the two WTC twin towers in the background.
Suddenly he screamed into the camera--
--HUGE EXPLOSION !!! ...raining debris down on all of us --
as the WTC2 tower began to collapse.
https://vidsn.com/v/liveleak-9-11-footage-a-reporter-doing-his-job+k0Tf5Q4Gc60.html
at 03:40

exhibit C
Firemen report explosions
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IO1ps1mzU8o
 
Last edited:
Tony, are you suggesting that "the NIST WTC reports (those involving WTC 1, 2, and 7) and what the public domain evidence points to as the reason for the collapses of these buildings" is a proposition for a plausible volitional plan of future action? It is no such thing.

Perhaps you're not understanding my point about the (only) kind of debate I'm interested in, a debate about a future deliberate measure (a change to be made, a law to be passed, a task to be undertaken...) that people can make a decision about, instead of about the unalterable past. Or perhaps you just want to disregard that preference and instead pretend that the words I used mean what you want instead of what I offered. Either way, that's not a promising start, but you're welcome to try again.
 
Last edited:
... NIST reports have been shown to be non-explanatory and incorrect.
...
You have never show, thus this statement remains a lie. I would read the rest of your post, but one lie is all it takes to debunk a debate based on BS.

A lie about NIST, and CD is a fantasy made up by paranoid conspiracy theorists.

Big clue, fire did it, NIST was right. Look up the meaning of probable.

The fantasy of explosions, will that lie be in the debate?


...
--HUGE EXPLOSION !!! ...raining debris down on all of us --
as the WTC2 tower began to collapse. ...
Big fail, he was hearing a building collapse. Simile, look it up.

No one heard an explosive on 9/11, they heard loud sounds. Bodies hitting the ground, and building falling, and stuff that blows up, but no explosives. Proof of no explosives, starts with the people trapped in the WTC stairs, who lived, and were not people with brains turned to mush by your fantasy explosives.

Simile, look it up. Did a train do it? Some people heard a freight train... simile

Have you been in an earthquake? What did you hear.
 
Last edited:
You know what's crazy? Some of the guys here are the only people who defend the official story while still understanding that the NIST WTC 7 report is completely incorrect and inadequate. Sometimes on reddit I'll try reasoning with a person calling the CD theory crazy, and they'll cite the NIST report, and totally dismiss me when I explain as clearly as possible that it's been soundly debunked, the last nail in the coffin being hammered in 2012 when the blueprints were released. They'll say "200 technical experts disagree, tin foil hat retard!!111", while in reality making themselves look foolish. But you guys understand. So, it doesn't bother you guys that the one and only official word on this controversial event is a proven fraud?
 
Tony, are you suggesting that "the NIST WTC reports (those involving WTC 1, 2, and 7) and what the public domain evidence points to as the reason for the collapses of these buildings" is a proposition for a plausible volitional plan of future action? It is no such thing.

Perhaps you're not understanding my point about the (only) kind of debate I'm interested in, a debate about a future deliberate measure (a change to be made, a law to be passed, a task to be undertaken...) that people can make a decision about, instead of about the unalterable past. Or perhaps you just want to disregard that preference and instead pretend that the words I used mean what you want instead of what I offered. Either way, that's not a promising start, but you're welcome to try again.

You have made it clear that you aren't genuinely interested.
 
Last edited:
It looks like there are no takers and tfk seems destined to be the one and only JREF'er to ever have the nerve to leave the nest here and debate in a one-on-one situation.

Not really surprising that none of you are confident enough to venture outside of the moral support of the gang after seeing what happened to him. He was a star here.
 
Last edited:
It looks like there are no takers and tfk seems destined to be the one and only JREF'er to ever have the nerve to debate outside of the gang here in a one-on-one situation.

Not really surprising that none of you are confident enough in either yourselves or the story you try to defend to leave your little nest and moral support after seeing what happened to him. He was a star here.

I'm game.
It's just that you lack the intellectual courage to even acknowledge my one and only rule, nevermind actually discuss it.
 
I love how it went from "the NIST report has some errors and is incomplete" to "the NIST report is a proven fraud".

And no, that doesn't bother me, because obvious lies are obvious.

Yup, total fraud. No better way to describe it. The fact that their website still promotes it as factual and complete proves that they are hucksters. Also recall how they took out the shear studs after Shayam Sunder said "We're having trouble getting a handle on Building 7".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom