does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Shall we list the persons and professional organizations that are wrong about 9/11:

NIST
CTBUH
ASCE
AIA
Purdue University Engineering Dept.
Nordenson & Associates
Weidlinger Associates
Jensen Hughes / Craig Beyler

Who else?
 
Considering that the .bdf (Bulk Data File) for a 60,000 degree-of-freedom model is only 197k, (Includes a fair number of CHEXA, CQUAD4 elements, along with PATRAN's idiotic "a property card for every element), I'm not sure what his problem is, other than hiding something.
at any rate, since he can't even seem to show the restraints and loads, or even the configuration, I'm done with him.

I told you the load on the girder was 130 kips uniformly distributed. I also told you the girder was sitting on its seats at columns 44 and 79 with contact interfaces (which allow lateral movement) since the bolts were considered broken.

For you to then say I am not giving you the loads and restraints (the word usually used is constraints) is absolute garbage.

I asked for your e-mail address via PM so I could give you the results in graphic form, but you refused to do so and then have the nerve to claim I was not willing to give you information.

I don't want anything to do with you either, because you are clearly disingenuous and obviously have no intent to discuss these things in a legitimate way. You are actually just trying to jerk me around, which is a low life thing to do.

Bon voyage!
 
Last edited:
And like others have said, the only way to change current perception of "what really happened" from an engineering perspective would be to prepare and publish an actual peer-reviewed paper in a relevant, major publication.

Why are you wasting your time here?

This reluctance, nay, obstinance, by truthers is quite baffling.

With Pilots for 911 Truth, I suggested that Balsamo et al write a purely technical paper outlining the reasons that they believe that the flight path described by the DFDR of Flight AA77 differed greatly from the flight path described by physical damage and witness accounts. It would be an issue of certain importance if DFDRs could not be counted upon to accurately record an aircraft's flight.

On this forum, Tony Szamboti has been repeatedly told that the best way to get AE911T's point accross would be to produce a full report on at least one of the three structures that came down on 9/11. Such report would necessarily have to be of at least the level of detail and research that the NIST reports were. Szamboti and AE911T would have the benefit of the baseline research done by NIST, such as the description of the structure prior to 9/11/01, and need only concentrate on fire and collapse. There would also be, of course, no need to speak to egress issues.

So far a single article in Europhysics, simply repeating all the unsubstantiated bald assertions seen in internet forums, and nothing else. AE911T and Szamboti say they want to be taken seriously but are either unwilling to, or at a loss as to how to, make this come about. Instead, Szamboti wishes for a series of one-on-one debates on the internet with mostly anonymous posters.

thus my questions on page one of this thread:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?
 
Last edited:
This reluctance, nay, obstinance, by truthers is quite baffling.

With Pilots for 911 Truth, I suggested that Balsamo et al write a purely technical paper outlining the reasons that they believe that the flight path described by the DFDR of Flight AA77 differed greatly from the flight path described by physical damage and witness accounts. It would be an issue of certain importance if DFDRs could not be counted upon to accurately record an aircraft's flight.

On this forum, Tony Szamboti has been repeatedly told that the best way to get AE911T's point accross would be to produce a full report on at least one of the three structures that came down on 9/11. Such report would necessarily have to be of at least the level of detail and research that the NIST reports were. Szamboti and AE911T would have the benefit of the baseline research done by NIST, such as the description of the structure prior to 9/11/01, and need only concentrate on fire and collapse. There would also be, of course, no need to speak to egress issues.

So far a single article in Europhysics, simply repeating all the unsubstantiated bald assertions seen in internet forums, and nothing else. AE911T and Szamboti say they want to be taken seriously but are either unwilling to, or at a loss as to how to, make this come about. Instead, Szamboti wishes for a series of one-on-one debates on the internet with mostly anonymous posters.

thus my questions on page one of this thread:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?

Heck, no one has even really answered the question of "Where is tfk?", so we can't even say what his state is in the debate. Did he end up in the hospital, prison, alien abduction? Don't know.
 
Heck, no one has even really answered the question of "Where is tfk?", so we can't even say what his state is in the debate. Did he end up in the hospital, prison, alien abduction? Don't know.

Do you really believe that? I think the chances are much better that tfk just bowed out of the debate because he had no answers to the opposing points made, and it would be embarrassing for him and the other present official story (NIST WTC and WTC 7 reports, 911 Commission report etc.) defenders for him to come back on here as he can no longer be said to be effective in defending it.

I have heard others say he still views this forum but does not post.

I have no malice towards him and wish him well. Everyone can make mistakes and his, while significant, are forgivable.
 
Last edited:
Does everyone here believe that lances were used to cut columns during clean up?

mk7p0w.jpg


welders.png
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by LSSBB
Heck, no one has even really answered the question of "Where is tfk?", so we can't even say what his state is in the debate. Did he end up in the hospital, prison, alien AE911T abduction? Don't know.


ftfy:D

That's the first time I heard that.
 
Last edited:
You are postulating a giant gash in the middle of the south wall, even though we only have evidence of the southwest corner gash and a single column missing down the middle. Do you have specific evidence for any damage worse than that?

In this photo, you can see serious damage on the high face of the south wall of WTC 7. The rest of the damage is obscured by heavy smoke.


news_wtc7_1.jpg



Take a look at the next photo and notice that the south wall of WTC 7 faced WTC 1 when it collapsed.


WTC7Hit1.jpg
 
Last edited:
Do you really believe that? I think the chances are much better that tfk just bowed out of the debate because he had no answers to the opposing points made, and it would be embarrassing for him and the other present official story (NIST WTC and WTC 7 reports, 911 Commission report etc.) defenders for him to come back on here as he can no longer be said to be effective in defending it.
.

I find that difficult to believe as tfk certainly never had a problem responding to anyone he disagreed with on this forum, including you, in the past.
I saw nothing you posted as being in any way different than what you have in the past posted here.
 
Oystein, you know I believe all three reports on WTC 7 are non-explanatory and that those from NIST and ARUP have been shown to have fatal flaws which invalidate them.

The only one which has not yet been shown to be invalid in a demonstrative way is that from Weidlinger, although its extreme steel temperatures and lack of transparency on how those were arrived at points to an area which is very possibly invalid.

That is really the only thing left here for you and I to discuss.
Uhm - no.
There is most definitely a lot more for us to discuss, since you, Tony,
  • insist that there must be a new investigation
  • claim that it is impossible for fires to have caused the collapse
  • hint that there was arson and explosive CD
The relevance of "shooting down" NIST, ARUP, WAI lies in your conviction that this helps you prove all those three.
You may have a point wrt to the first.
You are wrong that disproving any or all hypotheses helps you prove CD.
And that's what you need to discuss, if you want to change anything in this world that is important to you. You could, for example, change your mind. Or, you could work out how to get that "new investigation". I can help you with changing your mind, but am indifferent to the new investigation.

You did not address my suggestion that we could also discuss
  • Harrit et al
  • AE911Truth's next AIA resolution proposal
  • Your CD theory
under the condition that you apply the same standard of disprove - in short: If I find one flaw with any of these, you accept that they are totally broken and wrong.

However, I have only looked at it in a cursory way so far and have said what I thought based on that, so we really can adjourn for now, unless you have more to say on it, although you did not seem to want to earlier.
I discussed the WAI report in the context of benthamitemetric's explanations why your assertion that certain temperatures cannot be reached by WTC7 steel.

I am not highly interested in the WAI report. I am interested in your CD claims.
 
Weidlinger's choice to rely on an unavailable unpublished report ...

You forgot the context: Abboud's and Beyler's reports were both prepared as part of the defense's case in a court room.
Both reports, and any other materials they may have prepared, were of course available to the court and the plaintiffs.
 
Uhm - no.
There is most definitely a lot more for us to discuss, since you, Tony,
  • insist that there must be a new investigation
  • claim that it is impossible for fires to have caused the collapse
  • hint that there was arson and explosive CD
The relevance of "shooting down" NIST, ARUP, WAI lies in your conviction that this helps you prove all those three.
You may have a point wrt to the first.
You are wrong that disproving any or all hypotheses helps you prove CD.
And that's what you need to discuss, if you want to change anything in this world that is important to you. You could, for example, change your mind. Or, you could work out how to get that "new investigation". I can help you with changing your mind, but am indifferent to the new investigation.

You did not address my suggestion that we could also discuss
  • Harrit et al
  • AE911Truth's next AIA resolution proposal
  • Your CD theory
under the condition that you apply the same standard of disprove - in short: If I find one flaw with any of these, you accept that they are totally broken and wrong.


I discussed the WAI report in the context of benthamitemetric's explanations why your assertion that certain temperatures cannot be reached by WTC7 steel.

I am not highly interested in the WAI report. I am interested in your CD claims.

Disproving NIST, ARUP, and WAI does not prove controlled demolition and I don't say that. All I say in the context of showing those reports to be invalid and non-explanatory is that a new investigation is needed, as we do not have an answer at present.

The controlled demolition hypothesis arises from observation and should be something looked at in a new investigation.

I think you are trying to create a false condition with saying if you find one thing wrong in the three items that you mention that that would invalidate them. Invalidation is dependent on the level of dependence of the disproved item for the theory in question. For instance, showing Nordenson's analysis was in error did invalidate ARUP as the conclusion of the analysis was completely dependent on the floors below being broken through and a cascade failure leaving column 79 without lateral support.
 
Last edited:
You forgot the context: Abboud's and Beyler's reports were both prepared as part of the defense's case in a court room.
Both reports, and any other materials they may have prepared, were of course available to the court and the plaintiffs.

Nor has it been demonstrated that this report is unavailable to qualified, interested parties.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom