does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

No it doesn't! How anyone can declare that with a straight face is astounding to me.

It may invalidate the floor failure due to impact of one girder under the specific conditions of the FEA. THAT is as far as you can go with that.

It most certainly does not invalidate all mechanisms of collapse due to fire.
Are you trying to tell us it was actually rivet #3 that failed first, not #2?
That would render everything Tony has done as wrong!
 
Are you trying to tell us it was actually rivet #3 that failed first, not #2?
That would render everything Tony has done as wrong!

Actually to carry that metaphor further, Tony is trying to tell us that determining that rivet #2 could not fail under a set of conditions then also determines that none of the rivets could fail under a much wider set of conditions.

What is clear from all the studies carried out thus far, is that multiple floor failures would create instability in columns which would then also fail and the structure would then continue to see a progression of failures until the structure as a whole could no longer stand.

What is less clear is the single first failure that led to the initial floor failure.

Hey, if Tony wants to change his CD theory to "explosives/thermite severed girder connections of several contiguous floors to create a column instability that would bring the structure down" at least it would have the backing of every single report wrt sequence of failures.


ETA: wait, did I say Tony could "change" his CD theory? My mistake. Tony doesn't have a CD theory, he has a CD handwaving assertion.
 
Last edited:
A different analogy for what Tony is trying to do is to (correctly) state that a map isn't the same as the real terrain, just as a model isn't necessarily reality. Where he goes wrong is insisting that any detail in the map that doesn't correlate with the actual terrain is reason to completely discard the map and substitute one's own reality.

"Baltimore isn't a bunch of salmon-pink colored squares, so your atlas can be completely disregarded, and my claim that Baltimore is the capital of Arizona is completely deserving of time, attention, and funding. If there aren't any cartographers who are willing to provide their full name and credentials while supporting the ridiculous contention that Baltimore is actually salmon-pink in an on-line debate with rules of my choosing, means I automatically win, and everyone must agree that the governor of Maryland should be impeached for promoting false claims.

Oh, you all of you salmon-pink fools are obviously biased, blind, and clueless.

*Internet machismo ensues*"
 
Nope. I am not going to chase you around the internet. You demanded an email address from a qualified engineer. You got one and now you are welching and chickening out. Email your nonsense to me. Provide permission for me to post it on dropbox. It is that simple.

The fact that you will not is telling.

I put the girder stiffener analysis on the 911 free forum here http://the911forum.freeforums.org/stress-analysis-of-a2001-with-girder-stiffeners-included-t807.html

See the attached pdf below the post.

I put the girder trapping analysis up here http://the911forum.freeforums.org/post27178.html#p27178

I put the Nordenson stiffness error analysis here http://the911forum.freeforums.org/analysis-showing-nordenson-stiffness-error-t809.html
 
Last edited:
It isn't a private FEA I did for the Nordenson infinite stiffness issue. I gave you all of the details and you have had nearly a year to look at it. It doesn't sound like you can say anything about it.

The reality is that it is obvious on its face that the beam and girder assembly did not have an infinite stiffness which would not allow deflection and energy absorption.

The much lower stiffness is obvious and the FEA just put numbers to it showing what the energy absorption was and how it would significantly reduce the impact force. I can guarantee you won't find a result much different if you have your own FEA done to determine natural frequency of the beam and girder assembly to find the stiffness to use in the energy, deflection, and impact force equations.

The truth is Nordenson's error invalidates the ARUP conclusion that WTC 7 collapsed due to fire. The omitted girder web stiffeners and girder trapping by the column side plate invalidates the NIST conclusion that WTC 7 collapsed due to fire and the Nordenson error is also one NIST made in not being able to break through the next floor down. The WAI report has extreme steel temperatures that can be proven to not be attainable and they did not make the fire simulation and heat transfer analyses they depend on public. Did you ever read the article Performance-based fire protection of office buildings: A case study based on the collapse of WTC 7? It is on-line here http://www.challengejournal.com/index.php/cjsmec/article/view/36

Face it, the NIST, ARUP, and WAI reports on WTC 7 all have fatal flaws and are nothing but crapola being foisted on the public.

The problem is Tony does the evidence you provided prove an academic error, or does it present a case on mallace, a crime.

Your problem is you have to prove a crime, not simply an academic mistake, and that is an impossible case.
 
The problem is Tony does the evidence you provided prove an academic error, or does it present a case on mallace, a crime.

Your problem is you have to prove a crime, not simply an academic mistake, and that is an impossible case.

Anyone who does these analyses honestly will arrive at the same conclusion I have and that is that the three WTC 7 reports we have NIST, ARUP, and WAI do not explain the collapse because they contain impossibilities.
 
Right, that's the straight line down the middle representing a single column that came off.

Most of what you're seeing in that photo is dust. Only a few pieces of steel were flung far enough to even touch WTC 7.



It's at least a 20 story gash, along with the 3 or 4 story gash in the corner.

More than enough damage to cause a fire nobody could fight.

Damage and fire destroyed that building.

Period.
 
You can download and save the PDF files. That is what I would have sent by e-mail.

I did and I have a Question, the girder seat in the PDF seems to be held by the column in compression not tension is that correct?

It does not appear to be similar to the blue print drawing.
 
You can download and save the PDF files. That is what I would have sent by e-mail.

Why then did you refuse to post it here until your feet were held to the flames? Why did you refuse to post it at all until now? Why did you make such a big deal of it unless you had reason to conceal it? Why did you falsely claim that it was not possible to post it due to restrictions here yet somehow can now post it?

Something does not add up with those claims.
 
I did and I have a Question, the girder seat in the PDF seems to be held by the column in compression not tension is that correct?

It does not appear to be similar to the blue print drawing.

It is exactly like the drawing. The bearing seat was welded to the column flange at it back surface and sat on a 14" deep x 2" thick support plate that was welded to the column side plates. It is not held to the column by tension or compression.

You are showing your lack of education in these matters here. It doesn't sound like you are qualified to comment.
 
Why then did you refuse to post it here until your feet were held to the flames? Why did you refuse to post it at all until now? Why did you make such a big deal of it unless you had reason to conceal it? Why did you falsely claim that it was not possible to post it due to restrictions here yet somehow can now post it?

Something does not add up with those claims.

I tried to post the analyses here earlier but the upload file size limit is too low.

I didn't think of putting it on the 911 free forum until a short time ago. They allow for much larger files to be uploaded and attached to a post.

You have them now, so there is no reason to complain.
 
Last edited:
I tried to post the analyses here but the upload file size limit is too low.

I didn't think of putting it on the 911 free forum until a short time ago.

You have them now, so there is no reason to complain.

No. I want to know exactly why it is that you refused to provide your data right here on the basis that this site could not support it. Why, when it was put up to you did you cave in and provide it on this very site? Something does not ring true about this. You could, quite clearly have provided the crap you claim at any time. It is only when you are held to it that you finally provide it having previously denied that it was even possible. I want an explanation for that. Please provide one.
 
The controlled demolition hypothesis arises from observation and should be something looked at in a new investigation.

There is no extant CD hypothesis to investigate, therefore nothing to look at. I thought we made that point clear. If you would like to provide one then go right ahead. You have been asked a couple of times, requests which so far have been conspicuously ignored. Until then, the only plausible hypothesis is fire + time + gravity = collapse and all any new investigation is going to do is study different ways in which fire might have initiated collapse.

And might is all the better we are ever going to get given that no new information to investigate is likely to appear and what exists is inadequate to reach definitive conclusions.
 
Last edited:
No. I want to know exactly why it is that you refused to provide your data right here on the basis that this site could not support it. Why, when it was put up to you did you cave in and provide it on this very site? Something does not ring true about this. You could, quite clearly have provided the crap you claim at any time. It is only when you are held to it that you finally provide it having previously denied that it was even possible. I want an explanation for that. Please provide one.

I told you why. It was because I had no way to post them here and I wasn't going to some dropbox I am not familiar with. I also have no idea who you are or what your background is and you are somewhat out of line here. While he was disingenuous, rwguinn at least spoke like an engineer and I was going to e-mail him. At least there I had some assurance that I was talking to someone who would at least understand and not have to put up with uninformed questions and nonsense as just shown by Crazy Chainsaw here.

Edited by zooterkin: 
Edited for rule 0, rule 11 and rule 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I told you why. It was because I had no way to post them here.

Edited by zooterkin: 
Edited for rule 0, rule 11 and rule 12.

Nope. You claimed that it was impossible to post them here. That was your claim.

Your new claim is that you have posted them here. These claims cannot both be correct. Which is it?

Am I a qualified engineer? Yup. Have I provided my email address? Yup. Have I recieved an email from TS? Nope. My only available conclusion is obvious. I fulfilled TS's pointless requirements. TS failed to fulfil his own. That's how it is.

There is nothing I can do about that.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Nope. You claimed that it was impossible to post them here. That was your claim.

Your new claim is that you have posted them here. These claims cannot both be correct. Which is it?

Am I a qualified engineer? Yup. Have I provided my email address? Yup. Have I recieved an email from TS? Nope. My only available conclusion is obvious. I fulfilled TS's pointless requirements. TS failed to fulfil his own. That's how it is.

There is nothing I can do about that.

I have not seen you say anything which would show you are an engineer.

However, the files are available to you on the 911 free forum.

It sounds like you are crying about it just to have something to complain about. There is nothing to complain about. You have access to the files.

It is this kind of drivel that keeps people like me from answering a lot of posts here.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom