does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

You forgot the context: Abboud's and Beyler's reports were both prepared as part of the defense's case in a court room.
Both reports, and any other materials they may have prepared, were of course available to the court and the plaintiffs.

From what I understand the Weidlinger report was never entered into the court record, by order of the court, so Abboud's and Beyler's reports would not have been available to the plaintiffs.
 
Last edited:
Nor has it been demonstrated that this report is unavailable to qualified, interested parties.

Benthamitemetric is a lawyer who posts here and on Metabunk and he has been able to get other items involved in the case, such as the ARUP expert and Weidlinger reports on WTC 7. I have asked him for the Beyler 2010 analysis referenced by Abboud. He has thus far not been able to attain it from what he says.
 
Last edited:
I told you the load on the girder was 130 kips uniformly distributed. I also told you the girder was sitting on its seats at columns 44 and 79 with contact interfaces (which allow lateral movement) since the bolts were considered broken.

For you to then say I am not giving you the loads and restraints (the word usually used is constraints) is absolute garbage.

I asked for your e-mail address via PM so I could give you the results in graphic form, but you refused to do so and then have the nerve to claim I was not willing to give you information.

I don't want anything to do with you either, because you are clearly disingenuous and obviously have no intent to discuss these things in a legitimate way. You are actually just trying to jerk me around, which is a low life thing to do.

Bon voyage!

OK. I will provide my email address on condition that I can share your paper on a hosting site publicly. Fair enough?
 
abaddonire (at) gmail (dot) com

Let's have it. I will create a dropbox account for the purpose so that everyone can see it and examine it.

Go ahead. I await your imminent mail.
 
It is on post number 192 and 200 in the Metabunk.org link I gave you. Go have a ball.
Nope. I am not going to chase you around the internet. You demanded an email address from a qualified engineer. You got one and now you are welching and chickening out. Email your nonsense to me. Provide permission for me to post it on dropbox. It is that simple.

The fact that you will not is telling.
 
Disproving NIST, ARUP, and WAI does not prove controlled demolition and I don't say that.
I don't say you say that. I said "that this helps you prove" CD and other stuff - and you clearly must be thinking that!
You are certain of CD, aren't you? So why bother with fire scenarios and how hot which beam got? You ough to cut to the chase!

All I say in the context of showing those reports to be invalid and non-explanatory is that a new investigation is needed, as we do not have an answer at present.
Unless supporting your CD claim is really why you scrutinze all these reports, you'd need to explain who need a new investigation into this fire-induced collapse, and why, and if the cost is justified by the expected return.
You have a taker for that discussion: Myriad.

The controlled demolition hypothesis arises from observation and should be something looked at in a new investigation.
Would this not require for a controlled demolition hypothesis to exist?

Since no new evidence is ever going to surface - all the steel is gone, all photos and videos probably known, and 15 years is too long for new witness statements to be reliable - all the observations you need are already known. It should be possible to come up with a testable CD hypothesis that is consistent with all the evidence you have, if CD is what actually happened.

But there exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!

I think you are trying to create a false condition with saying if you find one thing wrong in the three items that you mention that that would invalidate them. Invalidation is dependent on the level of dependence of the disproved item for the theory in question. For instance, showing Nordenson's analysis was in error did invalidate ARUP as the conclusion of the analysis was completely dependent on the floors below being broken through and a cascade failure leaving column 79 without lateral support.
You overstate your case.
Your stiffness value is predicated on your own private FEA which no one so far has had a chance to scrutinize, because you have not made it available. You sent me some results, but a) I am clearly not the engineer to go to if you wish to have your work scrutinized, and b) I am sure the stuff you sent me is insufficient anyway.

Also, your value lands the force on the girder seat not decisively in "impossible territory". Nordenson assumed, conservatively, an undamaged connection. Was that justified? All his other numbers - are they near enough correct? You made a good case that non-progression is plausible, but you could not seal it.

All this goes back to the core problem that no one can know the true conditions inside WTC7. What we do know: There was a fire, it made the building move, deform, screetching so much that the trained, experienced FDNY officers at the scene expected the collapse. Which is why it is not in serious doubt among the ranks of the fire fighting, structural engineering etc ranks that of course fire damage was the cause of collapse.
No new investigation will be able to give us more information on internal conditions. So why bother? Several investigations and studies have unearthed new insight into the kinds of problems that brought WTC7 to the brink of collapse. Is it really so all-important that we know the exact straw that broke the camel's back?

No.

You are not interested in the straw either.
You want to change the paradigm.

If you want to change the paradigm, you need to make a good case for it.
 
From what I understand the Weidlinger report was never entered into the court record, by order of the court, so Abboud's and Beyler's reports would not have been available to the plaintiffs.

So what?
Doesn't rescue Ziggi's false (to be exact: anachronistic) accusation that Abboud relied on an unavailable report. At the time he finished his report, the justified expectation was that both reports would be available to whom it actually concerned.

And as jaydee pointed out: They may still both be available to those to whom it concerns. Just try and ask - and justify why it concerns you (they might not respond to business graduates or MEs, though).
 
I don't say you say that. I said "that this helps you prove" CD and other stuff - and you clearly must be thinking that!
You are certain of CD, aren't you? So why bother with fire scenarios and how hot which beam got? You ough to cut to the chase!


Unless supporting your CD claim is really why you scrutinze all these reports, you'd need to explain who need a new investigation into this fire-induced collapse, and why, and if the cost is justified by the expected return.
You have a taker for that discussion: Myriad.


Would this not require for a controlled demolition hypothesis to exist?

Since no new evidence is ever going to surface - all the steel is gone, all photos and videos probably known, and 15 years is too long for new witness statements to be reliable - all the observations you need are already known. It should be possible to come up with a testable CD hypothesis that is consistent with all the evidence you have, if CD is what actually happened.

But there exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!


You overstate your case.
Your stiffness value is predicated on your own private FEA which no one so far has had a chance to scrutinize, because you have not made it available. You sent me some results, but a) I am clearly not the engineer to go to if you wish to have your work scrutinized, and b) I am sure the stuff you sent me is insufficient anyway.

Also, your value lands the force on the girder seat not decisively in "impossible territory". Nordenson assumed, conservatively, an undamaged connection. Was that justified? All his other numbers - are they near enough correct? You made a good case that non-progression is plausible, but you could not seal it.

All this goes back to the core problem that no one can know the true conditions inside WTC7. What we do know: There was a fire, it made the building move, deform, screetching so much that the trained, experienced FDNY officers at the scene expected the collapse. Which is why it is not in serious doubt among the ranks of the fire fighting, structural engineering etc ranks that of course fire damage was the cause of collapse.
No new investigation will be able to give us more information on internal conditions. So why bother? Several investigations and studies have unearthed new insight into the kinds of problems that brought WTC7 to the brink of collapse. Is it really so all-important that we know the exact straw that broke the camel's back?

No.

You are not interested in the straw either.
You want to change the paradigm.

If you want to change the paradigm, you need to make a good case for it.

It isn't a private FEA I did for the Nordenson infinite stiffness issue. I gave you all of the details and you have had nearly a year to look at it. It doesn't sound like you can say anything about it.

The reality is that it is obvious on its face that the beam and girder assembly did not have an infinite stiffness which would not allow deflection and energy absorption.

The much lower stiffness is obvious and the FEA just put numbers to it showing what the energy absorption was and how it would significantly reduce the impact force. I can guarantee you won't find a result much different if you have your own FEA done to determine natural frequency of the beam and girder assembly to find the stiffness to use in the energy, deflection, and impact force equations.

The truth is Nordenson's error invalidates the ARUP conclusion that WTC 7 collapsed due to fire. The omitted girder web stiffeners and girder trapping by the column side plate invalidates the NIST conclusion that WTC 7 collapsed due to fire and the Nordenson error is also one NIST made in not being able to break through the next floor down. The WAI report has extreme steel temperatures that can be proven to not be attainable and they did not make the fire simulation and heat transfer analyses they depend on public. Did you ever read the article Performance-based fire protection of office buildings: A case study based on the collapse of WTC 7? It is on-line here http://www.challengejournal.com/index.php/cjsmec/article/view/36

Face it, the NIST, ARUP, and WAI reports on WTC 7 all have fatal flaws and are nothing but crapola being foisted on the public.
 
Last edited:
It isn't a private FEA I did for the Nordenson infinite stiffness issue. I gave you all of the details and you have had nearly a year to look at it. It doesn't sound like you say anything about it.

The reality is that it is obvious on its face that the beam and girder assembly did not have an infinite stiffness which would not allow deflection and energy absorption.

The much lower stiffness is obvious and the FEA just put numbers to it showing what the energy absorption was and how it would significantly reduce the impact force. I can guarantee you won't find a result much different if you have your own FEA done to determine natural frequency of the beam and girder assembly to use in the energy, deflection, and impact force equations.

The truth is Nordenson's error invalidates the ARUP conclusion that WTC 7 collapsed due to fire. The omitted girder web stiffeners and girder trapping by the column side plate invalidates the NIST conclusion that WTC 7 collapsed due to fire and the Nordenson error is also one NIST made in not being able to break through the next floor down. The WAI report has extreme steel temperatures that can be proven to not be attainable and they did not make the fire simulation and heat transfer analyses they depend on public.

Face it, these reports are crapola being foisted on the public.

oops...

missed a spot:

But there exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!
 
It isn't a private FEA I did for the Nordenson infinite stiffness issue. I gave you all of the details ...
All? Doubtful.

and you have had nearly a year to look at it. It doesn't sound like you can say anything about it.
Of course I can't. I have never been coy about the fact that I can't. I am not an engineer and have zero experience and next to zero knowledge about FEA.

The reality is that it is obvious on its face that the beam and girder assembly did not have an infinite stiffness which would not allow deflection and energy absorption.

The much lower stiffness is obvious...
Correct.

and the FEA just put numbers to it showing what the energy absorption was
No. Simply no.
Order of magnitude perhaps.

and how it would significantly reduce the impact force. I can guarantee you won't find a result much different if you have your own FEA done to determine natural frequency of the beam and girder assembly to find the stiffness to use in the energy, deflection, and impact force equations.
I could give you guarantees, too, that are worth nothing.
I don't need your guarantee - and you don't need my accepting any guarantees.

The truth is Nordenson's error invalidates the ARUP conclusion that WTC 7 collapsed due to fire.
And there goes your old, abject nonsense again. Unreal.

The omitted girder web stiffeners and girder trapping by the column side plate invalidates the NIST conclusion that WTC 7 collapsed due to fire
Abject nonsense.

and the Nordenson error is also one NIST made in not being able to break through the next floor down.
How do you know that?!?

The WAI report has extreme steel temperatures that can be proven to not be attainable
Bare assertion. You haven't proven it, nor has anybody else, so you speak out of your arse.

You make bare assertions there, as has been pointed out again and again.

and they did not make the fire simulation and heat transfer analyses they depend on public. Did you ever read the article Performance-based fire protection of office buildings: A case study based on the collapse of WTC 7? It is on-line here http://www.challengejournal.com/index.php/cjsmec/article/view/36
No.

Face it, the NIST, ARUP, and WAI reports on WTC 7 all have fatal flaws and are nothing but crapola being foisted on the public.
Face it, Harrit et al has fatal flaws and is nothing but crapola being foisted on the public.
Face it, all the AE911Truth talking points have fatal flaws and are nothing but crapola being foisted on the public.
Face it, your CD theory doesn't exist - and if it did, you know it would have fatal flaws. Remember thze question you quoted, which I bold-faced and colored red? You ignored it:
There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!
 
Heck, no one has even really answered the question of "Where is tfk?", so we can't even say what his state is in the debate. Did he end up in the hospital, prison, alien abduction? Don't know.

I thought I remembered TFK mentioning he was on vacation or was in a place where internet access was hard to come by. I imagine he was with his wife on vacation or something and she got pissed at him for spending time arguing on the internet, so he promised her never to argue on the internet again.
 
In this photo, you can see serious damage on the high face of the south wall of WTC 7. The rest of the damage is obscured by heavy smoke.


[qimg]http://911myths.com/assets/images/news_wtc7_1.jpg[/qimg]


Take a look at the next photo and notice that the south wall of WTC 7 faced WTC 1 when it collapsed.


[qimg]http://911myths.com/assets/images/WTC7Hit1.jpg[/qimg]

Right, that's the straight line down the middle representing a single column that came off.

Most of what you're seeing in that photo is dust. Only a few pieces of steel were flung far enough to even touch WTC 7.
 
Went on vacation and came back and see Oystein has taken up the torch of keeping everyone honest on the temperatures in NIST WTC 7 report. Great.

I can also confirm Tony's point re the availability of the Bailey report. I've scrubbed the case docket and appellate record and it was never filed with the court. The only way to obtain it now would be if he were willing to share it. I wouldn't mind asking for it, but, in my experience, people who have been involved in litigations have serious reservations about providing documents related to those litigations to random lawyers who claim to be evaluating conspiracy theories. Maybe Tony or another engineer here could reach out and ask for it? I'm sure Mick would host it at Metabunk to make it widely available to anyone if it can be obtained.

Still in a good mood from vacation, so I'll leave it at that.
 
From what I understand the Weidlinger report was never entered into the court record, by order of the court, so Abboud's and Beyler's reports would not have been available to the plaintiffs.

Benthamitemetric is a lawyer who posts here and on Metabunk and he has been able to get other items involved in the case, such as the ARUP expert and Weidlinger reports on WTC 7. I have asked him for the Beyler 2010 analysis referenced by Abboud. He has thus far not been able to attain it from what he says.

Are you a mechanical or civil engineer? rwguinn claimed to be and talked with the jargon of one.

A lawyer with no legal interest in the documents in question.

You ask that persons examining your work be mech, or civil (isn't that roads and bridges?) engineer. I assume so that they will be able to render an informed opinion of your work.

So, you must see the issue here, correct?

If you want to see the Beyler analysis then you will may have to a ) show you have legal interest in it, and/or b ) that you, or the requesting organization, are qualified to render an opinion on it.
I asked upthread if AE911T has a fire sciences engineer in it's number. I received no reply to that question.

You have unequivocally declared that the Beyler analysis of the fires in WTC7 is "ridiculous", yet you do this sight unseen. You do this despite having no qualifications to render an opinion on this unseen report, and certainly no qualifications equaling those of the authors of that report.
 
Last edited:
The truth is Nordenson's error invalidates the ARUP conclusion that WTC 7 collapsed due to fire.

No it doesn't! How anyone can declare that with a straight face is astounding to me.

It may invalidate the floor failure due to impact of one girder under the specific conditions of the FEA. THAT is as far as you can go with that.

It most certainly does not invalidate all mechanisms of collapse due to fire.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom