does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

I asked for facts.
You keep handing back opinion.
Show us the load conditions and boundary conditions that apply to the situation you "analyzed"

Don't fall for Tony's false bit of minutia.

The initial failure point and details of it's failure are less important than the fact that multiple floor failures will lead to a progression to global involvement.

Tony has set himself up as the preeminent expert not only in forensic structural engineering, but also in fire sciences, and, when he gets around to it, explosive demoltions.
 
Every single comprehensive report promoting structural failure of WTC 7 promotes a sudden onset of collapse.
Really? Got a few quotes to back that up?

Meanwhile, demolition theorists have been saying for years that WTC 7 may have been gradually weakened before the final collapse event, using witnesses and recordings of loud explosions from the area as evidence.
,,, and yet absolutely no complete scenario put forth. Nothing but mere handwaving and hysterics.

I don't know why the building moved a little 90 seconds or 6 seconds before the East Penthouse fell. Why don't you explain it? Either you admit all of the mainstream materials are incomplete or you are forced to say that was a coincidence not related to the actual collapse.
It is indicative of internal failures. Either you come up with a scenario that accounts for all the observed behaviour up to global collapse or admit you have nothing but a handwaving, hairbrained contention that doesn't even rise to the level of "theory".
 
From what I understand, isn't Boyle's statements (or this interpretation of his statements) literally the only evidence for a large amount of damage to the middle of the south face? That would be contradicted by several others who only noted the southwest corner gash. Consider also the column missing down the middle.

There is at least one indisputable photograph.

Well, indisputable to people who aren't dishonest hacks anyway.

Go find it.
 
Don't fall for Tony's false bit of minutia.

The initial failure point and details of it's failure are less important than the fact that multiple floor failures will lead to a progression to global involvement.

Tony has set himself up as the preeminent expert not only in forensic structural engineering, but also in fire sciences, and, when he gets around to it, explosive demoltions.

As I said before, and often:
Tony sets it up as You're wrong I'm right when a joint failure leads to collapse, and the consensus is that the joint failed.
His trick is "You're wrong! It wasn't the joint that failed, but Rivet#2 in the 6 Rivet pattern failed which caused the other 5 to overload! Therefore, explosives and CD!"
and he won't even telly you which one is #2... Pun intended....
 
I agree. Have tried for years to get the CD crowd to provide specifics. Not going to happen.

Tony ignores any request to present his explanation in detail. Pretty clear why he hasn't.


I would like to read Tony's CD explanation as well and have him explain why there is no sound of CD explosions in the 130-140 decibel range as WTC 7 collapsed and why no CD hardware evidence was ever found.

I would also like for Tony to explain in detail, how CD explosives could have been planted secretly within WTC 7.
 
From what I understand, isn't Boyle's statements (or this interpretation of his statements) literally the only evidence for a large amount of damage to the middle of the south face?



No. There were others who commented on the massive damage on the south wall.


That would be contradicted by several others who only noted the southwest corner gash. Consider also the column missing down the middle.


Not in this case. Let's take a look here.


Captain Varriale told Chief Coloe and myself that 7 World Trade Center was badly damaged on the south side and definitely in danger of collapse. Chief Coloe said we were going to evacuate the collapse zone around 7 World Trade Center, which we did.

http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/nyregion/20050812_WTC_GRAPHIC/9110462.PDF
 
Every single comprehensive report promoting structural failure of WTC 7 promotes a sudden onset of collapse.

Meanwhile, demolition theorists have been saying for years that WTC 7 may have been gradually weakened before the final collapse event, using witnesses and recordings of loud explosions from the area as evidence.


There were no explosions heard as WTC 7 collapsed and I have already provided video and audio proof as well. Explosions in New York City are nothing new and in fact, over 2000 explosions occur in New York City each year.


I don't know why the building moved a little 90 seconds or 6 seconds before the East Penthouse fell. Why don't you explain it? E


It's because fires raging out of control were weakening its steel structure.
 
Last edited:
Let's look at a few examples as to why AE911Truth cannot be taken seriously considering its continuous deceptive practices and outright lies.


[qimg]http://gallery.mailchimp.com/d03bf3ffcac549c7dc7888ef5/images/2a243048-e327-4425-a904-994753f66e32.jpg[/qimg]


Now, for the rest of the story on how those cuts were made.


[qimg]http://www.debunking911.com/cut.jpg[/qimg]


Videos

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DdBv7uaQT_0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eBXZOGc-DOg

Does everyone here believe that lances were used to cut columns during clean up?
 
Does everyone here believe that lances were used to cut columns during clean up?

Seeing as skyeagle409 provided clear and dramatic photo and video evidence to support that claim, yes.

You missed the part where he also provided evidence that Ae911Truth was trying to pass these types of cuts off as "thermite."

Does anyone here believe that thermite was used to cut columns during execution of an unspecified "controlled demolition" for which no evidence exists?
 
Does everyone here believe that lances were used to cut columns during clean up?
I see Dave beat me to the post by a couple of minutes. :thumbsup:

Naturally I cannot speak for "..everyone here.." minus 1.

But even before we turn to the evidence I would never doubt it. They are the tool of first choice in a clear up of large bits of steel.

It would take a lot of good argument to convince me that the tool of first choice was NOT used.


Then thank AE911 for some evidence. The picture linked from AE911 is conclusive - oxy-acetylene cut columns of very large sized bits of steel which you wouldn't try cutting with lesser scale gear.


The AE911 comparison with an explosive cutting method - the sort of thing you expect in the AE911 push to fool gullible people but --- seriously -- AFAIK there are no explosive cutting charges that have the added benefit for truthers of leaving oxy cutting slag behind.
 
Last edited:
Does everyone here believe that lances were used to cut columns during clean up?
You were fooled by 9/11 truth lies.

In your fantasy version, the cuts made after 9/11 were made with what? In your fantasy. Got evidence for CD? No. Ask questions, give answers. Why is science banned for 9/11 truth followers.
 
I asked for facts.
You keep handing back opinion.
Show us the load conditions and boundary conditions that apply to the situation you "analyzed"

That wasn't opinion, the load and boundary conditions were explained, and there were more than enough facts about the analyses given to show that both the NIST and ARUP hypotheses are impossible and their explanations for the collapse of WTC 7 invalid.

I would say you simply don't like the reality of the situation and were hoping you could find something wrong. Your lack of ability to throw anything but carping words makes it quite clear that you couldn't.

You seem to just want to waste my time. The only way to deal with someone like you is in front of a judge where you would be penalized for your unjustified obstinance.
 
Last edited:
Does everyone here believe that lances were used to cut columns during clean up?

The patent for the Thermal Lances, by thermitic lance that were used.
http://www.google.com/patents/US5472174

They produce the same residue, and Microspheres as thermite.

Basicly because they use the thermite reaction inside the steel tube, they were still new in 2001, and several were donated to the clean up effort, by the company.

The company changed the name from thermitic lance to something else because of the idiot
Cters.

A photo of the very column being cut inhanced only to show the beginning of the 45% cut.

diagonalcut-112_zpsdnvca0tm.jpg


Of course I understand Ziggi has me on ignore, to bad he might have learned something.
 
Seeing as skyeagle409 provided clear and dramatic photo and video evidence to support that claim, yes.

You missed the part where he also provided evidence that Ae911Truth was trying to pass these types of cuts off as "thermite."

Does anyone here believe that thermite was used to cut columns during execution of an unspecified "controlled demolition" for which no evidence exists?

Thermite or thermate charges cutting that column underload diagonally, violates the laws of physics, so I don't see how it would even be possible.

You are talking even with oxygen of heating the steel way past it's kindling temperature,
With any substantial loading, a large amount is thermal distortion mushrooming would have to occur.

Jones wanted to test residues because he knew he would find evidence of thermite cutting,
Because thermitic lances were used in the clean up.

Tony knows or should have legitamate reason to know, Jones and his cohorts at AE/911 truth are frauds, yet says nothing, about it.
 
No. There were others who commented on the massive damage on the south wall.

Not in this case. Let's take a look here.

You are postulating a giant gash in the middle of the south wall, even though we only have evidence of the southwest corner gash and a single column missing down the middle. Do you have specific evidence for any damage worse than that?
 
Last edited:
Does everyone here believe that lances were used to cut columns during clean up?
Nice change of subject. Somebody shoes you a picture of that which you deny exists, and you use it to go to the aftermath.
Answer the *********** question: Was there massive damage to that wall or not?
 
You are postulating a giant gash in the middle of the south wall, even though we only have evidence of the southwest corner gash and a single column missing down the middle. Do you have specific evidence for any damage worse than that?

Your Google broken?

There is no excuse except willful ignorance for you to have missed the image.

Go find it.
 
Your Google broken?

There is no excuse except willful ignorance for you to have missed the image.

Go find it.

I give up. What photograph are the referring to?

Of course, this is all meaningless because none of the damage that could've occurred on the south side could be a contributing factor to the collapse.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom