does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

I give up. What photograph are the referring to?

Of course, this is all meaningless because none of the damage that could've occurred on the south side could be a contributing factor to the collapse.

The one that shows the gash in the center of the south side of the building.

Amazing such an accomplished sleuth can't find the one image that contradicts you.

Strange, that.

Hey! How many planes crashed on 9/11? Your hero is proving too cowardly to answer. Maybe you cash help?
 
That wasn't opinion, the load and boundary conditions were explained, and there were more than enough facts about the analyses given to show that both the NIST and ARUP hypotheses are impossible and their explanations for the collapse of WTC 7 invalid.

I would say you simply don't like the reality of the situation and were hoping you could find something wrong. Your lack of ability to throw anything but carping words makes it quite clear that you couldn't.
What "reality of the situation "
You have shown nothing. I asked for this:

you give
I did an FEA with the girder on its seats at column 79 and column 44 with contact interfaces considering the bolts to the seats broken due to thermal expansion. The gravity load on the girder was a uniform load of 130 kips. The modulus of elasticity was that of ASTM A572 steel at 29 x 10e6 psi. The girder was shifted to the west to put its web past the edge of the seat incrementally to see what the stress on the flange was. With the web off the seat the flange stress was about 7,000 psi. It certainly wasn't going anywhere with the ASTM A572 grade used having a yield strength of 50 ksi. Even if it was at 500 C with a 30% loss of yield strength the yield strength would still be 35 ksi. The 18" long 5/16" fillet welds on both sides of the 18" tall x 3/4" thick girder stiffeners were also checked to see if they could transfer a 65 kip shear load from the web. They did that easily with a shear stress of about 8,200 psi on the welds.
Which tells exactly nothing.
You seem to just want to waste my time. The only way to deal with someone like you is in front of a judge where you would be penalized for your unjustified obstinance.
Hey: You're asking me to stamp and sign an analysis you have/can not explain. Won't even show me a bloody results plot, much less the .bdf so I can look at the validity.
And you want me to put my name on the thing? Not ;likely--it's my PE license and my name. I'm the one who gets sued when it turns to crap
 

Attachments

  • Freebody.jpg
    Freebody.jpg
    27.2 KB · Views: 4
What "reality of the situation "
You have shown nothing. I asked for this:
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_10695863c49b28dbd.jpg[/qimg]
you give Which tells exactly nothing.

Hey: You're asking me to stamp and sign an analysis you have/can not explain. Won't even show me a bloody results plot, much less the .bdf so I can look at the validity.
And you want me to put my name on the thing? Not ;likely--it's my PE license and my name. I'm the one who gets sued when it turns to crap

You really are being silly now. I told you the load was a 130 kip uniform load on the girder, that the bolts were broken and the girder was sitting on its seats at columns 44 and 79 with a contact interface. You didn't get your free body diagram right as you put a concentrated load on it and with the bolts broken there would be no side reactions.

Like I said, the only way to deal with someone like you is in front of a judge where you would be penalized for being obstinate.

If you PM me with your e-mail I will send you results.
 
Last edited:
I give up. What photograph are the referring to?

Of course, this is all meaningless because none of the damage that could've occurred on the south side could be a contributing factor to the collapse.

So you don't think that the lack of one corner of the structure would contribute at all to the collapse, in any way? :rolleyes:
 
You really are being silly now. I told you the load was a 130 kip uniform load on the girder, that the bolts were broken and the girder was sitting on its seats at columns 44 and 79 with a contact interface. You didn't get your free body diagram right as you put a concentrated load on it and with the bolts broken there would be no side reactions.
okay:


Like I said, the only way to deal with someone like you is in front of a judge where you would be penalized for being obstinate.

If you PM me with your e-mail I will send you results.

Not bloody likely. Share it so we can all see it. Even I have been known to miss things on occasion.
 
Says the guy who refuses to answer a simple question, because he can't fake-math his way out of it.

Most people would understand why I generally don't feel a need to answer nincompoop questions like "how many planes crashed on 911?" or nincompoop comments like "if you can't give a complete alternative scenario you can't criticize the official story".
 
Last edited:
I have asked Tony, Criteria, and others, including you iirc, how such a debate would further the agenda of the truth movement and AE911T. My exact wording, in case you missed the half dozen or more times I posted it here, concerns how said agenda has been furthered by tfk having withdrawn.
Oddly while you and others continue to derail into technical debate within this thread, not a soul has addressed my questions.
I'll make it easy on Tony.
Here you go, name, email and phone number ( the above mentioned 11 digit code that can be used in that app on your phone) for information on fire analysis.
http://www.jensenhughes.com/engineering-services/forensic-engineering-litigation-support/

Like I said, the only way to deal with someone like you is in front of a judge where you would be penalized for being obstinate.
:id:
 
Last edited:
The patent for the Thermal Lances, by thermitic lance that were used.
http://www.google.com/patents/US5472174

They produce the same residue, and Microspheres as thermite.

Basicly because they use the thermite reaction inside the steel tube, they were still new in 2001, and several were donated to the clean up effort, by the company.

The company changed the name from thermitic lance to something else because of the idiot
Cters.

A photo of the very column being cut inhanced only to show the beginning of the 45% cut.

[qimg]http://i271.photobucket.com/albums/jj132/chainsawprof/diagonalcut-112_zpsdnvca0tm.jpg[/qimg]

Of course I understand Ziggi has me on ignore, to bad he might have learned something.

So far as I know I am not on Ignore so here Ziggi, have some free edumecatium. :D
 
If you won't give me your e-mail address then why don't you have a one-on-one discussion with me on the 911 free forum? The limit on uploads here is too low for me to show the results here. The 911 free forum has a much higher limit.

Tony how can someone trust your work on faith value, when you know Jones & Harrit misrepresented the average concentration of Microspheres, in 130 west Liberty as an average for the total concentration for the whole event, and said nothing?

Your a mechanical engineer shouldn't you have corrected that error?
 
Tony how can someone trust your work on faith value, when you know Jones & Harrit misrepresented the average concentration of Microspheres, in 130 west Liberty as an average for the total concentration for the whole event, and said nothing?

Your a mechanical engineer shouldn't you have corrected that error?

Sure about that?

I'm not.
 
Like I said, the only way to deal with someone like you is in front of a judge where you would be penalized for being obstinate.


And like others have said, the only way to change current perception of "what really happened" from an engineering perspective would be to prepare and publish an actual peer-reviewed paper in a relevant, major publication (JONES doesn't count).

Why are you wasting your time here?
 
Dropbox
Google Drive

Considering that the .bdf (Bulk Data File) for a 60,000 degree-of-freedom model is only 197k, (Includes a fair number of CHEXA, CQUAD4 elements, along with PATRAN's idiotic "a property card for every element), I'm not sure what his problem is, other than hiding something.
at any rate, since he can't even seem to show the restraints and loads, or even the configuration, I'm done with him.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom