does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

You know, it can be really difficult to cope with being wrong. But to be proven wrong by some anonymous internet guy, man that must really suck.

What are you crowing about? For years most of the posters here (including you) supported the NIST explanation for the collapse of WTC 7 until it was proven invalid due to girder trapping on the column 79 side plate preventing westward travel and the stiffener omission which would prevent the flange from failing even if the web was past the seat.

The ARUP report has been also been proven wrong due to Nordenson's use of an infinite stiffness for the falling beam and girder assembly. They can't even break through the next floor down. This issue actually proves both the NIST WTC 7 report and ARUP experts report are invalid explanations for the collapse of WTC 7.

We are looking at the Weidlinger report right now and the extreme steel temperatures claimed aren't explained. They only reference Beyler 2010. NIST and Weiidlinger have vast differences in their analysis temperatures at the 9th and 10th floors on the east side of the building where Weidlinger claims the collapse initiated. NIST says the steel on those floors was about 500C and Weidilinger says it was about 850C. Who do you think is right?
 
Last edited:
What are you crowing about? For years most of the posters here (including you) supported the NIST explanation for the collapse of WTC 7 until it was proven invalid due to girder trapping on the column 79 side plate preventing westward travel and the stiffener omission which would prevent the flange from failing even if the web was past the seat.

The ARUP report has been also been proven wrong due to Nordenson's use of an infinite stiffness for the falling beam and girder assembly. They can't even break through the next floor down. This issue actually proves both the NIST WTC 7 report and ARUP experts report are invalid explanations for the collapse of WTC 7.

We are looking at Weidlinger and the extreme steel temperatures claimed don't have an explanation in that report. They only reference Beyler 2010.

Self-proclaimed victory?

NIST showed a plausible mechanism for collapse, as have others. You had a quibble with it, didn't fully show your work, and there it rests.

As for me, well, I saw all sorts of evidence that a bunch of buildings collapsed after a terrorist attack and fires. Looked like the terrorist attack caused it. No one, including YOU, have shown any other cause or evidence. The evidence of the terrorist attack was sufficient according to a court of law to send a guy to jail. Whatcha got?
 
Last edited:
Hahahahahahahahahahaha :D:D:D






FAIL ;)
(What you describe there is not a restriction to a debate - it is an invitation to wander endlessly in an effort not to come to a conclusion)




I declare Tony Szamboti the LOSER of this thread - reason: false start.

I've already declared Tony the winner due solely to the fact that the last time I checked, none of you were willing to take him up on his challenge and debate him in a non-safe space and withstand his intellectual micro-aggressions. Junior J-Men BIG FAIL!!!!!
 
Self-proclaimed victory?

NIST showed a plausible mechanism for collapse, as have others. You had a quibble with it, didn't fully show your work, and there it rests.

As for me, well, I saw all sorts of evidence that a bunch of buildings collapsed after a terrorist attack and fires. Looked like the terrorist attack caused it. No one, including YOU, have shown any other cause or evidence. The evidence of the terrorist attack was sufficient according to a court of law to send a guy to jail. Whatcha got?

I didn't just have a quibble. The stiffeners on girder A2001 stop the flange from folding as NIST claimed, as the section modulus with the stiffeners is 89 times what it is without them and the stress would only be about 7,000 psi with the web 3 inches past the seat. They can't even get to that point though, as the girder gets trapped behind the column 79 west side plate after a few inches of travel and Colin Bailey of ARUP showed that. The NIST WTC 7 report is crapola and you have to know it. You are just pretending by saying tongue and cheek that they provided a plausible mechanism. In reality it has no chance of occurring.

I proved Nordenson had a fatal flaw with his infinite stiffness beam and girder assembly and showed they can't even break through the next floor down, so column 79 never loses lateral support and doesn't buckle.

You can't use either of those reports to explain the collapse of WTC 7. The one who should be being asked "whatcha got?" is you. So what do you use now to explain the collapse of WTC 7 in a grown up world?
 
Last edited:
I didn't just have a quibble. The stiffeners on girder A2001 stop the flange from folding as NIST claimed, as the section modulus with the stiffeners is 89 times what it is without them and the stress would only be about 7,000 psi with the web 3 inches past the seat. They can't even get to that point though, as the girder gets trapped behind the column 79 west side plate after a few inches of travel and Colin Bailey of ARUP showed that. The NIST WTC 7 report is crapola and you have to know it. You are just pretending by saying tongue and cheek that they provided a plausible mechanism. In reality it has no chance of occurring.

I proved Nordenson had a fatal flaw with his infinite stiffness beam and girder assembly and showed they can't even break through the next floor down, so column 79 never loses lateral support and doesn't buckle.

You can't use either of those reports to explain the collapse of WTC 7. The one who should be being asked "whatcha got?" is you. So what do you use now to explain the collapse of WTC 7 in a grown up world?

Great. Now please stop messing about and get on with it - explaining in detail how it really went down.

I for one would be happy to grant you that none of the extant reports got it precisely right if you would just finally answer the above.
 
I've already declared Tony the winner due solely to the fact that the last time I checked, none of you were willing to take him up on his challenge and debate him in a non-safe space and withstand his intellectual micro-aggressions. Junior J-Men BIG FAIL!!!!!

Yet, I requested Tony to start a new thread to outline his CD explanation in detail. He has failed to do that. His stance is NIST is wrong. Where is his detailed explanation and evidence of CD?

I have also asked CD supports to explain why there is still no one concise CD explanation regarding 9/11. Prager believes he is correct is was mini neutron bombs for example. Tony does not accept the nuke explanation. But even Prager's explain lacks the details of how it was done.
 
Tony, will you post your detailed explanation on the CD of WTC7 with links to documentation to support it. Your CD theory needs to stand on its own merits. You have ruled out fire. Therefore NIST doesn't matter in your explanation. So it is past time for you to show what you got.
(Of course we all know a properly carried out CD can take a building down. It is all the details you fail to provide that weakens your theory).
 
It's all very simple: Tony (and CT's in general) knows that if they give a positive, testable hypothesis for CD, it would be subject to scrutiny, in a similar way they are scrutinizing every existing technical report about the collapses.

The easy way out is NOT to EVER give a testable hypothesis.
 
I didn't just have a quibble. The stiffeners on girder A2001 stop the flange from folding as NIST claimed, as the section modulus with the stiffeners is 89 times what it is without them and the stress would only be about 7,000 psi with the web 3 inches past the seat. They can't even get to that point though, as the girder gets trapped behind the column 79 west side plate after a few inches of travel and Colin Bailey of ARUP showed that. The NIST WTC 7 report is crapola and you have to know it. You are just pretending by saying tongue and cheek that they provided a plausible mechanism. In reality it has no chance of occurring.

I proved Nordenson had a fatal flaw with his infinite stiffness beam and girder assembly and showed they can't even break through the next floor down, so column 79 never loses lateral support and doesn't buckle.

You can't use either of those reports to explain the collapse of WTC 7. The one who should be being asked "whatcha got?" is you. So what do you use now to explain the collapse of WTC 7 in a grown up world?
You can't even draw a free-body diagram
You're no engineer, and certainly have no clue about what matters and what does not.
 
You can't even draw a free-body diagram
You're no engineer, and certainly have no clue about what matters and what does not.

A free body diagram of what? Just saying draw a free body diagram isn't specific enough for someone to even know what you want.

I asked you before and you didn't answer.

As far as being an engineer I have a degree and 30 years of experience having worked for General Electric, RCA, BAE Systems, and Lockheed Martin. It really doesn't matter what you say there. Let's see if you can describe what you want in a free body diagram and if it has any pertinence to the discussion.
 
Last edited:
I didn't just have a quibble. The stiffeners on girder A2001 stop the flange from folding as NIST claimed, as the section modulus with the stiffeners is 89 times what it is without them and the stress would only be about 7,000 psi with the web 3 inches past the seat. They can't even get to that point though, as the girder gets trapped behind the column 79 west side plate after a few inches of travel and Colin Bailey of ARUP showed that. The NIST WTC 7 report is crapola and you have to know it. You are just pretending by saying tongue and cheek that they provided a plausible mechanism. In reality it has no chance of occurring.

I proved Nordenson had a fatal flaw with his infinite stiffness beam and girder assembly and showed they can't even break through the next floor down, so column 79 never loses lateral support and doesn't buckle.

You can't use either of those reports to explain the collapse of WTC 7. The one who should be being asked "whatcha got?" is you. So what do you use now to explain the collapse of WTC 7 in a grown up world?
You SAY you don't just have a quibble. Your own word on your own complaints is nothing.

Your studies are nothing on the scale of any of these reports. No professional bodies have weighed them on an equal basis, maybe because your AE911 hasn't done squat with the burnt offerings from it's worshippers to produce anything of equal weight. Say, where exactly is the position of each column, girder and beam just prior to collapse?

I use the Zacarias Moussaoui trial. I have seen pretty definitive evidence that 4 planes were hijacked and flown into buildings and the ground, and that two of the buildings collapsed and there was flaming debris scattered all around, including on cars and other buildings, causing even more widespread damage. 15 years ago.

So who'd you convict? Got anything beyond your own engineeringly noodlings?

There really is nothing to debate until you do. And your admirers opinion of that doesn't change things, even admirers who have a pathological hatred of "debunkers".
 
A free body diagram of what? Just saying draw a free body diagram isn't specific enough for someone to even know what you want.

I asked you before and you didn't answer.

As far as being an engineer I have a degree and 30 years of experience having worked for General Electric, RCA, BAE Systems, and Lockheed Martin. It really doesn't matter what you say there. Let's see if you can describe what you want in a free body diagram and if it has any pertinence to the discussion.

I didn't just have a quibble. The stiffeners on girder A2001 stop the flange from folding as NIST claimed, as the section modulus with the stiffeners is 89 times what it is without them and the stress would only be about 7,000 psi with the web 3 inches past the seat. They can't even get to that point though, as the girder gets trapped behind the column 79 west side plate after a few inches of travel and Colin Bailey of ARUP showed that. The NIST WTC 7 report is crapola and you have to know it. You are just pretending by saying tongue and cheek that they provided a plausible mechanism. In reality it has no chance of occurring.



I proved Nordenson had a fatal flaw with his infinite stiffness beam and girder assembly and showed they can't even break through the next floor down, so column 79 never loses lateral support and doesn't buckle.
Lets see the free body that generates only 7ksi. Give the boundary conditions and applied loads, along with the "Correct" properties, as compared to the "Wrong" ones
Let's see the Applied loads and boundary conditions for the beam-floor load that doesn't break anything. Properties and dynamics (Mode shape and frequencies, as well as the Transient Function that generates the condition

You've been asked for anything along these lines before, and disappeared for 3 months afterwards.ETA : A source for the applied loads would be a good thing.
"I Guessed" is not a source.
 
Last edited:
Lets see the free body that generates only 7ksi. Give the boundary conditions and applied loads, along with the "Correct" properties, as compared to the "Wrong" ones
Let's see the Applied loads and boundary conditions for the beam-floor load that doesn't break anything. Properties and dynamics (Mode shape and frequencies, as well as the Transient Function that generates the condition

You've been asked for anything along these lines before, and disappeared for 3 months afterwards.

I never disappeared. You are talking out of your hat there.

I did an FEA with the girder on its seats at column 79 and column 44 with contact interfaces considering the bolts to the seats broken due to thermal expansion. The gravity load on the girder was a uniform load of 130 kips. The modulus of elasticity was that of ASTM A572 steel at 29 x 10e6 psi. The girder was shifted to the west to put its web past the edge of the seat incrementally to see what the stress on the flange was. With the web off the seat the flange stress was about 7,000 psi. It certainly wasn't going anywhere with the ASTM A572 grade used having a yield strength of 50 ksi. Even if it was at 500 C with a 30% loss of yield strength the yield strength would still be 35 ksi. The 18" long 5/16" fillet welds on both sides of the 18" tall x 3/4" thick girder stiffeners were also checked to see if they could transfer a 65 kip shear load from the web. They did that easily with a shear stress of about 8,200 psi on the welds.

The reason the NIST WTC 7 report left those stiffeners off was because they would prevent the flange from folding up once the web was past the seat. You do realize that don't you? Have you ever seen the drawing which shows the girder stiffeners that NIST omitted? It is Frankel drawing 9114.

The NIST girder walk-off issue is a static problem and there is no need for frequencies and mode shapes. They are needed for dynamic problems. I did do a frequency and mode shape analysis for the Nordenson issue to find the stiffness of the falling beam and girder assembly using Fn = 1/2pi x sqrt[k/m]. There the girder was seated on its column 44 seat with a contact interface and the beams were fixed to their seats at the north and east face since they were still bolted to their seats.
 
Last edited:
I never disappeared. You are talking out of your hat there.

I did an FEA with the girder on its seats at column 79 and column 44 with contact interfaces considering the bolts to the seats broken due to thermal expansion. The gravity load on the girder was a uniform load of 130 kips. The modulus of elasticity was that of ASTM A572 steel at 29 x 10e6 psi. The girder was shifted to the west to put its web past the edge of the seat incrementally to see what the stress on the flange was. With the web off the seat the flange stress was about 7,000 psi. It certainly wasn't going anywhere with the ASTM A572 grade used having a yield strength of 50 ksi. Even if it was at 500 C with a 30% loss of yield strength the yield strength would still be 35 ksi. The 18" long 5/16" fillet welds on both sides of the 18" tall x 3/4" thick girder stiffeners were also checked to see if they could transfer a 65 kip shear load from the web. They did that easily with a shear stress of about 8,200 psi on the welds.

The reason the NIST WTC 7 report left those stiffeners off was because they would prevent the flange from folding up once the web was past the seat. You do realize that don't you? Have you ever seen the drawing which shows the girder stiffeners that NIST omitted? It is Frankel drawing 9114.

The NIST girder walk-off issue is a static problem and there is no need for frequencies and mode shapes. They are needed for dynamic problems. I did do a frequency and mode shape analysis for the Nordenson issue to find the stiffness of the falling beam and girder assembly using Fn = 1/2pi x sqrt[k/m]. There the girder was seated on its column 44 seat with a contact interface and the beams were fixed to their seats at the north and east face since they were still bolted to their seats.
I asked for facts.
You keep handing back opinion.
Show us the load conditions and boundary conditions that apply to the situation you "analyzed"
 
What are you crowing about? For years most of the posters here (including you) supported the NIST explanation for the collapse of WTC 7 until it was proven invalid due to girder trapping on the column 79 side plate preventing westward travel and the stiffener omission which would prevent the flange from failing even if the web was past the seat.

The ARUP report has been also been proven wrong due to Nordenson's use of an infinite stiffness for the falling beam and girder assembly. They can't even break through the next floor down. This issue actually proves both the NIST WTC 7 report and ARUP experts report are invalid explanations for the collapse of WTC 7.
You called into question ONLY the initial failure beginning a progressive collapse sequence. The mechanism that is the most difficult to determine. Every engineering investifation concludes that the only probable cause of collapse initiation, the sole driver of such with any evidence whatsoever, is fire. Each engineering investigation also noted that their computer finite element analyses showed that multiple floor failures would create condition of unsupported columns, which in turn,,, well you know the rest.

We are looking at the Weidlinger report right now and the extreme steel temperatures claimed aren't explained. They only reference Beyler 2010. NIST and Weiidlinger have vast differences in their analysis temperatures at the 9th and 10th floors on the east side of the building where Weidlinger claims the collapse initiated. NIST says the steel on those floors was about 500C and Weidilinger says it was about 850C. Who do you think is right?

Yep. I posted the email and phone number for you. Stil waiting for you to tell us you have asked for that report. Quite a feather in your cap, a mechanical engineer, to prove a world renowned fire engineering expert wrong.
But
In
Order
To
Do
That
You
Will
Need
To
First
Ask
For
That
Report!!!!!
 
It's all very simple: Tony (and CT's in general) knows that if they give a positive, testable hypothesis for CD, it would be subject to scrutiny, in a similar way they are scrutinizing every existing technical report about the collapses.

The easy way out is NOT to EVER give a testable hypothesis.

I agree. Have tried for years to get the CD crowd to provide specifics. Not going to happen.

Tony ignores any request to present his explanation in detail. Pretty clear why he hasn't.
 
Last edited:
You are confused because you had posted damage of the southwest corner of WTC 7, not of the huge hole in the south wall of the building. Case in point:


It is obvious that Boyle is not referring to the damage on the southwest corner of WTC 7, he is referring to the south wall of the building. Another case in point:

From what I understand, isn't Boyle's statements (or this interpretation of his statements) literally the only evidence for a large amount of damage to the middle of the south face? That would be contradicted by several others who only noted the southwest corner gash. Consider also the column missing down the middle.
 
Hey, MicahJava!

Since you haven't provided any alternative explanation, and since we already know that there was fire, and that the collapse followed soon after, I guess the issue is settled once and for all that fire was the cause of the collapse, right?

Every single comprehensive report promoting structural failure of WTC 7 promotes a sudden onset of collapse.

Meanwhile, demolition theorists have been saying for years that WTC 7 may have been gradually weakened before the final collapse event, using witnesses and recordings of loud explosions from the area as evidence.

I don't know why the building moved a little 90 seconds or 6 seconds before the East Penthouse fell. Why don't you explain it? Either you admit all of the mainstream materials are incomplete or you are forced to say that was a coincidence not related to the actual collapse.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom