Tony Szamboti
Illuminator
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2007
- Messages
- 4,976
You know, it can be really difficult to cope with being wrong. But to be proven wrong by some anonymous internet guy, man that must really suck.
What are you crowing about? For years most of the posters here (including you) supported the NIST explanation for the collapse of WTC 7 until it was proven invalid due to girder trapping on the column 79 side plate preventing westward travel and the stiffener omission which would prevent the flange from failing even if the web was past the seat.
The ARUP report has been also been proven wrong due to Nordenson's use of an infinite stiffness for the falling beam and girder assembly. They can't even break through the next floor down. This issue actually proves both the NIST WTC 7 report and ARUP experts report are invalid explanations for the collapse of WTC 7.
We are looking at the Weidlinger report right now and the extreme steel temperatures claimed aren't explained. They only reference Beyler 2010. NIST and Weiidlinger have vast differences in their analysis temperatures at the 9th and 10th floors on the east side of the building where Weidlinger claims the collapse initiated. NIST says the steel on those floors was about 500C and Weidilinger says it was about 850C. Who do you think is right?
Last edited: