does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

That is NOT the south wall in your photo. Only the north and west walls are depicted and the south wall is NOT visible in the photo because the south wall is behind the north wall. Let's take a look at the following photo of the south wall to get you oriented and notice the plumes of smoke from the south wall.

[qimg]http://www.911myths.com/assets/images/db_images/db_Magnum1.jpg[/qimg]


The south wall and impact damage are hidden behind those plumes of smoke and what you'd posted was a photo of the north and west walls.

That gash in the corner visible in the photo I linked, and one column missing down the middle (seen here), is the most heavy damage to WTC 7. Any more extensive damage is most likely a myth.
 
The buckling of WTC 7 pretty much summed it up that fire was having a significant effect on its steel structure and the long duration of those fires also debunks the claim that explosives and/or thermite were responsible for the destruction of WTC 7.

There were no secondary explosions observed nor heard during the hours-long duration of those fires that could have been attributed to explosives. In addition, the WTC buildings did not collapse at free fall speed or collapse within their own footprints as evident by widespread damage inflicted on other buildings. In other words, the collapse of the WTC buildings was not typical of the way traditional CD operations are carried out.

* No CD explosions seen

* No CD explosions heard

* WTC buildings did not collapse at free-fall speed

* WTC buildings did not collapse within their footprints

* No CD hardware discovered within the WTC rubble

* No CD seismic data noted during the collapse of the WTC buildings

No one in government in their right mind would have used explosives during 9/11 as a false flag operation because explosives leave behind traceable physical evidence, and once again, there was no way the WTC buildings could have been properly pre-weakened and prepared for demolition in secret, otherwise, expect these results.


CD Gone Wrong

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XHcCbY2wY38


The fact that firefighters reported "creaking noises" from within WTC 7 should have been another clue that uncontrolled fires were having a significant effect on the structure of WTC 7. Furthermore, CD detonations sound like this:


Second Tallest Building ever imploded

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8U4erFzhC-U


Now, please point out to us, timelines where the sound of demolition explosions are heard as WTC 7 collapses in the following video and failing to do so will prove the point that the collapse of WTC 7 had nothing to do with explosives.


WTC 7 Collapse

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LD06SAf0p9A


WTC 5 suffered an internal collapse due solely to fire, so where's the claim that explosives were used in that collapse?


.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nEULui5-sEc
 
Weidlinger's choice to rely on an unavailable unpublished report to get a simulation showing extremely high temperature in Building 7 is even more interesting when it is considered that Weidlinger itself did a report on the WTC towers years ago that included an analysis of the fire conditions there. That Weidlinger report said the debris and dust from the jet impacts cut down the fire temperatures and limited the air temp to the 400 to 700C range, despite the often hyped loads of jet fuel. Yet now it is relying on a report that says B7 suffered extreme fires even though it lacked the jet fuel and had been smothered in fire suppressant debris and dust from the second tower crashing down that day.

What is up with you people and jet fuel?

Jet fuel is inconsequential to the temperature of the fires, the higher temperature fuel is carbon black.

I suggest Ziggi you actually do some research.
 
an illiterate insistence on "Pictorial evidence" allows one to drag a red herring through the conversation.
"Copy Paste errors" is the most egregious of those. It only applies if the words and figures don't agree, which is not the case here.
The Figures are used to illustrate a point made in the discussion. Tables are both raw data and results.
Having been involved with NASA reporting, and only on a "TM" (the lowest level of reports at NASA), the process is extremely rigorous. First you have department review, the an "Editorial Board" consisting of experts in the field who review every little thing (although they sometimes miss the overwhelmingly important stuff, like its and it's), and if the figures and tables don't agree with the body, you do it again.
Doing aircraft Certification Reports for Gulfstream, Bombardier, Embraer, and the Military is exceedingly tedious and nit-pickey, although less so than the inevitable incident and disaster reports.
Doing a design and analysis report for any Agency involves a lot of sessions answering lots of questions and defending a position against often hostile inquisition, making a Doctorate Thesis Defense seem as child's play.
You fake the data, it will get discovered and corrected (by someone else, because "You're Fired")
 
an illiterate insistence on "Pictorial evidence" allows one to drag a red herring through the conversation.
"Copy Paste errors" is the most egregious of those. It only applies if the words and figures don't agree, which is not the case here.
The Figures are used to illustrate a point made in the discussion. Tables are both raw data and results.
Having been involved with NASA reporting, and only on a "TM" (the lowest level of reports at NASA), the process is extremely rigorous. First you have department review, the an "Editorial Board" consisting of experts in the field who review every little thing (although they sometimes miss the overwhelmingly important stuff, like its and it's), and if the figures and tables don't agree with the body, you do it again.
Doing aircraft Certification Reports for Gulfstream, Bombardier, Embraer, and the Military is exceedingly tedious and nit-pickey, although less so than the inevitable incident and disaster reports.
Doing a design and analysis report for any Agency involves a lot of sessions answering lots of questions and defending a position against often hostile inquisition, making a Doctorate Thesis Defense seem as child's play.
You fake the data, it will get discovered and corrected (by someone else, because "You're Fired")

I agree, but we must also remember that things have changed greatly since 2008, the issue seems actually to be a soft ware glitch on reopened files before the 2010 update.
Looking at it with 2016 eyes and though 2016 programs might lead one into false arguments on an irrelevant issue.

After all they are only screen grabs on an ancient computer technology.
I mean they were from the looks of it using a conventional non flat screen monitor.
 
That gash in the corner visible in the photo I linked, and one column missing down the middle (seen here), is the most heavy damage to WTC 7. Any more extensive damage is most likely a myth.


You are confused because you had posted damage of the southwest corner of WTC 7, not of the huge hole in the south wall of the building. Case in point:


Boyle: There was a huge gaping hole and it was scattered throughout there. It was a huge hole. I would say it was probably about a third of it, right in the middle of it.
Boyle:...but then you looked on the south side of 7 there had to be a hole 20 stories tall in the building, with fire on several floors.



It is obvious that Boyle is not referring to the damage on the southwest corner of WTC 7, he is referring to the south wall of the building. Another case in point:


Hayden: early on, we saw a bulge in the southwest corner between floors 10 and 13, and we had put a transit on that and we were pretty sure she was going to collapse. You actually could see there was a visible bulge, it ran up about three floors.
 
Last edited:
There is no photographic evidence for either of the Twin Towers leaning. Any rumor of such could originate from the south face of WTC 1 bowing.

There is no photographic evidence for WTC 7 leaning. Any rumor of such could originate from the perimeter slightly warping from the heat of the fires, i.e. the bulge.

The collapses can not be explained as a consequence of these observations, because they're too insignificant, and you all know it.

I think you are on to something here and we should run with this to its logical conclusion.

There is no photographic evidence for collapse-initiating explosions in either of the Twin Towers. Any rumor of such could originate from the sound of the collapses themselves.

There is no photographic evidence for collapse-initiating explosions at WTC 7. Any rumor of such could originate from the sound of collapse itself.

The collapses can not be explained as a consequence of these out-of-context observations of explosions or things that sound like explosions, because they're too insignificant, and we all know it.

Therefore we can disregard all witness accounts of explosions.

Great, now that this is settled,....
 
You are confused because you had posted damage of the southwest corner of WTC 7, not of the huge hole in the south wall of the building. Case in point:
MJ doesn't care. The objective is to sustain a narrative that all CT's refuse to identify. Why might it be that CT's are reluctant to identify whatever narrative they propose? Well, if CT's propose any narrative, CT's are on the hook to demonstrate the claimed narritive. Thus CT's avoid making ANY affirmative claims. They know they are stuffed as soon as they assert anything.

It is obvious that Boyle is not referring to the damage on the southwest corner of WTC 7, he is referring to the south wall of the building. Another case in point:
It matters not. CT's rely upon insinuation. One can insinuate anything.
 
That gash in the corner visible in the photo I linked, and one column missing down the middle (seen here), is the most heavy damage to WTC 7. Any more extensive damage is most likely a myth.

It's amazing how you know better than all the eyewitnesses about parts of the building that weren't photographed.

Dave
 
What is up with you people and jet fuel?

Jet fuel is inconsequential to the temperature of the fires, the higher temperature fuel is carbon black.

I suggest Ziggi you actually do some research.

Some very ill informed truthers use the meme of jet fuel fires. It is quite telling that someone who should know better, our Ziggi here, would stoop to such stupid argument.
The jet fuel was a fire accelerant. It caused large areas of office space on several contiguous floors to ignite within a few seconds.
That is a fire condition that is basically unknown in common circumstances. These were obviously not common circumstances.
Truthers simply ignore all this because it is inconvenient to their world view.
 
... fire temperatures and limited the air temp to the 400 to 700C range, despite the often hyped loads of jet fuel. Yet now it is relying on a report that says B7 suffered extreme fires even though it lacked the jet fuel and had been smothered in fire suppressant debris and dust from the second tower crashing down that day.
You don't know much about fire. The jet fuel had the heat energy of 315 tons of TNT, the office fires in the towers Before collapse were equal in heat energy to more than 2,700 Tons of tnt; do you want that in joules or can you understand energy in tnt? Do you do any science, or is this all based on BS you read from 9/11 truth.

Fire did it, and you offer zero evidence for CD, or some inside job. Unfought fires. You offer no other high rise fires not fought, or with fires systems broke by a major terrorists event. You have no science to back up your cut and past attack on a report you don't comprehend for goals, or purpose. Make NIST a scapegoat? Why? Present your evidence for CD... oops, you failed. Better luck with Bigfoot.

Get over the jet fuel, it is insignificant compared to the office contents burning. The jet fuel in the towers started the biggest office fires in history, burning for weeks. ignore fire, it makes your argument more fantasy based nonsense.
 
I think you are on to something here and we should run with this to its logical conclusion.

There is no photographic evidence for collapse-initiating explosions in either of the Twin Towers. Any rumor of such could originate from the sound of the collapses themselves.

There is no photographic evidence for collapse-initiating explosions at WTC 7. Any rumor of such could originate from the sound of collapse itself.

The collapses can not be explained as a consequence of these out-of-context observations of explosions or things that sound like explosions, because they're too insignificant, and we all know it.

Therefore we can disregard all witness accounts of explosions.

Great, now that this is settled,....

Take it all the way:

We have no photographic evidence of explosives. Explosives are most likely a myth.

Thanks MicahJava, all settled now. See you later at the JFK discussion, where there is no photographic evidence of any other shooter.
 
Weidlinger's choice to rely on an unavailable unpublished report to get a simulation showing extremely high temperature in Building 7 is even more interesting when it is considered that Weidlinger itself did a report on the WTC towers years ago that included an analysis of the fire conditions there. That Weidlinger report said the debris and dust from the jet impacts cut down the fire temperatures and limited the air temp to the 400 to 700C range, despite the often hyped loads of jet fuel. Yet now it is relying on a report that says B7 suffered extreme fires even though it lacked the jet fuel and had been smothered in fire suppressant debris and dust from the second tower crashing down that day.

You wouldn't have a link for that earlier Weidlinger report would you?

You did make me chuckle though, had they used a fire study of the towers to determine fire conditions in #7 you would be crying foul, that there was no reason to expect fire to behave exactly the same in all buildings.

Btw, how many windows on the north, east and west sides were broken?
You might wonder what the difference would be wrt dust and debris, between impact of a 500mph, 150,000 kilo aircraft, and that of 2-5 ton steel moving at 30-50 kph

Jennings and Hess did not report dust and debris until lower in the building.
 
Last edited:
Weidlinger's choice to rely on an unavailable unpublished report to get a simulation showing extremely high temperature in Building 7 is even more interesting when it is considered that Weidlinger itself did a report on the WTC towers years ago that included an analysis of the fire conditions there. That Weidlinger report said the debris and dust from the jet impacts cut down the fire temperatures and limited the air temp to the 400 to 700C range, despite the often hyped loads of jet fuel. Yet now it is relying on a report that says B7 suffered extreme fires even though it lacked the jet fuel and had been smothered in fire suppressant debris and dust from the second tower crashing down that day.
Not everything is available on the internet. However your smart phone has an app that allows you to enter an easily found 11 digit code beginning with 1, that can put you in real time voice communication with almost any organization of specific individuual in the USA or Canada. Slightly different codes and that extends to the entire world.
You could try using that app to request the Weidlinger fire study of WTC7, or you can continue to cry and kvetch that it isn't available.

Try to guess which way I believe you and Szamboti will go with that.
 
How about you tell us who you are first to make sure you can understand.

When you request the fire study used by Weidlinger, be sure to include your bona fides so that they can determine if you are capable of understanding it.


,,,,,,,, oh who am I trying to kid,,, you won't be requesting that report. You prefer baldly asserting that it's in error.
 
When you request the fire study used by Weidlinger, be sure to include your bona fides so that they can determine if you are capable of understanding it.


,,,,,,,, oh who am I trying to kid,,, you won't be requesting that report. You prefer baldly asserting that it's in error.

You know, it can be really difficult to cope with being wrong. But to be proven wrong by some anonymous internet guy, man that must really suck.
 
You know, it can be really difficult to cope with being wrong. But to be proven wrong by some anonymous internet guy, man that must really suck.
Maybe it will sting less if he contacts, and is proven wrong by, a respected, named expert in the field.

I'll make it easy on Tony.
Here you go, name, email and phone number ( the above mentioned 11 digit code that can be used in that app on your phone) for information on fire analysis.
http://www.jensenhughes.com/engineering-services/forensic-engineering-litigation-support/
CONTACT US TODAY:
Contact us today using our online form or by contacting one of our many regional branches. For specific questions regarding JENSEN HUGHES’ Fire Spread Analysis services, please contact:

Dan Gottuk, PhD
[email protected]
+1 410-737-8677
 
Last edited:
Hey, MicahJava!
I'm pretty sure it's the effect of fire warping the steel. If you have an alternative explanation, I'd be willing to hear it.
Since you haven't provided any alternative explanation, and since we already know that there was fire, and that the collapse followed soon after, I guess the issue is settled once and for all that fire was the cause of the collapse, right?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom