does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

So has Tony told us how many planes crashed on 9/11 yet?
I'd really like to educate him, but we can't get to step two until he acknowledges the absolute basics.

Come on man. Scared to figure out on your own how wrong you are?

Proving your cute theories wrong doesn't even require engineering.
 
Well, until somebody presents actual photographic evidence, quoting unsubstantiated witnesses saying either of the buildings were leaning should be off the table.
Because five and a half hours before the building collapsed, an engineer (identity unknown) told the fire chiefs that the building would collapse "in five or six hours".

I see what you did there.
 
Tony,

I understand that chatting with multiple opponents is straining, so perhaps you overlooked my post #701, as well as these discussion offers:

If you agree to commit to this standard, I'd be happy to discuss with you...
  • The Harrit et al (2009) study
  • AE911truth's proposal for a 2017 AIA resolution
  • Your own "arson+explosive CD" hypothesis for WTC7
Or, you could preemptively agree that all three have ommissions, make inaccurate or misleading claims, and are thus proven non-explanatory and bogus. :)

I think our discussion yesterday wasn't so bad - we both managed to change the respective other's mind a liiittle bit. Now let's look what track we were actually on, and what the original intention of this thread was - and decide who to reply to and who not based on that.
 
Tony,

I understand that chatting with multiple opponents is straining, so perhaps you overlooked my post #701, as well as these discussion offers:



I think our discussion yesterday wasn't so bad - we both managed to change the respective other's mind a liiittle bit. Now let's look what track we were actually on, and what the original intention of this thread was - and decide who to reply to and who not based on that.

Oystein, you know I believe all three reports on WTC 7 are non-explanatory and that those from NIST and ARUP have been shown to have fatal flaws which invalidate them.

The only one which has not yet been shown to be invalid in a demonstrative way is that from Weidlinger, although its extreme steel temperatures and lack of transparency on how those were arrived at points to an area which is very possibly invalid.

That is really the only thing left here for you and I to discuss. However, I have only looked at it in a cursory way so far and have said what I thought based on that, so we really can adjourn for now, unless you have more to say on it, although you did not seem to want to earlier.
 
Last edited:
You had no legitimate comments. I am afraid I can't say anything more than that you seem to be a blustery bs artist.

Said the man with no PE license, no SE license, and no knowledge of structural engineering.

I wish you the best Tony, but you are wasting your time, wasting your life, chasing a delusional idea have no evidence to support it. And would be impossible to be true.

Good luck on the rest of your life, but the truth movement is dead.
 
Said the man with no PE license, no SE license, and no knowledge of structural engineering.
and nothing other than bald assertions of "You're wrong therefore I am right", and who runs and hides when asked to exhibit his evidence
I wish you the best Tony, but you are wasting your time, wasting your life, chasing a delusional idea have no evidence to support it. And would be impossible to be true.

Good luck on the rest of your life, but the truth movement is dead.
I wish him well, but I hope that it never gets to a point where lives depend on his "engineering"
 
No photographic evidence, Skyeagle. Where are the pictures showing what you think your witnesses are saying?

Oh, and here's your "massive damage to the south wall of WTC 7":

[qimg]https://i.imgur.com/JCCkUln.jpg[/qimg]


That is NOT the south wall in your photo. Only the north and west walls are depicted and the south wall is NOT visible in the photo because the south wall is behind the north wall. Let's take a look at the following photo of the south wall to get you oriented and notice the plumes of smoke from the south wall.

db_Magnum1.jpg



The south wall and impact damage are hidden behind those plumes of smoke and what you'd posted was a photo of the north and west walls.
 
Last edited:
and nothing other than bald assertions of "You're wrong therefore I am right", and who runs and hides when asked to exhibit his evidence

I wish him well, but I hope that it never gets to a point where lives depend on his "engineering"

The Idea of lives depending on Tony even Scares me, and I take a running chainsaw to my own neck while blindfolded.
 
Last edited:
The Idea of lives depending on Tony even Scares me, and I take a running chainsaw to my own neck while blindfolded.

So here we have anonymous internet posters making unsupported negative comments about a known person. That doesn't sound ethical, but who says anonymous internet posters feel a need to be ethical.
 
That is NOT the south wall in your photo. Only the north and west walls are depicted and the south wall is NOT visible in the photo because the south wall is behind the north wall. Let's take a look at the following photo of the south wall to get you oriented and notice the plumes of smoke from the south wall.

[qimg]http://www.911myths.com/assets/images/db_images/db_Magnum1.jpg[/qimg]


The south wall and impact damage are hidden behind those plumes of smoke and what you'd posted was a photo of the north and west walls.

He did that on purpose. Can you imagine he actually thought that would go through?

LOL
 
So here we have anonymous internet posters making unsupported negative comments about a known person. That doesn't sound ethical, but who says anonymous internet posters feel a need to be ethical.

If you don't know who I am Tony, by now then that shows your deductive and reasoning skills are not up to the task of putting your shoes on your own feet let alone tying them.

I question your engineering ability for good reason, you call for a criminal investigation when you have not taken on the responsibility, and responsibilities, of doing an actual scientific or engineering investigation!

That does show flawed thinking, the unbiased scientific discovery must come first, you said nothing about the Lies, and Fraud of Jones & Harrit, or of AE/911Truth.

That calls into question your qualifications to do honest and trust worthy work.

It is not myself Tony that casts a shadow over you, it is yourself, I had no part in the dishonesty of Jones & Harrit, or of AE/911Truth.

You have too know Tony they are frauds yet you are totally silent on the subject.

The question is why would an honest engineering professional remain silent?
 
Last edited:
Ziggi, you are right in that we don't know how far the cutting and pasting went.

I think all three reports are bogus and the NIST and ARUP reports have been proven to be non-explanatory due to omissions and inaccurate claims.

Those still willing to believe WTC 7 somehow came down via fire are now forced to put their eggs in the Weidlinger basket, hoping it can withstand the scrutiny the other two reports couldn't. There their problem is that the temperatures Weidlinger needs/claims are extremely implausible, due to fuel load and time at temperature, and the likelihood of these extremes happening on two contiguous floors is ridiculously low. The large disagreement in temperatures between Weidlinger and NIST on floors 9 and 10 also show how nebulous the fire simulation and heat transfer analyses were.

Weidlinger's choice to rely on an unavailable unpublished report to get a simulation showing extremely high temperature in Building 7 is even more interesting when it is considered that Weidlinger itself did a report on the WTC towers years ago that included an analysis of the fire conditions there. That Weidlinger report said the debris and dust from the jet impacts cut down the fire temperatures and limited the air temp to the 400 to 700C range, despite the often hyped loads of jet fuel. Yet now it is relying on a report that says B7 suffered extreme fires even though it lacked the jet fuel and had been smothered in fire suppressant debris and dust from the second tower crashing down that day.
 
Those still willing to believe WTC 7 somehow came down via fire are now forced to put their eggs in the Weidlinger basket, hoping it can withstand the scrutiny the other two reports couldn't.


The buckling of WTC 7 pretty much summed it up that fire was having a significant effect on its steel structure and the long duration of those fires also debunks the claim that explosives and/or thermite were responsible for the destruction of WTC 7.

There were no secondary explosions observed nor heard during the hours-long duration of those fires that could have been attributed to explosives. In addition, the WTC buildings did not collapse at free fall speed or collapse within their own footprints as evident by widespread damage inflicted on other buildings. In other words, the collapse of the WTC buildings was not typical of the way traditional CD operations are carried out.

* No CD explosions seen

* No CD explosions heard

* WTC buildings did not collapse at free-fall speed

* WTC buildings did not collapse within their footprints

* No CD hardware discovered within the WTC rubble

* No CD seismic data noted during the collapse of the WTC buildings

No one in government in their right mind would have used explosives during 9/11 as a false flag operation because explosives leave behind traceable physical evidence, and once again, there was no way the WTC buildings could have been properly pre-weakened and prepared for demolition in secret, otherwise, expect these results.


CD Gone Wrong

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XHcCbY2wY38


The fact that firefighters reported "creaking noises" from within WTC 7 should have been another clue that uncontrolled fires were having a significant effect on the structure of WTC 7. Furthermore, CD detonations sound like this:


Second Tallest Building ever imploded

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8U4erFzhC-U


Now, please point out to us, timelines where the sound of demolition explosions are heard as WTC 7 collapses in the following video and failing to do so will prove the point that the collapse of WTC 7 had nothing to do with explosives.


WTC 7 Collapse

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LD06SAf0p9A


WTC 5 suffered an internal collapse due solely to fire, so where's the claim that explosives were used in that collapse?


.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom