does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Off what table?

This field of study we're engaged in here has a name: history. On that table, witnesses saying and reporting the same things (substantiating one another) is how we know what happened.

Was there a Battle of Lexington? Well, people witnessed it, and wrote down or recounted to others what they saw and heard and did, but there's no photographic evidence, so...

The rumor of a leaning WTC tower originated from a few perimeter wall units bowing.

The rumor of a leaning WTC 7 originated from the perimeter slightly warping from heat.

Remember that video of a firefighter claiming that you could see WTC 7 leaning with the naked eye? That was because he was told an incorrect rumor based off a truth, and perhaps fooled himself into believing it.
 
Last edited:
They knew the building would collapse due to the fact the building suffered major impact and fire damage. That prudent decision is what saved lives.

The bulge was most likely seen after the prediction was made. I forgot where, but I think a firefighter said that the bulge was seen shortly before or around 1 pm. The prediction was made at 11:30 AM. Actually, we have a false news report of another collapse wherein "fifty floors went down" at 11:07 AM so it might've been earlier.
 
The rumor of a leaning WTC tower originated from a few perimeter wall units bowing.


"The rumor of the Titanic being about to sink originated from a few hull plates being breached below the waterline."

You're basically saying the rumor of a leaning WTC tower originated from the leaning of the WTC tower.

One part of a connected structure cannot "bow" without affecting the rest of the structure.

The rumor of a leaning WTC 7 originated from the perimeter slightly warping from heat.


And that's basically saying the rumor of a leaning WTC 7 originated from the leaning of WTC7.

One part of a connected structure cannot "warp" without affecting the rest of the structure.

Remember that video of a firefighter claiming that you could see WTC 7 leaning with the naked eye? That was because he was told an incorrect rumor based off a truth, and perhaps fooled himself into believing it.


If visible "warping" of part of the structure was observed by anyone and reported to that firefighter, then that firefighter was told a correct rumor, that the building was leaning. One part of a connected structure cannot "warp" without affecting the rest of the structure.

The energy required for the bowing/warping comes from the gravitational potential energy of the load supported. To supply that energy, the load above the warped or bowed structure must move to a lower position. Unless that happens to occur perfectly evenly over an entire horizontal cross-section of the structure (which did not happen for any WTC building on 9/11), the result of the lowering of the supported load of a portion of the structure above must be a lean.
 
Last edited:
Remember that video of a firefighter claiming that you could see WTC 7 leaning with the naked eye? That was because he was told an incorrect rumor based off a truth, and perhaps fooled himself into believing it.


You keep missing the boat.

Early on, we saw a bulge in the southwest corner between floors 10 and 13, and we had put a transit on that and we were pretty sure she was going to collapse. You actually could see there was a visible bulge, it ran up about three floors.


That doesn't sound like a rumor.
 
I think all three reports are bogus and the NIST and ARUP reports have been proven to be non-explanatory due to omissions and inaccurate claims.

.

Your complaints would carry a lot more weight if you could find a fire engineering specialist to write a report outlining your issues with these three reports which were compiled using the expertise of such specialists.
 
You keep missing the boat.




That doesn't sound like a rumor.

True, it's not an opinion. It reports an actual measurement done with a specific tool.
Any report of explosions otoh are opinions. If one noted an explosive sound and felt the shockwave ahead of debris then that would worth a bit more.

I witnessed an open air explosion when I was 17. A guy robbed a bank with himself strapped with dynamite. I was watching the cordoned off area in front of the bank, from the steps of a building down the street. Cops did not believe the bomb was real, but his shotgun certainly was. They shot the guy on the street, bomb was quite real.
I felt the shock. The distance was such that it felt like someone had just body slammed me with a really big pillow. Heard the bang, saw the smoke column, saw debris arcing through the air.
 
Tony, Past Due Debts

1]
Tony...how about a completely listing of all your published reports/papers/etc., with links?

2]
Load, temperature, Cross section, length and boundary conditions, please.
Show us a free body diagram.
You say you have analysis. It shouldn't take you 10 minutes to show that much to us, if you have actually done the work.
The one you ran away from when your premise was challenged back in August:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11422984#post11422984

3] The time I asked you for this you disappeared from ISF for 3 months or more.
Will you answer these three requests.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=10871355#post10871355

Belly flop on the T>670C question.
 
You're a bit confused, aren't you skyeagle?

Sounds like the perfect prelude to endless semantics quibbling. I'll get the popcorn while you defend your arbitrary photographic evidence line in the sand. Nothing like dragging out the argument. You conspiricists are champs, I learn a lot.

Not any technique I would use myself, mind you. I've got my own arbitrary standards.
 
Sounds like the perfect prelude to endless semantics quibbling. I'll get the popcorn while you defend your arbitrary photographic evidence line in the sand. Nothing like dragging out the argument. You conspiricists are champs, I learn a lot.

Not any technique I would use myself, mind you. I've got my own arbitrary standards.

There is no photographic evidence for either of the Twin Towers leaning. Any rumor of such could originate from the south face of WTC 1 bowing.

There is no photographic evidence for WTC 7 leaning. Any rumor of such could originate from the perimeter slightly warping from the heat of the fires, i.e. the bulge.

The collapses can not be explained as a consequence of these observations, because they're too insignificant, and you all know it.
 
Last edited:
There is no photographic evidence for either of the Twin Towers leaning. Any rumor of such could originate from the south face of WTC 1 bowing.

There is no photographic evidence for WTC 7 leaning. Any rumor of such could originate from the perimeter slightly warping from the heat of the fires, i.e. the bulge.

The collapses can not be explained as a consequence of these observations, because they're too insignificant, and you all know it.

Good work, keep it up.
 
There is no photographic evidence for either of the Twin Towers leaning.


That won't work for you and it is clear that you didn't bother to look on page 328


Any rumor of such could originate from the south face of WTC 1 bowing.


That won't work for you either because reports that the WTC buildings were leaning and buckling were not rumors at all because the reports were flowing in from the air and on the ground.

There is no photographic evidence for WTC 7 leaning.


Those WTC 7reports were not rumors either. In fact, buckling and massive damage on the south wall of WTC 7 was also reported.


Any rumor of such could originate from the perimeter slightly warping from the heat of the fires, i.e. the bulge.


The buckling of the WTC Towers should have provided a clue to you that the upper sections of those buildings were leaning as reported by airborne and ground-based observers.

The collapses can not be explained as a consequence of these observations, because they're too insignificant, and you all know it.


Wrong!! And, here's another case in point in reference to buckling and collapse of a steel structure due to fire.

Overpass collapses in fire

The fire quickly buckled a three-lane section of Interstate 580 and caused it to collapse onto Interstate 880 about 30 feet below.

http://articles.baltimoresun.com/20...1_highway-patrol-mosqueda-caused-the-collapse


Just as fire buckled and collapsed the overpass, fire buckled and collapsed WTC 1, WTC 2, WTC 7, and caused the internal collapse of WTC 5. Where are Truther reports that explosives or thermite brought down the floors within WTC 5?

To sum it up, you have no case and your claim the reports were just rumors have been proven false as well.
 
Last edited:
I answered.
I can't see it. Unless you mean that you answered to skyeagle regarding something loosely related to the question.


I'm not really sure why the building moved 90 seconds before collapse. It moved more about 6 seconds before the East Penthouse came down. No scientific literature promoting structural failure of WTC 7 has ever explained this.
I'm pretty sure it's the effect of fire warping the steel. If you have an alternative explanation, I'd be willing to hear it.

The authors of that scientific literature are most likely unaware of this movement, as it was detected by guys who have only published their work on internet forums and private pages, not on places that can possibly reach the scientifically oriented communities. Furthermore, they did so using some rather new video analysis techniques. No one has had access to see what happened inside the building, and the authors of the scientific literature have worked with what they had.

That's why they haven't tried to explain it, but even then, I think it's possible to reconcile the findings of the existing reports with that movement.
 
No photographic evidence, Skyeagle. Where are the pictures showing what you think your witnesses are saying?

Oh, and here's your "massive damage to the south wall of WTC 7":

JCCkUln.jpg
 
Tony...you know who I am. In 2012-13 you sent me the video of your computer model thru the HDR ftp website, for my review. You did not like my comments, called them nick picks..

You had no legitimate comments. I am afraid I can't say anything more than that you seem to be a blustery bs artist.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom