does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Would those temperatures be induced by carbon black drawn into the intake of a chimney effect higher up in the core fueled by the carbon black from pyrosis of hydrocarbon plastics?

That is of course assuming that an ignition source ignited enough plastic at once to over come the protective effect of the nitrogen fire retardants that would normally slow the fire progressions.

While these scenarios you are suggesting are quite tortured, I would hope you realize that with what you are saying you are implying a new investigation is needed to at least probe your speculative notions. By expressing them you are acknowledging that the explanations proffered thus far do not work.
 
Last edited:
Well, we can add "Never prepared and published a formal report" along with "Have no clue what FEA is" to the Resumes of Tony (and Crazy Chainsaw and Oystein)

I have prepared and published a number of reports in my work over the years.

Instead of just grousing about others why don't you tell us what you think of NIST's omission of the stiffeners on girder A2001 and Nordenson's use of an infinite stiffness for the falling beam and girder assembly in the northeast corner?
 
Last edited:
Well, we can add "Never prepared and published a formal report" along with "Have no clue what FEA is" to the Resumes of Tony (and Crazy Chainsaw and Oystein)

Seeing that the steel would under go Creep, and gratification changing from carbon to graphite, at a little over 650C, and do to that it's stiffness, and strength from the resulting change in it's crystalline nature, I wouldn't be so bold if I were you.

I never claimed to be an engineer, but I do understand the fire data from Thousands of actual experiments including some prepared by, and done by NIST even before the towers collapsed.
 
I have prepared and published a number of reports in my work over the years.

Instead of just grousing about others why don't you tell us what you think of NIST's omission of the stiffeners on girder A2001 and Nordenson's use of an infinite stiffness for the falling beam and girder assembly in the northeast corner?

Did that a long time ago in a different thread, from which you ran away, just like you are now.
 
I have prepared and published a number of reports in my work over the years.

Instead of just grousing about others why don't you tell us what you think of NIST's omission of the stiffeners on girder A2001 and Nordenson's use of an infinite stiffness for the falling beam and girder assembly in the northeast corner?

Tony...how about a completely listing of all your published reports/papers/etc., with links?
 
Because five and a half hours before the building collapsed, an engineer (identity unknown) told the fire chiefs that the building would collapse "in five or six hours".


They knew the building would collapse due to the fact the building suffered major impact and fire damage. That prudent decision is what saved lives.

Early on, we saw a bulge in the southwest corner between floors 10 and 13, and we had put a transit on that and we were pretty sure she was going to collapse. You actually could see there was a visible bulge, it ran up about three floors. It came down about 5 o’clock in the afternoon, but by about 2 o’clock in the afternoon we realized this thing was going to collapse.
 
While these scenarios you are suggesting are quite tortured, I would hope you realize that with what you are saying you are implying a new investigation is needed to at least probe your speculative notions. By expressing them you are acknowledging that the explanations proffered thus far do not work.

I don't mind investigation of the Science Tony, I only object to non scientific investigation
of stupidity.

In fact the paper I posted back in this thread done by NIST before 9/11/2001 points out that very occurance is completely viable.

Experiments to prove it are easy enough to do, in fact it may be induced by the effect I noticed in doing experiments into the towers collapse.
I achieved temperatures of over 1400C though pressure increased oxidation.
Similar to the piston effect of s dropped elevator car in an elevator shaft.
Such piston effects NIST states registered temperatures of close to 2000C.

I posted the URL to the PDF Tony, you are free to download and read it.

I also know much more but until the hypothesis is confirmed I do not want to comment publicly on what experimental data might indicate.
No use starting another conspiracy theory.
Get the evidence first, the see if it supports or falsifies the theory.
 
Did that a long time ago in a different thread, from which you ran away, just like you are now.

I never ran away and I am not now.

You are acting like a coy grouch that says what he wants and then refuses to answer legitimate questions he doesn't like.

Again, what do you think about NIST's omission of stiffeners on girder A2001 and Nordenson's use of an infinite stiffness for the falling beam and girder assembly on the 13th floor in the northeast corner of WTC 7?
 
Last edited:
No, you brought up that a few perimeter wall units were apparently bending slightly inwards.


As the WTC buildings, buckled, what do you think the upper levels of those buildings were doing? That should provide you with a clue as to why there are reports from the ground and in the air that the WTC buildings were buckling and leaning.

So what? You're making it into something that it isn't.


No. You can't accept reality and the significance of eyewitness reports and visual evidence that fire was weakening the steel structures of the WTC buildings.


Post proof of actual leaning or stop trying to say it existed.


You've dismissed reports of the NYPD, NYFD, and others when they've stated that the WTC buildings were leaning and buckling and have been provided with visual evidence as well. In other words, you have no case.
 
Last edited:
Tony this is the paper I was referring too.
NISTIR 89-4035
Considerations of Stack
Effect in Building Fires
John H. KJote
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
National Institute of Standards and Technology

Considerations of Stack Effect in Building Fires - National Institute of Standards and Technology
fire.nist.gov › bfrlpubs › fire89 › PDF
Stack Effect . 2.2. Buoyancy of Combustion Gases. 2.3. Expansion of Combustion Gases. 2.4. Wind Effect ..... effect. These names cornefrom the comparison with the upward flow of gases in a smoke stack or chimney.

Sorry for some reason this pad will not let me copy PDF URLs and repaste them.
 
Tony this is the paper I was referring too.
NISTIR 89-4035
Considerations of Stack
Effect in Building Fires
John H. KJote
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
National Institute of Standards and Technology

Considerations of Stack Effect in Building Fires - National Institute of Standards and Technology
fire.nist.gov › bfrlpubs › fire89 › PDF
Stack Effect . 2.2. Buoyancy of Combustion Gases. 2.3. Expansion of Combustion Gases. 2.4. Wind Effect ..... effect. These names cornefrom the comparison with the upward flow of gases in a smoke stack or chimney.

Sorry for some reason this pad will not let me copy PDF URLs and repaste them.

http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/fire89/PDF/f89013.pdf
 
I never ran away and I am not now.

You are acting like a coy grouch that says what he wants and then refuses to answer legitimate questions he doesn't like.
What is the significance of T>670C?

Again, what do you think about NIST's omission of stiffeners on girder A2001 and Nordenson's use of an infinite stiffness for the falling beam and girder assembly on the 13th floor in the northeast corner of WTC 7?
Inconsequential detail.
 
Because five and a half hours before the building collapsed, an engineer (identity unknown) told the fire chiefs that the building would collapse "in five or six hours".


Which further proves just how ridicules the CD claims are. That's like Nixon announcing on national TV that he personally ordered the break-in at the Democratic National Committee (DNC) headquarters and will reveal a plan to cover up the secret operation at his next press conference.

If you are going to conduct such an illegal operation in secret, you don't announce your secret illegal intentions to the whole world on national TV.

The fact that the fires burned as long as they did further proves no explosives were used to demolish WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7.
 
What is the significance of T>670C?

I know you want to say this is where the steel will yield under load as it only retains about 25% of its yield strength at 670 degrees C, but it isn't quite that simple. The actual design of the connections and factors of safety involved have something to say about it. The factors of safety of the floors against collapse were much greater than the column FoS.

Inconsequential detail.

The NIST omission of the stiffeners on girder A2001 and Nordenson's use of infinite stiffness invalidate those reports. The fact that you are inclined to call them inconsequential details tells us where your head is.
 
Tony...you know who I am. In 2012-13 you sent me the video of your computer model thru the HDR ftp website, for my review. You did not like my comments, called them nick picks..

What are nick picks..or is that a Santa Claus reference?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom