does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Where's the part with the pictures showing the buildings leaning?


In the first link, scroll on down to page 300 and work your way down from there, but gather as much information as you can as you do so.
 
Last edited:
Where's the part with the pictures showing the buildings leaning?


Photos of the buckling facades and tilting are there. The reason why I asked you to go to page 300 and work your way on down from there is because I wanted you to find the photos for yourself and to learn a bit more on the way down.
 
Photos of the buckling facades and tilting are there. The reason why I asked you to go to page 300 and work your way on down from there is because I wanted you to find the photos for yourself and to learn a bit more on the way down.

That's the inward bowing of the perimeter, not the entire upper section leaning.
 
In any FEA software I have ever used the maximum in structural and thermal analysis results is always presented as dark red with the lowest as dark blue and lighter shades of both and other colors such as different shades of orange, yellow, and green in between. The NIST WTC 7 FEA models use these colors and there is nothing shaded gray in the analysis results.

The gray somebody here thinks they are seeing in Chapter 10 of the NIST WTC 7 report is just the border around the key. It has nothing to do with any temperature somewhere in the model.

I looked at more of the NIST screen captures and apparently there are some areas which appear gray in the models in the report. However, this can only be a pixilation issue as there is no gray key color. As I mentioned, the gray in the key is just the border around the key and gray is not used for results.

Gray is often used for the 3-D model and the areas appearing gray are likely to be where the color of the results are not shown for some reason.
 
Last edited:
I looked at more of the NIST screen captures and apparently there are some areas which appear gray in the models in the report. However, this can only be a pixilation issue as there is no gray key color. As I mentioned, the gray in the key is just the border around the key and gray is not used for results.

Gray is often used for the 3-D model and the areas appearing gray are likely to be where the color of the results are not shown for some reason.

Usually that reason is because the tests the models were based on exceeded the capacity of the thermal couples used.

The Gray represent lack of data do to equipment malfunction, thermocouple have limits.

Remember this data is based on real world experiments, as well as computer models.
 
Usually that reason is because the tests the models were based on exceeded the capacity of the thermal couples used.

The Gray represent lack of data do to equipment malfunction, thermocouple have limits.

Remember this data is based on real world experiments, as well as computer models.

While the gray area may be due to a lack of data, there was no thermocouple data from physical tests on a scale model involved that I know of. As far as I know, the NIST FEA results were based on fire simulation and FEA heat transfer computer analyses only.

The bottom line here is the maximum steel temperatures (not air) found anywhere in the NIST WTC 7 analyses were no more than 675 degrees C (1,247 F) and this is far below the 850 degrees C (1,562 F) temperatures claimed to occur simultaneously on the steel of two contiguous floors (9 and 10) in the Weidlinger report.
 
Last edited:
While the gray area may be due to a lack of data, there was no thermocouple data from physical tests on a scale model involved that I know of. As far as I know, the NIST FEA results were based on fire simulation and FEA heat transfer computer analyses only.

The bottom line here is the maximum steel temperatures (not air) found anywhere in the NIST WTC 7 analyses were no more than 675 degrees C (1,247 F) and this is far below the 850 degrees C (1,562 F) temperatures claimed to occur simultaneously on the steel of two contiguous floors (9 and 10) in the Weidlinger report.
Bottom line?> CD is a fantasy, the NIST scapegoat tangent failed.

15 minutes of CD fantasy stretched out to 15 years of CD fantasy failure. How do you do it. Are we all in on the cover up in the CD fantasy world of woo?
 
That's the inward bowing of the perimeter, not the entire upper section leaning.


The buckling proved that fire was weakening their steel structures, which resulted in their collapse. Take a look at the photo on page 328. There are other photos you have missed as well. I figured you would not check all of the photos because you were in debunk mode.


WTC Pre-Collapse Bowing Debunks 9/11 "Controlled Demolition" Theory

Indications of the Imminent Collapseof the World Trade Center BuildingsDisprove Explosives Theory

Scientists investigating the Sept. 11, 2001 collapse of the twin towers said, "the World Trade Center towers showed telltale signs they were about to collapse several minutes before each crumbled to the ground." There would not be telltale signs if it was explosives (Controlled Demolition) that caused the buildings to collapse.

http://www.representativepress.org/BowingDebunksExplosives.html


The World Trade Center's Steel Structure Was Buckling Before the Collapse

Police, Firemen and Civilians Saw Warning Signs of Collapse of the Twin Towers on September 11th 2001

Before the collapse of either tower, evidence the structures of the WTC were failing was reported by Police, Firemen and civilians. As already mentioned, flying around outside the WTC, the NYPD helicopters reported "an inward bowing of the buildings' columns in the minutes before they collapsed." Inside WTC 1, New York City Fire Department's Assistant Chief Joseph Callan realized the building was in trouble even before the first building, building two, collapsed.

http://www.representativepress.org/BowingDebunksExplosives2.html

WTCTWO953.jpg


WTCTWO921.jpg


WTCONE1023.jpg



The WTC buildings were buckling and leaning under the direct effects of fire which was an indication that structural fire protection insulation failed. In other words, it was just a matter of time before WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 collapsed. In other words, no CD involvement at all.
 
Last edited:
Where's the part with the pictures showing the buildings leaning?
This image compares two different frames of a WTC7 video separated in time:

633033152.gif


This happened at most 1 minute before the EPH collapsed.

How do you explain that?

Edit: Here's a high-pass filter version to eliminate the foreground smoke:

633033152-highpass.gif
 
Last edited:
I looked at more of the NIST screen captures and apparently there are some areas which appear gray in the models in the report. However, this can only be a pixilation issue as there is no gray key color. As I mentioned, the gray in the key is just the border around the key and gray is not used for results.

Gray is often used for the 3-D model and the areas appearing gray are likely to be where the color of the results are not shown for some reason.

There appears to be a temperature gradient towards these gray areas, where gray follows dark red. This could suggest that the color key, for some reason, doesn't represent the full temperature range, such that the gray area exceeded 675 °C.

I agree though that this is conjecture. As is the claim that "the maximum steel temperatures (not air) found anywhere in the NIST WTC 7 analyses were no more than 675 degrees C". There is a lack of data there to decide either way.
 
There appears to be a temperature gradient towards these gray areas, where gray follows dark red. This could suggest that the color key, for some reason, doesn't represent the full temperature range, such that the gray area exceeded 675 °C.

I agree though that this is conjecture. As is the claim that "the maximum steel temperatures (not air) found anywhere in the NIST WTC 7 analyses were no more than 675 degrees C". There is a lack of data there to decide either way.

In every FEA software package that I ever used (which includes ANSYS) the color key always shows the maximum numeric value of temperature or stress in the model at the top of a vertical key and to the right of a horizontal key at the end of a dark red color. I would say that since the key in the NIST FEA model shows 675 degrees C, at the maximum end, that there was nothing beyond that anywhere in the model.

I have also never seen gray used in a color key in any FEA package. It is not in the color key for temperature in the NIST models. It is just the border around the key you are looking at there. That is unless you think the gray to the left and above and below the key colors has some significance, as well as that to the right, which you seem to believe does. In that case you have to now discern what the gray means. Does it mean temperatures below zero, since there is gray to the left of the zero value, or does it mean nothing because there is also gray above and below the other key colors.

I think the gray in the model is an anomaly due to printing and the color key gray border is just that, having nothing to do with any temperature. It may also be due to printing.

If you look at all of the color keys on the many pages of floor images in chapter 10 of the NIST WTC 7 report you will see that even where there is no gray in the models the color key is always bordered with gray. This shows it is just a border with no relation to temperatures in the model. 675 degrees C seems to be the highest steel temperature found in the NIST WTC 7 thermal FEA.
 
Last edited:
The buckling proved that fire was weakening their steel structures, which resulted in their collapse. Take a look at the photo on page 328. There are other photos you have missed as well. I figured you would not check all of the photos because you were in debunk mode.


WTC Pre-Collapse Bowing Debunks 9/11 "Controlled Demolition" Theory

Indications of the Imminent Collapseof the World Trade Center BuildingsDisprove Explosives Theory

Scientists investigating the Sept. 11, 2001 collapse of the twin towers said, "the World Trade Center towers showed telltale signs they were about to collapse several minutes before each crumbled to the ground." There would not be telltale signs if it was explosives (Controlled Demolition) that caused the buildings to collapse.

http://www.representativepress.org/BowingDebunksExplosives.html


The World Trade Center's Steel Structure Was Buckling Before the Collapse

Police, Firemen and Civilians Saw Warning Signs of Collapse of the Twin Towers on September 11th 2001

Before the collapse of either tower, evidence the structures of the WTC were failing was reported by Police, Firemen and civilians. As already mentioned, flying around outside the WTC, the NYPD helicopters reported "an inward bowing of the buildings' columns in the minutes before they collapsed." Inside WTC 1, New York City Fire Department's Assistant Chief Joseph Callan realized the building was in trouble even before the first building, building two, collapsed.

http://www.representativepress.org/BowingDebunksExplosives2.html

[qimg]http://toolateforregrets.tripod.com/WTCTWO953.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://911motive.tripod.com/WTCTWO921.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://toolateforregrets.tripod.com/WTCONE1023.jpg[/qimg]


The WTC buildings were buckling and leaning under the direct effects of fire which was an indication that structural fire protection insulation failed. In other words, it was just a matter of time before WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 collapsed. In other words, no CD involvement at all.

Don't overstate your case. You caught my attention when you claimed the upper sections of the Twin Towers were leaning prior to collapse, but then you wheeled out the old "a few perimeter wall units were bending" bit. I'm well aware. Please stop going around citing incorrect witnesses suggesting the entire buildings were leaning.
 
This image compares two different frames of a WTC7 video separated in time:

[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/_ph/7/633033152.gif[/qimg]

This happened at most 1 minute before the EPH collapsed.

How do you explain that?

Edit: Here's a high-pass filter version to eliminate the foreground smoke:

[qimg]http://www.formauri.es/personal/pgimeno/xfiles/11-s/633033152-highpass.gif[/qimg]

I'm aware of that. It's on the sharpprintinginc website. Would you really call that a "lean"? It's definitely not related to the incorrect rumor going around the fire department at the time that you could see the building leaning with the naked eye.
 
Last edited:
Don't overstate your case. You caught my attention when you claimed the upper sections of the Twin Towers were leaning prior to collapse, but then you wheeled out the old "a few perimeter wall units were bending" bit. I'm well aware. Please stop going around citing incorrect witnesses suggesting the entire buildings were leaning.


I brought up the fact the WTC buildings were buckling and leaning as fires raged out of control before they collapse to proved that fire, in conjunction with impact damage, was responsible for the collapse of those buildings.
 
A lean that would be easily visible from a viewpoint at the base of the tower looking upward (that is, where the firefighters were and photographers weren't) could still be very difficult to discern in a high-resolution photograph (and correspondingly impossible to discern in a low-resolution one) from a different angle.

Have you ever sighted down the length of a wooden plank or stud to see the warp in it? It's easy to see warps that are not visible from a normal side-on view.
 
It's definitely not related to the incorrect rumor going around the fire department at the time that you could see the building leaning with the naked eye.


Reports that the WTC buildings were buckling and leaning was not a rumor of the NYFD. In fact, civilians and even the NYPD reported the WTC buildings were buckling and leaning before they collapsed.


9/11: Absolute Proof NO DEMOLITION at WTC Twin Towers -- "THE TOWER IS LEANING" & Buckling


THE TOWER IS LEANING" declares NYC policeman. This ABC News clip broadcast on 9/11, PROVES ABSOLUTELY there was NO controlled demolition of the World Trade Center Twin Towers. "The Tower is LEANING" the police see, SEVERAL MINUTES before collapse. A bystander says he saw the tower BUCKLING before collapse. Explosives did NOT bring down the WTC Twin Towers. The Northern Tower was LEANING

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ERr6zSE3clM


1019 AM - A police helicopter reports that the top of the North Tower is buckling and leaning.

Buckling of WTC 2 (South Tower)

15d987530fb19f490198129171c8d200.gif
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom