does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

In every FEA software package that I ever used (which includes ANSYS) the color key always shows the maximum numeric value of temperature or stress in the model at the top of a vertical key and to the right of a horizontal key at the end of a dark red color. I would say that since the key in the NIST FEA model shows 675 degrees C, at the maximum end, that there was nothing beyond that anywhere in the model.
That is one of the (at least) three possibilities. To elevate this to a claim would be conjecture.
And I think you are wrong.

Consider this:
NIST uses the same color key (the horizontal bar below many of the Figures in Chapter 10, that runs from 0 to 675 °C / dark blue to bright red) in all the Figures - for all three fire scenarios A-C, all foors 7-14, all instances in time from 12:30 to 6:00 pm. But it is highly lilely that the different simulations - A, B, C - reached different peak temperatures. It is absolutely certain that the different floors reached different peaks.
I think NIST made a decision to normalize the color keys for all these Figures to the same scale, even though some areas on some floors exceeded that scale.

Look at Figure 10–38 on page 431 (497 in the electronic file) of NCSTAR 1-9: "Computed temperature distribution (ºC) in the top layer of the concrete
slab of Floor 13
at 12 different instants in time (Case B).
"
Starting at 4:00 p.m., there is a gray area in those graphs that keeps expanding. As an example, here is the 5pm heat map of that Figure:



The border of the gray area is bright red - the top temperature on the coloer key scale - and from there outward, there is a gradient towards cooler temps. It surely looks like the gray are is hotter than its red border, don't you think?

And here comes the proof:
Flip forward to Section 10.4 on page 455 (521 electronic file) and read:
"The following is a list of findings common to the three Cases:
  • ...
  • The fires on the 7th, 12th, and 13th floors heated portions of the tops of the floor slabs to over 900 ºC. ..."
We just looked at the 13th floor tops of the floor slab - the color key scale ended at 675 °C, but here we learn that top temperature exceeded 900 °C!

I have also never seen gray used in a color key in any FEA package. It is not in the color key for temperature in the NIST models.
Apparently, now you have.

It is just the border around the key you are looking at there. That is unless you think the gray to the left and above and below the key colors has some significance, as well as that to the right, which you seem to believe does.
No, it is not the border of the key I or benthamitemetric are talking about, and you already admitted that you see beams colored gray in Figures such as Figure 10–39 (page 432/498 elec.) - I here reproduce the 5pm heat map:



Open that image with a simple program like MS Paint (that shows you big pixels when you enlarge them), and zoom into the beams that frame from the east perimeter to the girders left and right of col 79 - you will see they are gray - and the gray areas border on red. All just like in the floor slab image we saw above.

In that case you have to now discern what the gray means. Does it mean temperatures below zero, since there is gray to the left of the zero value, or does it mean nothing because there is also gray above and below the other key colors.
I just did discern that: Gray means temperatures above 675 °C :)

I think the gray in the model is an anomaly due to printing and the color key gray border is just that, having nothing to do with any temperature. It may also be due to printing.

If you look at all of the color keys on the many pages of floor images in chapter 10 of the NIST WTC 7 report you will see that even where there is no gray in the models the color key is always bordered with gray. This shows it is just a border with no relation to temperatures in the model. 675 degrees C seems to be the highest steel temperature found in the NIST WTC 7 thermal FEA.
I think you will now agree that the gray is an artefact of NIST's choice to depict all heat maps on a uniform color key scale that begins at 0 °C and ends at 675 °C, which leaves hotter areas unkeyed; those obviously revert to gray then.
 
This happened at most 1 minute before the EPH collapsed.

How do you explain that?
I'm aware of that. It's on the sharpprintinginc website. Would you really call that a "lean"? It's definitely not related to the incorrect rumor going around the fire department at the time that you could see the building leaning with the naked eye.
I would call it a lean, yes.

Again, how do you explain that?
 
Gray means temperatures above 675 °C :)


I think you will now agree that the gray is an artefact of NIST's choice to depict all heat maps on a uniform color key scale that begins at 0 °C and ends at 675 °C, which leaves hotter areas unkeyed; those obviously revert to gray then.

I would agree that NIST used a single scale, but don't think they missed hotter temps. In my experience you can't truncate the scale's maximum numerical value to be below the highest temp in the model and hottest areas would still be red. If you set a range with a max numerical value which is less than the actual max temp it throws in a value at the top (or right) which is the exact max numerical value.

The gray in the key is all around it, top, bottom, left and right. You can't say it only holds for the right side, as in hotter than 675 °C.
 
Last edited:
A lean that would be easily visible from a viewpoint at the base of the tower looking upward (that is, where the firefighters were and photographers weren't) could still be very difficult to discern in a high-resolution photograph (and correspondingly impossible to discern in a low-resolution one) from a different angle.

Have you ever sighted down the length of a wooden plank or stud to see the warp in it? It's easy to see warps that are not visible from a normal side-on view.

Last month, one section of a cookie factory in my hometown burned down. The steel-frame roof collapsed and pulled the walls inward. I went there a few days later to look at the remains and take photographs.

From near the sidewalk:

From that vantage point it was already apparent to the naked eyes (or a pair of naked eyes) that the wall was leaning. I don't think the photo showed it.
I tried to capture the inward bowing by standing near the edge, and found it surprisingly difficult. I deleted two or three attemps directly on my cam before I shot this:


While the leaning of the wall is apparent in that photo, it appeared much more obvious in real life.

Here one more, through a side window (off the right margin of my first photo):
 
I would agree that NIST used a single scale, but don't think they missed hotter temps. In my experience even if the scale was truncated the hotter areas would still be red.
This shows that your experience is not a reliable reference!

The gray in the key is all around it, top, bottom, left and right. You can't say it only holds for the right side, as in hotter than 675 degrees.

There is no gray in the key (the border around the color scale does not count) - stop talking about the border.
Gray in the heat maps obviously stands for a temperature not in the key.

Tony, please quote and comment explicitly what I said about the 13th floor concrete slab temperatures!
Make sure you quote, and comment explicitly, the mention of "900 °C" in Section 10.4! Make sure you quote, and comment explicitly, what I said about the heat map of that very same 13th floor concrete slab, and the gray areas it shows!
Do you realize that Figure 10-38 (the 13th floor concrete slab temperature maps) must show some area that exceeded 900 °C, because NIST explicitly writes in Section 10.4 that parts of the 13th floor concrete slab exceeded 900 °C?
 
This shows that your experience is not a reliable reference!



There is no gray in the key (the border around the color scale does not count) - stop talking about the border.
Gray in the heat maps obviously stands for a temperature not in the key.

Tony, please quote and comment explicitly what I said about the 13th floor concrete slab temperatures!
Make sure you quote, and comment explicitly, the mention of "900 °C" in Section 10.4! Make sure you quote, and comment explicitly, what I said about the heat map of that very same 13th floor concrete slab, and the gray areas it shows!
Do you realize that Figure 10-38 (the 13th floor concrete slab temperature maps) must show some area that exceeded 900 °C, because NIST explicitly writes in Section 10.4 that parts of the 13th floor concrete slab exceeded 900 °C?

You have no clue as you have never even used FEA software. You are guessing based on your bias to believe NIST missed higher temps in their scale. The software does not let you do that. I think the gray areas could be all 675 °C but not hotter.
 
Last edited:
You have no clue as you have never even used FEA software. You are guessing based on your bias to believe NIST missed higher temps in their scale. The software does not let you do that.

Tony, you did not address the fact that NIST writes that the 13th floor concrete slab reached > 900 °C, and yet the 13th floor concrete slab heat map is keyed to only 675 °C - and shows large gray areas within a red (top keyed temp) border - those are obviously the areas that reached up to >900 °C!

You need to read and quote this and address this! Your "I am smart and you are dumb, so I am right" ploy is as condescending as it is stupid! Get smart! Address the evidence I pointed out to you, and do not handwave the >900 °C temperatures in concrete slabs, that directly contradicts your conjecture that they nowhere exceeded 675 °C!
 
Tony, you did not address the fact that NIST writes that the 13th floor concrete slab reached > 900 °C, and yet the 13th floor concrete slab heat map is keyed to only 675 °C - and shows large gray areas within a red (top keyed temp) border - those are obviously the areas that reached up to >900 °C!

You need to read and quote this and address this! Your "I am smart and you are dumb, so I am right" ploy is as condescending as it is stupid! Get smart! Address the evidence I pointed out to you, and do not handwave the >900 °C temperatures in concrete slabs, that directly contradicts your conjecture that they nowhere exceeded 675 °C!


I find it hard to believe there were slab temperatures as high as 900 °C. The NIST WTC 7 FEA model does not show that, so if you want to think what someone wrote is accurate and the model analysis results key somehow compromised to not show it explicitly you will have to take it up with them. In my experience the software won't do that. It will put an actual max value at the end of the key above your range max.

It can be emphatically said that the NIST FEA model does not show temperatures higher than 675 °C.
 
Last edited:
That is one of the (at least) three possibilities. To elevate this to a claim would be conjecture.
And I think you are wrong.

Consider this:
NIST uses the same color key (the horizontal bar below many of the Figures in Chapter 10, that runs from 0 to 675 °C / dark blue to bright red) in all the Figures - for all three fire scenarios A-C, all foors 7-14, all instances in time from 12:30 to 6:00 pm. But it is highly lilely that the different simulations - A, B, C - reached different peak temperatures. It is absolutely certain that the different floors reached different peaks.
I think NIST made a decision to normalize the color keys for all these Figures to the same scale, even though some areas on some floors exceeded that scale.

Look at Figure 10–38 on page 431 (497 in the electronic file) of NCSTAR 1-9: "Computed temperature distribution (ºC) in the top layer of the concrete
slab of Floor 13
at 12 different instants in time (Case B).
"
Starting at 4:00 p.m., there is a gray area in those graphs that keeps expanding. As an example, here is the 5pm heat map of that Figure:

[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/Papers-Figures/NCSTAR%201-9%20Fig%2010-38%200500pm_zpsgff0fyze.png[/qimg]

The border of the gray area is bright red - the top temperature on the coloer key scale - and from there outward, there is a gradient towards cooler temps. It surely looks like the gray are is hotter than its red border, don't you think?

And here comes the proof:
Flip forward to Section 10.4 on page 455 (521 electronic file) and read:
"The following is a list of findings common to the three Cases:
  • ...
  • The fires on the 7th, 12th, and 13th floors heated portions of the tops of the floor slabs to over 900 ºC. ..."
We just looked at the 13th floor tops of the floor slab - the color key scale ended at 675 °C, but here we learn that top temperature exceeded 900 °C!


Apparently, now you have.


No, it is not the border of the key I or benthamitemetric are talking about, and you already admitted that you see beams colored gray in Figures such as Figure 10–39 (page 432/498 elec.) - I here reproduce the 5pm heat map:

[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/Papers-Figures/NCSTAR%201-9%20Fig%2010-39%200500pm_zpsc0a9zdos.png[/qimg]

Open that image with a simple program like MS Paint (that shows you big pixels when you enlarge them), and zoom into the beams that frame from the east perimeter to the girders left and right of col 79 - you will see they are gray - and the gray areas border on red. All just like in the floor slab image we saw above.


I just did discern that: Gray means temperatures above 675 °C :)


I think you will now agree that the gray is an artefact of NIST's choice to depict all heat maps on a uniform color key scale that begins at 0 °C and ends at 675 °C, which leaves hotter areas unkeyed; those obviously revert to gray then.

This gives me a great deal of insight into the analysis capability and technical expertise of the truth movement. It is not at all flattering...

In every FEA Package I have used (IDEAS, PATRAN, ALGOR, FEMAP, and Pro_E) there is a way, and a method, and a need to have a User-defined scale for display.
For example, I have had occasion to color code only between Yield and Ultimate for stress. Everything above ultimate gets a color, and everything below yield gets a different color. Often I use white and/or gray. This is because I want/need to know something particular about a load path, or need to examine a particular range in finer detail
If you just let it autorange the scale, you make pretty pictures that actually don't tell you a godsdamned thing.
It's a *********** tool, guys, with a ****-pot of capability. You're using a compound Miter Saw just to cut boards to length.
 
Their model doesn't show that, so you will have to take it up with them.

This is FALSE!
Their model does show it!
What does not show it is merely the Figures in Chapter 10, because of a decision, for whatever reasons, to limit the comon color key to 675 °C.
This is the maximum of the key, NOT the maximum of the temperatures reached in the model!
If all the areas stayed below 676 °C, then wouldn't the FEA software color eht entire areas in colors contained in the key? But it doesn't - it colors some areas - those that border red - gray.

Now please turn to Section 10.4 on page 455 (521 electronic file) and read:

"10.4 FINDINGS FROM THE CALCULATED FIRE-INDUCED THERMAL
RESPONSE OF WTC 7

... FSI calculations were performed using the temperatures directly from the FDS simulations (Case A), temperatures that were 10 percent larger than the FDS temperatures (Case B), and temperatures that were 10 percent lower than the FDS temperatures (Case C). ...

The following is a list of findings common to the three Cases:
  • ...
  • The fires on the 7th, 12th, and 13th floors heated portions of the tops of the floor slabs to over 900 ºC. ..."

Now please answer the following four questions - straight and honestly, you know my usual preference for straight and honest answers:

  1. According to NIST's FSI model, what top temperature was reached at the top of the 13th floor slab?
  2. According to Fig 10-38, what top temperature was reached in the areas depicted red?
  3. According to Fig 10-38, what top temperature was reached in the areas depicted gray?
  4. Does the assumption, that gray areas in the heat map depict areas with a temperature outside the color key, reconcile the answers to 1. to 3.?
  5. In Fig 10-38, what areas are the most likely candidates for the >675 to >900 °C temperatures that are reported on page 455?

To make it easy on you, here are the answers that would be straight and honest:
  1. More than 900 °C
  2. Between 656.25 and 675 °C
  3. We can't tell directly, because gray is not in the color key scale.
  4. Yes.
  5. The gray areas are the only areas that could have reached 900 °C, as all other areas are keyed in a color that stands for <=675 °C.
 
I find it hard to believe there were slab temperatures as high as 900 °C.
Nothing new here - it has been pointed out numerous times, as you are painfully aware, that your only argument is an appeal to incredulity mixed with an appeal to your own, obviously lacking, authority.

The NIST WTC 7 FEA model does not show that,
Wrong.
It shows in gray the areas that exceeded 675 °C. You are in plain and obvious denial mode.

so if you want to think what someone wrote is accurate and the model analysis results key somehow compromised to not show it explicitly you will have to take it up with them.
You got your logic, and your burden of proof, backwards, as usual.

I do not claim that there is anything wrong in that part of the NIST report - you claim that there is something wrong in that part of the NIST report, namely the 900 °C claim; plus you claim that the gray areas in those Figures are some error of the rendering. It is therefore YOUR job to take it up with NIST.

In my experience the software won't do that. It will put an actual max value at the end of the key above your range max.
As rwguinn just explained, you obviously do not know nor understand the capabilities of these software packages, do not know how to properly and intelligently use them, and thus your experience is worth **** here. You are currently proving with great sharpness and clarity that you are most definitely NOT an authority on reading FEA outputs that anyone should make reference to - least of all yourself.

I learned a bit today.
You did not so far.

It can be emphatically said that the NIST FEA model does not show temperatures higher than 675 °C.
You emphaty is just blowing hot air and singing "LALALA" with fingers in ears.


I am once again at a juncture where I need to decide whether you are really so thick and so cruelly unable to open your eyes and see, or whether you already realize you have - once again - been shown wrong by me, the amateur, on an issue where you like to believe you are an expert, and now resort to aggressive dishonesty.

You commended me for agreeing with you when you are right and show me why you are right.
I cannot commend you for the reverse.
 
Why is this debate still going on? It's been known since 2008 why the building collapsed.

 
Last edited:
This is FALSE!
Their model does show it!
What does not show it is merely the Figures in Chapter 10, because of a decision, for whatever reasons, to limit the comon color key to 675 °C.
This is the maximum of the key, NOT the maximum of the temperatures reached in the model!
If all the areas stayed below 676 °C, then wouldn't the FEA software color eht entire areas in colors contained in the key? But it doesn't - it colors some areas - those that border red - gray.

Now please turn to Section 10.4 on page 455 (521 electronic file) and read:

"10.4 FINDINGS FROM THE CALCULATED FIRE-INDUCED THERMAL
RESPONSE OF WTC 7

... FSI calculations were performed using the temperatures directly from the FDS simulations (Case A), temperatures that were 10 percent larger than the FDS temperatures (Case B), and temperatures that were 10 percent lower than the FDS temperatures (Case C). ...

The following is a list of findings common to the three Cases:
  • ...
  • The fires on the 7th, 12th, and 13th floors heated portions of the tops of the floor slabs to over 900 ºC. ..."

Now please answer the following four questions - straight and honestly, you know my usual preference for straight and honest answers:

  1. According to NIST's FSI model, what top temperature was reached at the top of the 13th floor slab?
  2. According to Fig 10-38, what top temperature was reached in the areas depicted red?
  3. According to Fig 10-38, what top temperature was reached in the areas depicted gray?
  4. Does the assumption, that gray areas in the heat map depict areas with a temperature outside the color key, reconcile the answers to 1. to 3.?
  5. In Fig 10-38, what areas are the most likely candidates for the >675 to >900 °C temperatures that are reported on page 455?

To make it easy on you, here are the answers that would be straight and honest:
  1. More than 900 °C
  2. Between 656.25 and 675 °C
  3. We can't tell directly, because gray is not in the color key scale.
  4. Yes.
  5. The gray areas are the only areas that could have reached 900 °C, as all other areas are keyed in a color that stands for <=675 °C.

Below is the pertinent area of page 455 of the NIST WTC 7 report quoted in italics.

The following is a list of findings common to the three Cases.

• In none of the Cases did any of the columns, all of which were insulated, reach temperatures sufficiently high for significant loss of strength or stiffness.

o The temperatures of the large interior Columns 79, 80, and 81 stayed below 200 ºC on all of the floors.

o Only on floors 12 and 13 did any of the exterior column temperatures exceed 150 ºC. On these floors, the temperatures on the east and south perimeter columns reached 300 ºC.

• The fires on the 7th, 12th, and 13th floors heated portions of the tops of the floor slabs to over 900 ºC. In all cases, significant temperature gradients were observed through the thickness of the concrete slab.

• The temperatures of some sections of the beams supporting the 8th, 12th, 13th, and 14th floor slabs exceeded 600 ºC, except for the 8th floor beams in Case C. The temperatures of some sections of the beams supporting the 9th and 10th floors reached 400 ºC.

• The temperatures of the beam-column connectors in these regions would also have reached levels at which they would have experienced significant loss of strength.

For each of the three cases, Table 10–1 indicates, in blue, those regions of the steel structure that reached a temperature at which nominally half the steel strength remains.


In some places the steel is said to have exceeded 600 ºC. Had it exceeded 700 ºC they would have said that. They didn't, and you can't say steel exceeded the 675 ºC shown in the analysis results key.
 
Last edited:
This gives me a great deal of insight into the analysis capability and technical expertise of the truth movement. It is not at all flattering...

In every FEA Package I have used (IDEAS, PATRAN, ALGOR, FEMAP, and Pro_E) there is a way, and a method, and a need to have a User-defined scale for display.
For example, I have had occasion to color code only between Yield and Ultimate for stress. Everything above ultimate gets a color, and everything below yield gets a different color. Often I use white and/or gray. This is because I want/need to know something particular about a load path, or need to examine a particular range in finer detail
If you just let it autorange the scale, you make pretty pictures that actually don't tell you a godsdamned thing.It's a *********** tool, guys, with a ****-pot of capability. You're using a compound Miter Saw just to cut boards to length.

Thanks for this explanation, rwguinn. I have never seen a FEA software in action, let alone did the very first thing with any myself, and yet I was certain that FEA software can autorange the scale [*], or allow the user to define the scale. It is indeed telling that Tony pretends not to see this. And yet, he has already let it slip that, in his experience, FEA software only autoranges:
... if you want to think ... the model analysis results key [is] somehow compromised to not show it explicitly you will have to take it up with them. In my experience the software won't do that. It will put an actual max value at the end of the key above your range max.
Obviously, Tony's experience lacks the observation that he actually has control over the range. It is obvious that NIST did control the range -it is the same in all Chapter 10 Figures after all, despite the models reaching different max temperatures. Tony clearly has no experience with this, and his opinion is thus worthless and demonstrably wrong.


[*] An obvious IMO example of an autoranged color key is Figure 38 on page 51 of the WAI report (NN Abboud 2010), where the displacement intervals per color is 0.769 inches (1.953 cm), an oddly unround number. Figure 58 on page B-83 (215 of the electronic file) has 6 different temperature scales - the first has all colors at 20 °C - starting condition. The second (1 hour) has approx. 13 °C increments, the third (2 hours) 21.5 °C increments, etc., and the last (4.5 hours) 66 °C increments. This smacks of autoranging. Elsewhere, for example Figure 22, intervals are more "round" and thus easier to process for humans - apparently ranged by a human operator.
 
If one were familiar with Steel--contruction grade steel, and A36 in particular--one would realize that there is a reason that a 675oC cut-off temperature might have been used in the display...
 
Below is the pertinent area of page 455 of the NIST WTC 7 report quoted in italics. ...

Please answer the 5 questions I asked you - straight and honestly.

Or admit straight out and honestly that you now understand that the gray area in Fig. 10-38 (13th floor concrete slab top) shows areas hotter than 675 °C!
 
I find it hard to believe there were slab temperatures as high as 900 °C. The NIST WTC 7 FEA model does not show that, so if you want to think what someone wrote is accurate and the model analysis results key somehow compromised to not show it explicitly you will have to take it up with them. In my experience the software won't do that. It will put an actual max value at the end of the key above your range max.

It can be emphatically said that the NIST FEA model does not show temperatures higher than 675 °C.

The 900C is an obvious easy to verify typo. 900 is supposed to be 600. 10.4 pdf page 455 that Oystein quotes:

The following is a list of findings common to the three Cases:

...The fires on the 7th, 12th, and 13th floors heated portions of the tops of the floor slabs to over 900 ºC. ...

The "common to the three cases" refers to the 3 simulations, A being the baseline, B being slightly hotter than A and C slightly colder than A. All 3 do heat the slab of 13 to over 600C but case C just barely manages it, and fig 10-58 shows the colder than red burnt orange color but no red, meaning max temp below 660C. C can not be in any list for common temps over 660, but it can be included in a list for over 600, and the text Oystein cites does indeed continue and refer to table 10-1 showing areas over 600C.
 
Last edited:
Please answer the 5 questions I asked you - straight and honestly.

Or admit straight out and honestly that you now understand that the gray area in Fig. 10-38 (13th floor concrete slab top) shows areas hotter than 675 °C!

The steel temperature is what you are trying to claim was higher than 675 °C and you left out the part of page 455 where NIST only talks about steel temperatures exceeding 600 °C. This is important because there is no question they would have said exceeded 700 °C had that been the case, like you are trying to claim. Your questions about top of slab temperatures are thus not pertinent.

The above lends credence to why the NIST WTC 7 FEA did not show steel temperatures exceeding the 675 °C.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for this explanation, rwguinn. I have never seen a FEA software in action, let alone did the very first thing with any myself, and yet I was certain that FEA software can autorange the scale [*], or allow the user to define the scale. It is indeed telling that Tony pretends not to see this. And yet, he has already let it slip that, in his experience, FEA software only autoranges:

I did not say FEA software only autoranges. You can certainly edit the color coded results key with a range. What it won't do is eliminate the actual max numerical value if it is outside of the range you apply. It will still put that actual max numerical value above your range.

Without a higher max numerical value shown, above what is in the range, there is no chance the NIST WTC 7 FEA had steel temperatures exceeding the 675 °C max range value in the results key.
 
Last edited:
Oystein was using the data for the concrete slab temperatures to show how the gray coloring could represent temperatures over 675 degrees in general. Do you agree or disagree that this interpretation of the colors as it applies to the concrete slabs is reasonable or not? Answer that before you try to sidestep the point by focusing on the steel temperature maps. Anything else comes across as deliberately dishonest.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom