Oystein
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2009
- Messages
- 18,948
That is one of the (at least) three possibilities. To elevate this to a claim would be conjecture.In every FEA software package that I ever used (which includes ANSYS) the color key always shows the maximum numeric value of temperature or stress in the model at the top of a vertical key and to the right of a horizontal key at the end of a dark red color. I would say that since the key in the NIST FEA model shows 675 degrees C, at the maximum end, that there was nothing beyond that anywhere in the model.
And I think you are wrong.
Consider this:
NIST uses the same color key (the horizontal bar below many of the Figures in Chapter 10, that runs from 0 to 675 °C / dark blue to bright red) in all the Figures - for all three fire scenarios A-C, all foors 7-14, all instances in time from 12:30 to 6:00 pm. But it is highly lilely that the different simulations - A, B, C - reached different peak temperatures. It is absolutely certain that the different floors reached different peaks.
I think NIST made a decision to normalize the color keys for all these Figures to the same scale, even though some areas on some floors exceeded that scale.
Look at Figure 10–38 on page 431 (497 in the electronic file) of NCSTAR 1-9: "Computed temperature distribution (ºC) in the top layer of the concrete
slab of Floor 13 at 12 different instants in time (Case B)."
Starting at 4:00 p.m., there is a gray area in those graphs that keeps expanding. As an example, here is the 5pm heat map of that Figure:

The border of the gray area is bright red - the top temperature on the coloer key scale - and from there outward, there is a gradient towards cooler temps. It surely looks like the gray are is hotter than its red border, don't you think?
And here comes the proof:
Flip forward to Section 10.4 on page 455 (521 electronic file) and read:
"The following is a list of findings common to the three Cases:
We just looked at the 13th floor tops of the floor slab - the color key scale ended at 675 °C, but here we learn that top temperature exceeded 900 °C!- ...
- The fires on the 7th, 12th, and 13th floors heated portions of the tops of the floor slabs to over 900 ºC. ..."
Apparently, now you have.I have also never seen gray used in a color key in any FEA package. It is not in the color key for temperature in the NIST models.
No, it is not the border of the key I or benthamitemetric are talking about, and you already admitted that you see beams colored gray in Figures such as Figure 10–39 (page 432/498 elec.) - I here reproduce the 5pm heat map:It is just the border around the key you are looking at there. That is unless you think the gray to the left and above and below the key colors has some significance, as well as that to the right, which you seem to believe does.

Open that image with a simple program like MS Paint (that shows you big pixels when you enlarge them), and zoom into the beams that frame from the east perimeter to the girders left and right of col 79 - you will see they are gray - and the gray areas border on red. All just like in the floor slab image we saw above.
I just did discern that: Gray means temperatures above 675 °CIn that case you have to now discern what the gray means. Does it mean temperatures below zero, since there is gray to the left of the zero value, or does it mean nothing because there is also gray above and below the other key colors.
I think you will now agree that the gray is an artefact of NIST's choice to depict all heat maps on a uniform color key scale that begins at 0 °C and ends at 675 °C, which leaves hotter areas unkeyed; those obviously revert to gray then.I think the gray in the model is an anomaly due to printing and the color key gray border is just that, having nothing to do with any temperature. It may also be due to printing.
If you look at all of the color keys on the many pages of floor images in chapter 10 of the NIST WTC 7 report you will see that even where there is no gray in the models the color key is always bordered with gray. This shows it is just a border with no relation to temperatures in the model. 675 degrees C seems to be the highest steel temperature found in the NIST WTC 7 thermal FEA.


