Oystein
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2009
- Messages
- 18,948
A good argument has been made that the "900 °C" top slab temp on page 455 is a typo.
The Case C 13th floor slab peaks below 656 °C, but above 600 °C (Fig. Figure 10–58)
The Case A 13th floor slab peaks at least in the range 656-675 °C (red), but already has some gray spots inside red borders (Fig. Figure 10–18)
The Case B 13th floor slab again peaks at least in the range 656-675 °C (red), but the gray areas within red borders are much larger now (Fig. Figure 10–38).
Now again page 455:
In Case A, the slab peaked about 80 °C hotter than Case C, or about at least 718 °C.
In Case B, the slab peaked about 80 °C hotter than Case A, or about at least 798 °C. There is some variation in those increases - perhaps Case C peak was 780 °C, or 805 °C. But very certainly above 675 °C!
The next hotter case A peaked about 60 °C hotter. That would be nearly 700 °C - off the color scale - and indeed four of the beams around col79 in Fig. 10–19 are partially shown gray!
The next hotter case B peaked about 75 °C higher, which would now be very clearly above 700 °C, even above 750 °C. And indeed, Fig. 10–39 has more beams and longer parts of beams in gray, and for a longer time.
I concede that floor slabs didn't reach 900 °C, but it remains clear that gray indicates temperatures above 675 °C, which was reached for several beams in Cases A and B. Probably above 700 °C.
Tony's claim that NIST would have mentioned temperatures above 700 °C explicitly is conecture.
He is still in denial mode.
The Case C 13th floor slab peaks below 656 °C, but above 600 °C (Fig. Figure 10–58)
The Case A 13th floor slab peaks at least in the range 656-675 °C (red), but already has some gray spots inside red borders (Fig. Figure 10–18)
The Case B 13th floor slab again peaks at least in the range 656-675 °C (red), but the gray areas within red borders are much larger now (Fig. Figure 10–38).
Now again page 455:
"For the Case B computation, the following characteristics were observed relative to Case A results.
• The peak temperatures in the tops of the floor slabs increased by about 80 ºC. The peak temperatures in the floor beams increased by about 75 ºC."
And on the next page:• The peak temperatures in the tops of the floor slabs increased by about 80 ºC. The peak temperatures in the floor beams increased by about 75 ºC."
"For the Case C computation, the following characteristics were observed relative to Case A results:
• The peak temperatures in the tops of the floor slabs decreased by about 80 ºC. The peak temperatures in the floor beams decreased by about 60 ºC"
Case C reached at least 638 °C in the 13th floor slab.• The peak temperatures in the tops of the floor slabs decreased by about 80 ºC. The peak temperatures in the floor beams decreased by about 60 ºC"
In Case A, the slab peaked about 80 °C hotter than Case C, or about at least 718 °C.
In Case B, the slab peaked about 80 °C hotter than Case A, or about at least 798 °C. There is some variation in those increases - perhaps Case C peak was 780 °C, or 805 °C. But very certainly above 675 °C!
Similarly, the 13th floor beams near column 79 reached, or came very close, to "red" in the 5pm snapshot in Case C (Fig. Figure 10–59). That would be above above 638 at least.The steel temperature is what you are trying to claim was higher than 675 °C and you left out the part of page 455 where NIST only talks about steel temperatures exceeding 600 °C. This is important because there is no question they would have said exceeded 700 °C had that been the case like you are trying to claim. Your questions about top of slab temperatures are thus not pertinent.
There is no chance the NIST WTC 7 FEA had steel temperatures exceeding the 675 °C shown in the results key.
The next hotter case A peaked about 60 °C hotter. That would be nearly 700 °C - off the color scale - and indeed four of the beams around col79 in Fig. 10–19 are partially shown gray!
The next hotter case B peaked about 75 °C higher, which would now be very clearly above 700 °C, even above 750 °C. And indeed, Fig. 10–39 has more beams and longer parts of beams in gray, and for a longer time.
I concede that floor slabs didn't reach 900 °C, but it remains clear that gray indicates temperatures above 675 °C, which was reached for several beams in Cases A and B. Probably above 700 °C.
Tony's claim that NIST would have mentioned temperatures above 700 °C explicitly is conecture.
He is still in denial mode.