does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

A good argument has been made that the "900 °C" top slab temp on page 455 is a typo.
The Case C 13th floor slab peaks below 656 °C, but above 600 °C (Fig. Figure 10–58)
The Case A 13th floor slab peaks at least in the range 656-675 °C (red), but already has some gray spots inside red borders (Fig. Figure 10–18)
The Case B 13th floor slab again peaks at least in the range 656-675 °C (red), but the gray areas within red borders are much larger now (Fig. Figure 10–38).

Now again page 455:
"For the Case B computation, the following characteristics were observed relative to Case A results.
• The peak temperatures in the tops of the floor slabs increased by about 80 ºC. The peak temperatures in the floor beams increased by about 75 ºC."​
And on the next page:
"For the Case C computation, the following characteristics were observed relative to Case A results:
• The peak temperatures in the tops of the floor slabs decreased by about 80 ºC. The peak temperatures in the floor beams decreased by about 60 ºC"​
Case C reached at least 638 °C in the 13th floor slab.
In Case A, the slab peaked about 80 °C hotter than Case C, or about at least 718 °C.
In Case B, the slab peaked about 80 °C hotter than Case A, or about at least 798 °C. There is some variation in those increases - perhaps Case C peak was 780 °C, or 805 °C. But very certainly above 675 °C!


The steel temperature is what you are trying to claim was higher than 675 °C and you left out the part of page 455 where NIST only talks about steel temperatures exceeding 600 °C. This is important because there is no question they would have said exceeded 700 °C had that been the case like you are trying to claim. Your questions about top of slab temperatures are thus not pertinent.

There is no chance the NIST WTC 7 FEA had steel temperatures exceeding the 675 °C shown in the results key.
Similarly, the 13th floor beams near column 79 reached, or came very close, to "red" in the 5pm snapshot in Case C (Fig. Figure 10–59). That would be above above 638 at least.
The next hotter case A peaked about 60 °C hotter. That would be nearly 700 °C - off the color scale - and indeed four of the beams around col79 in Fig. 10–19 are partially shown gray!
The next hotter case B peaked about 75 °C higher, which would now be very clearly above 700 °C, even above 750 °C. And indeed, Fig. 10–39 has more beams and longer parts of beams in gray, and for a longer time.


I concede that floor slabs didn't reach 900 °C, but it remains clear that gray indicates temperatures above 675 °C, which was reached for several beams in Cases A and B. Probably above 700 °C.

Tony's claim that NIST would have mentioned temperatures above 700 °C explicitly is conecture.

He is still in denial mode.
 
A good argument has been made that the "900 °C" top slab temp on page 455 is a typo.
The Case C 13th floor slab peaks below 656 °C, but above 600 °C (Fig. Figure 10–58)
The Case A 13th floor slab peaks at least in the range 656-675 °C (red), but already has some gray spots inside red borders (Fig. Figure 10–18)
The Case B 13th floor slab again peaks at least in the range 656-675 °C (red), but the gray areas within red borders are much larger now (Fig. Figure 10–38).

Now again page 455:
"For the Case B computation, the following characteristics were observed relative to Case A results.
• The peak temperatures in the tops of the floor slabs increased by about 80 ºC. The peak temperatures in the floor beams increased by about 75 ºC."​
And on the next page:
"For the Case C computation, the following characteristics were observed relative to Case A results:
• The peak temperatures in the tops of the floor slabs decreased by about 80 ºC. The peak temperatures in the floor beams decreased by about 60 ºC"​
Case C reached at least 638 °C in the 13th floor slab.
In Case A, the slab peaked about 80 °C hotter than Case C, or about at least 718 °C.
In Case B, the slab peaked about 80 °C hotter than Case A, or about at least 798 °C. There is some variation in those increases - perhaps Case C peak was 780 °C, or 805 °C. But very certainly above 675 °C!



Similarly, the 13th floor beams near column 79 reached, or came very close, to "red" in the 5pm snapshot in Case C (Fig. Figure 10–59). That would be above above 638 at least.
The next hotter case A peaked about 60 °C hotter. That would be nearly 700 °C - off the color scale - and indeed four of the beams around col79 in Fig. 10–19 are partially shown gray!
The next hotter case B peaked about 75 °C higher, which would now be very clearly above 700 °C, even above 750 °C. And indeed, Fig. 10–39 has more beams and longer parts of beams in gray, and for a longer time.


I concede that floor slabs didn't reach 900 °C, but it remains clear that gray indicates temperatures above 675 °C, which was reached for several beams in Cases A and B. Probably above 700 °C.

Tony's claim that NIST would have mentioned temperatures above 700 °C explicitly is conecture.

He is still in denial mode.

For what you are saying to be true then whoever set up the FEA results scale in the report had to manually cut and paste it, as the software will put the actual max numerical value in above the range if it is outside the range applied. If that is true then there was some level of incompetence and it calls into question the NIST analysis. There have been serious questions leveled against the fuel load they used.

It is also strange that page 455 would only talk about steel temperatures exceeding 600 °C if there were temperatures above 700 °C shown in the analysis as you claim the gray areas imply.
 
Last edited:
For what you are saying to be true then whoever set up the FEA results scale in the report had to manually cut and paste it, as the software will put the actual max numerical value in above the range if it is outside the range applied. If that is true then there was some level of incompetence and it calls into question the NIST analysis. There have been serious questions leveled against the fuel load they used.

It is also strange that page 455 would only talk about steel temperatures exceeding 600 °C if there were temperatures above 700 °C shown in the analysis as you claim the gray areas imply.

No.
 
For what you are saying to be true then whoever set up the FEA results scale in the report had to manually cut and paste it, as the software will put the actual max numerical value in above the range if it is outside the range applied.
It would be a different max for every chart, wouldn't it.
They apparently decided to have the same scale on all heat maps. So perhaps they did indeed cut and paste the scale bar. ETA: and left out the gray box, for the upper end of its temperature range would be different from Figure to Figure

If that is true then there was some level of incompetence and it calls into question the NIST analysis.
At most, it would be mild incompetence in editing figures - this is independent of the quality of the analysis.
Aparently, NIST was chiefly interested if and where temperatures exceeded 600 °C.

There have been serious questions leveled against the fuel load they used.
Put that goal post back to where you stole it from, please ;)

It is also strange that page 455 would only talk about steel temperatures exceeding 600 °C if there were temperatures above 700 °C shown in the analysis as you claim the gray areas imply.
You find it strange - personal incredulity - we've been through this before.

You don't address the argument I presented. I guess that means you can't find a fault with it.

It really becomes obvious that gray means > 675 °C, doesn't it?


I can offer you the following face-saving compromise:
  • >700 °C definitely looks plausible.
  • It is however implausible that beam temperatures in NIST's model exceeded 800 °C, and they may not have exceeded 750 °C even in Case B.
  • This seems consistent with the peak temperatures that Beyler and Abboud reported - albeit for floors 10 and 9. [*]
  • Obviously, NIST and WAI have a considerable disagreement about the fire development, or heat transfer, under floors 10 and 9, for NIST has beams peaking on those floors at much cooler temperatures
All agreed?


[*] According to page B-85 of the WAI report (Abboud 2010), floor 10 reached 750 °C locally, while Figure 81 on page B-102 suggests that floor 9 hardly exceeded 600 °C (color shades are a bit difficult to pin down).
 
Last edited:
It would be a different max for every chart, wouldn't it.
They apparently decided to have the same scale on all heat maps. So perhaps they did indeed cut and paste the scale bar. ETA: and left out the gray box, for the upper end of its temperature range would be different from Figure to Figure


At most, it would be mild incompetence in editing figures - this is independent of the quality of the analysis.
Aparently, NIST was chiefly interested if and where temperatures exceeded 600 °C.


Put that goal post back to where you stole it from, please ;)


You find it strange - personal incredulity - we've been through this before.

You don't address the argument I presented. I guess that means you can't find a fault with it.

It really becomes obvious that gray means > 675 °C, doesn't it?


I can offer you the following face-saving compromise:
  • >700 °C definitely looks plausible.
  • It is however implausible that beam temperatures in NIST's model exceeded 800 °C, and they may not have exceeded 750 °C even in Case B.
  • This seems consistent with the peak temperatures that Beyler and Abboud reported - albeit for floors 10 and 9. [*]
  • Obviously, NIST and WAI have a considerable disagreement about the fire development, or heat transfer, under floors 10 and 9, for NIST has beams peaking on those floors at much cooler temperatures
All agreed?


[*] According to page B-85 of the WAI report (Abboud 2010), floor 10 reached 750 °C locally, while Figure 81 on page B-102 suggests that floor 9 hardly exceeded 600 °C (color shades are a bit difficult to pin down).

You know, if I wanted my report to be consistent, I might generate a color scale like this
0-225C green
226-450C blue
451-425C orange
426-675C red
675-900C grey
(You can subdivide this any way you want. I don't have the report in front of me, so I can't respond exactly how it was done)

The FEM Will report 900C as max on the PPFDPS (pretty picture for dog and pony show), since that is the scale it is given simply because that is the way the damn things work (PATRAN and ALGOR allow you to actually post "Max 782C at node 29346", if you want it to...ETA buy you can turn that feature OFF)
 
Last edited:
(You can subdivide this any way you want. I don't have the report in front of me, so I can't respond exactly how it was done)

If you are interested:
All of NIST's WTC investigation reports, and the FEMA report, can be conveniently downloaded from here:
https://onedrive.live.com/?id=23638DA582FECBF6!106&cid=23638DA582FECBF6
You can download entire folders, or drill down to individual reports.
The PDFs are "unlocked", which mainly means you can copy from them.
The document we are referring to here, NCSTAR 1-9, is this.
 
If you are interested:
All of NIST's WTC investigation reports, and the FEMA report, can be conveniently downloaded from here:
https://onedrive.live.com/?id=23638DA582FECBF6!106&cid=23638DA582FECBF6
You can download entire folders, or drill down to individual reports.
The PDFs are "unlocked", which mainly means you can copy from them.
The document we are referring to here, NCSTAR 1-9, is this.
Actually, I had them and read them some time ago. There was nothing remarkable in there, so I made room on my hard drive. Nothing anybody has said or argued has caused me any reason to re-evaluate my position, especially when the arguments come from folks as incompetent at using the available tools as I've seen so far...
 
Actually, I had them and read them some time ago. There was nothing remarkable in there, so I made room on my hard drive. Nothing anybody has said or argued has caused me any reason to re-evaluate my position, especially when the arguments come from folks as incompetent at using the available tools as I've seen so far...

It is not the original run, it is a reopened file, after the original true run with the standardized color key for A36 steel.

The original run may have in fact had another color key reopen the program on an already run file,

The program will display the images with the standard auto range.

It is a human error, in the report.

The Report was written after the data sets were run, plenty of possibility for human errors.

I just tried it on a similar program, save image close file and the key reverts to standard auto range for the steel, in question.

This happens because people make mistakes.
 
It is not the original run, it is a reopened file, after the original true run with the standardized color key for A36 steel.

The original run may have in fact had another color key reopen the program on an already run file,

The program will display the images with the standard auto range.

It is a human error, in the report.

The Report was written after the data sets were run, plenty of possibility for human errors.

I just tried it on a similar program, save image close file and the key reverts to standard auto range for the steel, in question.

This happens because people make mistakes.
********. No competent engineer or engineering manager lets that sort of crap throough. Those reports were vetted 7 ways from Sunday.
Don't know what you use, cobber, but when I save an image in PATRAN, IDEAS, or ALGOR, that saved image stays exactly as I saved it.
The program may revert (PATRAN doesn't necessarily) when you close it, but it's easy enough to catch and fix when you re-open it.
 
********. No competent engineer or engineering manager lets that sort of crap throough. Those reports were vetted 7 ways from Sunday.
Don't know what you use, cobber, but when I save an image in PATRAN, IDEAS, or ALGOR, that saved image stays exactly as I saved it.
The program may revert (PATRAN doesn't necessarily) when you close it, but it's easy enough to catch and fix when you re-open it.

Might someone simply not believed it was critical to the validity of the report to use the customized Scale, vs the standard Scale?

As I said human error, is what it appears to be.

It happens even on billion dollar space craft.
 
It would be a different max for every chart, wouldn't it.
They apparently decided to have the same scale on all heat maps. So perhaps they did indeed cut and paste the scale bar. ETA: and left out the gray box, for the upper end of its temperature range would be different from Figure to Figure


At most, it would be mild incompetence in editing figures - this is independent of the quality of the analysis.
Aparently, NIST was chiefly interested if and where temperatures exceeded 600 °C.

Put that goal post back to where you stole it from, please ;)


You find it strange - personal incredulity - we've been through this before.

You don't address the argument I presented. I guess that means you can't find a fault with it.

It really becomes obvious that gray means > 675 °C, doesn't it?


I can offer you the following face-saving compromise:
  • >700 °C definitely looks plausible.
  • It is however implausible that beam temperatures in NIST's model exceeded 800 °C, and they may not have exceeded 750 °C even in Case B.
  • This seems consistent with the peak temperatures that Beyler and Abboud reported - albeit for floors 10 and 9. [*]
  • Obviously, NIST and WAI have a considerable disagreement about the fire development, or heat transfer, under floors 10 and 9, for NIST has beams peaking on those floors at much cooler temperatures
All agreed?


[*] According to page B-85 of the WAI report (Abboud 2010), floor 10 reached 750 °C locally, while Figure 81 on page B-102 suggests that floor 9 hardly exceeded 600 °C (color shades are a bit difficult to pin down).

To use a common scale for all heat maps most people would use the worst case, which would have been about 750 °C if what you are saying is true. You are clearly guessing as to what NIST's intent was, but I will agree that they might have left off the actual max color and value if they manually cut and pasted the results color key. My guess is they wanted to show as much red as possible on all maps, so they edited the keys on all to show red at a lower temperature than the actual max and then didn't use the color key for those that exceeded the cut off. The software would have put a gray block at the end in those cases and showed the actual max numerical value.

We should also consider why NIST has the steel on floors 9 and 10 at about 500 °C. Why the big difference between what they show and what Weidlinger shows?

I personally think Wedilinger's temperatures are nothing more than reverse engineered to get what they needed on two contiguous floors to have the first floor collapse and break through the next one down. NIST's analysis doesn't have two contiguous floors at high temps like 700 °C and they actually have none as high as those claimed by Weidlinger.

We have seen how Nordenson and NIST failed on the break through count and they had to know it couldn't occur at the temperatures they showed in the areas they said it happened. NIST didn't even show an analysis for it and Nordenson ridiculously used an infinite stiffness.

Weidlinger brought up the problem with breaking through the next floor down for ARUP, so they knew it, and I think decided to ensure enough heating on two contiguous floors to make it plausible and moved the implausibility to the temperature they needed. The extreme temperature they claim would require much more work for others to mathematically ascertain than the structural calculations for break through, even if it would seem implausible on its face to experienced people, due to lack of fuel load and time at temperature for the fire to generate those extreme temperatures on large pieces of insulated steel.
 
Last edited:
To use a common scale for all heat maps most people would use the worst case, which would have been about 750 °C if what you are saying is true. You are clearly guessing as to what NIST's intent was, but I will agree that they might have left off the actual max color and value if they manually cut and pasted the results color key. My guess is they wanted to show as much red as possible on all maps, so they edited the keys on all to show red at a lower temperature than the actual max and then didn't use the color key for those that exceeded the cut off. The software would have put a gray block at the end in those cases and showed the actual max numerical value.

We should also consider why NIST has the steel on floors 9 and 10 at about 500 °C. Why the big difference between what they show and what Weidlinger shows?

I personally think Wedilinger's temperatures are nothing more than reverse engineered to get what they needed on two contiguous floors to have the first floor collapse and break through the next one down. NIST's analysis doesn't have two contiguous floors at high temps like 700 °C and they actually have none as high as those claimed by Weidlinger.

We have seen how Nordenson and NIST failed on the break through count and they had to know it couldn't occur at the temperatures they showed in the areas they said it happened. NIST didn't even show an analysis for it and Nordenson ridiculously used an infinite stiffness.

Weidlinger brought up the problem with breaking through the next floor down for ARUP, so they knew it, and I think decided to ensure enough heating to make it plausible and moved the implausibility to the temperature they needed. The extreme temperature they claim would require much more work for others to mathematically ascertain than the structural calculations for break through, even if it would seem implausible on its face to experienced people, due to lack of fuel load and time at temperature for the fire to generate those extreme temperatures on large pieces of insulated steel.

If off scale gray pixels in the ch 10 figues are supposed to be significant then one has to wonder how far the cut and pasting went. 600C Case C temps are not consistent with the principal resuts in ch 14, which show that for the baseline Case A, and the beams topping out at about 670C in the extra hot CaseB. The wording "exceeding" 600 plus 70 for Case B comes to "exceeding" 670 which is consistent with the color scale topping out at 675C:

NIST 14.3.3 pdf page 623:
Quote:
The temperatures of some sections of the beams supporting Floors 8, 12, 13, and 14 exceeded 600 ºC (1100 ºF). The temperatures of some sections of the floor beams at Floors 9 and 10 reached 400 ºC (750 ºF)...Raising the fire-generated air temperatures by 10 percent, which was within the range of reasonable and realistic fires, raised the peak temperatures in the floor beams and slabs by about 70 ºC (170 ºF)...
 
If off scale gray pixels in the ch 10 figues are supposed to be significant then one has to wonder how far the cut and pasting went. 600C Case C temps are not consistent with the principal resuts in ch 14, which show that for the baseline Case A, and the beams topping out at about 670C in the extra hot CaseB. The wording "exceeding" 600 plus 70 for Case B comes to "exceeding" 670 which is consistent with the color scale topping out at 675C:

Ziggi, you are right in that we don't know how far the cutting and pasting went.

I think all three reports are bogus and the NIST and ARUP reports have been proven to be non-explanatory due to omissions and inaccurate claims.

Those still willing to believe WTC 7 somehow came down via fire are now forced to put their eggs in the Weidlinger basket, hoping it can withstand the scrutiny the other two reports couldn't. There their problem is that the temperatures Weidlinger needs/claims are extremely implausible, due to fuel load and time at temperature, and the likelihood of these extremes happening on two contiguous floors is ridiculously low. The large disagreement in temperatures between Weidlinger and NIST on floors 9 and 10 also show how nebulous the fire simulation and heat transfer analyses were.
 
Last edited:
Ziggi, you are right in that we don't know how far the cutting and pasting went.

I think all three reports are bogus and the NIST and ARUP reports have been proven to be non-explanatory due to omissions and inaccurate claims.

Those still willing to believe WTC 7 somehow came down via fire are now forced to put their eggs in the Weidlinger basket, hoping it can withstand the scrutiny the other two reports couldn't. There their problem is that the temperatures Weidlinger needs/claims are extremely implausible, due to fuel load and time at temperature, and the likelihood of these extremes happening on two contiguous floors is ridiculously low. The disagreement between Weidlinger and NIST on floors 9 and 10 also show how nebulous the fire simulation and heat transfer analyses were.

The ch 14 summary puts the max temps for floor beams for the hottest simulation at exceeding 670 which is consistent with the color charts topping out at 675, meaning the max temp was 670-675. This is also consistent with NIST not talking about any beams exceeding 700 in the text anywhere or lists or charts. To me it looks like any gray pixels in ch 10 were either error or photoshopping, and some ch 10 text was then either intentionally or by mistake rewritten to fit.
 
Ziggi, you are right in that we don't know how far the cutting and pasting went.

I think all three reports are bogus and the NIST and ARUP reports have been proven to be non-explanatory due to omissions and inaccurate claims.

Those still willing to believe WTC 7 somehow came down via fire are now forced to put their eggs in the Weidlinger basket, hoping it can withstand the scrutiny the other two reports couldn't. There their problem is that the temperatures Weidlinger needs/claims are extremely implausible, due to fuel load and time at temperature, and the likelihood of these extremes happening on two contiguous floors is ridiculously low.

This is abject nonsense. You have not proved what you claim to have proved, but that is really a deliberate distraction, anyway.

There is no way that you will ever be able to disprove every possible fire-induced hypothesis by merely speculating about what was happening inside the building. The only way that you can prove the negative claim that fire did not cause the collapse is by proving that something else caused it. If something else caused it, there should be evidence, so that should be entirely possible. But you will not even make the attempt because you know you cannot even formulate a plausible hypothesis, much less prove it.

You will never face up to this because it shuts down your entire game. Arguing with such a disingenuous person is a complete waste of time.
 
I brought up the fact the WTC buildings were buckling and leaning as fires raged out of control before they collapse to proved that fire, in conjunction with impact damage, was responsible for the collapse of those buildings.

No, you brought up that a few perimeter wall units were apparently bending slightly inwards. So what? You're making it into something that it isn't. And now you're trying to post gifs of the first second of collapse as if it has anything to do with the leaning purported to exist. Can you just stop your games, please? Post proof of actual leaning or stop trying to say it existed.
 
A lean that would be easily visible from a viewpoint at the base of the tower looking upward (that is, where the firefighters were and photographers weren't) could still be very difficult to discern in a high-resolution photograph (and correspondingly impossible to discern in a low-resolution one) from a different angle.

Have you ever sighted down the length of a wooden plank or stud to see the warp in it? It's easy to see warps that are not visible from a normal side-on view.

Surely some photographic expert can (or has tried to) look into the possibility of leaning by measuring individual pixels?
 
There is no way that you will ever be able to disprove every possible fire-induced hypothesis by merely speculating about what was happening inside the building. The only way that you can prove the negative claim that fire did not cause the collapse is by proving that something else caused it. If something else caused it, there should be evidence, so that should be entirely possible. But you will not even make the attempt because you know you cannot even formulate a plausible hypothesis, much less prove it.
And that was indeed how I planned to frame the discussion with Tony. The reports that he so desperately tries to prove wrong are completely inconsequential to the question of whether there was CD or not, because CD needs positive proof.

Alas, he weaselled out of the discussion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom