does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Originally Posted by Ziggi View Post
Your posts are full of non-sense, apparently with "facts" made up on the go.
Originally Posted by Ziggi
There are no color boxes to represent beam temperatures in the 675 to 700 range because NISTs simulation did not find any beams approaching 700C. There are a few tiny partial beam areas showing read color on a couple of floors but the red color box is the last one in a row of 4 boxes that split the 600 to 675 temp range, which means it designates a temp range that begins at 656.25 and ENDS at 675.
Now that you are staring multiple charts showing beams that reached 675 C + in the face, you are reduced to conflating the average temperature of an entire beam (which are the 400 C temperatures) with the max temperature on that beam. Sad..

Your only responses consist of making up more BS. Again, your red boxes designate temps up to 675, not over 675, no matter how often you repeat your false claim. And I am quite obviously referring to temps for "tiny partial beam areas" not whole beams as that is exactly what I wrote. The really sad part is not that you had to ignore that to make up your BS about me conflating average whole beam temperatures, the really sad part is that you also had to cut out my reference to NIST to back up my claim that NIST is indeed talking about partial sections of beams reaching up to 670 to 675C:

NIST 14.3.3 pdf page 623:

The temperatures of some sections of the beams supporting Floors 8, 12, 13, and 14 exceeded 600 ºC (1100 ºF). The temperatures of some sections of the floor beams at Floors 9 and 10 reached 400 ºC (750 ºF)...Raising the fire-generated air temperatures by 10 percent, which was within the range of reasonable and realistic fires, raised the peak temperatures in the floor beams and slabs by about 70 ºC (170 ºF)..

Now benthamitemetric,it is sad if you do not realize how pathetic it is for you to keep getting caught making up BS, and it would be really sad if your response is going to be about pretending again that it did not happen and continuing making up more BS to cover up the old BS. What is it that you think that could accomplish? You think this kind of behavior is going to increase the credibility of the ISF "debunkers" and discredit truthers? As always, it is very interesting to see that your fellow "debunkers" here never say anything when one of them is caught doing this.

Did you know that people can and that many people have researched the common traits of people that are psychopaths and/or pathological liars?
 
Last edited:
Now that you are staring multiple charts showing beams that reached 675 C + in the face,
For example on page 410, are you looking at beam sections that are coded in a purple shade that is not on the color chart?

you are reduced to conflating the average temperature of an entire beam (which are the 400 C temperatures) with the max temperature on that beam. Sad. The charts I cited clearly show beams that reached temperatures of 675 C +. Anyone can see that and anyone can read the report and understand the 400 C temperature you cite was what happened when NIST averaged the temperature across a whole beam. They explicitly say as much.
I think you want to review that. I think you are talking about a different "400 °C" than Ziggi. Ziggi refers to (max!) beam temperatures on floors 9 and 10. See for example pages 424 and 426 to see that beams on those floors did not get nearly "red hot" in NIST's color chart. I believe the 400 °C "average" temperature refer to the modes of failure that a beam would experience: Below 400 °C average temp. a beam would buckle, or fail its connection, in compression due to thermal expansion, above 400 °C, thermal weakening would dominate (sagging, I guess).
 
Your only responses consist of making up more BS. Again, your red boxes designate temps up to 675, not over 675, no matter how often you repeat your false claim. And I am quite obviously referring to temps for "tiny partial beam areas" not whole beams as that is exactly what I wrote. The really sad part is not that you had to ignore that to make up your BS about me conflating average whole beam temperatures, the really sad part is that you also had to cut out my reference to NIST to back up my claim that NIST is indeed talking about partial sections of beams reaching up to 670 to 675C:


Now benthamitemetric,it is sad if you do not realize how pathetic it is for you to keep getting caught making up BS, and it would be really sad if your response is going to be about pretending again that it did not happen and continuing making up more BS to cover up the old BS. What is it that you think that could accomplish? You think this kind of behavior is going to increase the credibility of the ISF "debunkers" and discredit truthers? As always, it is very interesting to see that your fellow "debunkers" here never say anything when one of them is caught doing this.

Did you know that people can and that many people have researched the common traits of people that are psychopaths and/or pathological liars?

What temperature is represented by grey? (Hint: it's 675 C +.) Now look at the pages I cited. See all of the grey areas on the beams?

Since you are either dishonest or blind, I'm uploading a screenshot of the grey areas too.
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 10-37.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 10-37.jpg
    52.5 KB · Views: 15
What temperature is represented by grey? (Hint: it's 675 C +.) Now look at the pages I cited. See all of the grey areas on the beams?

Since you are either dishonest or blind, I'm uploading a screenshot of the grey areas too.

Color perception is subjective. I think I see purple shades where you see grey. Possible? Some beams betweem the c79-c80 girder and the east face.
 
Color perception is subjective. I think I see purple shades where you see grey. Possible? Some beams betweem the c79-c80 girder and the east face.

Zoom in to the pixel level. It is grey--the same grey NIST used in the same set of figures to represent the temperatures of the concrete slabs that NIST stated were 900 C +. The grey color is clearly a temperature in excess of the depicted scale (i.e., 675 C+).
 
Zoom in to the pixel level. It is grey--the same grey NIST used in the same set of figures to represent the temperatures of the concrete slabs that NIST stated were 900 C +. The grey color is clearly a temperature in excess of the depicted scale (i.e., 675 C+).

Yes, I see it now.

I believe you still want to review that "400 °C average" issue.
 
As always, it is very interesting to see that your fellow "debunkers" here never say anything when one of them is caught doing this.
Well, since you include me by implication, I will tell you why I have stayed out of this component temp discussion of late.
1) The topic of the thread is debate, it is not a technical debate in itself
2) I used to have several NIST reports saved but I long since deleted them to free up space on my computer. Finding specific reports on nist.gov again is a pain. Besides, we now have at least three professional engineering firms that have concluded fire brought down WTC7 by initiating a progressive collapse sequence, versus your compatriots who have,,,,, personal incredulity and a series of drawings by a carpenter.

YOU, and those compatriots will have to do one hell of a lot better to sway my thoughts on this. Hell, you have to do a lot better to even garner credibility.

That said, I have had no problem following discussion within the threads on this forum. A separate, dedicated debate elsewhere would mean nothing other than my having to switch back and forth between websites. I utterly fail to see any usefullness in such a separate debate.

With that in mind I have asked Tony, Criteria, and others, including you iirc, how such a debate would further the agenda of the truth movement and AE911T. My exact wording, in case you missed the half dozen or more times I posted it here, concerns how said agenda has been furthered by tfk having withdrawn.
Oddly while you and others continue to derail into technical debate within this thread, not a soul has addressed my questions.
 
Last edited:
Zoom in to the pixel level. It is grey--the same grey NIST used in the same set of figures to represent the temperatures of the concrete slabs that NIST stated were 900 C +. The grey color is clearly a temperature in excess of the depicted scale (i.e., 675 C+).

Your story keeps evolving to fit your wishes and you divert attention from being caught making up BS, as you did when you claimed NIST "explicitly" said the 400C number was an average for the whole beam when the truth was just the opposite:

Originally Posted by benthamitemetric View Post
..Anyone can see that and anyone can read the report and understand the 400 C temperature you cite was what happened when NIST averaged the temperature across a whole beam. They explicitly say as much.
NIST 14.3.3 pdf page 623:
...The temperatures of some sections of the floor beams at Floors 9 and 10 reached 400 ºC (750 ºF)...

When NIST is describing areas with a temp range that reaches and goes beyond 700C, it has a color chart that goes as high as the max temps, as in fig 9-4 and others showing temps up to 1000C. Here the red box represents 900 to 1000C. The color charts for the floor beams otoh do not reach 700C, and that is because the simulations did not show any floor beams anywhere close to 700C, let alone above 700C. There is no another row of 4 boxes representing the next 75C above 675 because there is no use for them. There is not even 1 of 4 of those extra boxes to reach 693.75C because there was no need for even that because no beams even approached 700C remotely. This is also why you see no text referring to any floor beams getting above 680 or 690 or getting close to 700C. Instead of imagining temperatures from figures, cite NIST actually talking about floor beams getting to 700C or over 700C...you can find a reference to at least one partial beam over 700C, right?
 
Your story keeps evolving to fit your wishes and you divert attention from being caught making up BS, as you did when you claimed NIST "explicitly" said the 400C number was an average for the whole beam when the truth was just the opposite:




When NIST is describing areas with a temp range that reaches and goes beyond 700C, it has a color chart that goes as high as the max temps, as in fig 9-4 and others showing temps up to 1000C. Here the red box represents 900 to 1000C. The color charts for the floor beams otoh do not reach 700C, and that is because the simulations did not show any floor beams anywhere close to 700C, let alone above 700C. There is no another row of 4 boxes representing the next 75C above 675 because there is no use for them. There is not even 1 of 4 of those extra boxes to reach 693.75C because there was no need for even that because no beams even approached 700C remotely. This is also why you see no text referring to any floor beams getting above 680 or 690 or getting close to 700C. Instead of imagining temperatures from figures, cite NIST actually talking about floor beams getting to 700C or over 700C...you can find a reference to at least one partial beam over 700C, right?

What temperature range is signified by the grey areas on the figures I explicitly cited to you?
 
Yes, I see it now.

I believe you still want to review that "400 °C average" issue.

Ok, I misread his earlier comment and mistakenly assumed he was making a comment relevant to the question we are actually discussing (whether the NIST fire temperature models are consistent with WAI's). I see now that he was just raising the difference in floors point, which isn't even relevant to determine the difference in modeling of the fire behavior in the context of Tony's objection that the overall temperatures reached in the WAI model were "ridiculous". NIST states elsewhere that beam average temperatures were 400 C in places. I see that is not what Ziggi was referring too.
 
Last edited:
In the State of Washington, during my time, at more than one college, you can take the Philosophy of Logic and carry it out to a Doctorate level by whatever name the college chose to call it. If nothing else you major in philosophy with a minor in formal logic.
I have seen MAs in Logic, but no BAs, which is what you were requiring posters here to have before being, in your estimate, qualified to debate with TS.
And do you have this qualification?
Why do I need to have formal logic debate skills to make the observation that neo-skeptics like to strut and crow with their rat pack backing them up, but when faced with a one-on-one formal, moderated debate in the grand fashion of this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbTxLmbCoo4
Neos turn tail and run. Last time I checked no one has taken Tony up on his challenge which can be expressed by this psychological equation:
Neo + challenge - willing takers = BIG FAIL!!

Apparently not. And neither does Tony S.
As for "strutting and crowing", all I have done so far in this thread is to ask for evidence of CD. And I'm still waiting. Until and unless any of you present some evidence for your ideas, there is nothing to debate. Nit-picking NIST is not debating, and goes precisely nowhere in terms of proving CD.
As for the rest of your post, you're just trying to veer away from the inevitable, which is that if you don't take him up on it, he wins by default.
Also, it gives a really bad example of how science is conducted.
As others have noted, this is not the case at all. What's more, two posters have offered to take him up on this debate. I have not because I am not an engineer. I was also not aware until now that science was conducted through debates on internet forums. Does this only apply to conspiracy theory science, or do you have other examples of this in other scientific fields?
Just because I am not a qualified engineer does not preclude me from examining the evidence for CD. The evidence I have repeatedly asked TS to present, and which he has yet to provide. I have also asked ziggi, Criteria and fonebone, and they have also been unusually silent on this issue. Perhaps you'd like to ride to the rescue of your peergroup and provide this evidence? It would add significantly to your case, which at the moment is composed of empty bluster and hubris.
Why haven't you taken him up on his challenge? Are you going to take him up on his challenge? If no, please state why. If what you're doing is either an outright strawman or at the very least a Godzilla sized strawman is on fire one farm over.
I see no strawman. Please explain.

p.s. Hey Cosmic, I finally tracked down the Flying Friar debuggery Shameless Joe Nickel pathetically tried to debunk. I will be using it in a new thread which I will start after this one has run its course.

Stay tuned. Same Bat time, Same Bat Channel

My sense of anticipation could be described as "almost actual".
In the meantime, I await the evidence you have for CD with actual anticipation.
 
Your story keeps evolving...
Projection. Where do you guys get the silent explosives for your fantasy CD by unknown sources?

How can we debate CD and Tony making NIST a scapegoat for 9/11 truth's fantasy CD wishes? Fire did it, debate ends, you and Tony need to read NIST before you can debate your CD fantasy. Study the goals, and go ahead, explain what they failed on. Fire caused the collapse, and CD is a fantasy for non-science paranoid conspiracy theorists.

Why can't you post the details of the CD fantasy in the current events section?

Why make NIST your scapegoat, why not prove CD? 15 years of failure, CD fantasy.

Better run on, Tony won the debate, the CD fantasy remains the Big Lie of 9/11 truth.
 
Originally Posted by Ziggi View Post

...The color charts for the floor beams otoh do not reach 700C, and that is because the simulations did not show any floor beams anywhere close to 700C, let alone above 700C. There is no another row of 4 boxes representing the next 75C above 675 because there is no use for them. There is not even 1 of 4 of those extra boxes to reach 693.75C because there was no need for even that because no beams even approached 700C remotely. This is also why you see no text referring to any floor beams getting above 680 or 690 or getting close to 700C...
What temperature range is signified by the grey areas on the figures I explicitly cited to you?

In your head the gray range must signify whatever temp range you wish, but in the NIST report there is no gray or other color box above the red max temp box which ends at 675C. If you have another version of the report with another color scale with a gray box starting at 676C, then by all means post a copy of this scale here. And by all means do not be shy about citing NIST talking about your "vast swath" of floor beams at the 800plus temps you want to be there, or at least talking about a bunch of floor beams over 700C - or since it is Xmas and I am really nice and willing to make this really easy for you, please just cite NIST talking about at least ONE floor beam at over 680C. You cant even do that, can you?
 
Last edited:
...in the NIST report there is no gray or other color box above the red max temp box which ends at 675C. ...

There is also no gray color box below the red max temp box which ends at 675C.

  • Are you suggesting that NIST computed no temperature for those parts of the beams they colored gray?
  • Would you concede it's at least possible the gray parts are off the temperature scale which begins at 0 °C and ends at 675 °C?
  • Or do you see a third possibility to explain why NIST would color some beams gray, or any other color not on the scale 0-675 °C?

Or do you prefer to handwave and ignore the information you see? What you don't admit doesn't exist, so to say?
 
There is also no gray color box below the red max temp box which ends at 675C.

  • Are you suggesting that NIST computed no temperature for those parts of the beams they colored gray?
  • Would you concede it's at least possible the gray parts are off the temperature scale which begins at 0 °C and ends at 675 °C?
  • Or do you see a third possibility to explain why NIST would color some beams gray, or any other color not on the scale 0-675 °C?

Or do you prefer to handwave and ignore the information you see? What you don't admit doesn't exist, so to say?

In any FEA software I have ever used the maximum in structural and thermal analysis results is always presented as dark red with the lowest as dark blue and lighter shades of both and other colors such as different shades of orange, yellow, and green in between. The NIST WTC 7 FEA models use these colors and there is nothing shaded gray in the analysis results.

The gray somebody here thinks they are seeing in Chapter 10 of the NIST WTC 7 report is just the border around the key. It has nothing to do with any temperature somewhere in the model.
 
Last edited:

FAQs - NIST WTC 7 Investigation


How hot did WTC 7's steel columns and floor beams get?


Due to the effectiveness of the spray-applied fire-resistive material (SFRM) or fireproofing, the highest steel column temperatures in WTC 7 only reached an estimated 300 degrees Celsius (570 degrees Fahrenheit), and only on the east side of the building did the steel floor beams exceed 600 degrees Celsius (1,100 degrees Fahrenheit). However, fire-induced buckling of floor beams and damage to connections—which caused buckling of a critical column initiating collapse—occurred at temperatures below approximately 400 degrees Celsius (where thermal expansion dominates. Above 600 degrees Celsius (1,100 degrees Fahrenheit), there is significant loss of steel strength and stiffness.

In the WTC 7 collapse, the loss of steel strength or stiffness was not as important as the thermal expansion of steel structures caused by heat.

https://www.nist.gov/el/faqs-nist-wtc-7-investigation


What heat can do to steel railroad tracks.

extreme-heat-railroad-tracks-buckle-new-jersey-1978.jpg



An 1800-foot length of rail will expand almost one foot with an 80-degree change in temperature. Temperatures within WTC 7 were much higher.
 
Last edited:
Those who've been following the JFK thread will already be familiar with the fact that MicahJava always considers himself a more accurate eyewitness than the people who were actually present.

Dave

Says the guy who probably thinks the autopsy doctors didn't know how to use a ruler.
 
Since I don't go to the JFK thread because the nuts that think JFK was shot from the front are just to idiotic for me to care. I will take your word for it.

Actually, I was arguing for all shots coming from behind, with Kennedy being hit three times. At least three hits must be the only answer if you accept that the small head wound was near the external occipital protuberance.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom