does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

It does make a difference. Everybody knows that.

While looking for some videos of people pouring molten aluminum, I actually did come across one that appeared to show a thin stream of aluminum glowing yellow under what appears to be fairly daylight conditions. No word on how high it was heated, but check it out.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NUYqGX6a4vQ

[qimg]https://i.imgur.com/hMERKFC.jpg[/qimg]

But also, 1. The South Tower molten material stayed glowing while dropping hundreds of feet through cool air, and 2. Some of the material appears to be somehow exploding or "popping" in mid-air.

In this video, molten aluminum heated to 1800 F does not stay glowing when poured on a room-temperature pan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=30OVAvg1aGQ


I might add that the northeast corner of WTC 2 is where major portions of United 175 came to rest.

021104-13Bb.gif



You will notice in the following video that there is a fire raging in that corner of WTC 2 and you will notice there is no sound of CD explosions and that there is not a single steel column being cut by thermite nor are there the extremely bright flashes of light visible that would have indicated the use of thermite.

WTC 2 Collapse Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9SSS0DDqfm0


In addition, molten aluminum from the airframe would have been mixed with contents from the cabin of the aircraft and from within WTC 2.
 
Last edited:
Skyeagle, can you provide any photographic study that shows the Twin Towers or WTC 7 leaning prior to collapse?


Let's begin with this video.


9/11 - The Top of the North Tower (WTC 1) Is Leaning - NYPD Warning


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BNyjofoQ-Vw


AN ANALYSIS OF THE TIPPING OF THE UPPER SECTION OF WTC 2

http://www.911myths.com/WTC2TIP.pdf


WTC 7

Then this other officer I’m standing next to said, that building doesn’t look straight. So I’m standing there. I’m looking at the building. It didn’t look right, but, well, we’ll go in, we’ll see.

http://www.debunking911.com/pull.htm
 
It does make a difference. Everybody knows that.

While looking for some videos of people pouring molten aluminum, I actually did come across one that appeared to show a thin stream of aluminum glowing yellow under what appears to be fairly daylight conditions. No word on how high it was heated, but check it out.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NUYqGX6a4vQ

[qimg]https://i.imgur.com/hMERKFC.jpg[/qimg]

But also, 1. The South Tower molten material stayed glowing while dropping hundreds of feet through cool air, and 2. Some of the material appears to be somehow exploding or "popping" in mid-air.

In this video, molten aluminum heated to 1800 F does not stay glowing when poured on a room-temperature pan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=30OVAvg1aGQ

That's because the aluminum in the video is pure aluminum that has not undergone a chemical reaction process in a fire. Aluminums rapid thermal conductivity, allows it to cool rapidly back to silver on the surface, chemically react it not simply mixing it, changes that allowing both lower conductivity and self heating of the material as it moves in air.
One of the best ways to do that is to expose A large molt of Aluminum with steel dust to nitrates while it
Is oxygen shielded in a stack effect fire.
Most Cters simply try to mix the components not chemically react them.
 
Skyeagle, can you provide any photographic study that shows the Twin Towers or WTC 7 leaning prior to collapse?

There is photographic evidence of fire fighters setting up a tripod and transit that verifies the claims the building was leaning, and they set a transit on it.
 
Let's begin with this video.


9/11 - The Top of the North Tower (WTC 1) Is Leaning - NYPD Warning


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BNyjofoQ-Vw


AN ANALYSIS OF THE TIPPING OF THE UPPER SECTION OF WTC 2

http://www.911myths.com/WTC2TIP.pdf


WTC 7

Then this other officer I’m standing next to said, that building doesn’t look straight. So I’m standing there. I’m looking at the building. It didn’t look right, but, well, we’ll go in, we’ll see.

http://www.debunking911.com/pull.htm

I want photographic evidence, not witnesses and a text document about the first seconds of the South Tower collapse. Do you have photographic evidence that WTC 7 or either Twin Towers were leaning before they started collapsing?
 
Last edited:
You've been here quite a while, have you ever seen any evidence that the upper sections of either Twin Towers were leaning?

Yes it was presented by Major Tom but I do not know if many here saw it.

As the columns failed the towers tilted, that had to occur as a multi story event within the core structure.
 
Those who've been following the JFK thread will already be familiar with the fact that MicahJava always considers himself a more accurate eyewitness than the people who were actually present.

Dave

Since I don't go to the JFK thread because the nuts that think JFK was shot from the front are just to idiotic for me to care. I will take your word for it.
 
Skyeagle, can you provide any photographic study that shows the Twin Towers or WTC 7 leaning prior to collapse?

Right after you swear that you will once and forever discard every single oral mention of "explosions" that cannot be corroborated by a sound recording of explosion sounds consistent in timing, number, loudness and brisance with actual explosives charges :)
 
Originally Posted by Ziggi View Post
Your posts are full of non-sense, apparently with "facts" made up on the go. For example: The NIST report on 7 is very specific about temps, and it does not show your claimed "vast swaths" of steel over 675C, or any floor beams at all over 700C - and especially not the floor beams in question, of floors 9 and 10. NISTs fire simulation shows those beams reaching 400 C in the medium fire simulation and 475 in the extreme fire simulation, meaning the 850 C WAI number that you say is consistent with NIST is actually about double the NIST temp...
Eight years later and you still don't even know the NIST WTC 7 report very well, it seems. There are figures that clearly show beams in excess of 675 C degrees on pages 410, 412, 414, 430, 432, 434, and 528 of NIST NCSTAR 1-9. Want to check your eye sight and then try again?.....

You cant cite any text or figures to refute what I said, and your attempts to cover that up with your bluster just make you look silly, at best. You dont know what you are talking about. There are no color boxes to represent beam temperatures in the 675 to 700 range because NISTs simulation did not find any beams approaching 700C. There are a few tiny partial beam areas showing read color on a couple of floors but the red color box is the last one in a row of 4 boxes that split the 600 to 675 temp range, which means it designates a temp range that begins at 656.25 and ENDS at 675. That you translate this into "vast swaths" of beams at over 675 does not shine a favorable light on your eye sight or intellect or reading comprehension - and neither does you bluster about this being consistent with another simulation showing the same beams at 850C. You are a joke.

NISTs temp for the floors shown at 850C by WAI was 400C and 470C in the extra hot simulation. NIST temp for floor beams on other floors that reached the highest temps in NISTs simulations just "exceeded" 600C and 670C in the extra hot simulation. That excess was obviously not much more than about 5C since NIST found no reason to even include any color boxes for temps above 675C.

NIST 14.3.3 pdf page 623:
The temperatures of some sections of the beams supporting Floors 8, 12, 13, and 14 exceeded 600 ºC (1100 ºF). The temperatures of some sections of the floor beams at Floors 9 and 10 reached 400 ºC (750 ºF)...Raising the fire-generated air temperatures by 10 percent, which was within the range of reasonable and realistic fires, raised the peak temperatures in the floor beams and slabs by about 70 ºC (170 ºF)...
 
You cant cite any text or figures to refute what I said, and your attempts to cover that up with your bluster just make you look silly, at best. You dont know what you are talking about. There are no color boxes to represent beam temperatures in the 675 to 700 range because NISTs simulation did not find any beams approaching 700C. There are a few tiny partial beam areas showing read color on a couple of floors but the red color box is the last one in a row of 4 boxes that split the 600 to 675 temp range, which means it designates a temp range that begins at 656.25 and ENDS at 675. That you translate this into "vast swaths" of beams at over 675 does not shine a favorable light on your eye sight or intellect or reading comprehension - and neither does you bluster about this being consistent with another simulation showing the same beams at 850C. You are a joke.

NISTs temp for the floors shown at 850C by WAI was 400C and 470C in the extra hot simulation. NIST temp for floor beams on other floors that reached the highest temps in NISTs simulations just "exceeded" 600C and 670C in the extra hot simulation. That excess was obviously not much more than about 5C since NIST found no reason to even include any color boxes for temps above 675C.

NIST 14.3.3 pdf page 623:

No one need cite info into nonsense Ziggi, the fires were capible of much higher temps,
Of near 1400C.

If NIST made a mistake that does not mean CD, is a reality.

Nothing you have presented is scientificly worthy of reexamination.
 
You cant cite any text or figures to refute what I said, and your attempts to cover that up with your bluster just make you look silly, at best. You dont know what you are talking about. There are no color boxes to represent beam temperatures in the 675 to 700 range because NISTs simulation did not find any beams approaching 700C. There are a few tiny partial beam areas showing read color on a couple of floors but the red color box is the last one in a row of 4 boxes that split the 600 to 675 temp range, which means it designates a temp range that begins at 656.25 and ENDS at 675. That you translate this into "vast swaths" of beams at over 675 does not shine a favorable light on your eye sight or intellect or reading comprehension - and neither does you bluster about this being consistent with another simulation showing the same beams at 850C. You are a joke.

NISTs temp for the floors shown at 850C by WAI was 400C and 470C in the extra hot simulation. NIST temp for floor beams on other floors that reached the highest temps in NISTs simulations just "exceeded" 600C and 670C in the extra hot simulation. That excess was obviously not much more than about 5C since NIST found no reason to even include any color boxes for temps above 675C.

NIST 14.3.3 pdf page 623:

Now that you are staring multiple charts showing beams that reached 675 C + in the face, you are reduced to conflating the average temperature of an entire beam (which are the 400 C temperatures) with the max temperature on that beam. Sad. The charts I cited clearly show beams that reached temperatures of 675 C +. Anyone can see that and anyone can read the report and understand the 400 C temperature you cite was what happened when NIST averaged the temperature across a whole beam. They explicitly say as much. As I said before, you should stick to defrauding people who want to be blind because that's what it takes to take you seriously.

It's now been 7 days and Tony has not cited a single fire science-based reason for believing the WAI simulations are "ridiculous". His wanna-be fellow travelers sure are having fun demonstrating that they also lack a basis for their critique of the WAI report. Almost humorously, one is even now trying to cite the NIST report as an unerring authority on the WTC 7 fires. Too bad he doesn't understand that report, but it's a funny series of mental spasms to witness, in any event.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom