does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

You know what you're doing and it's pretty pathetic. Like how you post pictures of the smoke alongside the south face of WTC 7 because you're trying to trick people into thinking the entire building was engulfed in flames. You waste your time on dumb tricks and contribute nothing, not even a personality.


Where there is smoke, there is fire. Let's hear it from firefighters who were there.


WTC 7 Fire Accounts

When the building came down it was completely involved in fire, all forty-seven stories.
–FDNY Assistant Chief Harry Myers (Smith, Dennis, 2002. Report From Ground Zero: The Heroic Story of the Rescuers at the World Trade Center. New York: Penguin Putnam. p. 160)


"I had a clear view down Washington Street of Building Seven, which was on the north edge of the site. All forty-seven stories were on fire. It was wild. The MPs said the building was going to collapse. I said, "Nah, I don't know." And then all of a sudden I watched the building shake like an earthquake hit it, and the building came down."

–Ground Zero Superintendant Charlie Vitchers


Then we had to move because the Duane Reade, they said, wasn't safe because building 7 was really roaring.
–FDNY Chief Medical Officer Kerry Kelly.


I walked out and I got to Vesey and West, where I reported to Frank [Cruthers]. He said, we’re moving the command post over this way, that building’s coming down. At this point, the fire was going virtually on every floor, heavy fire and smoke that really wasn’t bothering us when we were searching because it was being pushed southeast and we were a little bit west of that. I remember standing just where West and Vesey start to rise toward the entrance we were using in the World Financial Center. There were a couple of guys standing with me and a couple of guys right at the intersection, and we were trying to back them up – and here goes 7. It started to come down and now people were starting to run.

–FDNY Deputy Chief Nick Visconti
 
Where there is smoke, there is fire. Let's hear it from firefighters who were there.

While I would agree that the NIST report and others all have fires in about 20% of the entire 47 storey structure, your firefighter quotes bring out a bit of hypocrisy in Ziggi et al.
While they will loudly expound upon the witness statements that include references to explosions despite there being no physical or documentary evidence to bolster that, here you have provided witness statements that they feel compelled to dismiss despite there being some evidence to support it.
More in depth investigation reveals fire on 10 floors out of the 47, yet do truthers have anything more in depth to support 'explosions"? No!
They have claims, and bald assertions.

Tony wants to debate the NIST reports and incidentally, other reports and studies concerning three WTC structures. Only recently has he acquiesced to debating HIS contention of controlled demolition. What does that mean? It means putting forth his opinion and claims and bald assertions. It does not mean any study or calculations.
 
While we wait for Tony to contact him, here is a bio for Dr. Beyler:

https://www.nap.edu/read/10777/chapter/6

Craig Beyler is the technical director for Hughes Associates, Inc. He is recognized for his unique leadership in developing and implementing scientifically based methods for engineering analyses of fire phenomena. His many contributions to this area have included both theoretical and experimental work in enclosure fire phenomena and extinguishment mechanisms. Of particular relevance is his work on an analytical basis for fire detector response, SFPE’s Practice Guide on Radiation from Pool Fires, and his advancements of heat/smoke vent engineering calculation methods. Recently he received the Arthur B. Guise Medal recognizing eminent achievement in advancing the science of fire protection engineering and was elected as an SFPE fellow. Dr. Beyler holds a B.S. degree in fire protection engineering from the University of Maryland, a B.S. in civil engineering from Cornell, an M.S. in mechanical engineering from Cornell, an M.Sc. in fire safety engineering from the University of Edinburgh, and a Ph.D. in engineering science from Harvard.

That bio is from a publication with these authors (These are Beyler's peers.):
DAVID LUCHT, Chair,
Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, Massachusetts
CRAIG BEYLER,
Hughes Associates, Inc., Baltimore
DAVID COLLINS,
American Institute of Architects, Cincinnati
FRED DRYER,
Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey
KEN DUNGAN,
Risk Technologies, LLC, Knoxville, Tennessee
OFODIKE “DK” A. EZEKOYE,
University of Texas at Austin
WILLIAM FEINBERG,
University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati
CHARLES KIME,
Arizona State University East, Mesa
JOHN LYONS,
U.S. Army Research Lab (retired), Mt. Airy, Maryland
FRED MOWRER,
University of Maryland, College Park
ELI PEARCE,
Polytechnic University, Brooklyn
JUDY RIFFLE,
Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg
JAMES T’IEN,
Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland
BETH TUBBS,
International Conference of Building Officials, Northbridge, Massachusetts
FORMAN WILLIAMS,
University of California at San Diego, La Jolla
TOM WOODFORD,
Oklahoma State University, Stillwater

Attached are Dr. Beyler's CV and selected publications list as submitted to the court in connection with his initial affidavit in the Aegis case. The guy is one of the top fire science experts in the world. It's seriously sad to watch a bunch of know-nothings straining their hardest to assert, without any evidence, that he must have gotten his analyses wrong because... because... because... well, they can't really say, but they know it in their heart...
 

Attachments

Last edited:
Interesting. I did a quick google of this, and couldn't find a single university offering such a thing.
I'd like to add my voice to those asking if you have such a qualification, and, if so, where you obtained it. I'd also like to know if Tony Szamboti has one and, if not, whether you consider him qualified to engage in this debate.

In the State of Washington, during my time, at more than one college, you can take the Philosophy of Logic and carry it out to a Doctorate level by whatever name the college chose to call it. If nothing else you major in philosophy with a minor in formal logic.

Why do I need to have formal logic debate skills to make the observation that neo-skeptics like to strut and crow with their rat pack backing them up, but when faced with a one-on-one formal, moderated debate in the grand fashion of this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbTxLmbCoo4
Neos turn tail and run. Last time I checked no one has taken Tony up on his challenge which can be expressed by this psychological equation:
Neo + challenge - willing takers = BIG FAIL!!

As for the rest of your post, you're just trying to veer away from the inevitable, which is that if you don't take him up on it, he wins by default.
Also, it gives a really bad example of how science is conducted.

Why haven't you taken him up on his challenge? Are you going to take him up on his challenge? If no, please state why. If what you're doing is either an outright strawman or at the very least a Godzilla sized strawman is on fire one farm over.


p.s. Hey Cosmic, I finally tracked down the Flying Friar debuggery Shameless Joe Nickel pathetically tried to debunk. I will be using it in a new thread which I will start after this one has run its course.

Stay tuned. Same Bat time, Same Bat Channel
 
...the inevitable, which is that if you don't take him up on it, he wins by default ...

Urrr ... what?!?!

*MEEEEEEEP*
Wrong. ;)

And by the way, at least two posters have already agreed to discuss this topic with Tony:
  • pgimeno, who, exactly like Tony, posted his list of discussion rules - which Tony declined to accept; so by your logic, Tony lost to pgimeno by default?
  • ozeco43, who has been ignored. Tony is of course perfectly aware of ozeco's arguments - the two have met on numerous fora for many years, and Tony has a long history of evading ozeco's very focused arguments. Again, it seems Tony loses by default, ignoring ozeco - per your criterion.
 
As for the rest of your post, you're just trying to veer away from the inevitable, which is that if you don't take him up on it, he wins by default.


So what? What, exactly, changes in the world as we know it by Tony "winning"? Will laws be revised? Building codes? Will there be criminal prosecutions, addendums to the laws of physics, or overturning of major structural engineering principles?

Or will it simply mean that a tiny minority of the Internet population can now pound their chests in triumph, and remain mired in obscurity?
 
Urrr ... what?!?!

*MEEEEEEEP*
Wrong. ;)

And by the way, at least two posters have already agreed to discuss this topic with Tony:
  • pgimeno, who, exactly like Tony, posted his list of discussion rules - which Tony declined to accept; so by your logic, Tony lost to pgimeno by default?
  • ozeco43, who has been ignored. Tony is of course perfectly aware of ozeco's arguments - the two have met on numerous fora for many years, and Tony has a long history of evading ozeco's very focused arguments. Again, it seems Tony loses by default, ignoring ozeco - per your criterion.

Prediction(it's that time if year after all): jakey will continue to claim Tony wins by default because jakey will not acknowledge any takers.

That said, let us assume no debate takes place because no ISF member would do it. Once again the question comes: what effect will this have on AE911T desire for a new investigation?
 
Last edited:
Without heating? As in a regular piece of aluminum glaring off of the sunlight?

No it is hot molten material containing Aluminum, poured into a steel pan, setting on a wooden block exhibiting black body radiation.

It is not that molten aluminum will not glow, it is that it cools so fast.
 
I skimmed over this point yesterday, but let's put it to rest.

NIST's WTC 1 & 2 report (for which they actually did the equivalent of the Cardington study by measuring the fires of model WTC cubicles) found peak fire temperatures between 800-1100 C with structural elements reaching temperatures of 800-1000 C in computer simulations based on models of those fires (SEE NIST NCSTAR 1-5).
For its WTC 7 report, NIST used peak gas temperatures between 800-1100 C. The NIST WTC 7 report isn't as explicit on the max structural temperatures reach, but if you look at the figures set forth in Chapter 10 of NIST NCSTAR 1-9, you can see that there were vast swaths of structural elements that were heated to in excess of 675 C (the highest temperature depicted via color coding). It looks likely that these elements were in the 700-850 C range given the massive expanse of these 675+ C areas.
The Cardington study saw very similar results. Max gas temperatures between 800-1108 C, with structural elements reaching 800-1000 C. Yes, many of those elements were not fire protected, but the test building was also far smaller than WTC 7 and the fires thus burned for a far shorter time over all, among other differences. Given that the peak structural element temperature in the Cardington study was 150+ C over the temperatures predicted for the peak structural element temperature in the WAI study, I'd say they look pretty consistent too. Do you have any specific modeling that predicts the the fire insulation on wtc 7 would have provided a larger degree of protection given the difference between the size of the building, fuel load, over all fire duration, etc? Of course you don't.

In sum, the fire temperatures are broadly consistent across the board. This is why after 6 days, Tony has still failed to produce any actual fire science-based support for his claim that the WAI fire model was provably "ridiculous".

Your posts are full of non-sense, apparently with "facts" made up on the go. For example: The NIST report on 7 is very specific about temps, and it does not show your claimed "vast swaths" of steel over 675C, or any floor beams at all over 700C - and especially not the floor beams in question, of floors 9 and 10. NISTs fire simulation shows those beams reaching 400 C in the medium fire simulation and 475 in the extreme fire simulation, meaning the 850 C WAI number that you say is consistent with NIST is actually about double the NIST temp. And btw, NIST found no evidence for fire ravaging the east side of floor 9, so there does not appear to be a solid foundation for the 850C WAI collapse initiation - you could call it ridiculous, or baseless and extremely unlikely. I already went over this for you, but you must have "skimmed over this point" as well:

Originally Posted by Ziggi View Post

....Mr. Szamboti has other reasons to doubt the high temps cited, the conflict with the official NIST fire simulation being one. That simulation has been critiqued for showing specific fires at specific times without having proof for them and for being rather generous in its estimates about how long they endured and how much heat they generated in the critical areas. There is then good reason to be skeptical about some report no-one can see claiming much higher temperatures. This is supposed to be a forum for scientifically minded skeptics, but you guys forgot about that years ago.

You dont know what you are talking about benthamitemetric, and your attempts to prove otherwise just end up making you look silly. I do not have time for this.
 
Gee Ziggi, if you have an issue with the report performed by a leading expert in fire sciences, you might have to contact him and ask for the full paper. Of course you would have more standing if the request came from someone with fire sciences/engineering background. You do have someone with better training, education and experience than a carpenter, right?

You see the protestations from you or Szamboti or Gage ring very hollow given that not a soul in the 911 truth movement other than a carpenter can be arsed to do anything concrete to back up those complaints.
 
Your posts are full of non-sense, apparently with "facts" made up on the go. For example: The NIST report on 7 is very specific about temps, and it does not show your claimed "vast swaths" of steel over 675C, or any floor beams at all over 700C - and especially not the floor beams in question, of floors 9 and 10. NISTs fire simulation shows those beams reaching 400 C in the medium fire simulation and 475 in the extreme fire simulation, meaning the 850 C WAI number that you say is consistent with NIST is actually about double the NIST temp. And btw, NIST found no evidence for fire ravaging the east side of floor 9, so there does not appear to be a solid foundation for the 850C WAI collapse initiation - you could call it ridiculous, or baseless and extremely unlikely. I already went over this for you, but you must have "skimmed over this point" as well:



You dont know what you are talking about benthamitemetric, and your attempts to prove otherwise just end up making you look silly. I do not have time for this.
Are you looking at the diagrams of the slabs, or the diagrams of the floor beams? It appears to be that you are looking at the slabs. see oages 422, 424 and 426 for example.
 
Your posts are full of non-sense, apparently with "facts" made up on the go. For example: The NIST report on 7 is very specific about temps, and it does not show your claimed "vast swaths" of steel over 675C, or any floor beams at all over 700C - and especially not the floor beams in question, of floors 9 and 10. NISTs fire simulation shows those beams reaching 400 C in the medium fire simulation and 475 in the extreme fire simulation, meaning the 850 C WAI number that you say is consistent with NIST is actually about double the NIST temp. And btw, NIST found no evidence for fire ravaging the east side of floor 9, so there does not appear to be a solid foundation for the 850C WAI collapse initiation - you could call it ridiculous, or baseless and extremely unlikely. I already went over this for you, but you must have "skimmed over this point" as well:

Eight years later and you still don't even know the NIST WTC 7 report very well, it seems. There are figures that clearly show beams in excess of 675 C degrees on pages 410, 412, 414, 430, 432, 434, and 528 of NIST NCSTAR 1-9. Want to check your eye sight and then try again?

As to which floors the fires were on--NEWSFLASH--no one knows exactly. NIST, ARUP, WAI, Nordenson all have slightly different theories. No one knows for sure and know one can know for sure. There was no way of monitoring that for sure and we don't have a time machine. None of these reports is looking to pin down exactly what happened because smart people understand that is impossible. The reports are looking at reasonable scenarios that could have happened given different assumptions about where the fire was and its exact progression timeline. Contrary to your ignorant misunderstanding, however, all of the reports use very similar parameters for the actual fire and its heating potential at any given place.

In sum, anyone who isn't color blind can see you are completely wrong about the WAI fires being inconsistent with NIST's fire simulations. Eight years later and you are completely ignorant of the NIST report--both of its detail and, more importantly, of its aim and purpose.

Fire scientists have now demonstrated repeatedly that various reasonable fire scenarios could have brought the building down. Are you ever going to actually read these reports and realize just how hot these fires actually were.
 
Last edited:
Where there is smoke, there is fire. Let's hear it from firefighters who were there.

Skyeagle, those firefighters were making the same mistake you are. Smoke does not always mean fire. The NIST report even acknowledges that fire could not have spread floor-by-floor, so it would be impossible for North Tower rubble to somehow start fires on every floor. NIST only acknowledges fires on ten floors in total throughout the day. That smoke didn't last for a very long time, so if it was fire it was totally insignificant.
 
Skyeagle, those firefighters were making the same mistake you are. Smoke does not always mean fire. The NIST report even acknowledges that fire could not have spread floor-by-floor, so it would be impossible for North Tower rubble to somehow start fires on every floor. NIST only acknowledges fires on ten floors in total throughout the day. That smoke didn't last for a very long time, so if it was fire it was totally insignificant.

Your interpretation is incorrect. Fire only needs to be sufficient, and can spread in strange ways via ventilation and other ways. If it hits the right places, in just the right way, heat can be high enough to cause expansion and collapse. No study to date thay I have has shown it impossible for fire to be sufficient. Hence the focus by die-hard conspiricists on disproving specific mechanisms in NIST, and not the fact that NIST separately ruled out explosives due to lack of sound.

Until you can establish the existence of feasible low decible explosive methods, you got nothing.So go ahead, avoid the question, continue to stave off the inevitable, that way you don't have to face the existential horror of admitting you were wrong.
 
You fell for the old trick of the CT'ers because rather it's sunlight or interior lighting, makes no difference to the aluminum temperature color chart.

It does make a difference. Everybody knows that.

While looking for some videos of people pouring molten aluminum, I actually did come across one that appeared to show a thin stream of aluminum glowing yellow under what appears to be fairly daylight conditions. No word on how high it was heated, but check it out.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NUYqGX6a4vQ

hMERKFC.jpg


But also, 1. The South Tower molten material stayed glowing while dropping hundreds of feet through cool air, and 2. Some of the material appears to be somehow exploding or "popping" in mid-air.

In this video, molten aluminum heated to 1800 F does not stay glowing when poured on a room-temperature pan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=30OVAvg1aGQ
 
Last edited:
Your interpretation is incorrect. Fire only needs to be sufficient, and can spread in strange ways via ventilation and other ways. If it hits the right places, in just the right way, heat can be high enough to cause expansion and collapse. No study to date thay I have has shown it impossible for fire to be sufficient. Hence the focus by die-hard conspiricists on disproving specific mechanisms in NIST, and not the fact that NIST separately ruled out explosives due to lack of sound.

Until you can establish the existence of feasible low decible explosive methods, you got nothing.So go ahead, avoid the question, continue to stave off the inevitable, that way you don't have to face the existential horror of admitting you were wrong.

The photographs of smoke alongside the south face of the building do not represent all 48 floors engulfed in flames. That's all I'm saying.
 
I recently re-discovered this rare aerial photograph of the gash in the southwest corner of WTC 7. Just if case any of you haven't seen it.

JCCkUln.jpg
 
Your posts are full of non-sense, apparently with "facts" made up on the go. For example: The NIST report on 7 is very specific about temps, and it does not show your claimed "vast swaths" of steel over 675C, or any floor beams at all over 700C - and especially not the floor beams in question, of floors 9 and 10. NISTs fire simulation shows those beams reaching 400 C in the medium fire simulation and 475 in the extreme fire simulation, meaning the 850 C WAI number that you say is consistent with NIST is actually about double the NIST temp.


Indicators without the NIST report, that fire in conjunction with impact damage was responsible for the collapse of WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7.

-----------------------------------------------------

Steel

The yield strength of steel is reduced to about half at 550 ºC. At 1000 ºC, the yield strength is 10 percent or less. Because of its high thermal conductivity, the temperature of unprotected internal steelwork normally will vary little from that of the fire. Structural steelwork is, therefore, usually insulated.

Apart from losing practically all of its load-bearing capacity, unprotected steelwork can undergo considerable expansion when sufficiently heated. The coefficient of expansion is 10-5 per degree Celsius.

Steel structures must me protected from direct effects of fire. However, fire protection was dislodged by aircraft and debris impacts, which exposed the steel structures to temperatures at ranges known to weaken steel under structural loads.

WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 had suffered massive impact damage, whereas, their steel structures redistributed their structural loads. Now we have a situation where their steel structures, which are now handling those redistribute structural loads, now exposed to the direct effects of fires that were raging out of control.

Reports started flowing in from the NYPD helicopter, firefighters, and civilians that WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 were buckling, and leaning just prior to their collapse events. That is an indication that fire was weakening their steel structures which would eventually result in their destruction.

We can take a look at the following reports to provide a picture as to what was happening prior to the collapse events of WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7.

Communication from NYPD Aviation Unit

10:06 am Advises everybody to evacuate area in vicinity of Battery Park City and states that, about 15 floors from top, it is totally glowing red on inside and collapse was inevitable. Advises that it is isn’t going to take much longer before North tower comes down and to pull emergency vehicles back from building.

10:21 am First reports that top of tower might be leaning, then confirms that it is buckling and leaning to the South. Reports that North tower is leaning to the Southwest and appears to be buckling in Southwest corner. Advises that all personnel close to building pull back three blocks in every direction.

10:28 am Reports that roof is going to come down very shortly. Reports that tower is collapsing.


NYPD reported WTC 2 buckling

"The NYPD aviation unit reported critical information about the impending collapse of the buildings." They could see that the exterior steel beams of the buildings were bowing. You can see the inward bowing of the steel columns in pictures of both WTC 2, (the first building to collapse) and WTC 1 (the second building to collapse.)

At 9:37, a civilian on the 106th floor of the South Tower reported to a 911 operator that a lower floor-the "90-something floor"-was collapsing. - "The 9/11 Commission Report" p304


WTC 7

Deputy Fire Chief Peter Hayden,

quoted as saying:
By now, this is going on into the afternoon, and we were concerned about additional collapse, not only of the Marriott, because there was a good portion of the Marriott still standing, but also we were pretty sure that 7 World Trade Center would collapse.

Early on, we saw a bulge in the southwest corner between floors 10 and 13, and we had put a transit on that and we were pretty sure she was going to collapse. You actually could see there was a visible bulge, it ran up about three floors. It came down about 5 o'clock in the afternoon, but by about 2 o'clock in the afternoon we realized this thing was going to collapse.
First responder: “You see where the white smoke is? You see this thing leaning like this? It’s definitely coming down. There’s no way to stop it. Cause you have to go up in there to put it out and it already – the structural integrity is just not there in the building. It’s tough, it’s.. it’s.. You know we can handle just about anything, this is beyond…


Why did WTC 2 collapse before WTC 1 even though WTC 1 was struck first? Let's take a look at the following depiction and remember, the collapse of the WTC Towers commenced at the impact points. Notice that the overhead mass at the WTC 2 impact point is much greater than the overhead mass at the impact point of WTC 1.

1024px-World_Trade_Center_9-11_Attacks_Illustration_with_Vertical_Impact_Locations.svg.png



Any CD explosives or thermite planted at the impact points would have been ineffective, yet no one saw secondary explosions during the impacts.

Thermite would not be used because of if ineffectiveness on tall steel-framed buildings, which is why cutter chargers are used rather than thermite and implosion demolition requires that their steel structures be pre-weakened prior to the emplacement of explosives, a very noisy and dirty operation that would have taken almost a year to complete for each tower, otherwise the steel structure will simply redistribute its structural loads, and it would have been impossible to properly prepare each of the WTC buildings for CD in secret.

We can take a look at the Chinese embassy bombing in Serbia, which absorbed multiple JDAM strikes and the WTC 1 bombing in 1993 as examples of how those buildings absorbed the explosions and remained standing.
 
Last edited:
Skyeagle, those firefighters were making the same mistake you are. Smoke does not always mean fire.

Apparently, they were right because WTC 7 began to lean and buckle just prior to its collapse which is undeniable evidence that fire, in conjunction with impact damage was responsible for the collapse of WTC 7 and that also explains why WTC 7 tilted toward the south in the final seconds of its collapse. In other words, WTC 7 did not collapse within its own footprint.


The NIST report even acknowledges that fire could not have spread floor-by-floor,..so it would be impossible for North Tower rubble to somehow start fires on every floor.


Provide visual evidence that every floor of the North Tower was on fire.
 
Skyeagle, can you provide any photographic study that shows the Twin Towers or WTC 7 leaning prior to collapse?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom