does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

More pompous and evasive bluster. When push comes to shove, you have nothing real to say.

Stop projecting. Do you realize 9/11 truth, and you, have zero evidence to support your 9/11 claims. All 9/11 truth has is talk, no evidence. Hurry back, when you learn 9/11 truth is a scam, and the followers are gullible.


Debating Tony and his fantasy of CD, using NIST as a scapegoat... might work for you, but not rational people. What can you debate about, you and Tony ignore the goals of NIST, and use NIST as a scapegoat to fool followers who can't read for comprehension, and have no practical/useful knowledge of science/physics/math, etc, no tools to save them from falling for your, and Tony's CD lies and the failed fantasy of an inside job.
 
Last edited:
Oh what an evasion. That the WAI describes and copies the results in a public report does not change the fact that the original study that gave those results is not available for scrutiny, or change the fact that citing unverifiable data as a certain truth is not scientific.

The data is easily verifiable by know experiments.



They are much higher than NISTs temps, meaning not consistent. The Cardington study reports artificially induced maximum flame temperatures on unprotected steel beams, which is not at all consistent with real world conditions and fire proofed steel beams. You are talking out your a#"$%&.

No one knows the damage done to the fire proofing in the building during the collapses but, damage to the fireproofing is highly likely. Believing the fire proofing is intact is fallacy.



We have both noted that the collapse initiation is based on am unscientific basis, namely the secret fire temperature report. The verifiability of the data underlying a hypothesis is the most basic scientific requirement. Then the rest of the report awaits further scrutiny; does is prove that the proposed east-west core collapse propagation is plausible? Does it replicate free-fall, etc?

Yes, and Yes. If conditions in the reports are duplicated in the collapses.



Unverifiable data underlying the conclusion is the opposite of a flimsy excuse. The report is based on a secret fire propagation model and it does not address most of our major concerns. It does debunk NISTs column 79 walk off theory and single floor collapse initiation but it replaces it with a new initiation hypothesis, so it does not really matter that it corrects some errors there. So far the WTC investigations have involved identities tainted with the military complex, NIST under insider control and working with SAIC, ARUP and Weidlinger reports on 7 - SAIC, ARUP and Weidlinger are all part of the DOD run Blast Mitigation for Structures Program. Another Weidlinger report does not exactly address (our wish for a study )without this major conflict of interest. This report does not address the melted steel and witnesses of explosions or the iron spheres or the thermitic chips or the freefall..etc etc.

No evidence for melted steel exists.
Eye Witnesses that don't support high explosive and no evidence of such.
Iron spheres are meaningless nonsense, to many sources including printed burned paper, thermitic oxygen lances, and a ton of other sources.
Have Mark Basile finish the paint chip study, then maybe we will listen.




The WAI report is based on the notion that WTC 7 suffered extreme fires but offers little proof. Perhaps you could whip up a little report? Show us the pictures and other evidence. Compare it to other known big fires in steel framed skyscrapers, and show us that this was a much more severe fire. Then you give us what WAI did not; give us a science based figure for the fires actually observed that day.

No problem if you wish I could experimentally prove that the Lack of flames, shows increased oxidation levels by dirrect conversion of carbon into CO2. High levels of conversion of hydrocarbons into the high temperature generating fuel carbon black.
Carbon black generated by high temperature pyrosis of hydrocarbon plastics.
It is not the fault of Science that fools can not interpret the evidence correctly by a scientific, unbiased basis.

Ziggi there is no scientific basis, for any of that Rant.
 
I think he'll get the point.

Over the years, I have had to respond in detail to CT'ers especially in reference to aviation and explosives. Much of what they have posted was false, which I knew was false based on my own experience in the field.

I have also been aware that much of what CT'ers have posted was false and misleading information that was deliberately planted in order to discredit the truth movement and it worked. Now, Truthers are fighting amongst themselves.

You know what you're doing and it's pretty pathetic. Like how you post pictures of the smoke alongside the south face of WTC 7 because you're trying to trick people into thinking the entire building was engulfed in flames. You waste your time on dumb tricks and contribute nothing, not even a personality.
 
You know what you're doing and it's pretty pathetic. Like how you post pictures of the smoke alongside the south face of WTC 7 because you're trying to trick people into thinking the entire building was engulfed in flames. You waste your time on dumb tricks and contribute nothing, not even a personality.

Translation: Please stop posting verifiable facts that I don't agree with.

Dave
 
You know what you're doing and it's pretty pathetic. Like how you post pictures of the smoke alongside the south face of WTC 7 because you're trying to trick people into thinking the entire building was engulfed in flames. You waste your time on dumb tricks and contribute nothing, not even a personality.

So you have nothing then?
 
Translation: Please stop posting verifiable facts that I don't agree with.

Dave

You know that ten floors in total, throughout the day, had heavy fires. And another example with skyeagle, he posted pictures of molten aluminum in dimly lit foundries and factories, while the South Tower molten material poured in daylight conditions. Everybody knows these old tricks.
 
You know that ten floors in total, throughout the day, had heavy fires. And another example with skyeagle, he posted pictures of molten aluminum in dimly lit foundries and factories, while the South Tower molten material poured in daylight conditions. Everybody knows these old tricks.

Years ago posted a photo of glowing materials including Aluminum in full sunlight with out heating.
It was actually setting on a piece of wood.
The thing is MicahJava it is not pure aluminum it is a large molten mass that was chemically reacted in a fire!

Also everyone does know your tricks.
 
Last edited:
You know that ten floors in total, throughout the day, had heavy fires.

No, I know that at least ten floors had heavy fires, that eyewitness accounts from firefighter on the scene suggested the possibility of more, and the pictures show these fires producing a huge amount of smoke. And I find it most illuminating that you're objecting to the posting of primary evidence.

And another example with skyeagle, he posted pictures of molten aluminum in dimly lit foundries and factories, while the South Tower molten material poured in daylight conditions. Everybody knows these old tricks.

No, the tricks being played are the denials that molten aluminium can possibly glow orange, and again you're objecting to the posting of evidence to the contrary. It's the old conspiracy theorist's razor; if the evidence doesn't support the conspiracy theory, it must be disposed of.

Please keep on objecting to the posting of actual evidence, though. It makes it perfectly clear to everyone what your agenda is.

Dave
 
No, I know that at least ten floors had heavy fires, that eyewitness accounts from firefighter on the scene suggested the possibility of more, and the pictures show these fires producing a huge amount of smoke. And I find it most illuminating that you're objecting to the posting of primary evidence.



No, the tricks being played are the denials that molten aluminium can possibly glow orange, and again you're objecting to the posting of evidence to the contrary. It's the old conspiracy theorist's razor; if the evidence doesn't support the conspiracy theory, it must be disposed of.

Please keep on objecting to the posting of actual evidence, though. It makes it perfectly clear to everyone what your agenda is.

Dave

Actually they say if the evidence doesn't support the theory, fake evidence that does.
 
No, I know that at least ten floors had heavy fires, that eyewitness accounts from firefighter on the scene suggested the possibility of more, and the pictures show these fires producing a huge amount of smoke. And I find it most illuminating that you're objecting to the posting of primary evidence.


No, the tricks being played are the denials that molten aluminium can possibly glow orange, and again you're objecting to the posting of evidence to the contrary. It's the old conspiracy theorist's razor; if the evidence doesn't support the conspiracy theory, it must be disposed of.

Please keep on objecting to the posting of actual evidence, though. It makes it perfectly clear to everyone what your agenda is.

Dave

Real mature, Dave. Now you're doing it. :P

You know that those pictures of smoke alongside the south face of the building don't actually show all floors engulfed in flames. It's a trick to post those pictures without the context in the timeline of WTC 7. And Skyeagle either doesn't know any better or thinks he can trick someone.
 
Last edited:
Years ago posted a photo of glowing materials including Aluminum in full sunlight with out heating.
It was actually setting on a piece of wood.
The thing is MicahJava it is not pure aluminum it is a large molten mass that was chemically reacted in a fire!

Also everyone does know your tricks.

Without heating? As in a regular piece of aluminum glaring off of the sunlight?
 
You know that those pictures of smoke alongside the south face of the building don't actually show all floors engulfed in flames.

Please provide a link to the place I claimed any such thing, or admit you're simply building strawmen. It would be nice if you could also link to the post where skyeagle409 says "These pictures of smoke alongside the south face of the building show all floors engulfed in flame."

Oh, and also note that you've admitted to heavy fires on ten floors, and that the WAI study appears to show that global collapse could result from only two floors collapsing.

Dave
 
While we wait for Tony to contact him, here is a bio for Dr. Beyler:

https://www.nap.edu/read/10777/chapter/6

Craig Beyler is the technical director for Hughes Associates, Inc. He is recognized for his unique leadership in developing and implementing scientifically based methods for engineering analyses of fire phenomena. His many contributions to this area have included both theoretical and experimental work in enclosure fire phenomena and extinguishment mechanisms. Of particular relevance is his work on an analytical basis for fire detector response, SFPE’s Practice Guide on Radiation from Pool Fires, and his advancements of heat/smoke vent engineering calculation methods. Recently he received the Arthur B. Guise Medal recognizing eminent achievement in advancing the science of fire protection engineering and was elected as an SFPE fellow. Dr. Beyler holds a B.S. degree in fire protection engineering from the University of Maryland, a B.S. in civil engineering from Cornell, an M.S. in mechanical engineering from Cornell, an M.Sc. in fire safety engineering from the University of Edinburgh, and a Ph.D. in engineering science from Harvard.

That bio is from a publication with these authors (These are Beyler's peers.):
DAVID LUCHT, Chair,
Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, Massachusetts
CRAIG BEYLER,
Hughes Associates, Inc., Baltimore
DAVID COLLINS,
American Institute of Architects, Cincinnati
FRED DRYER,
Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey
KEN DUNGAN,
Risk Technologies, LLC, Knoxville, Tennessee
OFODIKE “DK” A. EZEKOYE,
University of Texas at Austin
WILLIAM FEINBERG,
University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati
CHARLES KIME,
Arizona State University East, Mesa
JOHN LYONS,
U.S. Army Research Lab (retired), Mt. Airy, Maryland
FRED MOWRER,
University of Maryland, College Park
ELI PEARCE,
Polytechnic University, Brooklyn
JUDY RIFFLE,
Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg
JAMES T’IEN,
Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland
BETH TUBBS,
International Conference of Building Officials, Northbridge, Massachusetts
FORMAN WILLIAMS,
University of California at San Diego, La Jolla
TOM WOODFORD,
Oklahoma State University, Stillwater

The review of this report was overseen by Frank H. Stillinger, Princeton University. Appointed by the National Research Council, he was responsible for making certain that an independent examination of this report was carried out in accordance with institutional procedures and that all review comments were carefully considered.
 
Last edited:
Molten, liquid steel doesn't glow orange or yellow, it glows white hot.
If what you can see is orange or yelliw and it is liquid, it's not steel.
 
We have both noted that the collapse initiation is based on am unscientific basis, namely the secret fire temperature report. The verifiability of the data underlying a hypothesis is the most basic scientific requirement. Then the rest of the report awaits further scrutiny; does is prove that the proposed east-west core collapse propagation is plausible? Does it replicate free-fall, etc?
If you want to play the "verify this" claim, we have visual evidence to verify that fires were present in the buildings and substantial video documentation throughout the time of the event to determine that they got progressively worse over time. We have video recordings of what started the fires.

The best you can do to "verify" other culprits is quote-mine witnesses so that what they say sounds like something else, and you have to try to cast doubt on temperature scenarios by rejecting fire temperature studies and trends, and misreading a report.

Meanwhile in...the last 16 years not a single physical trace of explosive devices or any other culprit has been located... at all. Let that sink in. You are complaining that we cannot verify the fires initiated the collapse and you ignore the impact damages like they played absolutely no contributory role to the final result despite the fact that far more evidence corroborates this case than any doubt-casting you've attempted on the results of the studies you criticize. But we are supposed to believe something other than the fires lead to the collapse of the buildings when you can't even provide compelling evidence of your alternative.

Again, let that sink in.

Actually I've had this conversation in various forms with the OP and many, many CD believers over the years... almost 9 to be precise. It never does sink in

As to the OP, I've seen enough history over the years to know what the base issues with that "CD" thesis is. It's based on years' old mistakes that have remained uncorrected. I do not see a "debate" as being realistic until the OP accounts for those mistakes, much as I appreciate his effort to reach out
 
Last edited:
You know that ten floors in total, throughout the day, had heavy fires. And another example with skyeagle, he posted pictures of molten aluminum in dimly lit foundries and factories, while the South Tower molten material poured in daylight conditions. Everybody knows these old tricks.


You fell for the old trick of the CT'ers because rather it's sunlight or interior lighting, makes no difference to the aluminum temperature color chart.
 
You fell for the old trick of the CT'ers because rather it's sunlight or interior lighting, makes no difference to the aluminum temperature color chart.

That would be because.... this light is generated by the material itself and not dependant upon reflecting ambient light.

How it is represented by video or photography however also depends on the white balance setting of the recording equipment.
 
They are much higher than NISTs temps, meaning not consistent. The Cardington study reports artificially induced maximum flame temperatures on unprotected steel beams, which is not at all consistent with real world conditions and fire proofed steel beams. You are talking out your a#"$%&.

I skimmed over this point yesterday, but let's put it to rest.

NIST's WTC 1 & 2 report (for which they actually did the equivalent of the Cardington study by measuring the fires of model WTC cubicles) found peak fire temperatures between 800-1100 C with structural elements reaching temperatures of 800-1000 C in computer simulations based on models of those fires (SEE NIST NCSTAR 1-5).

For its WTC 7 report, NIST used peak gas temperatures between 800-1100 C. The NIST WTC 7 report isn't as explicit on the max structural temperatures reach, but if you look at the figures set forth in Chapter 10 of NIST NCSTAR 1-9, you can see that there were vast swaths of structural elements that were heated to in excess of 675 C (the highest temperature depicted via color coding). It looks likely that these elements were in the 700-850 C range given the massive expanse of these 675+ C areas.

The Cardington study saw very similar results. Max gas temperatures between 800-1108 C, with structural elements reaching 800-1000 C. Yes, many of those elements were not fire protected, but the test building was also far smaller than WTC 7 and the fires thus burned for a far shorter time over all, among other differences. Given that the peak structural element temperature in the Cardington study was 150+ C over the temperatures predicted for the peak structural element temperature in the WAI study, I'd say they look pretty consistent too. Do you have any specific modeling that predicts the the fire insulation on wtc 7 would have provided a larger degree of protection given the difference between the size of the building, fuel load, over all fire duration, etc? Of course you don't.

In sum, the fire temperatures are broadly consistent across the board. This is why after 6 days, Tony has still failed to produce any actual fire science-based support for his claim that the WAI fire model was provably "ridiculous".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom