does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Another post, another missed chance to provide actual science-based evidence for disbelieving the documented temperatures reached in the WAI model. By the way, you do realize Tony claimed he had enough information to prove those temperatures were "ridiculous", right? Did you miss that? It was only the start to this entire chain between he and I. Seems you and Tony disagree on that point, but not surprisingly, your reasons for disagreeing aren't even remotely informed or interesting--just lame innuendo re the fact that WAI does state of the art professional forensic science work for the DOD as well and happens to be expert on blast effects too (something I didn't bring up, but certainly something that doesn't help your knee jerk, by-the-numbers attempt to dismiss their award winning report). You should stick to defrauding people who want to believe; you're far better at that than actually thinking things through.

More pompous and evasive bluster. When push comes to shove, you have nothing real to say.
 
More pompous and evasive bluster. When push comes to shove, you have nothing real to say.

Hey Ziggi, what's going on with Mark Basile's thermite study? 8 months ago he was working on it and doing the best he could, yet not a peep since.

When can we expect him to deliver on the $5000 obligation to his donors?
 
This report does not address the melted steel...


There was no melted steel, and I have identified the molten metal flowing from the northeast corner of WTC 2 as aluminum, not steel, which was clearly evident as molten aluminum droplets.


Aluminum droplet

389183196_34d4817a75_z.jpg



Notice the silvery droplets in the lower portion of the next photo.

moltenal2.jpg



Steven Jones duped Truthers with this photo claiming the light reflection in the photo was molten steel.

wtc_light.jpg



But this video has proven that Steven Jones was lying because the light reflection was from a flashlight.


The Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YW1jsUXoRgs


...and witnesses of explosions


There were no CD explosions as WTC 7 collapsed, which videos have proven beyond a shadow of a doubt.


WTC 7 Collapse Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LD06SAf0p9A


Not a sound of CD explosions as WTC 7 collapsed, unlike true demolition implosions as in the case in the following CD video.


CD Video: The Sound of Explosions

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eem7d58gjno


A number of experts in the area have stated they heard no sound of CD explosions as WTC 7 collapsed, which is backed by those videos and lack of CD hardware within the rubble and their statements are backed by those videos. Explosions were later attributed to things that had nothing to do with explosives.


Did experts on the scene think WTC 7 was a controlled demolition?

"Several demolition teams had reached Ground Zero by 3:00 pm on 9/11, and these individuals witnessed the collapse of WTC 7 from within a few hundred feet of the event.

We have spoken with several who possess extensive experience in explosive demolition, and all reported seeing or hearing nothing to indicate an explosive detonation precipitating the collapse.
As one eyewitness told us, "We were all standing around helpless...we knew full well it was going to collapse. Everyone there knew. You gotta remember there was a lot of confusion and we didn't know if another plane was coming...but I never heard explosions like demo charges. We knew with the damage to the building and how hot the fire was, that building was gonna go, so we just waited, and a little later it went."

https://sites.google.com/site/wtc7lies/didexpertsonthescenethinkwtc7resembledac


... or the iron spheres


Investigations found no evidence of thermite in their dust samples and I have posted their findings on many occasions.

Debunked: Iron Microspheres in 9/11 WTC Dust as Evidence for Thermite

www.nmsr.org_rjlee.jpg


wheel-lg.png


The RJ Lee Group Report

The RJ Lee Group report considers samples taken several months after the collapses, and it is certain that torch-cutting of steel beams as part of the cleanup process contributed some, if not all, of the spherules seen in these samples.

http://www.wtcreflections.rjlg.com/science/


No Evidence of Explosive or Thermite Found

The R.J. Lee Company did a 2003 study on the dust and didn't find thermitic material. Other sampling of the pulverized dust by United States Geological Survey and RJ Lee did not report any evidence of thermite or explosives. It has been theorized the "thermite material" found was primer paint.

No evidence has ever been found of explosive charges and there are no recordings of a series of very loud explosions that would have been expected with controlled demolition. Furthermore, there is an alternative explanation for the "thermitic material" the sceptical scientists found in the dust - it is just a type of primer paint. It's calculated 1,200,000 tonnes of building materials were pulverised at the World Trade Center and most minerals are present in the dust (not necessarily in a large quantity).

More extensive sampling of the dust has not found any evidence of thermite or explosives, says a report from the US Geological Survey and another from RJ Lee.

http://911research.wtc7.net/essays/..._WTCDustSignatureCompositionAndMorphology.pdf


... or the thermitic chips


The thermite chips claim was determined to be false and I've even posted primer ingredients to prove my point and one of the ingredients used in primers is iron oxide.

What can be expected from a structural primer?

Nucor offers our steel coated with both red and gray primer, galvanized, or unpainted. Unpainted steel is usually used when special paint or cementous coatings are specified. The contractor or owner usually subcontracts the finish painting or application of the more aggressive primer systems.

Nucor offers primers in either red or gray. The gray primers usually cost slightly more and often come with a schedule impact. Some miscellaneous clips will be provided in red primer even on the gray orders.

www.nucorbuildingsystems.com...


Aluminum & Gray Epoxy-Mastic Primer

* Coating Section Dry Film Thickness mils
* Aluminum Epoxy-Mastic Primer 1045.8 5.0 min.
* Gray Epoxy-Mastic Primer 1045.9 5.0 m

Corothane I - MIO Aluminum

COROTHANE I MIO-ALUMINUM is a single component, VOC compliant, moisture curing, aluminum and Micaceous Iron Oxide (MIO) filled, urethane primer, intermediate coating, or finish. It has excellent surface wetting properties and provides extended recoatability.


... or the freefall..etc etc.


WTC 7 did not fully collapse at free-fall speed.


WTC 7 Collapse in 17 Seconds Video


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrIBOTfRFXo


17 seconds is far too long to be considered as free-fall.


The WAI report is based on the notion that WTC 7 suffered extreme fires but offers little proof. Perhaps you could whip up a little report? Show us the pictures and other evidence. Compare it to other known big fires in steel framed skyscrapers, and show us that this was a much more severe fire. Then you give us what WAI did not; give us a science based figure for the fires actually observed that day.


We have all the proof of fires within WTC 7.

db_Magnum1.jpg


db_wtc7_smoke_c.jpg


WTC7_Smoke.jpg


db_WTC7_smoke_a.jpg
 
More pompous and evasive bluster. When push comes to shove, you have nothing real to say.

I have a state of the art forensic study of the collapse of wtc 7 that was conducted by some of the worlds foremost experts on structural engineering and fire science. You have a fundamental conflict with Tony over whether that report is sufficiently detailed to be falsified and some unsubstantiated innuendo that the authors of the study are biased due to previously having done expert work for the DOD. Take up the former with Tony and stew in the latter all you want. That's your unthinking prerogative. Your empty objections aren't even interesting to me, but maybe you'll come up with a novel way to use them as a basis to defraud more of your fellow travelers. In the meantime, I'll keep waiting for Tony to provide his proof that the WAI temperature model is flawed. The intelligent people here, including Tony, understand very well the implications of his inability to do so.
 
People researching 9/11 are often Googled to this forum.

To 9/11 truth seekers, uncontested lies and misrepresentations by people gaming the truth create the impression of ‘acceptance’.

If not challenged, 9/11 urban myths are born.

I agree. It might be helpful at this point to lay out some of the 9/11 Urban Myths, distortions, fabrications, arguments from incredulity and false equivalencies that have been presented just in this thread alone:

Criteria said:
WTC 5 & 6 stood between WTC 7 and the Twin Towers.

Though suffering far more impact damage than WTC7, as well as suffering from long lasting major fires, WTC 5 & 6 did not collapse.

Criteria said:
Considering it also suffered from long lasting major fires, the fact that the 10 story WTC 5 dramatically resisted global collapse is absolutely amazing, especially considering your ready acceptance of the total high speed global collapse of the more distant, far less damaged 47 story WTC 7.

Criteria said:
WTC 7 is the 'smoking gun'.

Criteria said:
You could argue that the first bird that flew into WTC7 was “the first step in a ‘progressive collapse’. The term is really quite meaningless.

Criteria said:
CD describes well what was observed.

Criteria said:
Office cubicle fires heating fire-proofed structural steel to the point of sudden global collapse was only observed by the minds of those who desperately cling to the NIST hypothesis.

Just to pick a few completely at random.
 
Why focus on the steel beams? Why not the rivets and connecting bolts instead?

Flawed rivets helped sink the Titanic, and this could be the case here too.

If you can buy into secret explosive charges then why not a contractor cutting corners with knock-off hardware?

Just asking questions...:thumbsup:
 
There was no melted steel, and I have identified the molten metal flowing from the northeast corner of WTC 2 as aluminum, not steel, which was clearly evident as molten aluminum droplets.


Aluminum droplet

[qimg]http://farm1.staticflickr.com/126/389183196_34d4817a75_z.jpg[/qimg]


Notice the silvery droplets in the lower portion of the next photo.

[qimg]http://www.debunking911.com/moltenal2.jpg[/qimg]


Steven Jones duped Truthers with this photo claiming the light reflection in the photo was molten steel.

[qimg]http://www.debunking911.com/wtc_light.jpg[/qimg]


But this video has proven that Steven Jones was lying because the light reflection was from a flashlight.


The Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YW1jsUXoRgs





There were no CD explosions as WTC 7 collapsed, which videos have proven beyond a shadow of a doubt.


WTC 7 Collapse Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LD06SAf0p9A


Not a sound of CD explosions as WTC 7 collapsed, unlike true demolition implosions as in the case in the following CD video.


CD Video: The Sound of Explosions

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eem7d58gjno


A number of experts in the area have stated they heard no sound of CD explosions as WTC 7 collapsed, which is backed by those videos and lack of CD hardware within the rubble and their statements are backed by those videos. Explosions were later attributed to things that had nothing to do with explosives.








Investigations found no evidence of thermite in their dust samples and I have posted their findings on many occasions.







The thermite chips claim was determined to be false and I've even posted primer ingredients to prove my point and one of the ingredients used in primers is iron oxide.







WTC 7 did not fully collapse at free-fall speed.


WTC 7 Collapse in 17 Seconds Video


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrIBOTfRFXo


17 seconds is far too long to be considered as free-fall.





We have all the proof of fires within WTC 7.

[qimg]http://www.911myths.com/assets/images/db_images/db_Magnum1.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://www.911myths.com/assets/images/db_images/db_wtc7_smoke_c.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://www.911myths.com/assets/images/WTC7_Smoke.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://www.911myths.com/assets/images/db_images/db_WTC7_smoke_a.jpg[/qimg]

Would it be too much to kindly ask you to stop?
 
Last edited:
...
,,,, or.......here's a thought,,,,,,,,, AE911T could do that! After all they have disputed the fire sciences studies since day one, yet the only one AE911T participant who bothered to 'study' it himself has no qualifications in the field at all, and based his 'study' on part of a single sentence in the NIST report.
Are there no signatories to the AE911T petition that have qualifications in the field of fire sciences?

To answer your last question: Apparently not or none of the A&E could be bothered. Evidence:
Just last week, AE started re-posting old Chris-Sarns articles. Part 1 of 5 "BURNED-OUT FIRE":
http://www.ae911truth.org/news/317-news-media-events-fraud-exposed-in-nist-wtc-7-reports-part-1.html
AE911Truth said:
Chris Sarns’ research appears in Dr. David Ray Griffin’s book, The Mysterious Collapse of World Trade Center 7. Sarns has been deeply involved in the work of AE911Truth, where he provides his expertise on WTC 7.

So the 2750 architects and engineers still rely on the "expertise" of a carpenter who got published by a theologian, the confessed Godfather of the organization's cult leader.
 
Last edited:
Would it be too much for me to kindly ask you to stop?


I think he'll get the point.

Over the years, I have had to respond in detail to CT'ers especially in reference to aviation and explosives. Much of what they have posted was false, which I knew was false based on my own experience in the field.

I have also been aware that much of what CT'ers have posted was false and misleading information that was deliberately planted in order to discredit the truth movement and it worked. Now, Truthers are fighting amongst themselves.
 
To answer your last question: Apparently not or none of the A&E could be bothered. Evidence:
Just last week, AE started re-posting old Chris-Sarns articles. Part 1 of 5 "BURNED-OUT FIRE":
http://www.ae911truth.org/news/317-news-media-events-fraud-exposed-in-nist-wtc-7-reports-part-1.html


So the 2750 architects and engineers still rely on the "expertise" of a carpenter who got published by a theologian, the confessed Godfather of the organization's cult leader.

Did not know they were again pyshingthe Sarns b.s.

Point number 5 claims to debunk NIST's diesel fuel fire. How misleading can you get? NIST itself rejected such fires because of lack of evidence. Yes, I know, Sarns claims he is predominantly responsible for NIST not using this theoretical fire.

Then there is this
NIST will not release the input data because doing so, it claims, might “jeopardize public safety.”

How odd that others managed to use state of the art forensic fire study software to come up with their fire models for WTC7, but Sarns/AE911T could not.
 
Ok, but how is a current/future debate within an internet forum help to create the illusion of "intense public debate"? There is no link in that pamphlet to any debate. All they do is state that it is so.

I think very few readers, if any, of that pamphlet will go onto the internet to search for this "intense public debate" about 9/11.
That's not the point. It's clear to me that Gage is very careful to avoid lying. He needed an excuse to be able to say that, and Tony helped him.

At least that's my take on what happened.
 
Why focus on the steel beams? Why not the rivets and connecting bolts instead?

Flawed rivets helped sink the Titanic, and this could be the case here too.

If you can buy into secret explosive charges then why not a contractor cutting corners with knock-off hardware?

Just asking questions...:thumbsup:


Speaking of bolts and rivets, check out this link.

https://web.wpi.edu/Pubs/ETD/Available/etd-042907-214619/unrestricted/LaMalva.pdf

However, using explosives or thermite would have left behind evidence.
 
Mirror speech?

Projection? Would be expected with Truthers, as a 2011 psychological study showed.
Douglas+Sutton said:
...individuals use the social-cognitive tool of projection when making social judgments about others.

... contemporary models tend to view projection as a means of making sense of the social environment, informing judgments about others when more reliable or objective information is lacking (Ames, 2004).
 
Tony's name appears with Steven Jones on this highly flawed report.


15 YEARS LATER: ON THE PHYSICS OF HIGH-RISE BUILDING COLLAPSES

http://www.europhysicsnews.org/articles/epn/pdf/2016/04/epn2016474p21.pdf


For an example, take a look at Fig. 5 and you will notice the report tries to paint the squibs as the result of explosives, but from what I learn in high school, the squibs were the result of compressed air and nothing to do with explosives.

Here is an example of similar compressed air squibs with nothing to do with CD explosives.

contrailscience.com_skitch_http__demolitions.free.fr__E2_80_A22e203ef45d6fceb66abba893219a1052.jpg


lin.contrailscience.com_skitch_verinage_20120406_071438.jpg


Another clear example where the report is highly flawed seems to claim that molten aluminum will be silver at any temperature, which isn't true at all. The report goes on to say that "molten aluminum, even when mixed with organic materials, has a silvery appearance—thus suggesting that the orange molten metal," is thermite-molten steel, so let's take a look at an aluminum temperature color chart to determine what color aluminum glows are various temperature ranges.


Aluminum Temperature Color Chart

htchar1.gif



Using the aluminum temperature color chart above, what temperature range can we ascertain in reference to molten aluminum in the following photos?


molten.jpg


CAB297a-Molten-Aluminium-350x250.jpg


alum_casting_equipment.jpg


lg_molten-lg.jpg



To continue with his report, it says that some "156 witnesses, including 135 first responders, have been documented as saying that they saw, heard, and/or felt explosions prior to and/or during the collapses." However, none of those reports had anything to do with explosives and such reports were later attributed to gas line explosions, falling elevators, etc. No explosions were heard as the WTC building collapsed and the overwhelming majority of those people did not attribute the sounds they heard to explosives, which the report did not mention.

An Elevator Man's Tale

What we heard was 6 and 7 car free-falling from the 107th floor and they impacted the basement at B-2 Level. And that’s the explosion that filled the lobby within a matter of two or three seconds, engulfed the lobby in dust, smoke.
http://www.thrnewmedia.com/adayinseptember/jones.htm

Craig Carlsen

Craig Carlsen said that he and other firefighters “heard explosions coming from . . . the south tower

...there were about ten explosions. At the time I didn't realize what it was. We realized later after talking and finding out that it was the floors collapsing to where the plane had hit.

Jay Swithers

An ambulance pulled up which was very clean, So I assumed that the vehicle had not been in the what I thought was an explosion at the time, but was the first collapse.


I could take that highly-flawed report and tear it up in pieces so small that even all the king's men could not put it back together again.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom