does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Your bluster is unimpressive. Citing evidence that no-one can see is not scientific. You have no data to prove that the WAI temperatures are right. You have not seen the data that backs up your belief that fire induced collapse was possible, because the WAI temp data is not available for scrutiny. Non of you alleged skeptics here seem to have a problem with that. You are ranting about Mr. Szamboti not having disproved it, even though you know he has no access to it:



Your reply was a clear no:



Mr. Szamboti has other reasons to doubt the high temps cited, the conflict with the official NIST fire simulation being one. That simulation has been critiqued for showing specific fires at specific times without having proof for them and for being rather generous in its estimates about how long they endured and how much heat they generated in the critical areas. There is then good reason to be skeptical about some report no-one can see claiming much higher temperatures. This is supposed to be a forum for scientifically minded skeptics, but you guys forgot about that years ago.

The temperatures are described in a publicly available report with enough specificity so that we can determine whether they are consistent with prevailing fire science methodologies. They are consistent with the NIST report temperatures, consistent with ARUP's model (not the parametric temperature scales they used in their Analysis for Nordenson, but the traveling fire model they made with Dr. Mowrer), consistent with fires observed in the wtc scale model simulation, and consistent with the Cardington study that Tony himself cited. To date, neither you nor Tony can cite any actual basis for disbelieving them other than that they open the door to a clear fire collapse scenario where all of the NIST omitted elements are included and where Nordenson's floor collapse calculations are explicitly corrected. The WAI study is a professional forensic study that built on all of the work done to date and, as such, it explicitly addressed the major concerns of truthers to date, and yet, instead of being embraced by truthers who have been claiming they wanted such a study, it is rejected out of hand on the flimsiest of excuses. As stated above, you reject it out of pure incredulity. The awards panel at ACEC certainly didn't agree with your baseless incredulity in this case. Have you won a significant professional recognition for an alternative temperature model of wtc 7? If you could be honest with yourself, you'd realize that incredulity came from your cognitivie biases. You don't want to admit to yourself that you wasted peoples' time and money on a baseless cause.

Do you want to venture a science-based figure on the maximum temperature a given beam on the east side of he 9th or 10th floor of WTC 7 could have reached given the fires observed that day?
 
Last edited:
Nordenson was also wrong in assuming pristine floors below the collapse zone, an error he thought didn't matter due to his mistake in calculating the impact forces but also an error you deliberately repeat despite knowing his mistake on the force calculations. You only repeat that error because you know it is necessary for you to maintain the fiction that fire induced collapse was impossible.

Still waiting for you to state what you think the temperatures of the steel were, by the way. It's almost been a full five days since you claimed you could prove the WAI temperatures were wrong and no proof has been forthcoming.

To prove WAI wrong he has to know the exact oxidation rate in the effected areas, observation of the videos points to high temperatures, exstream pyrosis, dirrect conversation
of carbon to carbon dioxide with little of no flame.
Flames indicate low temperature fires, not high temp 1200-1400C fires.
Tony to have any validity has to prove low temperatures and low oxidation rate, that is not consistent with the observed data in the videos, of intense carbon pyrosis.
The air flow and observation of chemical reactions induced by the fire, indicate intense heating is occurring in the building, most likely a stack effect in a damaged elevator shaft.
The main effect though is something over came the fire retardants in the plastics that typically slow and limit fire spread.
This would be indicative of multiple high heat ignition sources and ample air flow in the early fire.
All this can be spacificly observed on the videos.
 
LOL
Such a failure.

I should have added that high temperature rupture of day tanks on the Cat gen sets could have lead to fuel air blasts, those could have easily overwhelmed the fire retardants in the plastics just as the jet fuel did in the towers.
 
Temperatures within WTC 7 were more than high enough to weaken its steel structure to the point of collapse and let's not forget massive structural damage on the south side of WTC 7.

Why do you do this? Barely anybody comes to this forum, and you come out a few months ago and every day you post like a robot copying off of a script with slight changes.
 
Originally Posted by Ziggi View Post
Your bluster is unimpressive. Citing evidence that no-one can see is not scientific. You have no data to prove that the WAI temperatures are right. You have not seen the data that backs up your belief that fire induced collapse was possible, because the WAI temp data is not available for scrutiny..
The temperatures are described in a publicly available report with enough specificity so that we can determine whether they are consistent with prevailing fire science methodologies...

Oh what an evasion. That the WAI describes and copies the results in a public report does not change the fact that the original study that gave those results is not available for scrutiny, or change the fact that citing unverifiable data as a certain truth is not scientific.

..They are consistent with the NIST report temperatures, consistent with ARUP's model (not the parametric temperature scales they used in their Analysis for Nordenson, but the traveling fire model they made with Dr. Mowrer), consistent with fires observed in the wtc scale model simulation, and consistent with the Cardington study that Tony himself cited...

They are much higher than NISTs temps, meaning not consistent. The Cardington study reports artificially induced maximum flame temperatures on unprotected steel beams, which is not at all consistent with real world conditions and fire proofed steel beams. You are talking out your a#"$%&.

..To date, neither you nor Tony can cite any actual basis for disbelieving them other than that they open the door to a clear fire collapse scenario where all of the NIST omitted elements are included and where Nordenson's floor collapse calculations are explicitly corrected...

We have both noted that the collapse initiation is based on am unscientific basis, namely the secret fire temperature report. The verifiability of the data underlying a hypothesis is the most basic scientific requirement. Then the rest of the report awaits further scrutiny; does is prove that the proposed east-west core collapse propagation is plausible? Does it replicate free-fall, etc?

..The WAI study is a professional forensic study that built on all of the work done to date and, as such, it explicitly addressed the major concerns of truthers to date, and yet, instead of being embraced by truthers who have been claiming they wanted such a study, it is rejected out of hand on the flimsiest of excuses..

Unverifiable data underlying the conclusion is the opposite of a flimsy excuse. The report is based on a secret fire propagation model and it does not address most of our major concerns. It does debunk NISTs column 79 walk off theory and single floor collapse initiation but it replaces it with a new initiation hypothesis, so it does not really matter that it corrects some errors there. So far the WTC investigations have involved identities tainted with the military complex, NIST under insider control and working with SAIC, ARUP and Weidlinger reports on 7 - SAIC, ARUP and Weidlinger are all part of the DOD run Blast Mitigation for Structures Program. Another Weidlinger report does not exactly address our wish for a study without this major conflict of interest. This report does not address the melted steel and witnesses of explosions or the iron spheres or the thermitic chips or the freefall..etc etc.

Do you want to venture a science-based figure on the maximum temperature a given beam on the east side of he 9th or 10th floor of WTC 7 could have reached given the fires observed that day?

The WAI report is based on the notion that WTC 7 suffered extreme fires but offers little proof. Perhaps you could whip up a little report? Show us the pictures and other evidence. Compare it to other known big fires in steel framed skyscrapers, and show us that this was a much more severe fire. Then you give us what WAI did not; give us a science based figure for the fires actually observed that day.
 
Barely anybody comes to this forum,
Can you then explain Tony continues to come here and want to debate people on this forum? How does a "victory" in a debate on an obscure subforum that "nobody comes to" help to advance the supposed need for a new investigation?

The only reason Tony wants to debate is because IF, and that's a big IF, he would win, all it would be used for is to stroke his own ego. This is the only thing he has to do at this point. If he didn't come here to throw down the gantlet and belittle people, he'd have nothing to do in regards to 9/11. Nobody takes him seriously outside of a few fringe forums so he comes back here.
 
Can you then explain Tony continues to come here and want to debate people on this forum? How does a "victory" in a debate on an obscure subforum that "nobody comes to" help to advance the supposed need for a new investigation?

The only reason Tony wants to debate is because IF, and that's a big IF, he would win, all it would be used for is to stroke his own ego. This is the only thing he has to do at this point. If he didn't come here to throw down the gantlet and belittle people, he'd have nothing to do in regards to 9/11. Nobody takes him seriously outside of a few fringe forums so he comes back here.

You guys still post on here. It's a very lop-sided forum now. I've read through old threads from 2006 that have people passionately debating about whether or not some kind of inter-dimensional quandary occurred north of the Citgo. Those were the good old days.
 
That the WAI describes and copies the results in a public report does not change the fact that the original study that gave those results is not available for scrutiny, or change the fact that citing unverifiable data as a certain truth is not scientific.
I keep seeing it said that this fire report is not available. Has anyone who questions it ever contacted the authors for a copy?
Not-everything-is-available-on-the-web!

They are much higher than NISTs temps, meaning not consistent. The Cardington study reports artificially induced maximum flame temperatures on unprotected steel beams, which is not at all consistent with real world conditions and fire proofed steel beams. You are talking out your a#"$%&.
Yet you and Tony are fine dismissing a report you haven't even tried to find. How wonderfully hypocritical.

The verifiability of the data underlying a hypothesis is the most basic scientific requirement
SO ASK FOR IT.

Then the rest of the report awaits further scrutiny; does is prove that the proposed east-west core collapse propagation is plausible? Does it replicate free-fall, etc?
All studies done on the progression of collapse done so far have showed a progression of failures leading to global collapse, including IIRC, an east to west propagation through lower levels. Do you have an FEA that shows this not to be the case? Do you have 2 or 3 of them?
What's that, "No!" you say! Imagine that!
What is this bugaboo about a period of free fall that occurs a few seconds AFTER the entire building has already been moving. It would be nigh on impossible to construct an FEA that is accurate that far into this collapse. In fact it would be nigh on impossible to construct an FEA that replicates a CD that has the building begin falling at the increasing acceleration as observed. That is my humble opinion but we will never know because AE911T will never perform one will they?


Unverifiable data underlying the conclusion is the opposite of a flimsy excuse. The report is based on a secret fire propagation model and it does not address most of our major concerns.
It's NOT a secret. You haven't tried.

It does debunk NISTs column 79 walk off theory and single floor collapse initiation but it replaces it with a new initiation hypothesis, so it does not really matter that it corrects some errors there. So far the WTC investigations have involved identities tainted with the military complex, NIST under insider control and working with SAIC, ARUP and Weidlinger reports on 7 - SAIC, ARUP and Weidlinger are all part of the DOD run Blast Mitigation for Structures Program. Another Weidlinger report does not exactly address our wish for a study without this major conflict of interest. This report does not address the melted steel and witnesses of explosions or the iron spheres or the thermitic chips or the freefall..etc etc.
,,,,,,,,,,,and the paranoia slips into view! Implied accusation but NOTHING concrete, the hallmark of the 911 truth movement.

Les Nessman of "WKRP in Cincinnati" : "think about it......"

The WAI report is based on the notion that WTC 7 suffered extreme fires but offers little proof.
They offer both a citation of the study they used and excepts from it. Quite common in the world of science to cite another's work.
Perhaps you could whip up a little report? Show us the pictures and other evidence. Compare it to other known big fires in steel framed skyscrapers, and show us that this was a much more severe fire. Then you give us what WAI did not; give us a science based figure for the fires actually observed that day.

,,,, or.......here's a thought,,,,,,,,, AE911T could do that! After all they have disputed the fire sciences studies since day one, yet the only one AE911T participant who bothered to 'study' it himself has no qualifications in the field at all, and based his 'study' on part of a single sentence in the NIST report.
Are there no signatories to the AE911T petition that have qualifications in the field of fire sciences?
 
Last edited:
Oh what an evasion. That the WAI describes and copies the results in a public report does not change the fact that the original study that gave those results is not available for scrutiny, or change the fact that citing unverifiable data as a certain truth is not scientific.



They are much higher than NISTs temps, meaning not consistent. The Cardington study reports artificially induced maximum flame temperatures on unprotected steel beams, which is not at all consistent with real world conditions and fire proofed steel beams. You are talking out your a#"$%&.



We have both noted that the collapse initiation is based on am unscientific basis, namely the secret fire temperature report. The verifiability of the data underlying a hypothesis is the most basic scientific requirement. Then the rest of the report awaits further scrutiny; does is prove that the proposed east-west core collapse propagation is plausible? Does it replicate free-fall, etc?



Unverifiable data underlying the conclusion is the opposite of a flimsy excuse. The report is based on a secret fire propagation model and it does not address most of our major concerns. It does debunk NISTs column 79 walk off theory and single floor collapse initiation but it replaces it with a new initiation hypothesis, so it does not really matter that it corrects some errors there. So far the WTC investigations have involved identities tainted with the military complex, NIST under insider control and working with SAIC, ARUP and Weidlinger reports on 7 - SAIC, ARUP and Weidlinger are all part of the DOD run Blast Mitigation for Structures Program. Another Weidlinger report does not exactly address our wish for a study without this major conflict of interest. This report does not address the melted steel and witnesses of explosions or the iron spheres or the thermitic chips or the freefall..etc etc.



The WAI report is based on the notion that WTC 7 suffered extreme fires but offers little proof. Perhaps you could whip up a little report? Show us the pictures and other evidence. Compare it to other known big fires in steel framed skyscrapers, and show us that this was a much more severe fire. Then you give us what WAI did not; give us a science based figure for the fires actually observed that day.

Another post, another missed chance to provide actual science-based evidence for disbelieving the documented temperatures reached in the WAI model. By the way, you do realize Tony claimed he had enough information to prove those temperatures were "ridiculous", right? Did you miss that? It was only the start to this entire chain between he and I. Seems you and Tony disagree on that point, but not surprisingly, your reasons for disagreeing aren't even remotely informed or interesting--just lame innuendo re the fact that WAI does state of the art professional forensic science work for the DOD as well and happens to be expert on blast effects too (something I didn't bring up, but certainly something that doesn't help your knee jerk, by-the-numbers attempt to dismiss their award winning report). You should stick to defrauding people who want to believe; you're far better at that than actually thinking things through.
 
Last edited:
Why do you do this? Barely anybody comes to this forum,
”Can you then explain Tony continues to come here and want to debate people on this forum?”

People researching 9/11 are often Googled to this forum.

To 9/11 truth seekers, uncontested lies and misrepresentations by people gaming the truth create the impression of ‘acceptance’.

If not challenged, 9/11 urban myths are born.
 
​


People researching 9/11 are often Googled to this forum.
Which means that Google's algorithms have this site as having a large enough amount of traffic to be listed high up in the search results list. Imagine that from an irrelevant forum... :confused:

To 9/11 truth seekers, uncontested lies and misrepresentations by people gaming the truth create the impression of ‘acceptance’.
I agree, but probably not in the same vein as you meant it.

If not challenged, 9/11 urban myths are born.
Congratulations, you are part of the creation of a myth.
 
People researching 9/11 are often Googled to this forum.
And how does that help when the debate will be held on another forum?

To 9/11 truth seekers, uncontested lies and misrepresentations by people gaming the truth create the impression of ‘acceptance’.
Truth seekers? How many NEW 9/11 truth seekers do you think there are 15 years after the event that need to be converted to the conspiracy side?

If not challenged, 9/11 urban myths are born.
And how does converting lurkers, IF Tony were to win a debate on a fringe internet forum, help the main cause which is to get a new investigation? Do you think converting 2 people every month (if that) due to the outcome of a debate on a fringe internet forum to believing 9/11 was a conspiracy is going to help push for a new investigation?

You've supposedly got 2,751 architects and engineers over at AE911, yet even those professionals who believe the conspiracy crap can't get anything done. Why no group effort to publish anything with substance that proves demolition with explosives/thermite?

So you truly believe debating in a fringe internet forum is the path to getting a new investigation? No wonder the truth movement hasn't done squat in 15 years. You guys have your priorities wrong.
 
The only reason Tony wants to debate is because IF, and that's a big IF, he would win, all it would be used for is to stroke his own ego. This is the only thing he has to do at this point.
I don't think that's quite right.

I think it's part of a strategy with AE911T.

WHEREAS, the cause of the total collapse of WTC 7 has become the subject of intense public debate, to which architects — through their knowledge, skill, and experience — are uniquely qualified to contribute; and
​
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=315048

Creating the illusion that there's "intense public debate" is the goal.
 
Last edited:
[If not challenged, 9/11 urban myths are born.
And what does a challenge get you if no resolution acheived? So far all we have is Tony debating TFK and TFK not showing up for awhile. Then you have people thumping their chest declaring victory, not based on fact, but based on a forfeit due to someone not responding for some time?!

What good is that Criteria?

You think a new 9/11 truth seeker is going to wade through pages and pages of insults and belittling from both sides in order to siphon out relevant facts and information that they are searching for?

The truth movement has STILL not come to a unified conclusion as to what happened that day. What do you think 9/11 truth seekers are gaining from this?

Nukes?
Thermite?
Explosives?
Energy weapon?
Planes?
No planes?
Drones?
Missiles?
Holograms?

15 years and you folks are STILL fighting with each other about what you think happened conspiracy-wise.

You go ahead and think that fringe internet forum debates are worthwhile for advancing your cause. This type of thinking has gotten you where after 15 years?

:thumbsup:
 
And how does converting lurkers, IF Tony were to win a debate on a fringe internet forum, help the main cause which is to get a new investigation? Do you think converting 2 people every month (if that) due to the outcome of a debate on a fringe internet forum to believing 9/11 was a conspiracy is going to help push for a new investigation?

You've supposedly got 2,751 architects and engineers over at AE911, yet even those professionals who believe the conspiracy crap can't get anything done. Why no group effort to publish anything with substance that proves demolition with explosives/thermite?

So you truly believe debating in a fringe internet forum is the path to getting a new investigation? No wonder the truth movement hasn't done squat in 15 years. You guys have your priorities wrong.

All good questions.
Hope you have better luck getting a response than everyone else has.
 
You guys still post on here. It's a very lop-sided forum now. I've read through old threads from 2006 that have people passionately debating about whether or not some kind of inter-dimensional quandary occurred north of the Citgo. Those were the good old days.

Please understand that there are other sections on ISF, and this subforum is pretty much used to mock clueless truthers.
 
The truth movement has STILL not come to a unified conclusion as to what happened that day. What do you think 9/11 truth seekers are gaining from this?
Well AE911T signatories haven't come out in favour of some of the below;

Nukes?
Thermite? (this meme has morphed from all thermite to nanothermite to explosive thermite to thermite fuses for conventional explosives:rolleyes: )
Explosives? (yes, of course gotta be magical hush-a-booms)
Energy weapon?
Planes? (sure but at least one modified aircraft, possibly, maybe PFT might have a point)
No planes?
Drones?
Missiles?
Holograms?
 
I don't think that's quite right.

I think it's part of a strategy with AE911T.

WHEREAS, the cause of the total collapse of WTC 7 has become the subject of intense public debate, to which architects — through their knowledge, skill, and experience — are uniquely qualified to contribute; and
​
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=315048

Creating the illusion that there's "intense public debate" is the goal.
Ok, but how is a current/future debate within an internet forum help to create the illusion of "intense public debate"? There is no link in that pamphlet to any debate. All they do is state that it is so.

I think very few readers, if any, of that pamphlet will go onto the internet to search for this "intense public debate" about 9/11.

How can Tony and/or AE911 think that having an internet debate (if that is indeed part of their strategy), without a reference to it, helps their cause?
 
Well AE911T signatories haven't come out in favour of some of the below;

Nukes?
Thermite? (this meme has morphed from all thermite to nanothermite to explosive thermite to thermite fuses for conventional explosives:rolleyes: )
Explosives? (yes, of course gotta be magical hush-a-booms)
Energy weapon?
Planes? (sure but at least one modified aircraft, possibly, maybe PFT might have a point)
No planes?
Drones?
Missiles?
Holograms?
Yes, but I said the truth movement in general. New 9/11 truth seekers will go to Google and do searching and see the wide variety of conspiracy theories along with the infighting accompanying them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom