benthamitemetric
Muse
- Joined
- Dec 21, 2015
- Messages
- 572
Your bluster is unimpressive. Citing evidence that no-one can see is not scientific. You have no data to prove that the WAI temperatures are right. You have not seen the data that backs up your belief that fire induced collapse was possible, because the WAI temp data is not available for scrutiny. Non of you alleged skeptics here seem to have a problem with that. You are ranting about Mr. Szamboti not having disproved it, even though you know he has no access to it:
Your reply was a clear no:
Mr. Szamboti has other reasons to doubt the high temps cited, the conflict with the official NIST fire simulation being one. That simulation has been critiqued for showing specific fires at specific times without having proof for them and for being rather generous in its estimates about how long they endured and how much heat they generated in the critical areas. There is then good reason to be skeptical about some report no-one can see claiming much higher temperatures. This is supposed to be a forum for scientifically minded skeptics, but you guys forgot about that years ago.
The temperatures are described in a publicly available report with enough specificity so that we can determine whether they are consistent with prevailing fire science methodologies. They are consistent with the NIST report temperatures, consistent with ARUP's model (not the parametric temperature scales they used in their Analysis for Nordenson, but the traveling fire model they made with Dr. Mowrer), consistent with fires observed in the wtc scale model simulation, and consistent with the Cardington study that Tony himself cited. To date, neither you nor Tony can cite any actual basis for disbelieving them other than that they open the door to a clear fire collapse scenario where all of the NIST omitted elements are included and where Nordenson's floor collapse calculations are explicitly corrected. The WAI study is a professional forensic study that built on all of the work done to date and, as such, it explicitly addressed the major concerns of truthers to date, and yet, instead of being embraced by truthers who have been claiming they wanted such a study, it is rejected out of hand on the flimsiest of excuses. As stated above, you reject it out of pure incredulity. The awards panel at ACEC certainly didn't agree with your baseless incredulity in this case. Have you won a significant professional recognition for an alternative temperature model of wtc 7? If you could be honest with yourself, you'd realize that incredulity came from your cognitivie biases. You don't want to admit to yourself that you wasted peoples' time and money on a baseless cause.
Do you want to venture a science-based figure on the maximum temperature a given beam on the east side of he 9th or 10th floor of WTC 7 could have reached given the fires observed that day?
Last edited: