does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Everybody notices that you, too, fail to answer the question:

"How many planes crashed on 9/11?"

Like Tony failed to answer a simple question: "What did Danny Jowenko say about explosive CD charges in burning buildings?"

One should think that even you guys would give the same answers as we do - we agree! And yet you cannot make yourself say something that is true and that everybody here agrees with. Why is that? Why are you so scared of simple, undisputed facts?
John Kenneth Galbraith:
Faced with the choice between changing one's mind and proving that there is no need to do so, almost everyone gets busy on the proof.
It's not about reality, or what's best. It's about Winning! to many people. That's how we end up with reprehensible elected leaders.

That's why we have Ziggi, jakesteele and Criteria here propagandizing. They aren't really interested in the debate - it won't change their opinions anyway. They're just here to count coup on their critics. To have to change your mind, you have to admit you might be wrong. I haven't seen any willingness to do so in the Truthers that remain.
 
Quoted for Truth.

Case in point:
It was over at metabunk, where Tony, I and some others (mostly or solely "debunkers", I think) discussed an aspect of the Nordenson study - Nordenson claimed that the potential energy of a floor section, that's falling after the infamous c79-c44 girder walks off its seat at column 79, is sufficient to first deform, break, bend conrete floors and steel elements and then punch out the c79-c44 girder one floor below, to send the floors into a cascading collapse. Tony argued that Nordenson missed one big energy sink, namely that the entire descending floor frame would bend on impact, and that would eat up a lot of energy. The all-important parameter was the "stiffness" of that floor frame - Nordenson treated it as essentially infinite, which results in no energy dissipation through bending, when in fact it has to be finite, and must eat energy. But how much? We developed the formulas, put in some reasonably well established numbers for mass etc, and the remaining free variable was, again, this "stiffness", which can in principle be computed from material properties of steel and the geometry of the frame, but doing this analytically is infeasible. Tony convinced me that modelling this frame with FEA software can get the result - FEA can find out the frequency with which this assembly would "swing", which is directly related to the stiffness. So he did plug stuff into his FEA software, and out came a stiffness value that gave us a conclusion "collapse progression highly unlikely".

I asked Tony to show his model - the input data, or perhaps explain in words exactly what he modeled. Boundary conditions, element types, yada yada. Not like I could have scrutinized any of this, I have not the slightest idea how to vet a FEA model. I had hoped to get some other engineer to do the scrutinizing for me.
There was no risk for Tony - the other engineers present in that discussion didn't seem inclined, or able, to do it.
And yet, Tony never revealed what he did. Essentially, he through secret ingredients into a secret black box, and got the result he needed and wanted. D'uh.

Don't get me wrong - I really trust that his model was okay, at least as a draft version, I don't allege he fudged things to get what he wanted.

So there is an example where Tony actually scored a win - he convinced me! - and yet he refused to share calculations for scrutiny. Something he and AE never tire accusing NIST of.

I sent you a pdf explaining the input of the finite element modal analysis of the northeast corner floor frame, such as the constraints and mass, and we discussed the mass by e-mail also. It was hardly a secret black box and I haven't intentionally kept anything from you. As for element types, you said you didn't know much about FEA and that never even crossed my mind to tell you. They were tetrahedrals. Do you want to know something else?
 
Last edited:
I sent you a pdf explaining the input of the finite element modal analysis of the northeast corner floor frame, such as the constraints and mass, and we discussed the mass by e-mail also. It was hardly a secret black box and I haven't intentionally kept anything from you. As for element types, you said you didn't know much about FEA and that never even crossed my mind to tell you. They were tetrahedrals. Do you want to know something else?

That ship sailed.

The thing is that it never crossed your mind to be transparent and provide the evidence you were asked for.
We had a public discussion, and I think I asked publicly for your model so that it could be scrutinized - and I asked the others for help in my quest to scrutinize. I got neither your model publicly, nor an offer to help scrutinize it.

I think I wrote explicitly that I don't even know which questions to ask, and admittedly, no one came to my help. I felt that you took that as convenient.
 
I sent you a pdf explaining the input of the finite element modal analysis of the northeast corner floor frame, such as the constraints and mass, and we discussed the mass by e-mail also. It was hardly a secret black box and I haven't intentionally kept anything from you. As for element types, you said you didn't know much about FEA and that never even crossed my mind to tell you. They were tetrahedrals. Do you want to know something else?

LOL
How many planes crashed on 9/11?
 
That ship sailed.

The thing is that it never crossed your mind to be transparent and provide the evidence you were asked for.
We had a public discussion, and I think I asked publicly for your model so that it could be scrutinized - and I asked the others for help in my quest to scrutinize. I got neither your model publicly, nor an offer to help scrutinize it.

I think I wrote explicitly that I don't even know which questions to ask, and admittedly, no one came to my help. I felt that you took that as convenient.

I wasn't asked. I've been FEA since before IDEAS was known as Supertab...
 
That ship sailed.

The thing is that it never crossed your mind to be transparent and provide the evidence you were asked for.

We had a public discussion, and I think I asked publicly for your model so that it could be scrutinized - and I asked the others for help in my quest to scrutinize. I got neither your model publicly, nor an offer to help scrutinize it.

I think I wrote explicitly that I don't even know which questions to ask, and admittedly, no one came to my help. I felt that you took that as convenient.

You never asked for the model. I gave you everything you asked for and explained anything you had a question about, both publicly and privately. I have e-mails showing we discussed the mass off-line because you had a question about it and then agreed I was right after the discussion. I spend my time like that and acquiesce a novice who is often flippant and now that novice wants to say I wasn't transparent and that he thinks I was glad he didn't know what to ask.

Oystein, when you talk like this it explains why you are confused about 911.
 
Last edited:
You never asked for the model. I gave you everything you asked for and explained anything you had a question about, both publicly and privately. I have e-mails showing we discussed the mass off-line because you had a question about it and then agreed I was right after the discussion. I spend my time like that and acquiesce a novice who is often flippant and now that novice wants to say I wasn't transparent and that he thinks I was glad he didn't know what to ask.

Oystein, when you talk like this it explains why you are confused about 911.
So kiddo....

How many planes crashed on 9/11?
 
Everybody on this thread and on this site, in general, that were too intimidated to take Tony up on his challenge = BIG FAIL. Phundie NeoSkeptics anywhere in the world will always believe in the Official Story, at all costs, no matter what.

Tony 100
Bragging Neos 0


Law of Immaculate Perception™ – they are the only ones who see reality exactly as it is unhindered by any cognitive biases. So therefore, to disagree with them is to disagree with reality itself.

Then you or Tony should have no problem starting a new thread to discuss the CD of WTC1,2,7. Each explanation should stand on its own merits. Tony has ruled out any effect fire had on the destruction of WTC7. So according to Tony, fire played no role. So it should not be hard for Tony or you to lay out the specifics of the CD along with your evidence. Or will you fall back on the excuse that a new investigation is needed?

Funny after 16+ years there is no one concise CD explanation.
 
Last edited:
You never asked for the model. I gave you everything you asked for and explained anything you had a question about, both publicly and privately. I have e-mails showing we discussed the mass off-line because you had a question about it and then agreed I was right after the discussion. I spend my time like that and acquiesce a novice who is often flippant and now that novice wants to say I wasn't transparent and that he thinks I was glad he didn't know what to ask.

Oystein, when you talk like this it explains why you are confused about 911.

I think I need to eat a bit of dirt now and apologize - and retract to some extent what I wrote in my previous two posts :boxedin:

The public exchange was here:
https://www.metabunk.org/does-the-e...alculations-demonstrate-anything.t7185/page-6

You posted a visual of the model in post #200.
Page 6 has much of the discussion about it.
I did lament at one point (#227) that I don't actually have the model in the detail necessary to scrutinize, but you are correct that I didn't outright ask for it.

My memory was faulty.
I apologize ;)
 
I think I need to eat a bit of dirt now and apologize - and retract to some extent what I wrote in my previous two posts :boxedin:

The public exchange was here:
https://www.metabunk.org/does-the-e...alculations-demonstrate-anything.t7185/page-6

You posted a visual of the model in post #200.
Page 6 has much of the discussion about it.
I did lament at one point (#227) that I don't actually have the model in the detail necessary to scrutinize, but you are correct that I didn't outright ask for it.

My memory was faulty.
I apologize ;)

Its okay. Glad we got it straightened out. I have nothing to hide. The model and results are what they are and Nordenson was wrong.
 
Last edited:
Its okay. Glad we got it straightened out. I have nothing to hide. The model and results are what they are and Nordenson was wrong.

Nordenson was also wrong in assuming pristine floors below the collapse zone, an error he thought didn't matter due to his mistake in calculating the impact forces but also an error you deliberately repeat despite knowing his mistake on the force calculations. You only repeat that error because you know it is necessary for you to maintain the fiction that fire induced collapse was impossible.

Still waiting for you to state what you think the temperatures of the steel were, by the way. It's almost been a full five days since you claimed you could prove the WAI temperatures were wrong and no proof has been forthcoming.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by Oystein View Post
”Hehe.

Ziggi and Criteria hate me like the plague.”

Hate?

I like you a great deal.

It saddens me to see you waste so much potential in a quest to be loved.

Poor Oystein is perhaps mistaking lack of respect for hate? I have to agree with you though that I really like Oystein a lot, and I explained why a short while ago in a post about Oystein and his behavior:
As before, that no "debunker" interjects to make it clear this is not accepted in this circle of "debunkers" is more interesting and revealing than this behavior by itself. Saying that you guys have sunken to a new low after the JREF got rid of you would be a massive understatement. And for that you get a big from me:
Originally Posted by Ziggi View Post
.. We are here to let you guys debunk yourselves with this kind of behavior in the eyes of real researchers that may be checking both sides...
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=293443&page=65

It also interesting to note that the post from me that Oystein referred to was actually about noting that Oystein and other NIST defenders here are now refusing to try to defend the NIST reports:

In early 2015, Oystein and other "debunkers" here were all very sure of themselves in their failed arguments defending the NIST explanation for the collapse of WTC7, to the point of making utter fools of themselves in their desperation to defend NIST, as perfectly exemplified by one "skeptic" called WilliamSeger...
...But now by the end of 2016, these same people refuse to enter a one-on-one debate where they would be expected to defend the NIST report, and the excuses are blatantly pathetic. Suddenly, people that have spent years on this forum and other forums defending the NIST report claim there is no point debating whether or not the NIST report was erroneous. Obviously they failed to "find enough reason to believe" and want to change the subject.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11636610&postcount=432

Oystein' s response to this was "Ziggi hates me"...and this change the subject routine came as no surprise:rolleyes:
 
It also interesting to note that the post from me that Oystein referred to was actually about noting that Oystein and other NIST defenders here are now refusing to try to defend 5the NIST report

A few here did offer to debate Tony, perhaps you missed it.
Defend NIST? Why is that important?
Did the ASCE declare serious problems with the NIST reports?
No!
Did IEEE claim serious problems with the NIST reports?
No!
Did any recognized professional engineering organization have serious issue with the eports?
No!

Why then is there a need to defend the NIST reports? Because a group who boasts that 2000 engineers and architects but no formal membership, holds no meetings, sponsors little research and no peer review articles, and is but a single issue lobbying group, says the NIST reports are a fraud and cover up of treasonous acts.

Is that why?
 
Last edited:
Hey, Ziggi, Criteria responded, and pretty much utterly failed to address, my post (requoted below).
Care to have a go?
1) How will one on one debates further your desire for a new investigation? What is it's purpose?

2) All studies of WTC7's collapse converge on fire induced multifloor collapses that are the first step in progressive collapse that leads to global involvement.

3) As I recall it, most if not all debunkers here did not so much defend NIST's initiating event as point out that it was described as a "most probable" first event but that many other factors would have been in play such as column spreading, stresses induced due to loss of SW corner and other impact damage, and stresses due to fires on other floors.

4) WRT the towers, many here distinctly describe collapse and include how jolt could not happen and how internal collapse led perimeter peel, and core destruction.

5) NIST was not alone in studying any if these three buildings. There are numerous professional engineering organizations that have, and exactly none have deduced that anything other than impact and fire was responsible for the demise of theee buildings. A point made numerous times in this forum's pages.


OTOH, the extreme paucity of any engineering study from those who deny the commonly accepted history of the events of 9/11, has been pointed out. The fact that the leading "9/11truth" group, while loudly touting support of 2000+ engineers and architects, has chosen to spend funds raised not on engineering, but to concentrate on sending Gage and a few others on speaking tours for the general public. Little effort has been made to ellicit support from recognized professional organizations.

Lately Tony Sz. has declared that the steel temperatures used in the WAI report are ridiculous despite not having any research to back his declaration up ( since neither he or any other professional at AE911T has been bothered to produce a fire spread/intensity study) , nor bothering to try to find the fire engineering study that is cited by Abboud.
 
Last edited:
Then you or Tony should have no problem starting a new thread to discuss the CD of WTC1,2,7. Each explanation should stand on its own merits. Tony has ruled out any effect fire had on the destruction of WTC7. So according to Tony, fire played no role.


That flies in the face of reality when considering fire and impact evidence on a number of videos, not to mention that explosives generate blast waves and an extremely loud noise upon detonation, which clearly was not the case as WTC1, WTC2, and WTC7 collapsed. The WTC videos alone were enough to debunk the use of explosives.

Structural buckling observed on the exteriors of WTC 1, WTC2, and WTC7 just prior to their collapse events was firm evidence that fire, not explosives, was responsible for the collapse of those buildings.

CT'ers don't understand the extensive and lengthy preparation process required prior to the emplacement of explosives within steel-framed buildings.

WTC1, WTC2, and WTC7 incurred massive impact damage yet those buildings remained standing as structural loads were redistributed around their damaged structures. Fires continued to weaken their structures even further, which was evident by the observed structural buckling occurring prior to their collapse events. That was a major clue that the fires were mainly responsible for the collapse of WTC1, WTC2, and WTC7, and for the internal collapse of WTC5.

In addition to the fact that there is no CD evidence after all of these years, I would think that no one would have kept his finger on the CD trigger button for over 6 hours while WTC7 burned, leaving CD explosives exposed to the full effects of raging fires burning out of control within that building, but what government explosive agent/agents would use explosives knowing that in doing do would leave behind hardware, data, visual and audio evidence? Not to mention doing so in a country full of investigative reporters looking for a sensational story to further their careers, which brings back memories of how the Watergate scandal was revealed.
 
,,,Still waiting for you to state what you think the temperatures of the steel were, by the way. It's almost been a full five days since you claimed you could prove the WAI temperatures were wrong and no proof has been forthcoming.

Your bluster is unimpressive. Citing evidence that no-one can see is not scientific. You have no data to prove that the WAI temperatures are right. You have not seen the data that backs up your belief that fire induced collapse was possible, because the WAI temp data is not available for scrutiny. Non of you alleged skeptics here seem to have a problem with that. You are ranting about Mr. Szamboti not having disproved it, even though you know he has no access to it:

Originally Posted by Tony Szamboti
The extreme heating of the steel on contiguous floors to 850 degrees C is only asserted in the Weidlinger structural analysis with a reference to Hughes Associates Craig Beyler's heat transfer analysis. No other specifics are given.
...You had said you would try to get a copy of Beyler's analysis. Have you been able to?

Your reply was a clear no:

Originally Posted by benthamitemetric
Dr. Beyler's report never made it into the court record due to how the case unfolded procedurally. I obtained an affidavit of his from early in the litigation, but that was merely responding to Dr. Bailey and Dr. Mowrer re whether the photographic evidence provided in discovery proved the flutes were filled or unfilled; it does not provide any insight into his fire model

Mr. Szamboti has other reasons to doubt the high temps cited, the conflict with the official NIST fire simulation being one. That simulation has been critiqued for showing specific fires at specific times without having proof for them and for being rather generous in its estimates about how long they endured and how much heat they generated in the critical areas. There is then good reason to be skeptical about some report no-one can see claiming much higher temperatures. This is supposed to be a forum for scientifically minded skeptics, but you guys forgot about that years ago.
 
Last edited:
Ziggi;11639357 Mr. Szamboti has other reasons to doubt the high temps cited said:
Temperatures within WTC 7 were more than high enough to weaken its steel structure to the point of collapse and let's not forget massive structural damage on the south side of WTC 7.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom