does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Tony,

I have some time right now and am wondering if anyone here who supports the statements from ae911truth made about the three high-rise collapses in NYC on Sept. 11, 2001, would want to debate me one-on-one as I contend that the statements made by ae911truth are deliberately false and misleading and do not indicate evidence of controlled demolition.

The debate would take place on the 911 free forum, like the one Tony did with tfk, and the rules would be the same as those for that debate shown below.
...

A most excellent debate proposal!

AE's claims are enumerated and simple enough to be discussed in relatively few and short posts.

And that debate could end with a recommendation of action; such as both participants jointly writing an open letter to AE911T, asking them to inform all their followers about all the claims that have been wrong for all these years, and never got corrected by the thousands of A&E.
 
Office cubicle fires heating fire-proofed structural steel to the point of sudden global collapse was only observed by the minds of those who desperately cling to the NIST hypothesis.

Let's take a look at the fireproofing on WTC7 steel.

Notification_Center-12-20130605-144517.jpg


Figure-D-14-Appendix-C-FEMA.png


Figure-D-17-Appendix-C-FEMA.png
 
On the investigation side, Dr. Hulsey’s study is being funded by AE911T.

AE911T have made no secret about their belief that the most effective way to inform the public, is to ‘inform the public’.


Let's look at a few examples as to why AE911Truth cannot be taken seriously considering its continuous deceptive practices and outright lies.


2a243048-e327-4425-a904-994753f66e32.jpg



Now, for the rest of the story on how those cuts were made.


cut.jpg



Videos

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DdBv7uaQT_0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eBXZOGc-DOg
 
Let's look at a few examples as to why AE911Truth cannot be taken seriously considering its continuous deceptive practices and outright lies.


[qimg]http://gallery.mailchimp.com/d03bf3ffcac549c7dc7888ef5/images/2a243048-e327-4425-a904-994753f66e32.jpg[/qimg]


Now, for the rest of the story on how those cuts were made.


[qimg]http://www.debunking911.com/cut.jpg[/qimg]


Videos

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DdBv7uaQT_0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eBXZOGc-DOg

Sky eagle why didn't you just post the picture of that very Column being cut with a lance, at 45 degrees?

diagonalcut-112_zpsgwbijabg.jpg


Simply applying a sepa lenses filter shows the cut line in the photo, to be the same 45 as posted in Jones's photo.
 
Last edited:
A most excellent debate proposal!

AE's claims are enumerated and simple enough to be discussed in relatively few and short posts.

And that debate could end with a recommendation of action; such as both participants jointly writing an open letter to AE911T, asking them to inform all their followers about all the claims that have been wrong for all these years, and never got corrected by the thousands of A&E.

Unfortunately the Twoofers will run from such a proposed debate at hyperlight speeds.
Such true debates work similar to garlic on vampires.

Twoofers have no intentions of exposing the truth.
 
This has always been Criteria's SOP: Quote, fudge with the quotes in strange ways (like add quote marks in addition to QUOTE tags; insert INDENT tags that enclose nothing...), but he totally, systematically fails to address the content of the quotes.
For example, if he quotes a question, he fails to answer it.

Another, secondary tactic is to quote only the most irrelevant bit of longer posts and respond to them, while not using ellipses to indicate that, and where, parts of the quoted post were left out.


All this editing and fudging seems to me to be proof of the deliberate nature of his non-answers and evasions.

That describes what I see certainly.

I did note the very odd indent tags.
 
Once you've realized that Tony is so ignorant of fire science that he cannot even state how hot the steel in wtc 7 could have been, it becomes silly to debate him in depth on any other point related to the collapse thereof. I hope whoever is debating him is paying attention to his inability to articulate any research-based position on the fire and steel temperatures. Every point in the debate needs to be couched in "and Tony cannot even say how hot any of the steel members in wtc 7 could have been, so he cannot have meaningfully conducted even the basic calculations he claims to have done re their reaction in the fire (putting aside that Tony never actually shares those calculations for scrutiny)."
 
Last edited:
Haven't checked into the thread in a while.

Has Tony been able to muster the answer to the question "How many planes crashed on 9/11" yet?

Everybody on this thread and on this site, in general, that were too intimidated to take Tony up on his challenge = BIG FAIL. Phundie NeoSkeptics anywhere in the world will always believe in the Official Story, at all costs, no matter what.

Tony 100
Bragging Neos 0


Law of Immaculate Perception™ – they are the only ones who see reality exactly as it is unhindered by any cognitive biases. So therefore, to disagree with them is to disagree with reality itself.
 
Law of Immaculate Perception™ – they are the only ones who see reality exactly as it is unhindered by any cognitive biases. So therefore, to disagree with them is to disagree with reality itself.
This. ^

Especially when you have to ignore the reality of the rest of the events of 9/11 in order to maintain your view.

I think I'm going to use that law in future. Thanks.
 
Once you've realized that Tony is so ignorant of fire science that he cannot even state how hot the steel in wtc 7 could have been, it becomes silly to debate him in depth on any other point related to the collapse thereof. I hope whoever is debating him is paying attention to his inability to articulate any research-based position on the fire and steel temperatures. Every point in the debate needs to be couched in "and Tony cannot even say how hot any of the steel members in wtc 7 could have been, so he cannot have meaningfully conducted even the basic calculations he claims to have done re their reaction in the fire (putting aside that Tony never actually shares those calculations for scrutiny)."

The problem at the heart of all this, in fact, is that Tony considers the argument from incredulity to be logically sound. He doesn't believe that the steel could have reached the temperatures determined from fire simulations, so although he has no alternative values to suggest he still considers this sufficient grounds to reject these simulations in toto. He then believes that, by stating his disbelief, he has shifted the burden of proof back to the claimant, and is therefore able reasonably to demand proof that his disbelief is unjustified. Scroll back up the thread and you'll find at least one very clear example of him doing precisely this. Quite how one is to hold a formal debate with someone who thinks "I don't believe you" is the end of the matter, I've never been able to work out, and it's one of many reasons why I think this sort of structured debate with truthers, all of whom more or less start from the argument from incredulity, is futile.

Dave
 
The problem at the heart of all this,.................

Is that such an online debate is not designed to garner a new investigation at all. Instead it is simply a platform whereby Tony can pontificate for his converted and drum up more funds from the gullible to continue the fight for truth.

You, I, Tony, and all here are participating in a discussion of a fringe issue that has been settled, as far as the vast majority of the engineering community is concerned, long ago now.

It ranks up there with Apollo Hoax and JFK.
 
[First internet post since Trump won the election electoral college]

I think I speak for all lurkers when I say

:popcorn1

Please continue!

[Reengaging cloaking device]
 
Last edited:
Everybody on this thread and on this site, in general, that were too intimidated to take Tony up on his challenge = BIG FAIL. Phundie NeoSkeptics anywhere in the world will always believe in the Official Story, at all costs, no matter what.

Tony 100
Bragging Neos 0


Law of Immaculate Perception™ – they are the only ones who see reality exactly as it is unhindered by any cognitive biases. So therefore, to disagree with them is to disagree with reality itself.

What in that gibberish was supposed to be a response to the post you quoted?
 
The problem at the heart of all this, in fact, is that Tony considers the argument from incredulity to be logically sound. He doesn't believe that the steel could have reached the temperatures determined from fire simulations, so although he has no alternative values to suggest he still considers this sufficient grounds to reject these simulations in toto. He then believes that, by stating his disbelief, he has shifted the burden of proof back to the claimant, and is therefore able reasonably to demand proof that his disbelief is unjustified. Scroll back up the thread and you'll find at least one very clear example of him doing precisely this. Quite how one is to hold a formal debate with someone who thinks "I don't believe you" is the end of the matter, I've never been able to work out, and it's one of many reasons why I think this sort of structured debate with truthers, all of whom more or less start from the argument from incredulity, is futile.

Dave

I think this is exactly right. Tony wants to debate all of the various points of contention re the collapse of the building independently as if they were all separate issues of equal probative value re how the building collapsed. This allows him to gloss over major, fundamental points such as the fact that fifteen years after the collapse of the building, he still has not established a framework by which he can reasonably predict the degree to which the fires in the building could have heated the steel members thereof. Maybe it's the lawyer in me, but I don't see how you can move beyond that point as all further analyses must necessarily flow from it. If I were cross examining Tony for his "expert" opinion on the collapse, I'd probably just establish his inability to articulate the temperatures in the fire (as has been done in this thread and in the fire simulation thread he started) and then just stop further questions. Tony is of course also wrong about a series of related issues, but it doesn't even really matter how or why he is wrong about those points if he can't even pass the minimum threshold of demonstrating he is looking at the structure in the context of realistic temperature conditions predicted by established fire science principles. Rather than giving pause at such shortcomings in his own understanding, however, Tony, as you say, just dips into his cognitive bias for some incredulity magic, waves his hands, and moves on to another point.
 
Last edited:
... (putting aside that Tony never actually shares those calculations for scrutiny)."

Quoted for Truth.

Case in point:
It was over at metabunk, where Tony, I and some others (mostly or solely "debunkers", I think) discussed an aspect of the Nordenson study - Nordenson claimed that the potential energy of a floor section, that's falling after the infamous c79-c44 girder walks off its seat at column 79, is sufficient to first deform, break, bend conrete floors and steel elements and then punch out the c79-c44 girder one floor below, to send the floors into a cascading collapse. Tony argued that Nordenson missed one big energy sink, namely that the entire descending floor frame would bend on impact, and that would eat up a lot of energy. The all-important parameter was the "stiffness" of that floor frame - Nordenson treated it as essentially infinite, which results in no energy dissipation through bending, when in fact it has to be finite, and must eat energy. But how much? We developed the formulas, put in some reasonably well established numbers for mass etc, and the remaining free variable was, again, this "stiffness", which can in principle be computed from material properties of steel and the geometry of the frame, but doing this analytically is infeasible. Tony convinced me that modelling this frame with FEA software can get the result - FEA can find out the frequency with which this assembly would "swing", which is directly related to the stiffness. So he did plug stuff into his FEA software, and out came a stiffness value that gave us a conclusion "collapse progression highly unlikely".

I asked Tony to show his model - the input data, or perhaps explain in words exactly what he modeled. Boundary conditions, element types, yada yada. Not like I could have scrutinized any of this, I have not the slightest idea how to vet a FEA model. I had hoped to get some other engineer to do the scrutinizing for me.
There was no risk for Tony - the other engineers present in that discussion didn't seem inclined, or able, to do it.
And yet, Tony never revealed what he did. Essentially, he through secret ingredients into a secret black box, and got the result he needed and wanted. D'uh.

Don't get me wrong - I really trust that his model was okay, at least as a draft version, I don't allege he fudged things to get what he wanted.

So there is an example where Tony actually scored a win - he convinced me! - and yet he refused to share calculations for scrutiny. Something he and AE never tire accusing NIST of.
 
Everybody on this thread and on this site, in general, that were too intimidated to take Tony up on his challenge = BIG FAIL. Phundie NeoSkeptics anywhere in the world will always believe in the Official Story, at all costs, no matter what.

Tony 100
Bragging Neos 0


Law of Immaculate Perception™ – they are the only ones who see reality exactly as it is unhindered by any cognitive biases. So therefore, to disagree with them is to disagree with reality itself.

Everybody notices that you, too, fail to answer the question:

"How many planes crashed on 9/11?"

Like Tony failed to answer a simple question: "What did Danny Jowenko say about explosive CD charges in burning buildings?"

One should think that even you guys would give the same answers as we do - we agree! And yet you cannot make yourself say something that is true and that everybody here agrees with. Why is that? Why are you so scared of simple, undisputed facts?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom