does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

The fires in WTC 7 weren't on every floor and I think the evidence shows they were started by arsonists who could have known what floors the charges were on.

Run run run away again, Tony? Really? Did you really think you would not get called out once more for evading a straight question - as always always always always always always ALWAYS ALWAYS?!? Grrrrr!!!!

What did Danny Jowenko say in 2006 about explosive CD charges in burning buildings?
 
So you're admitting that all you have is an argument from incredulity plus the assumption that the study you disagree with is based on deliberate lies. I'm sure that's far more credible than, you know, actually doing the work.

Dave

I don't believe it/understand it therefore it can not be true is the fundamental basis of all CT (non)thinking. Such a startling admission is however rare.

God forbid the real problem is the limits of the believers knowledge or comprehension. Reality must be wrong.
 
No, I do not believe the steel in WTC 7 could have been heated to 850 degrees C on even a single floor. ...

Ok. Just wanted to point out the sloppy way you ask questions.

Focus, Tony.

Oh, and as for the question you pose to Dave: We already know that all you offer for your answer is incredulity, and probably invite Dave to reply with bare assertions. You know he is too clever to take such ill-conceived bait. What do you hope to achieve with such guess-work?
 
No, the fuel will not last long enough and the heat will transfer to cooler areas long before 850 degrees C is achieved in the steel.

There is a technical basis for what I am saying.

Does that include dirrect heating by all fuels, even those in dirrect contact with the steel at transported by fluidic actions induced in the fires?
 
The fires in WTC 7 weren't on every floor and I think the evidence shows they were started by arsonists who could have known what floors the charges were on.

Please share a few of your sources that backs up the arsonists theory.
 
No, I do not believe the steel in WTC 7 could have been heated to 850 degrees C on even a single floor. It was protected and the fuel would have burned out long before those temperatures could be reached. I am sure Dave will not be able to explain how it could happen. I'll be surprised if he even tries.

I am sorry Tony, I have to go the fits of Laughter, are making my sides hurt!
 
No, I do not believe the steel in WTC 7 could have been heated to 850 degrees C on even a single floor. It was protected and the fuel would have burned out long before those temperatures could be reached. I am sure Dave will not be able to explain how it could happen. I'll be surprised if he even tries.

Fluidic movements of transportable fuels!
 
Ok. Just wanted to point out the sloppy way you ask questions.

Focus, Tony.

Oh, and as for the question you pose to Dave: We already know that all you offer for your answer is incredulity, and probably invite Dave to reply with bare assertions. You know he is too clever to take such ill-conceived bait. What do you hope to achieve with such guess-work?

Focus, LOL.

The comments by you and your like minded brethren here are ninny like and it seems none of you are willing to debate one-on-one because you know you will have your head handed to you.

I have time for a legitimate one-on-one debate taking place over a few weeks time but not this hit and run chicken s__t you guys want to play.
 
Last edited:
No, I do not believe the steel in WTC 7 could have been heated to 850 degrees C on even a single floor. It was protected and the fuel would have burned out long before those temperatures could be reached.

I disagree. The Windsor building burned for over 26 hours, which resulted in the collapse of its upper steel structure, leaving the concrete core exposed.
 
Focus, LOL....y.

Please explain how a fellow engineer insists on a debate based on your fantasy?

15 years, and all you have as evidence; simile. This is all you have. Oh, it looked like CD - simile. Oh, loud noises, sounded like explosives - simile.

Is OKC an inside job too? Bigfoot? JFK? LOL, you are a CTer from way back.

I think you think you have evidence, like Trump had a landslide, = landslide is 2.8 million votes less than what your opponent got? Have you tweeted trump for a new investigation? 15 years and no evidence.

I debated you, and your failure to produce evidence means you lost. What kind of explosives were used in the WTC? What, you can't say? Debate done. you lost again
 
The fires in WTC 7 weren't on every floor and I think the evidence shows they were started by arsonists who could have known what floors the charges were on.

Oh man, I would have loved to have been at that planning meeting.

Evil Leader: Okay, the plan is to set #7 on fire and let it burn for eight hours and then we will set off explosives and collapse the entire building.

Black Ops Guy: Why not just blow the building with at the same time as the towers?

EL: Because we need devastation on live TV.

BOG: But...if you blow all three buildings at once you kill more people, and triple the devastation.

EL: No, we need it to look organic, so it has to be later.

BOG: But if it's later the building will be empty of people...wait, why are we blowing up WTC7 in the first place?

EL: *mumbles*

BOG: No, seriously, why flatten #7, why not Banker's Trust?

EL: That building has standard, traditional construction, and is less likely to collapse after an eight hour fire. #7 was a newer design, and will come down easier after a fire.

BOG: So why plant explosives?

EL: We need it to come down.

BOG: How long do you plan to burn it?

EL: Eight hours. Also, we're gonna need you and your men to go into #7 to set the fires.

BOG: Won't the collapse of WTC1 do that on it's own?

EL: We need to guarantee the fire, to cover the explosives.


...Yeah, a masterpiece of tactical and strategic:thumbsup: logic for sure.
 
Focus, LOL.

The comments by you and your like minded brethren here are ninny like and it seems none of you are willing to debate one-on-one because you know you will have your head handed to you.

I have time for a legitimate one-on-one debate taking place over a few weeks time but not this hit and run chicken s__t you guys want to play.

Soot. - National Institute of Standards and Technology
fire.nist.gov › bfrlpubs › fire93 › PDF
hydrocarbon fire. the total radiation intensity emitted by soot far exceeds that of gaseous emission. The total ..... a temperature range 1000—2000°C. In their analysis, they assumed that oxidation by OH 0 was negligible.
 
Focus, L
I have time for a legitimate one-on-one debate taking place over a few weeks time but not this hit and run chicken s__t you guys want to play.


What do you know about structural load redistribution after impact and fire damage? Explain why WTC 1 remained standing despite the detonation of a vehicle bomb. Did the huge blast leave the steel columns of WTC 1 standing within a large bomb crater? Did the 1993 WTC 1 explosion leave behind evidence that identified the bombers?

How many times has thermite/nano-thermite been used to demolish tall steel-framed buildings since 1930? Do demolition companies use thermite to demolish steel-framed buildings?

Did you know that a steel structure can fail at temperatures below 850 degrees C. and that contents within a steel-framed building will allow a fire to rage out of control long after the original fuel source has burned out?

I posed those questions because I know where you are going.
 
Last edited:
Focus, LOL.

The comments by you and your like minded brethren here are ninny like and it seems none of you are willing to debate one-on-one because you know you will have your head handed to you.

I have time for a legitimate one-on-one debate taking place over a few weeks time but not this hit and run chicken s__t you guys want to play.

Quote the posts where I address your debate proposal if you want to comment on my ability or willingness to engage your debate proposal.

Everything else is transparently dishonest.
 
Really? Let's see how true that is.

I will discuss the matter with you under the following rules:
  1. It's not a debate, it's a forum discussion, just in a dedicated thread where no other posters are allowed.
  2. The forum will be ISF. I don't trust the911forum. It's known for having had people banned on a whim, and for having allowed edition of messages even years after posted. ISF, on the other hand, has a history of not allowing edition of posts past 2 hours, and of reasonably fair moderation.
  3. Since you want to prove that the collapses of 1, 2 and 7 WTC were controlled demolitions (per the 2nd rule of the debate you held with tfk), the title of the thread (and the main topic) will be: Evidence for controlled demolition.
  4. There's no restriction on the topics, even though a somewhat coherent line is expected in accordance with ISF's rule 11.
  5. The post length is unlimited. The number of posts per poster is unlimited. Just like in any other forum discussion.
  6. There's no obligation to respond to any of the points raised by the other.
  7. Breaking ISF's membership agreement rules, in particular rule 0, rule 10 and rule 12, is not allowed.
  8. After 30 days without a response, the discussion is over.
These rules are designed to be pretty much like those in any other forum discussion. If what you said above is true, there should be no problem for you to agree to them.

Are you game?

Tony,

in case you have pgimeno on your ignore list, he is game to debate you!

Here is is debate proposal:

I [pgimeno] will discuss the matter with you under the following rules:
  1. It's not a debate, it's a forum discussion, just in a dedicated thread where no other posters are allowed.
  2. The forum will be ISF. I don't trust the911forum. It's known for having had people banned on a whim, and for having allowed edition of messages even years after posted. ISF, on the other hand, has a history of not allowing edition of posts past 2 hours, and of reasonably fair moderation.
  3. Since you want to prove that the collapses of 1, 2 and 7 WTC were controlled demolitions (per the 2nd rule of the debate you held with tfk), the title of the thread (and the main topic) will be: Evidence for controlled demolition.
  4. There's no restriction on the topics, even though a somewhat coherent line is expected in accordance with ISF's rule 11.
  5. The post length is unlimited. The number of posts per poster is unlimited. Just like in any other forum discussion.
  6. There's no obligation to respond to any of the points raised by the other.
  7. Breaking ISF's membership agreement rules, in particular rule 0, rule 10 and rule 12, is not allowed.
  8. After 30 days without a response, the discussion is over.
These rules are designed to be pretty much like those in any other forum discussion. If what you said above is true, there should be no problem for you to agree to them.

Are you game?​

(Pesonally, I, Oystein, think that this proposal is about as unfocused and infeasible as yours, but that shouldn't bother you, Tony, should it ;))
 
The fires in WTC 7 weren't on every floor and I think the evidence shows they were started by arsonists who could have known what floors the charges were on.


For the record, are you now implying that arsonists and bombers were working together in an effort to demolish WTC 7? What happens when explosives are exposed to fire?
 
The extreme heating of the steel on contiguous floors to 850 degrees C is only asserted in the Weidlinger structural analysis with a reference to Hughes Associates Craig Beyler's heat transfer analysis. No other specifics are given.

I do not believe there is any chance that one floor's steel could have been at 850 degrees C, let alone two contiguous floors simultaneously. It sounds like they made it as hot as it needed to be to get a failure of the floor below. It is about as likely as putting a man on Jupiter.

What happened here?

wtc5pic.jpg
 
Hence, a new investigation is necessary.


Is a debate with an ISF member a requirement for there to be a new investigation?

If not, then why are you fussing about it?

If so, then how did you end up in a position where you need cooperation from people who oppose your goals in order to achieve your goals?

I decided to try Tony's approach in other spheres of life. First I went to the central office of Chase Bank and stood in the lobby yelling, "Which of you unqualified financial ignoramuses has the guts to give me a million dollars free and clear with no obligation?" Then I went to Google's offices and yelled, "Which of you fraudulent computer-illiterate morons is self-assured enough to put me in charge of your biggest development project and pay me six figures a year for it?" Then I went to a meeting of Elite Model Management's top female talent and yelled, "Which of you ugly frumpish amateurs has the courage to marry me?"

I returned a few times a week for five years, each time repeating variations of "I see that none of you incompetent dishonest unworthy people has dared to meet my demands."

Surprisingly, my financial, employment, and marital status were in no way improved by these activities.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom