does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Originally Posted by Dave Rogers
No, there's just proof by assertion as usual. Shouldn't you start insulting people next? That's the normal progression.

Dave

Dave, please explain how the steel could have been heated to 850 degrees C on two contiguous floors in WTC 7.

Do you believe the fires were restricted to one floor only? (Screenshot is for reference purposes; best to watch the complete video.)
 

Attachments

  • Dementri.jpg
    Dementri.jpg
    80.5 KB · Views: 8
Thanks. In my view, it's just another thread*, there's nothing to terminate. I don't know of many threads which have been discussed up to a termination point.

(*) With the small peculiarity that it's between two people instead of many, that is. In that, I agree with Tony that so many people intervening at the same time makes the thread too chaotic.

Well, my criticism used the subjective criterion of what I or you find "bearable" ;)
I wouldn't take you up on your challenge. Which is no problem; I trust you would not call me a coward for it, or other language to that effect.
 
Originally Posted by Oystein
What did Danny Jowenko say in 2006 about explosive CD charges in burning buildings?

The fires in WTC 7 weren't on every floor and I think the evidence shows they were started by arsonists who could have known what floors the charges were on.

Were the fires to the north of WTC 7 set by arsonists, too? What about the fires in WTC 5 and WTC 6?

If the answer is "no", did the NWO expect that fires would ignite in WTC 7, but they had to bring in an elite team of arsonists when no fires actually ignited?

Or were the fires to the north of WTC 7 and in WTC 5 and WTC 6 also set by this elite team of Stealth Ninja Arsonists? If so, did they carry out their operations unnoticed by the E.P. on the scene, or were they protected and assisted by the E.P.? About how many people, IYO, were involved?
 

Attachments

  • Burnt Vehicles on West Broadway.jpg
    Burnt Vehicles on West Broadway.jpg
    54 KB · Views: 5
The Cardington test data does not support the assertion that the steel in two contiguous fire protected floors in WTC 7 would be able to reach 850 degrees C (1,562 F). That is really a non-starter based on the short time frame a fire in any one area is active, due to fuel limitations, and the heat transfer characteristics of the fire proofing material.

You should realize there are photographs of fire areas having been burned out in WTC 7 prior to its collapse. The fire on another side of the building is not heating the already burned out area or anything 70 to 100 feet away in any significant way.

Did you ever even look at the temperature graphs accompanying the WAI report? They show temperature spikes at the key locations in question that are entirely consistent (both in terms of intensity and duration) with the temperatures reached in the Cardington tests that you cited. I hope your fellow travelers are paying attention to this chutzpah. Your entire theory now rests on it being impossible for the fires on two floors of WTC 7 to relatively simultaneously have reached the peak temperatures expected per the Cardington test's results for the duration expected per the Cardington test's results. Not improbable, but impossible.

Wake up, Tony. I know you see how tenuous and flawed your own premise is.
 
Last edited:
Did you ever even look at the temperature graphs accompanying the WAI report? They show temperature spikes at the key locations in question that are entirely consistent (both in terms of intensity and duration) with the temperatures reached in the Cardington tests that you cited. I hope your fellow travelers are paying attention to this chutzpah. Your entire theory now rests on it being impossible for the fires on two floors of WTC 7 to relatively simultaneously peaked at temperatures expected per the Cardington test's experimental results and for a duration expected per the Cardington test's results. Not improbable, but impossible.

Wake up, Tony. I know you see how tenuous and flawed your own premise is.

Don't mean to discourage you, but your wasting your time, and intellect trying to wake Tony,
he is permanently asleep, in his nonsensical dream universe.
 
Right or wrong about whether the NIST part of the OFFICIAL STORY, which is the neo-skeptics lynchpin to their whole debuggery of 911, actually holds water in a formal, moderated debate. On this forum, a CIVIL, formal, moderated debate is as rare as a unicorn, and you know what neo-skeptics say about unicorns, paranormal, UFOs, et al., if you believe one, you got to believe all of them.

I don't need a degree in formal logic to see, "Mud on your face, big disgrace, kickin' your can all over the place. Singing 'We will rock you, rock you.'"

It's simple. You are being challenged to put your money where your mouth is; the gauntlet has been thrown. I'm just sitting on the sideline hoping for a long overdue just comeuppance, a hoisting by their own petards, good old fashioned ass kicking. But that's just me.

So how 'bout it? Are you going to take the battle between the light side and the dark side of the force to them goofy nutter, gosh darnedtroofers?
I get ut now. You are suffering from the delusions that this is still an issue in the engineering community, and that retreading truther arguments here or elsewhere on the internet will help establish tge much vaunted "new investigation".
 
The Weidlinger Associates report has a provably unsupportable and ridiculous assumption of two floors being heated to 850 degrees C simultaneously through 4 hour long preheating.

The extreme heating of the steel on contiguous floors to 850 degrees C is only asserted in the Weidlinger structural analysis with a reference to Hughes Associates Craig Beyler's heat transfer analysis. No other specifics are given.

I do not believe there is any chance that one floor's steel could have been at 850 degrees C, let alone two contiguous floors simultaneously. It sounds like they made it as hot as it needed to be to get a failure of the floor below. It is about as likely as putting a man on Jupiter.

You had said you would try to get a copy of Beyler's analysis. Have you been able to?

Provably unsupportable and ridiculous but you haven't even seen the cited fire study.

Is that how your search for truth works? Arrive at conclusion without actual study?:rolleyes:
 
No, I do not believe the steel in WTC 7 could have been heated to 850 degrees C on even a single floor. It was protected and the fuel would have burned out long before those temperatures could be reached. I am sure Dave will not be able to explain how it could happen. I'll be surprised if he even tries.

Because Chris Sarns performed serious forensic fire study?
 
Again: ALL studies converge on all the relevant results: Fires affected the long span floor bays around 79-81, made them collapse, and that triggered the global collapse.

Oystein you have been given a golden opportunity to back up your 9/11 ‘schtick’.

I’m guessing that given the opportunity to test his claims in a disciplined debate, Oystein will do what he accuses ’truthers’ of doing; ‘running and hiding’.
What?
Is there any doubt that all of the wtc7 studies converge on floor bay failure due to fire, that lead to a progressive collapse involving the entire structure?

Tony? Criteria? Jakesteele?

I have seen responses, but so far nothing that actually addresses this question, which itself is directly begged of a comment that Critetia made.
 
Last edited:
While I am at it, so far nada addressing this yet either....

And it actually directly relates to the thread.

So, Tony, as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?
 
No, I answered that the charges would not need to be on fire floors. The fires were on floors 7 ,8, 9, 11, 12, 13, 19, 22, 29, and 30. There were plenty of floors without fires where charges could have been preset and avoided by arsonists.

Let's take a look at WTC 7.

WTC7_Smoke.jpg


db_Magnum1.jpg



Eyewitness Accounts of WTC 7 Fires


FDNY Lieutenant Robert Larocco

* We walked over by number Seven World Trade Center as it was burning and saw this 40-plus story building with fire on nearly all floors.

–FDNY Lieutenant Robert Larocco


FDNY Lieutenant James McGlynn

*...Just when you thought it was over, you're walking by this building and you're hearing this building creak and fully involved in flames. It's like, is it coming down next? Sure enough, about a half an hour later it came down.

–FDNY Lieutenant James McGlynn


FDNY Assistant Chief Harry Myers

* When the building came down it was completely involved in fire, all forty-seven stories.

–FDNY Assistant Chief Harry Myers


PAPD P.O. Edward McQuade

* Building #7 was still actively burning and at that time we were advised by a NYFD Chief that building #7 was burning out of control and imminent collapse was probable.
–PAPD P.O. Edward McQuade


Capt. Chris Boyle

Boyle: There was a huge gaping hole and it was scattered through there. It was a huge hole. I would say it was probably a third of it, right in the middle of it.

-Capt. Chris Boyle


FDNY Chief Frank Fellini

The major concern at that time was number Seven, building number Seven, which had taken a big hit from the north tower. When it fell, it ripped steel out from between the third and sixth floors across the facade on Vesey Street. We were concerned that the fires on several floors and the missing steel would result in the building collapsing.
–FDNY Chief Frank Fellini


FDNY Captain Anthony Varriale

We were unaware of the damage in the front of 7, because we were entering from the northeast entrance. We weren't aware of the magnitude of the damage in the front of[ the building.

– FDNY Captain A

Anthony Varriale


FAQs - NIST WTC 7 Investigation

13. Did investigators consider the possibility that an explosion caused or contributed to the collapse of WTC 7?

Yes, this possibility was investigated carefully. NIST concluded that blast events inside the building did not occur and found no evidence supporting the existence of a blast event.
In addition, no blast sounds were heard on the audio tracks of video recordings during the collapse of WTC 7 or reported by witnesses. According to calculations by the investigation team, the smallest blast capable of failing the building's critical column would have resulted in a sound level of 130 decibels (dB) to 140 dB at a distance of at least half a mile, if unobstructed by surrounding buildings. This sound level is consistent with a gunshot blast, standing next to a jet plane engine, and more than 10 times louder than being in front of the speakers at a rock concert.

For the building to have been prepared for intentional demolition, walls and/or column enclosures and fireproofing would have to be removed and replaced without being detected. Preparing a column includes steps such as cutting sections with torches, which produces noxious and odorous fumes. Intentional demolition usually requires applying explosive charges to most, if not all, interior columns, not just one or a limited set of columns in a building.

https://www.nist.gov/el/faqs-nist-wtc-7-investigation
 
Last edited:
There have been moderated threads in past. I suggest to start with unmoderated and if someone interferes, request moderation for the thread (if that's still possible - maybe ask first). But I don't think anyone will interfere, since they can comment in a separate thread created to the effect.



I didn't say incessant. I said on a whim.



That's a risk you run in about every forum discussion.



There's no such need. If I feel I want to add or correct something after the editing period has passed, I want to be able to do so, like in any other forum discussion.



You want this to become something other than a forum discussion. I want to keep it as a forum discussion. Forum discussions don't have these limits. That's why I put that as the very first rule: it's not a debate, it's a forum discussion.

But if you prefer me to propose changes, here they are. They are mostly the consequence of removing the limits that you set in the other discussion. As you can see, I've been about as comprehensive as you were in the other rules.


Add this:

1. It's not a debate, it's a forum discussion, just in a dedicated thread where no other posters are allowed.

1. The debate is restricted to the collapses of WTC 1, 2 & 7 in NYC on September 11, 2001, the NIST reports on these events, and any additional objectively verifiable information and analyses in the public domain about them.

2. Each person shall make an opening statement (of no more than 500 words) explaining what they believe caused the collapse of WTC 7 and briefly stating what they believe are the (approximately) 3 strongest pieces of verifiable evidence for/against Controlled Demolition, as "Controlled Demolition vs. No Controlled Demolition" is the heart of the debate.

Substitute 1 and 2 with:

2. Since you want to prove that the collapses of 1, 2 and 7 WTC were controlled demolitions (per the 2nd rule of the debate you held with tfk, reproduced in stricken form in the previous paragraph), the title of the thread (and the main topic) will be: Evidence for controlled demolition.

(And see 6 below)

3. tfk will go first after both participants make an opening statement on June 21, 2016.
I don't care who goes first. Since it's a free-form discussion, there's no clearly defined opening statement. Obviously both will make a first post each, and that's all.

4. Each person shall make no more than one post per day and cannot make another until it is responded to.
5. If a post is not responded to within a week the person not responding is considered to have forfeited his turn & the other person will proceed with his next statement.
6. Individual posts are limited to 1,000 words. If it is deemed necessary to exceed that limit, justification shall be provided by the person wanting to exceed it and agreement to by the other participant received prior to doing so. This should be done by private messaging, so as not to interrupt the flow of the debate, and should be the exception rather than the rule.

Substitute the limits imposed by 4, 5 and 6 with:

4. The post length is unlimited. The number of posts per poster is unlimited. The time between posts is unlimited, just like in any other forum discussion, except that after a month without a post from either poster the discussion is considered to be over.

7. Each post will discuss one princip[al] topic. Each topic consists of 4 posts. Person A will state a topic post, Person B replies, Person A counters, then Person B counters, and that topic is closed. Person B then leads off the next sequence.

8. Every point that either person brings up must be addressed in some manner by the other. Both parties will do their best to stay focused on the original topic point.

Substitute the limits imposed by 7 and 8 with:

5. There's no obligation to respond to any of the points raised by the other.

6. There's no restriction on the topics, even though a somewhat coherent line is expected in accordance with ISF's rule 11.

9. There shall be no name calling, denigration, or defamatory language used. Each person shall bring only technical arguments to the debate. If any derogatory comments are used they shall be addressed to arguments only, not to individuals.

Arguments don't have to be technical. The rest is already covered by the forum rules. Substitute 9 with:

7. Breaking ISF's membership agreement rules, in particular rule 0, rule 10 and rule 12, is not allowed.

10. The debate will end after a maximum of 50 total posts, or earlier if the participants mutually agree to an earlier termination, or whenever either participant decides to stop responding.

See 4.
​

It sounds like you don't want a one-on-one debate with your insistence on it being a "forum discussion" and even having to consider the possibility of interference, which would then require a moderator's interaction. I am not going to subject myself to that kind of nonsense.

I do not want to be held to any of the ISF's rules and will not debate on this forum. The 911 Free Forum did not apply any of these types of restrictions and set up a special section for one-on-one debates. The ground rule about name calling etc. covered this type of thing sufficiently.

Rules concerning frequency and length of posts, and time for response are necessary. There can't be a debate without them.

The debate I proposed is about technical issues concerning the WTC Tower and WTC 7 collapses and any verifiable public domain information about them. If you want to talk about other issues you aren't even considering the debate I proposed.

I do not think your rules are conducive to an ordered and structured debate/discussion and I can't go along with them.

My counter is to debate on the 911 Free Forum with at least most of the rules set up for the debate I had with tfk. The differences can be: no opening statements, and no need to respond point by point if it isn't desired. If you can't do that I have to wonder what you really have in mind other than a straightforward discussion.
 
Last edited:
BOG: So why plant explosives?

EL: We need it to come down.

BOG: How long do you plan to burn it?

EL: Eight hours. Also, we're gonna need you and your men to go into #7 to set the fires.

BOG: Won't the collapse of WTC1 do that on it's own?

EL: We need to guarantee the fire, to cover the explosives.

BOG: Okay, I think we can do that. So it burns for eight hours, then the explosives go off, and the building collapses, right?

EL: No, it's not quite that simple. We need a whole series of explosive charges.

BOG: Sorry, what?

EL: We want a series of charges, each going off with split-second precision after the building's already started to collapse.

BOG: But you only need the charges to start the collapse. That's how demolition works.

EL: Not this time. We want the building to fall smoothly. We have to have a whole series of charges, so that each floor gets blown up just before the bit above reaches it.

BOG: Um... But it just increases the amount of work we have to do, and makes it more likely we'll get caught. Why would we want to do that?

EL: The same reason the villain never just shoots James Bond. Don't you go to the movies?

Dave
 
Your agenda, as always for the conspiracist, is to try and prevent the case against you from being laid out in full, so as to give the suggestion that the minor detail you disagree with is the whole story. It's an attempt to create a false sense of equivalence between your fantasies and reality, and it's fundamentally dishonest. And this is why you'll reject, or at least try to modify, pgimeno's proposed terms; you simply can't risk playing on a level field.

Dave

Rules concerning frequency and length of posts, and time for response are necessary. There can't be a debate without them.

Man, I'm tired of being right.

Dave
 
Haven't checked into the thread in a while.

Has Tony been able to muster the answer to the question "How many planes crashed on 9/11" yet?
 
It's too bad no one will debate TS. I really wanted to find out if the NIST reports were valid or not.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom