does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Tony's lucky his fellow travelers checked their critical thinking at the door. He's been hiding from facing up to the WAI findings for months now. It's so painfully obvious to the few people who pay attention. He relished pointing out an error in Nordenson's floor collapse calculations, and now he realizes that WAI pointed out an error in his (to wit--assuming the lower floors were pristine). Tony--how long do you plan to keep hiding from the truth? Your fellow travelers may not be sharp enough to understand it--but you actually do understand it, which is why you are hiding from it.


The extreme heating of the steel on contiguous floors to 850 degrees C is only asserted in the Weidlinger structural analysis with a reference to Hughes Associates Craig Beyler's heat transfer analysis. No other specifics are given.

I do not believe there is any chance that one floor's steel could have been at 850 degrees C, let alone two contiguous floors simultaneously. It sounds like they made it as hot as it needed to be to get a failure of the floor below. It is about as likely as putting a man on Jupiter.

You had said you would try to get a copy of Beyler's analysis. Have you been able to?
 
Last edited:
Not really. A BA logician would recognise that they're being invited to put their money where Tony decides their mouth is.

Well I have been known to say many of these alleged debunkers are talking out of their hat.

They usually just blindly support the present official story without an objective basis. That can be gotten away with when their group is ganging up on an individual poster who is challenging them but doesn't work well in a one-on-one debate.
 
Last edited:
I do not believe there is any chance that one floor's steel could have been at 850 degrees C, let alone two contiguous floors. It sounds like they made it as hot as it needed to be to get a failure of the floor below.

So you're admitting that all you have is an argument from incredulity plus the assumption that the study you disagree with is based on deliberate lies. I'm sure that's far more credible than, you know, actually doing the work.

Dave
 
He relished pointing out an error in Nordenson's floor collapse calculations, and now he realizes that WAI pointed out an error in his (to wit--assuming the lower floors were pristine).

Ironically, that takes us straight back to the "Missing Jolt" nonsense of years ago, in which Tony, among his other fatal errors, made the same assumption about WTC1 and WTC2. Even more ironically, this was finally debunked by one T. Szamboti, in an exchange currently recorded in my signature.

Dave
 
So you're admitting that all you have is an argument from incredulity plus the assumption that the study you disagree with is based on deliberate lies. I'm sure that's far more credible than, you know, actually doing the work.

Dave

No, the fuel will not last long enough and the heat will transfer to cooler areas long before 850 degrees C is achieved in the steel.

There is a technical basis for what I am saying.
 
Well I have been known to say many of these alleged debunkers are talking out of their hat.

They usually just blindly support the present official story without an objective basis.

The "blindly support" is a unfounded assumption on your part. You cannot know what a poster has read or not read.

You also fail in lumping those who believe it was fire induced collapse, after damage), to that of only the official report. That is the same as saying CD could only take place using "thermite" and no other source of explosives.

That is why you and AE911T have failed to provide a concise explanation to the CD of WTC 1,2, 7. You know you can't.
 
No, the fuel will not last long enough and the heat will transfer to cooler areas long before 850 degrees C is achieved in the steel.

There is a technical basis for what I am saying.

No, there's just proof by assertion as usual. Shouldn't you start insulting people next? That's the normal progression.

Dave
 
Ironically, that takes us straight back to the "Missing Jolt" nonsense of years ago, in which Tony, among his other fatal errors, made the same assumption about WTC1 and WTC2. Even more ironically, this was finally debunked by one T. Szamboti, in an exchange currently recorded in my signature.

Dave

The load carrying capability of the floors below could have only been reduced by explosives. Otherwise, to defeat their reserve strength a jolt to gain load amplification is needed.

It sounds like you only understand half of what is discussed there.
 
Oystein said:
What, exactly, does this guy claim that we could discuss and try to show whether he is right or wrong?
Right or wrong about whether the NIST part of the OFFICIAL STORY,
*MEEEEP*
Fail.

which is the neo-skeptics lynchpin to their whole debuggery of 911,
*MEEEEP*
Childish babble.

actually holds water in a formal, moderated debate.
*MEEEEP*
The debate is supposed to be about the debate?!? What crazy thinking is that?
I asked you what, exactly, does "this guy" claim that we could discuss and try to show whether he is right or wrong? I see that you, too, could not detect a debatable claim in T.Sz.'s proposal. Thanks for playing.
 
I knew Oystein would run from such a fair debate, but who would have expected such speed.

Good thing you didn't quote me.
That might keep some folks from noticing that you ran away from my response and resort to a lie instead.

Classy.

ETA:
Someone hasn't been paying attention :rolleyes:
He's cherry picking what he pays attention to. What a totally dishonest performance.
Oops *MEEEEP* sorry, Criteria, some folks DID notice your dishonesty.
 
Last edited:
Good thing you didn't quote me.
That might keep some folks from noticing that you ran away from my response and resort to a lie instead.

Classy.

So, it sounds like you don't want to do a one-on-one debate about the NIST WTC and WTC 7 reports and other public domain information such as the ARUP and Weidlinger reports, where things can be more clearly stated without interference from other posters.
 
Last edited:
...
I do not believe there is any chance that one floor's steel could have been at 850 degrees C, ...

Ah ok - you don't believe. That convinces me.

Hey guys! It's a false-flag thermite-nuclear inside jobby job after all! :)
 
The load carrying capability of the floors below could have only been reduced by explosives. Otherwise, to defeat their reserve strength a jolt to gain load amplification is needed.

It sounds like you only understand half of what is discussed there.

What did Danny Jowenko say in 2006 about explosive CD charges in burning buildings?
 
Dave, please explain how the steel could have been heated to 850 degrees C on two contiguous floors in WTC 7.

Uhm - to clarify: Is it important to explain the heating for two, not just one, floor? Do you agree that 850 °C could have been reached on one floor? Or do you actually want Dave to explain how the steel could have been heated to 850 degrees C on any one floor?
 
So, it sounds like you don't want to do a one-on-one debate about the NIST WTC and WTC 7 reports and other public domain information such as the ARUP and Weidlinger reports, where things can be more clearly stated without interference from other posters.

Try quoting in full those of my posts where I am talking to YOU, not this Criteria person, so that anyone reading here can more easily see you run away and hide from my stated reasons why debating you under the conditions you outlines so far would be a fool's errand.

ETA to give you a chance to earn back a little respect:
Did you notice Criteria's dishonesty?
 
Last edited:
What did Danny Jowenko say in 2006 about explosive CD charges in burning buildings?

The fires in WTC 7 weren't on every floor and I think the evidence shows they were started by arsonists who could have known what floors the charges were on.
 
Uhm - to clarify: Is it important to explain the heating for two, not just one, floor? Do you agree that 850 °C could have been reached on one floor? Or do you actually want Dave to explain how the steel could have been heated to 850 degrees C on any one floor?

No, I do not believe the steel in WTC 7 could have been heated to 850 degrees C on even a single floor. It was protected and the fuel would have burned out long before those temperatures could be reached. I am sure Dave will not be able to explain how it could happen. I'll be surprised if he even tries.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom