does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Huh??
The only thing that Tony totally avoids even mentioning is this ephemeral "CD theory".


Which CD theory, pray tell?
I have not seen any CD theory pushed by any truther ever.
None that deserved the title "theory" anyway.
"Vage and timid insinuation, studiously void of any testable detail" is more like it.
I wish Tony would present a concise, comprehensive CD theory. That could be a great debate topic.

Tony implies that the collapse of WTC 7 was CD.
 
Huh??
The only thing that Tony totally avoids even mentioning is this ephemeral "CD theory".


Which CD theory, pray tell?
I have not seen any CD theory pushed by any truther ever.
None that deserved the title "theory" anyway.
"Vage and timid insinuation, studiously void of any testable detail" is more like it.
I wish Tony would present a concise, comprehensive CD theory. That could be a great debate topic.

Tony has always pushed Jones's theories, and always will, I believe he is one of those holding his breath waiting for the conclusion of Mark Basile's studies.

I have heard privately they are trying to get a release of dust samples from the government.
They are claiming that they will prove the thermite claim, if they have more dust to study.:D
 
The falling girder can't break through the next floor down. You saw that with my critique of Nordenson.

That does not address my question, nor the statement by Oystein that Criteria quoted.

Once again,
Is there any doubt that all of the wtc7 studies converge on floor bay failure due to fire, that lead to a progressive collapse involving the entire structure?
 
Last edited:
Actually they haven't.

Let's take a look to see if you are correct.

NIST WTC 7 Investigation Finds Building Fires Caused Collapse

To reach the conclusions in its report, NIST complemented its in-house expertise with private-sector technical experts; accumulated an extensive collection of documents, photographs and videos related to the WTC events of 9/11.

https://www.nist.gov/news-events/ne...tigation-finds-building-fires-caused-collapse
 
Tony implies that the collapse of WTC 7 was CD.

Yes he does but he refuses to give a viable theory for how.

He wants to use mathematical modeling, that could never be exact, because all have a long list of unknowns, that can never be known.

That is why it is criticality important to insist that tony flesh out his theories.

Otherwise all we have are dry withered bones and very few of them.

So we can not know how they dinosaur died in the lake, weather it was old age or drowning.
all we know is it was in a lake when it drowned.

Tony shows us a couple of bones and wants to claim he knows who killed the dinosaur.

Sorry I am laughing so hard I can't think!
 
Tony has always pushed Jones's theories, and always will, I believe he is one of those holding his breath waiting for the conclusion of Mark Basile's studies. ...

I might debate him on that some day. Pending a properly, narrowly defined debate proposition.
The Jones&Harrit nonsense can and should be cleanly separated from pretty much all the rest of the 9/11 events and studies thereof: In case the chips are determined to be thermite, doesn't prove CD or disprove that fires caused collapses.
Conversely, if they are paint (or otherwise non-thermitic), that doesn't disprove CD or prove fires did it. However, that result would demonstrate that Truthers cannot distinguish facts from lies even after looking a hoax in the eye for over seven years.
 
Right or wrong about WHAT?

That guy came here to debate about a dozend buildings, half a dozend or so building performance studies, and uncounted (100+) academic papers on all these buildings.

So please help me: What, exactly, does this guy claim that we could discuss and try to show whether he is right or wrong?

When you got your B.A. in formal logic, did they teach you how to frame a debate proposal? Then please explain it to that guy ;)

Right or wrong about whether the NIST part of the OFFICIAL STORY, which is the neo-skeptics lynchpin to their whole debuggery of 911, actually holds water in a formal, moderated debate. On this forum, a CIVIL, formal, moderated debate is as rare as a unicorn, and you know what neo-skeptics say about unicorns, paranormal, UFOs, et al., if you believe one, you got to believe all of them.

I don't need a degree in formal logic to see, "Mud on your face, big disgrace, kickin' your can all over the place. Singing 'We will rock you, rock you.'"

It's simple. You are being challenged to put your money where your mouth is; the gauntlet has been thrown. I'm just sitting on the sideline hoping for a long overdue just comeuppance, a hoisting by their own petards, good old fashioned ass kicking. But that's just me.

So how 'bout it? Are you going to take the battle between the light side and the dark side of the force to them goofy nutter, gosh darnedtroofers?
 
Yes he does but he refuses to give a viable theory for how.

He wants to use mathematical modeling, that could never be exact, because all have a long list of unknowns, that can never be known.

That is why it is criticality important to insist that tony flesh out his theories.

Otherwise all we have are dry withered bones and very few of them.

So we can not know how they dinosaur died in the lake, weather it was old age or drowning.
all we know is it was in a lake when it drowned.

Tony shows us a couple of bones and wants to claim he knows who killed the dinosaur.

Sorry I am laughing so hard I can't think!


Simply amazing considering there are conspiracy theorist who actually believe him just as there were those who believed the hoaxed WTC 7 demolition video by Eddy Current. I can just imagine the numerous warning signs throughout WTC 7 before 9/11.


****BEWARE****


Detonation Cord Tripping Hazards
 
He waves his hands and claims CD.
Take the failure of the EPH, he implies, suggests, puts forth a hand waving argument that col 79 was CD'd high up in the building to make it look like it failed down where the fires were.

And yet, Tony wants a debate, but can't provide a single video that depicts actual demolition explosions occurring before, or during the collapse of WTC 7.

I would think that a trigger person would get a bit tired as fires raged out of control within WTC 7 for hours before pushing the CD button.
 
I knew Oystein would run from such a fair debate, but who would have expected such speed.
 
It should have been called the improbable collapse scenario. That would be generous though as it is actually impossible.

And what, magical ferries sneaking through a fully occupied building that nobody had ever heard of or cared about planting super-secret totally silent hush-a-boom explosives that produce no sound, blast, supersonic pressure wave, or high velocity ejecta and leave no trace - all for no plausible reason - is sooooooo much better :confused:

If only you paid so much scrutiny to your own case.

Hey, you never answered my question from earlier. Why do you only care about buildings, not people? Nearly 3,000 people died on 9/11. You never mention them. You think the whole thing was about re-arranging the New York City real estate market.

Why is it that CT's never mention the human casualties and fixate on inanimate objects? Someone should do a study.
 
Last edited:
Right or wrong about whether the NIST part of the OFFICIAL STORY, which is the neo-skeptics lynchpin to their whole debuggery of 911,

Let me stop you there. No, it isn't any such thing. You seem to be deluded into thinking that nothing but the collapse of WTC7 happened on 9/11. In truth, it was a minor footnote, and it's only fantasists who feel the need to pretend otherwise.

Dave
 
I knew Oystein would run from such a fair debate, but who would have expected such speed.

Fair debate, Sounds more like twoofer Russian Roulette, with only Tony playing.
In a fair open debate Tony could never win, that's why it would never bee one.
 
Tony's lucky his fellow travelers checked their critical thinking at the door. He's been hiding from facing up to the WAI findings for months now. It's so painfully obvious to the few people who pay attention. He relished pointing out an error in Nordenson's floor collapse calculations, and now he realizes that WAI pointed out an error in his (to wit--assuming the lower floors were pristine). Tony--how long do you plan to keep hiding from the truth? Your fellow travelers may not be sharp enough to understand it--but you actually do understand it, which is why you are hiding from it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom