does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Really? Let's see how true that is.

I will discuss the matter with you under the following rules:
  1. It's not a debate, it's a forum discussion, just in a dedicated thread where no other posters are allowed.
  2. The forum will be ISF. I don't trust the911forum. It's known for having had people banned on a whim, and for having allowed edition of messages even years after posted. ISF, on the other hand, has a history of not allowing edition of posts past 2 hours, and of reasonably fair moderation.
  3. Since you want to prove that the collapses of 1, 2 and 7 WTC were controlled demolitions (per the 2nd rule of the debate you held with tfk), the title of the thread (and the main topic) will be: Evidence for controlled demolition.
  4. There's no restriction on the topics, even though a somewhat coherent line is expected in accordance with ISF's rule 11.
  5. The post length is unlimited. The number of posts per poster is unlimited. Just like in any other forum discussion.
  6. There's no obligation to respond to any of the points raised by the other.
  7. Breaking ISF's membership agreement rules, in particular rule 0, rule 10 and rule 12, is not allowed.
  8. After 30 days without a response, the discussion is over.
These rules are designed to be pretty much like those in any other forum discussion. If what you said above is true, there should be no problem for you to agree to them.

Are you game?

There will not be a one-on-one debate/forum discussion here. The 911 Free Forum is the place for it as there is already a precedent of non-interference. The moderator there did change the editing time to two hours like it is here to satisfy your complaint over their lack of a restriction before the debate between tfk and myself. He also said today, in response to your allegation of incessant banning, that there has only been five people banned on that forum.

The individual post length has to be limited to 1,000 words otherwise one might try to overwhelm with nonsense.

One post at a time per individual and the next post is in response. There also needs to be a limit on responses to one post so one person doesn't lead all the time.

I suggest you show the rules used for my debate with tfk and propose changes that you feel necessary by crossing out and adding. Your rules here are not comprehensive.
 
Last edited:
Well I have been known to say many of these alleged debunkers are talking out of their hat.

They usually just blindly support the present official story without an objective basis.


Since you've implied that WTC 7 was the result of CD, tell us how explosives were placed in an occupied building in strict secrecy and why no one found such evidence after 15 years and then, explain why there were no secondary explosions observed in a building that suffered major impact damage and where fires raged for hours during which time no one heard demolition explosions.

Give me something that real demolition experts will take seriously.
 
Is a debate with an ISF member a requirement for there to be a new investigation?

If not, then why are you fussing about it?

If so, then how did you end up in a position where you need cooperation from people who oppose your goals in order to achieve your goals?

I decided to try Tony's approach in other spheres of life. First I went to the central office of Chase Bank and stood in the lobby yelling, "Which of you unqualified financial ignoramuses has the guts to give me a million dollars free and clear with no obligation?" Then I went to Google's offices and yelled, "Which of you fraudulent computer-illiterate morons is self-assured enough to put me in charge of your biggest development project and pay me six figures a year for it?" Then I went to a meeting of Elite Model Management's top female talent and yelled, "Which of you ugly frumpish amateurs has the courage to marry me?"

I returned a few times a week for five years, each time repeating variations of "I see that none of you incompetent dishonest unworthy people has dared to meet my demands."

Surprisingly, my financial, employment, and marital status were in no way improved by these activities.

Aren't you clever.
 
Yes, focus.
You took your focus of a simple, straight question:

What did Danny Jowenko say in 2006 about explosive CD charges in burning buildings?

No, I answered that the charges would not need to be on fire floors. The fires were on floors 7 ,8, 9, 11, 12, 13, 19, 22, 29, and 30. There were plenty of floors without fires where charges could have been preset and avoided by arsonists.
 
No, I answered that the charges would not need to be on fire floors. The fires were on floors 7 ,8, 9, 11, 12, 13, 19, 22, 29, and 30. There were plenty of floors without fires where charges could have been preset and avoided by arsonists.

All very well.
What's the damned problem with answering a straight question?

What did Danny Jowenko say in 2006 about explosive CD charges in burning buildings?
 
No, I answered that the charges would not need to be on fire floors. The fires were on floors 7 ,8, 9, 11, 12, 13, 19, 22, 29, and 30. There were plenty of floors without fires where charges could have been preset and avoided by arsonists.


Considering no explosions were seen or heard, either before, during or after the collapse of WTC 7, simply proves beyond a shadow of a doubt there were no explosives placed within WTC 7 prior to its collapse.
 
Last edited:
The extreme heating of the steel on contiguous floors to 850 degrees C is only asserted in the Weidlinger structural analysis with a reference to Hughes Associates Craig Beyler's heat transfer analysis. No other specifics are given.

I do not believe there is any chance that one floor's steel could have been at 850 degrees C, let alone two contiguous floors simultaneously. It sounds like they made it as hot as it needed to be to get a failure of the floor below. It is about as likely as putting a man on Jupiter.

You had said you would try to get a copy of Beyler's analysis. Have you been able to?

Dr. Beyler's report never made it into the court record due to how the case unfolded procedurally. I obtained an affidavit of his from early in the litigation, but that was merely responding to Dr. Bailey and Dr. Mowrer re whether the photographic evidence provided in discovery proved the flutes were filled or unfilled; it does not provide any insight into his fire model beyond stating that his over all analysis (which is not otherwise detailed in the affidavit) "included detailed heat transfer modeling (both two dimensional and three dimensional) of beams, columns, floor assemblies and connections in the building."

In any case, as has been pointed out to you, your incredulity is not the basis for an argument. So far, the only authority on fire science you've even attempted to cite in support of your views is the Cardington study. You made the post linking to it here.

I actually read through that study and quickly found that it did not at all support your argument. The max temperature recorded in the Cardington study you linked was 1108 C, with many elements (including beams, bolts, end plates, etc. reaching temperatures of 800-1000 C). Given that the test structure (a narrow, 8 floor building) was a great deal smaller than wtc 7, and the fires in the test structure burnt for a far shorter time over all, it's really hard to compare the two. The study temperatures look in line with the WAI temperatures and the temperatures observed in the scale model test of the WTC 1 fires, in any case. (You do know they built a scale model of WTC 1 to get accurate fire observations, right? There is a peer reviewed paper that documents that experiment here: http://ascelibrary.org/doi/abs/10.1061/(ASCE)0887-3828(2007)21:6(414)).

So where are you getting these magical temperature limit numbers from? You aren't getting them from the only authority on the matter than you've claimed to have read so far.

Re how the fires could be on multiple floors--this was covered ad nauseum in the Aegis expert reports: the structural damage to the building allowed the the fire to start on, and spread around, multiple floors at once. This is just one of the many ways in which the WTC 7 fire was not a typical office fire.

It's ok to admit you are wrong. The truth shall set you free, Tony.
 
Last edited:
No, I answered that the charges would not need to be on fire floors. The fires were on floors 7 ,8, 9, 11, 12, 13, 19, 22, 29, and 30. There were plenty of floors without fires where charges could have been preset and avoided by arsonists.

How do you know the fires were solely on those floors?
 
No, I answered that the charges would not need to be on fire floors. The fires were on floors 7 ,8, 9, 11, 12, 13, 19, 22, 29, and 30. There were plenty of floors without fires where charges could have been preset and avoided by arsonists.

"Could have". This is not a statement of certainty. Seem even you are not convinced of what you post.

Once again, your evidence of arson is? Your evidence of planted explosives is?

Are you saying the "arsonist" was so sure of the expected fire behavior over many hours that the fires would not impact the explosives? Sometimes fires have a way of surprising even the best fire scientists. Seems the "planners" of the CD took a unnecessary risk. Explain how "they" the explosives would be safe. Provide evidence to back up what you state.
 
Last edited:
"Could have". This is not a statement of certainty. Seem even you are not convinced of what you post.

Once again, your evidence of arson is? Your evidence of planted explosives is?

Are you saying the "arsonist" was so sure of the expected fire behavior over many hours that the fires would not impact the explosives? Sometimes fires have a way of surprising even the best fire scientists. Seems the "planners" of the CD took a unnecessary risk. Explain how "they" the explosives would be safe. Provide evidence to back up what you state.

He can't he is flapping his arms and orbiting alpha prime by now.:D
Sorry just couldn't resist.
 
Dr. Beyler's report never made it into the court record due to how the case unfolded procedurally. I obtained an affidavit of his from early in the litigation, but that was merely responding to Dr. Bailey and Dr. Mowrer re whether the photographic evidence provided in discovery proved the flutes were filled or unfilled; it does not provide any insight into his fire model beyond stating that his over all analysis (which is not otherwise detailed in the affidavit) "included detailed heat transfer modeling (both two dimensional and three dimensional) of beams, columns, floor assemblies and connections in the building."

In any case, as has been pointed out to you, your incredulity is not the basis for an argument. So far, the only authority on fire science you've even attempted to cite in support of your views is the Cardington study. You made the post linking to it here.

I actually read through that study and quickly found that it did not at all support your argument. The max temperature recorded in the Cardington study you linked was 1108 C, with many elements (including beams, bolts, end plates, etc. reaching temperatures of 800-1000 C). Given that the test structure (a narrow, 8 floor building) was a great deal smaller than wtc 7, and the fires in the test structure burnt for a far shorter time over all, it's really hard to compare the two. The study temperatures look in line with the WAI temperatures and the temperatures observed in the scale model test of the WTC 1 fires, in any case. (You do know they built a scale model of WTC 1 to get accurate fire observations, right? There is a peer reviewed paper that documents that experiment here: http://ascelibrary.org/doi/abs/10.1061/(ASCE)0887-3828(2007)21:6(414)).

So where are you getting these magical temperature limit numbers from? You aren't getting them from the only authority on the matter than you've claimed to have read so far.

Re how the fires could be on multiple floors--this was covered ad nauseum in the Aegis expert reports: the structural damage to the building allowed the the fire to start on, and spread around, multiple floors at once. This is just one of the many ways in which the WTC 7 fire was not a typical office fire.

It's ok to admit you are wrong. The truth shall set you free, Tony.

The Cardington test data does not support the assertion that the steel in two contiguous fire protected floors in WTC 7 would be able to reach 850 degrees C (1,562 F). That is really a non-starter based on the short time frame a fire in any one area is active, due to fuel limitations, and the heat transfer characteristics of the fire proofing material.

You should realize there are photographs of fire areas having been burned out in WTC 7 prior to its collapse. The fire on another side of the building is not heating the already burned out area or anything 70 to 100 feet away in any significant way.
 
Last edited:
T...the assertion that the steel in two contiguous fire protected floors in WTC 7 would be able to reach 850 degrees C ...

Tony, we just established that the "two contiguous" bit is entirely irrelevant to your question - sloppy wording. Why do you blow this smoke again?

(This apart from the fact that you failed to substantially address the point benthamitemetric made - that the Cardington test showed that 850 °C can be reached in some structures on fires - they actually did in the Cardington tests -, and that you thus cannot conclude that this would be impossible in WTC7 from the Cardington tests. If anything, the opposite os suggested by the Cardingon tests: They make the the assertion that the steel in two contiguous fire protected floors in WTC 7 would be able to reach 850 degrees C plausible.)
 
Do we still have that smilie image of an exploding irony meter?

Dave

I got your irony image right here

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychological_projection
Psychological projection is a theory in psychology in which humans defend themselves against their own unconscious impulses or qualities (both positive and negative) by denying their existence in themselves while attributing them to others.[1] For example, a person who is habitually rude may constantly accuse other people of being rude. It incorporates blame shifting.

Just like politicians in trouble; "It wasn't me, it was theirs/his/hers/thems fault.
 
The Cardington test data does not support the assertion that the steel in two contiguous fire protected floors in WTC 7 would be able to reach 850 degrees C (1,562 F). That is really a non-starter based on the short time frame a fire in any one area is active, due to fuel limitations, and the heat transfer characteristics of the fire proofing material.

You should realize there are photographs of fire areas having been burned out in WTC 7 prior to its collapse. The fire on another side of the building is not heating the already burned out area or anything 70 to 100 feet away in any significant way.

Can you see Soot burning in day light?
 
There will not be a one-on-one debate/forum discussion here.
There have been moderated threads in past. I suggest to start with unmoderated and if someone interferes, request moderation for the thread (if that's still possible - maybe ask first). But I don't think anyone will interfere, since they can comment in a separate thread created to the effect.


The 911 Free Forum is the place for it as there is already a precedent of non-interference. The moderator there did change the editing time to two hours like it is here to satisfy your complaint over their lack of a restriction before the debate between tfk and myself. He also said today, in response to your allegation of incessant banning, that there has only been five people banned on that forum.
I didn't say incessant. I said on a whim.


The individual post length has to be limited to 1,000 words otherwise one might try to overwhelm with nonsense.
That's a risk you run in about every forum discussion.


One post at a time per individual and the next post is in response. There also needs to be a limit on responses to one post so one person doesn't lead all the time.
There's no such need. If I feel I want to add or correct something after the editing period has passed, I want to be able to do so, like in any other forum discussion.


I suggest you show the rules used for my debate with tfk and propose changes that you feel necessary by crossing out and adding. Your rules here are not comprehensive.
You want this to become something other than a forum discussion. I want to keep it as a forum discussion. Forum discussions don't have these limits. That's why I put that as the very first rule: it's not a debate, it's a forum discussion.

But if you prefer me to propose changes, here they are. They are mostly the consequence of removing the limits that you set in the other discussion. As you can see, I've been about as comprehensive as you were in the other rules.


Add this:

1. It's not a debate, it's a forum discussion, just in a dedicated thread where no other posters are allowed.

1. The debate is restricted to the collapses of WTC 1, 2 & 7 in NYC on September 11, 2001, the NIST reports on these events, and any additional objectively verifiable information and analyses in the public domain about them.

2. Each person shall make an opening statement (of no more than 500 words) explaining what they believe caused the collapse of WTC 7 and briefly stating what they believe are the (approximately) 3 strongest pieces of verifiable evidence for/against Controlled Demolition, as "Controlled Demolition vs. No Controlled Demolition" is the heart of the debate.

Substitute 1 and 2 with:

2. Since you want to prove that the collapses of 1, 2 and 7 WTC were controlled demolitions (per the 2nd rule of the debate you held with tfk, reproduced in stricken form in the previous paragraph), the title of the thread (and the main topic) will be: Evidence for controlled demolition.

(And see 6 below)

3. tfk will go first after both participants make an opening statement on June 21, 2016.
I don't care who goes first. Since it's a free-form discussion, there's no clearly defined opening statement. Obviously both will make a first post each, and that's all.

4. Each person shall make no more than one post per day and cannot make another until it is responded to.
5. If a post is not responded to within a week the person not responding is considered to have forfeited his turn & the other person will proceed with his next statement.
6. Individual posts are limited to 1,000 words. If it is deemed necessary to exceed that limit, justification shall be provided by the person wanting to exceed it and agreement to by the other participant received prior to doing so. This should be done by private messaging, so as not to interrupt the flow of the debate, and should be the exception rather than the rule.

Substitute the limits imposed by 4, 5 and 6 with:

4. The post length is unlimited. The number of posts per poster is unlimited. The time between posts is unlimited, just like in any other forum discussion, except that after a month without a post from either poster the discussion is considered to be over.

7. Each post will discuss one princip[al] topic. Each topic consists of 4 posts. Person A will state a topic post, Person B replies, Person A counters, then Person B counters, and that topic is closed. Person B then leads off the next sequence.

8. Every point that either person brings up must be addressed in some manner by the other. Both parties will do their best to stay focused on the original topic point.

Substitute the limits imposed by 7 and 8 with:

5. There's no obligation to respond to any of the points raised by the other.

6. There's no restriction on the topics, even though a somewhat coherent line is expected in accordance with ISF's rule 11.

9. There shall be no name calling, denigration, or defamatory language used. Each person shall bring only technical arguments to the debate. If any derogatory comments are used they shall be addressed to arguments only, not to individuals.

Arguments don't have to be technical. The rest is already covered by the forum rules. Substitute 9 with:

7. Breaking ISF's membership agreement rules, in particular rule 0, rule 10 and rule 12, is not allowed.

10. The debate will end after a maximum of 50 total posts, or earlier if the participants mutually agree to an earlier termination, or whenever either participant decides to stop responding.

See 4.
​
 
Last edited:
Very unlikely to terminate after a bearable duration and after having covered all necessary bases.
Thanks. In my view, it's just another thread*, there's nothing to terminate. I don't know of many threads which have been discussed up to a termination point.

(*) With the small peculiarity that it's between two people instead of many, that is. In that, I agree with Tony that so many people intervening at the same time makes the thread too chaotic.
 
...
Psychological projection is a theory in psychology in which humans defend themselves against their own unconscious impulses or qualities (both positive and negative) by denying their existence in themselves while attributing them to others.[1] ...

Coincidentally, I have here at my fingertips this psychological study:

https://kar.kent.ac.uk/26187/1/Douglas & Sutton 2011 BJSP.pdf

From the abstract:
Douglas + Sutton said:
We advance a new account of why people endorse conspiracy theories, arguing that individuals use the social-cognitive tool of projection when making social judgments about others. ...

... These results suggest that some people think “they conspired” because they think “I would conspire”.

:p
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom