does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

​


Excellent suggestion Tony!

Oystein you have been given a golden opportunity to back up your 9/11 ‘schtick’.

I’m guessing that given the opportunity to test his claims in a disciplined debate, Oystein will do what he accuses ’truthers’ of doing; ‘running and hiding’.

Truthers don't run and Hide, Criteria, Twoofers do.

No one need to debate either you or Tony until you acknowledge, recognize, and shed the intellectual dishonesty, and disavow those that are also intellectually dishonest such as AE/9/11truth.
 
​


Excellent suggestion Tony!

Oystein you have been given a golden opportunity to back up your 9/11 ‘schtick’.

I’m guessing that given the opportunity to test his claims in a disciplined debate, Oystein will do what he accuses ’truthers’ of doing; ‘running and hiding’.
What?
Is there any doubt that all of the wtc7 studies converge on floor bay failure due to fire, that lead to a progressive collapse involving the entire structure?
 
What?
Is there any doubt that all of the wtc7 studies converge on floor bay failure due to fire, that lead to a progressive collapse involving the entire structure?

The falling girder can't break through the next floor down. You saw that with my critique of Nordenson.
 
So if I read you correctly what you are saying is that because a government agency produces a report concluding with a Probable Collapse Scenario which is by definition not provable (because no single scenario can be absolutely proven under the circumstances), along with recommendations to prevent future catastrophe's - conclusions all supported by every other, private study - it needs a complete redo?

To achieve what?

More Probable Collapse Scenario's that you can object to because they aren't absolutely provable and don't support your pet cause- a cause which you refuse to support yourself because there is no support for it?

Honestly, why are we even still discussing any of this?!?!?! :confused:

It should have been called the improbable collapse scenario. That would be generous though as it is actually impossible.
 
Not being able to unseat a girder and not being able to break through the next floor down are most certainly major details.
You read the WAI report, didn't you.
You still assume that debunking some specific detailed hypothesis of which beam went first is somehow important, when it is pretty clear that it is unlikely we can ever know.
Again, six floors on fire. dozens of girders and many more beams and connections affected. Several candidated for "the one", several candidates for "the one" mechanism.
Your objections assume that the rest of the connection(s) and assembly was pristine - that the distance between columns was what it was before the fire; that strenght of the connections impacted remained unaffected.
In other words: Illicit assumptions.

Do you want to debate one-on-one? We can then explore these notions on both sides in a much more rigorous and serious way than what is possible here.
No, you cannot, Tony. You aren't thinking rigorously. You can't even formulate a feasible debate proposal, with a well-defined point of contention.

It is not reasonable to have to answer multiple posters (who can interject at any time) in a debate and that is why I prefer the one-on-one situation. It will not take up any more of your time than what you spend here, as there will be ample time to answer. What do you say?
Try to formulate a rigorous, single point of contention that can be reasonable debated in finite time and space. Then we will see if you have any takers.

Your opinion that some issues you have with NIST are "major" and warrant "a new investigation" is an opinion. I see no point in debating it. I'd require something more specific and provable. Ideally you make a positive claim. As DGM pointed out yesterday, you failed that first step in your debate with tfk.

I will not be the taker of your debate proposal IF you manage to formulate some engineering proposition - I am not an engineer.
 
It is clear that the self appointed debunkers on this forum are scared to debate one-on-one with someone they claim to disagree with on the causes of the collapses of the three WTC high-rise buildings. ...

Not so much scared to death of you as annoyed to the brim with your irrelevant focus and inevitable dishonesty.
 
Excellent suggestion Tony!

Oystein you have been given a golden opportunity to back up your 9/11 ‘schtick’.

I’m guessing that given the opportunity to test his claims in a disciplined debate, Oystein will do what he accuses ’truthers’ of doing; ‘running and hiding’.

You should sometimes read my posts, too, with your thinking cap on, and notice all the objections I raise, not least among them the observation that Tony has no feasible debate topic. No point of contention that raises to the level of "claim of fact". He just presents an unsubstantiated opinion.

Waste of time.
 
The falling girder can't break through the next floor down. You saw that with my critique of Nordenson.

Possibly true that.
Najib Abboud made the same obeservation.
But he also told you that there were consecutive floors on fires, rendering the impacted floor below pre-damaged. You did read his WAI report, didn't you?

As David said a few posts up, you commit the call to perfection fallacy. You pretend the circumstances of every micro-detail can be known and computed perfectly.

Perhaps it is true that the floor 13 girder 44-79 could not have knocked out his partner on floor 12. But perhaps their floor 11 partner could have knocked out the floor 10 partner, or the floor 9 beams zipped off the 80-81 girder and then knocked out floor 9.
Or perhaps the damage on the other side of the 79-80-81 row on floor 12 damaged the connections sufficiently to knock through that girder.

We don't know that in perfect detail.
Too bad.
And a major "D'oh".


So what did happen, huh? You saw columns 79-81 collapse ahead of the rest of the core, didn't you? What happened?

You know that 15 years after 9/11, and 10 years into Richard Gage's ministry, 2700 architects and engineers are as clueless as ever and have not even the roughest draft of a competing hypothesis.


Therefore, the "fires made eastern floors collapse" hypothesis stands unassailed.
 
Tony
I asked before. Please start a thread laying out your CD explanation. Let us look at in detail. Any explanation should stand on its own merit.

What will be interesting is to see your evidence on how "they" protected the explosives from the fire for hours.

Seems if it is such a slam dunk case for CD. You can provide the detail report.
 
It should have been called the improbable collapse scenario. That would be generous though as it is actually impossible.

Suppose you have ten canditdate scenarios with 15%, 14%, 13%, 12%, 11%, 9%, 8%, 7%, 6%, 5% probability, respectively.

You see that each has a low probability of being true.
Yet one of them has to be true.

They all share a few common elements (such as "fires damaged floor assemblies"; "floor assemblies suffered cascading collapse"; "left columns 79-81 unbraced"; "total collapse ensued"). They merely differ on the details (which beam went first; did the connection fail in tension, torsiom or compression...).

Now you come along and show that the 15% scenario is actuall only 1%.
The 14% scenario only 2%
The 13% scenario fully impossible.

So what?

You have no other probable scenario - do you?

If in the end God intervenes and lifts the veil and lets you see True History, and you find that actually the 1% scenario was the true one, what's that to you?


tl;dr: It doesn't matter what the ex ante probability value of a scenario is. There is a host of low probability detail explanations on the table that all converge on the big picture: Fires did it.
And you have no competing theory. And you know it. No truther has a competing theory, and no, you can't use the excuse "but that's why we need a new investigation". You KNOW that your "explosives" proto-hypothesis is mortally flawed from the get-go.
 
A proper debatable proposition would be
"WTC 1,2 and 7 collapsed due to controlled demolition”
 
Oh, and one other thing.

While all aboard the train were killed, it was not falsely used to justify wars where upwards of a million innocent people were killed.

Neither, of course, was WTC7; one of the classic truther complaints is that the collapse of WTC7 was subjected to excessive secrecy in news reports about 9/11 and has been hushed up ever since. At the same time, miraculously, it now appears to be the major cause of the War on Terror, as if hijacking four airliners, crashing them and killing nearly three thousand people is merely strong enough to warrant a sternly worded diplomatic note, but the destruction of a building nobody outside New York had ever heard of after it's been evacuated is an outrage that can only be washed away in blood. Again, it's a classic example of obsessing over minor details because the big picture isn't what you want it to be.

Dave
 
It is clear that the self appointed debunkers on this forum are scared to debate one-on-one with someone they claim to disagree with on the causes of the collapses of the three WTC high-rise buildings.

This shows these people can only operate in a group where they can gang up on someone who challenges them and obfuscate that person's points. They are clearly only here in an attempt to maintain a false image that the present official story has some credibility.

What a joke.

Yet here you are, day after day, hurling the same invective to no effect except amusement. Suppose that every single person at ISF really is terrified of debating you one-on-one. What effect does that have on whether a new investigation is conducted? You write the membership here off as unqualified laymen and try to make them feel ashamed both for that and for their supposed cowardice in not accepting your challenge on your terms. If your model of the controversy is true, it would be like a grown man standing on a playground ringed by a bunch of kindergartners and taunting them all for not wanting to fight him. Not even your invective is consistent, nor is it rationally related to your stated cause.

If there are no critics here who are up to your standards, find some elsewhere who are. Write a scholarly paper laying out your claims and theory, get it peer-reviewed by eminent practitioners in the field so there can be no question of its correctness and import, then get it published in one of the flagship journals of the relevant fields, so that no one in the field can have a reasonable excuse for not having seen it and dealt with it in some fashion. If you succeed, you will have a solid foothold from which to lobby for a new investigation, which is what you say you want.

What you say you want, anyway. You can make up whatever reasons you want for no one having accepted your debate terms. Pretend all you want that it's because you're such an indomitable researcher, such an incisive litigant, and such an illustrious professional that everyone is quaking in their boots at the thought of going one-one-one with you. But as you've seen, the membership here seems fairly impervious to that sort of gaslighting. They know that you've been conscpicuously unsuccessful at getting anyone in the real world to pay attention to you, and they rightly conclude it's probably not because everyone else is wrong and you alone are right. And they further conclude that it's more likely you come here not to build support for your theory, but rather to verbally beat up on people you consider beneath you, apparently hoping for some sort of validation. And the membership seems prudently unwilling to indulge you. Good for them.
 
The convention here where multiple posters can chime in against one poster and expect to be answered by that poster is ridiculous.

This is why I am asking individuals to debate one-on-one.

It is puzzling that no one here seems to be willing to do so, since if they think their beliefs in what caused the failures had merit they should be wanting to get those points out in a much more structured and followable situation.
It is clear that the self appointed debunkers on this forum are scared to debate one-on-one with someone they claim to disagree with on the causes of the collapses of the three WTC high-rise buildings.

This shows these people can only operate in a group where they can gang up on someone who challenges them and obfuscate that person's points. They are clearly only here in an attempt to maintain a false image that the present official story has some credibility.

What a joke.
You must have missed my post. I can't imagine any other honest reason for ignoring it so blatantly. Here it is again:

You debate here all the time. I am just asking to do the debate one-on-one to eliminate all of the noise from other posters and allow time for more thoughtful responses.

I am trying to show you and others that the present official story explanations for the collapses of the three WTC high-rises do not withstand scrutiny and in a more serious debating situation that can be done, where on a fast paced forum with a lot of different posters arguments get drowned out.
Really? Let's see how true that is.

I will discuss the matter with you under the following rules:
  1. It's not a debate, it's a forum discussion, just in a dedicated thread where no other posters are allowed.
  2. The forum will be ISF. I don't trust the911forum. It's known for having had people banned on a whim, and for having allowed edition of messages even years after posted. ISF, on the other hand, has a history of not allowing edition of posts past 2 hours, and of reasonably fair moderation.
  3. Since you want to prove that the collapses of 1, 2 and 7 WTC were controlled demolitions (per the 2nd rule of the debate you held with tfk), the title of the thread (and the main topic) will be: Evidence for controlled demolition.
  4. There's no restriction on the topics, even though a somewhat coherent line is expected in accordance with ISF's rule 11.
  5. The post length is unlimited. The number of posts per poster is unlimited. Just like in any other forum discussion.
  6. There's no obligation to respond to any of the points raised by the other.
  7. Breaking ISF's membership agreement rules, in particular rule 0, rule 10 and rule 12, is not allowed.
  8. After 30 days without a response, the discussion is over.
These rules are designed to be pretty much like those in any other forum discussion. If what you said above is true, there should be no problem for you to agree to them.

Are you game?
 
Not so much scared to death of you as annoyed to the brim with your irrelevant focus and inevitable dishonesty.

He doesn't realize that to verify his claims of impossibility, of collapse in any hypothetical theory, he has to quantify the unknowables.
He loses any debate before it begins, he even lost the last debate with TFK, he is just not smart enough to realize that, or he is intentionally ignoring the illogic in his claims.
He can not possibility factor in all the unknowable quantities into his equations in his FEA, therefore his FEA's are self Falsified.
 
​


Excellent suggestion Tony!

Oystein you have been given a golden opportunity to back up your 9/11 ‘schtick’.

I’m guessing that given the opportunity to test his claims in a disciplined debate, Oystein will do what he accuses ’truthers’ of doing; ‘running and hiding’.


Tony doesn't have anything to debate with, which would simply be a waste of time considering that he will continue to push his CD theory, a theory that has been debunked time after time using the laws of physics, facts, evidence and common sense. Even demolition and structural experts have trashed the CD theory.
 
...he will continue to push his CD theory,
Huh??
The only thing that Tony totally avoids even mentioning is this ephemeral "CD theory".

a theory that has been debunked time after time using the laws of physics, facts, evidence and common sense. Even demolition and structural experts have trashed the CD theory.
Which CD theory, pray tell?
I have not seen any CD theory pushed by any truther ever.
None that deserved the title "theory" anyway.
"Vage and timid insinuation, studiously void of any testable detail" is more like it.
I wish Tony would present a concise, comprehensive CD theory. That could be a great debate topic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom