does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

This is called the appeal to perfection, and is a classic staple of the conspiracy theorist. The principle is that, if the official story fails to explain the smallest detail of events, it must be replaced with an alternative theory that explains that small detail but fails to explain the overall majority of events. And that's the game Tony's been playing for the last decade.

Dave

The problems with the present official story are not small and the reports do not explain the collapses.
 
Last edited:
There is presently no study which explains the observations in the collapse of the Tay Bridge, after 140 years. Are we to conclude that that too was demolished using thermite?

Dave

The Tay Bridge failure had a couple of reasons, such as wind loading and oscillations due to vibratory loads. It was essentially a design which was not up to the task like many early bridge designs. It was also not unprecedented for a bridge like that to fail at that time.

While all aboard the train were killed, it was not falsely used to justify wars where upwards of a million innocent people were killed.

Do you want to debate one-on-one Dave?
 
Last edited:
The convention here where multiple posters can chime in against one poster and expect to be answered by that poster is ridiculous.

This is why I am asking individuals to debate one-on-one.

It is puzzling that no one here seems to be willing to do so, since if they think their beliefs in what caused the failures had merit they should be wanting to get those points out in a much more structured and followable situation.
 
There is presently no study which explains the observations in the collapse of WTC 7. Hence, a new investigation is necessary.

There is more than one major detail that has been shown to be wrong in the existing analyses, to the point where the hypotheses themselves are rendered impossible. No amount of babying them will allow them to be viable. Your argument doesn't hack it.

If you are so sure of what you believe you should be willing to debate me one-on-one. Are you?


Why, then, will you not debate a valid premise such as "A new investigation of the events of 9/11 should be performed?" Why do you instead insist on debating only about the NIST report and about unalterable past events that are just a few of many facets relevant to that premise?


This thread has been useful to me in another discussion elsewhere, about differences between effective and ineffective movements. Thanks partly to Tony's efforts, I've noticed one difference that seems very consistent. Advocates within effective movements debate about making the changes that are their goal to make. For example, gay rights advocates who wanted gay marriage legalized were able and willing to debate the premise "gay marriage should be legalized." They didn't limit debate to, for instance, whether the Bible was true or who should be blamed for 19th-century U.S. anti-miscegenation laws. They got to the point.

A contrasting example is the peak oil movement. That movement was united not by a single cause (something they wanted to happen or change) but by a single concern, an anticipated decline in global oil production. They could not be united on preventing peak oil from occurring because part of the basic point of peak oil is that it cannot be prevented. (The anti climate change arm of the environmental movement is gradually sliding toward the same problematic position as atmospheric carbon continues to build up unabated.) Instead, individual members of the movement advocated a diverse variety of post peak oil solutions, from massive alternative energy build-outs to doomsday prepping. Outside their own sites (including here), most peak oil discussion consisted only of "debate" about whether or not peak oil would inevitably happen. That was a trap; such debate leads (and led, in this case) nowhere.

A movement on the bubble is the Creationism movement. What they really want is for Creationism to be taught in schools (and/or for the theory of evolution not to be). But what they usually prefer to debate about is how the world began and how species came to be. Not the same thing! I don't support their cause, but I can tell them if they want changes in the school curriculum, they should be debating about schools and curricula, not about e.g. fossils and Noah's flood. As they focus more and more on the latter, it's a sign (either a cause or an effect or both) of their movement becoming ineffective.


Which brings us back to question in the start of this post. Why, oh, why? Why must Tony debate about the NIST report instead of about the new investigation he claims as his goal?

Is it a case of "searching over there, where the light is better"? That is, he sees the case against NIST as somehow more convincing than the case FOR a new investigation? Is it because a debate about a new investigation would allow for questions he doesn't want to address, such as who should conduct the investigation and under what legal authority would the new investigators compel testimony? Is it because of the ancient prophecy:

First must the NCSTAR fall from the firmament
Slain by words of power from a forum sent
Only then shalt the New Investigation arise
To sunder the evil ones' false flag disguise


…that I just made up? Tony knows, but we never will. It's a mystery deeper than all the historical unknowns of 9/11 put together.
 
The problems with the present official story are not small and their reports do not explain the collapses.

Wrong. The various investigations into the collapse of WTC7 fail to accurately predict the fine details of the collapse while agreeing on the major features. As they are based on modelling where the input values are not and cannot possibly be known, this is unsurprising. And what you falsely present as "the official story" is in itself a minor part of the overall story, which you've chosen to obsess over because you think a single piece of doubt can overturn a mountain of evidence. And this, of course, is why you're so anxious to hold a debate in which the flow of information is so strongly and artificially restricted; by only allowing three pieces of evidence to be presented by each side, for example, you seek to give the impression that the amount of evidence against you is minimal. Your agenda, as always for the conspiracist, is to try and prevent the case against you from being laid out in full, so as to give the suggestion that the minor detail you disagree with is the whole story. It's an attempt to create a false sense of equivalence between your fantasies and reality, and it's fundamentally dishonest. And this is why you'll reject, or at least try to modify, pgimeno's proposed terms; you simply can't risk playing on a level field.

Dave
 
And this, of course, is why you're so anxious to hold a debate in which the flow of information is so strongly and artificially restricted; by only allowing three pieces of evidence to be presented by each side, for example, you seek to give the impression that the amount of evidence against you is minimal. Your agenda, as always for the conspiracist, is to try and prevent the case against you from being laid out in full, so as to give the suggestion that the minor detail you disagree with is the whole story. It's an attempt to create a false sense of equivalence between your fantasies and reality, and it's fundamentally dishonest. And this is why you'll reject, or at least try to modify, pgimeno's proposed terms; you simply can't risk playing on a level field.


It's a mystery deeper than all the historical unknowns of 9/11 put together.


Or maybe not, after all...
 
The Tay Bridge failure had a lot of reasons, such as wind loading, oscillations due to vibratory loads. It was essentially a design which was not up to the task like many early bridge designs. It was also not unprecedented for a bridge like that to fail at that time.

While all aboard the train were killed it was not falsely used to justify wars where upwards of a million innocent people were killed.

Do you want to debate one-on-one Dave?

You have not proven that the collapses of the towers were falsely used to justify warfare Tony!

You are now tied into the entirety of the event not just the collapses of three buildings!
Your expressing Fallacy, and trying to claim intellectual superiorities, none of the buildings
Collapses were not to be expected from the exsream conditions the buildings were subjected too.
Fact is Tony the buildings can not be separated from the total context of that day, and Cole himself though one of his dimwitted videos has debunked one of your hypothetical analysis of the collapse theories.
 
It is clear that the self appointed debunkers on this forum are scared to debate one-on-one with someone they claim to disagree with on the causes of the collapses of the three WTC high-rise buildings.

This shows these people can only operate in a group where they can gang up on someone who challenges them and obfuscate that person's points. They are clearly only here in an attempt to maintain a false image that the present official story has some credibility.

What a joke.
 
It is clear that the self appointed debunkers on this forum are scared to debate one-on-one with someone they claim to disagree with on the causes of the collapses of the three WTC high-rise buildings.

This shows these people can only operate in a group where they can gang up on someone who challenges them and obfuscate that person's points. They are clearly only here in an attempt to maintain a false image that the present official story has some credibility.

What a joke.

Probably just shills for the government. Maybe even employees of NIST. There are more than 5,000 people listed in their directory: https://www.nist.gov/about-nist/our-organization/people?name=&page=1

That's a lot of jobs.
 
Another day, another failure by Tony to substantiate his BS claim that the temperature model used by WAI was "provably" erroneous. About now is the time in these exchanges where Tony will run away for a few weeks. Maybe next he'll do another AMA on the restricted 911truth subreddit where no one will bother to ask him to actually back up his ridiculous claims because they, like he, just want to believe.
 
Last edited:
You are saying that even if a provably non-explanatory report is put out by a government agency, which was funded to explain a catastrophic failure, you think that because no private citizen has come up with what you consider to be a coherent alternative theory that everything is fine.

You really can't be taken seriously. The twisted logic here is astounding and shows why the official WTC collapse explanation supporters on this forum are generally viewed with disdain in most other places on the Internet.

So if I read you correctly what you are saying is that because a government agency produces a report concluding with a Probable Collapse Scenario which is by definition not provable (because no single scenario can be absolutely proven under the circumstances), along with recommendations to prevent future catastrophe's - conclusions all supported by every other, private study - it needs a complete redo?

To achieve what?

More Probable Collapse Scenario's that you can object to because they aren't absolutely provable and don't support your pet cause- a cause which you refuse to support yourself because there is no support for it?

Honestly, why are we even still discussing any of this?!?!?! :confused:
 
You debate here all the time. I am just asking to do the debate one-on-one to eliminate all of the noise from other posters and allow time for more thoughtful responses.

I am trying to show you and others that the present official story explanations for the collapses of the three WTC high-rises do not withstand scrutiny and in a more serious debating situation that can be done, where on a fast paced forum with a lot of different posters arguments get drowned out.

You have been doing that here and elsewhere for years, to seemingly no avail. Why do you want to show me? Do you think I have the ability to grant a new investigation?

You have been quite vocal about tfk leaving the debate. Did you change his mind? I doubt it.
So,
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?
 
Last edited:
It is clear that the self appointed debunkers on this forum are scared to debate one-on-one with someone they claim to disagree with on the causes of the collapses of the three WTC high-rise buildings.

This shows these people can only operate in a group where they can gang up on someone who challenges them and obfuscate that person's points. They are clearly only here in an attempt to maintain a false image that the present official story has some credibility.

What a joke.

The point is Tony you have nothing to debate, you have no valid evidence for CD.
The failure also may not even be shown by one of the three current hypothesis,
It could be a composite failure combining two of the hypothesised failures, or one of the Hypothesis, and another as of yet unknown failure.

There is no evidence for CD, and you can not and never have presented anything.
Some one would need a valid reason to believe that debating you would be of intellectual
Value or interest other than fits of exstream laughter.
 
Let's take a look here. Investigation assistance from:

* Structural Engineering Institute of the American Society of Civil Engineers (SEI/ASCE)

* The Society of Fire Protection Engineers (SFPE)

* The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA)

* The American Institute of Steel Construction (AISC)

* The Council Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat (CTBUH)

* The Structural Engineers Association of New York (SEAoNY).

Tony, how many of these organizations, or others, have you convinced in the decade since you began, that a new investigation is required?
 
It is clear that the self appointed debunkers on this forum are scared to debate one-on-one with someone they claim to disagree with on the causes of the collapses of the three WTC high-rise buildings.

This shows these people can only operate in a group where they can gang up on someone who challenges them and obfuscate that person's points. They are clearly only here in an attempt to maintain a false image that the present official story has some credibility.

What a joke.

Still wanting answers as to why you want this debate. So far though it simply points to you wanting yet another soapbox. There is no other point to such a debate.

It follows the pattern that AE911T uses. It is not a real engineering organization, it is a perpetual speaking tour, funds generation machine. There has been no engineering study or research, no attempt to write, let alone publish a report or study, only weak, recent attempts to sway any true professional organization, in this case, the AIA, by means of yet another speech and a vote ( failed each time).

AE911T and the 911 truth movement in general , is a fringe minority relegated to endless internet discussion and debate, and seemingly with no plan to be anything else.

THAT, TONY, is why your debate is not worth my time, and I suspect the same goes for many others.
 
The problems with the present official story are not small and the reports do not explain the collapses.

They only problem you and your compatriots have been able to uncover in the "official story" is a 1" discrepancy on a drawing.

Tony, I hate to break this to you, but in the real world, 1" is pretty small.

There really is nothing to debate. It settles nothing for anyone. This is no august deliberative body, in a wood panelled room deciding the fate of Mr. George W. Bush, (retired), and Mr. Osama bin Laden (deceased).

This is an obscure forum of a ragtag group of folks who share a desire to approach matters skeptically. Thankfully demonstrated skeptical ability is no condition of membership. So here you are, browbeating us as cowards, because we don't want to play your pointless rigged game, purposefully narrowed in scope by you to your comfort zone.

Wake up.
 
Why is it puzzling? Many have posted on exactly that issue.

Tony was involved in the Microspheres debate, With myself, Steven E. Jones, Dr. Frank Greening and others.

He knows Jones was dishonest and said nothing about that intellectual dishonesty, ever
Jones wanted to use the RJ, Lee report as an average, for all the spheres in all the dust.
The very fact The RJ Lee report was a damage report on the damage on a bank building, where checks, and magnetic credit cards were printed made that a fallacy, not to mention that, the building was exposed to cutting operations with Thermitic brand thermal lances, thermal lances that produce reduce iron Microspheres because they contained Aluminum wires with oxidizing steel.

Tony's known Lack of intellectual honesty is what makes a debate with him useless and meaningless, it would be just like debating Stundie, it would be a useless and pointless endeavor.

Only when Tony addresses and rejects the Intellectual dishonesty of his partners at AE/911 Truth, would I even consider debating him again, and we all know that will never happen!
 
”Again: ALL studies converge on all the relevant results: Fires affected the long span floor bays around 79-81, made them collapse, and that triggered the global collapse.

It's only you unsubstantiated OPINION that these details are "major".
”If you are so sure of what you believe you should be willing to debate me one-on-one.

Are you?
”

Excellent suggestion Tony!

Oystein you have been given a golden opportunity to back up your 9/11 ‘schtick’.

I’m guessing that given the opportunity to test his claims in a disciplined debate, Oystein will do what he accuses ’truthers’ of doing; ‘running and hiding’.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom