does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Come on, Tony, tell us the answer to these questions.

You debate here all the time. I am just asking to do the debate one-on-one to eliminate all of the noise from other posters and allow time for more thoughtful responses.

I am trying to show you and others that the present official story explanations for the collapses of the three WTC high-rises do not withstand scrutiny and in a more serious debating situation that can be done, where on a fast paced forum with a lot of different posters arguments get drowned out.
 
I am saying we need a new investigation that does replicate and explain the observations.

You obviously can't name one that has and thus are forced to agree.

Any New investigation would only be another hypothetical theory, these were never before seen event fires like these have never before occurred in the history of mankind.
 
You debate here all the time. I am just asking to do the debate one-on-one to eliminate all of the noise from other posters and allow time for more thoughtful responses.

I am trying to show you and others that the present official story explanations for the collapses of the three WTC high-rises do not withstand scrutiny and in a more serious debating situation that can be done, where on a fast paced forum with a lot of different posters arguments get drowned out.

That's because all the simulations are too conservative on the fires and effect.
 
Actually they haven't. You are just saying they have. There is no published analysis purporting to explain the collapse of WTC 7 that is consistent with observation.

It's all very simple. We have evidence that fires raged out of control for hours and we know that temperatures were high enough to weaken structural steel. What we don't have evidence for is that the destruction of WTC7 involved explosives, thermite, or nano-thermite, but it would have been impossible to pre-weaken its steel structural, which is required, and wire WTC7 with explosives in secrecy anyway.
 
Last edited:
I am saying we need a new investigation that does replicate and explain the observations.



It is a waste of time considering that it has been determined that fire, in conjunction with impact damage, was responsible for the collapse of the WTC buildings, and it has been determined that the collapse of those buildings had nothing to do with CD.
 
Actually they haven't. You are just saying they have. .

Let's take a look here. Investigation assistance from:

* Structural Engineering Institute of the American Society of Civil Engineers (SEI/ASCE)

* The Society of Fire Protection Engineers (SFPE)

* The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA)

* The American Institute of Steel Construction (AISC)

* The Council Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat (CTBUH)

* The Structural Engineers Association of New York (SEAoNY).
 
Last edited:
bahahaha!!!!!! The thought of a formal, moderated debate is terrifying to the average neo-skeptic. For the most part, very few, if any neo-skeptic people, on this site have at least a B.A. in formal logic(nor do most other regular people).



p.s. I haven't read past this post so if I'm wrong to any degree, which I will be the judge of, I will openly stand corrected.

Interesting. I did a quick google of this, and couldn't find a single university offering such a thing.
I'd like to add my voice to those asking if you have such a qualification, and, if so, where you obtained it. I'd also like to know if Tony Szamboti has one and, if not, whether you consider him qualified to engage in this debate.
 
...the official WTC collapse explanation supporters on this forum are generally viewed with disdain in most other places on the Internet ...

Add: "... that I, T.Sz., allow into my personal filter bubble; not in the real world though".
Then we can agree :)
 
... I am just asking to do the debate one-on-one ...

You really haven't made a stringent point that you wish to debate.

We understand that you think there is something wrong in the NIST report, that you disagree with their "probable" collapse sequence.
That's an average "D'oh".

I think every smart person here agrees that there is something wrong in the NIST report.
I think most smart persons here will agree that the word "probable" introduces the idea that possibly, the probable collapse sequence is not the actual one.
Which is a lame "D'uh".
The smart ones here understand easily that it is difficult, and quite probably impossible, to know with certainty just how and where the collapse initiated. However, all the scholarly work done so far converges on a few common conclusions, such as
  • Long beam spans can cause problems when subject to unusual fires on a scale that previously had not been taken into account sufficiently
  • It is almost certain that failure of a floor system somewhere in the eastern lower 14 stories triggered the global collapse
  • Loss of lateral support for columns 79-81 over enough stories will lead to global collapse
  • Fires raged through at least six of the candidate floor areas
  • It is certain beyond reasonable doubt that these multifloors fires damaged the floors enough to trigger the collapse
You'd need to explain why you think that refuting one detail in one of the reports that have been done changes these facts one bit.

We all know that you are married by religious faith to the silly idea that there were huge explosive charges on all the core columns somewhere in the middle of the raging fires that magically survived the heat (Danny Jowenko explained ten years ago that demolition charges cannot survive fires) and then magically exploded without sound, magically leaving no cut marks on the steel. You don't fool us. You know that we know that this IS your hypothesis, and that it is spectacularly at odds with observed reality, and unsupported by any study whatsoever.
 
You really haven't made a stringent point that you wish to debate.

We understand that you think there is something wrong in the NIST report, that you disagree with their "probable" collapse sequence.
That's an average "D'oh".

I think every smart person here agrees that there is something wrong in the NIST report.
I think most smart persons here will agree that the word "probable" introduces the idea that possibly, the probable collapse sequence is not the actual one.
Which is a lame "D'uh".
The smart ones here understand easily that it is difficult, and quite probably impossible, to know with certainty just how and where the collapse initiated. However, all the scholarly work done so far converges on a few common conclusions, such as
  • Long beam spans can cause problems when subject to unusual fires on a scale that previously had not been taken into account sufficiently
  • It is almost certain that failure of a floor system somewhere in the eastern lower 14 stories triggered the global collapse
  • Loss of lateral support for columns 79-81 over enough stories will lead to global collapse
  • Fires raged through at least six of the candidate floor areas
  • It is certain beyond reasonable doubt that these multifloors fires damaged the floors enough to trigger the collapse
You'd need to explain why you think that refuting one detail in one of the reports that have been done changes these facts one bit.

We all know that you are married by religious faith to the silly idea that there were huge explosive charges on all the core columns somewhere in the middle of the raging fires that magically survived the heat (Danny Jowenko explained ten years ago that demolition charges cannot survive fires) and then magically exploded without sound, magically leaving no cut marks on the steel. You don't fool us. You know that we know that this IS your hypothesis, and that it is spectacularly at odds with observed reality, and unsupported by any study whatsoever.

There is presently no study which explains the observations in the collapse of WTC 7. Hence, a new investigation is necessary.

There is more than one major detail that has been shown to be wrong in the existing analyses, to the point where the hypotheses themselves are rendered impossible. No amount of babying them will allow them to be viable. Your argument doesn't hack it.

If you are so sure of what you believe you should be willing to debate me one-on-one. Are you?
 
Last edited:
There is presently no study which explains the observations in the collapse of WTC 7. Hence, a new investigation is necessary.
Again: ALL studies converge on all the relevant results: Fires affected the long span floor bays around 79-81, made them collapse, and that triggered the global collapse.

There is more than one major detail that has been shown to be wrong/impossible in the existing analyses to the point where the hypotheses themselves are rendered impossible. No amount of babying them will allow them to be viable. Your argument doesn't hack it.
It's only you unsubstantiated OPINION that these details are "major".
 
Again: ALL studies converge on all the relevant results: Fires affected the long span floor bays around 79-81, made them collapse, and that triggered the global collapse.


It's only you unsubstantiated OPINION that these details are "major".

Not being able to unseat a girder and not being able to break through the next floor down are most certainly major details.

Do you want to debate one-on-one? We can then explore these notions on both sides in a much more rigorous and serious way than what is possible here.

It is not reasonable to have to answer multiple posters (who can interject at any time) in a debate and that is why I prefer the one-on-one situation. It will not take up any more of your time than what you spend here, as there will be ample time to answer. What do you say?
 
Last edited:
You are saying that even if a provably non-explanatory report is put out by a government agency, which was funded to explain a catastrophic failure, you think that because no private citizen has come up with what you consider to be a coherent alternative theory that everything is fine.

No, I'm not. But I'm sure you'll continue to pretend I am.

Dave
 
I am saying we need a new investigation that does replicate and explain the observations.

This is called the appeal to perfection, and is a classic staple of the conspiracy theorist. The principle is that, if the official story fails to explain the smallest detail of events, it must be replaced with an alternative theory that explains that small detail but fails to explain the overall majority of events. And that's the game Tony's been playing for the last decade.

Dave
 
There is presently no study which explains the observations in the collapse of WTC 7. Hence, a new investigation is necessary.

There is presently no study which explains the observations in the collapse of the Tay Bridge, after 140 years. Are we to conclude that that too was demolished using thermite?

Dave
 
Do you want to debate one-on-one? We can then explore these notions on both sides in a much more rigorous and serious way than what is possible here.

Since it's been pointed out a couple of pages back that you won't even follow the rules you've set yourself for such a debate, I can't see why anyone would bother. You've already failed the first and simplest test of integrity.

Dave
 
Not being able to unseat a girder and not being able to break through the next floor down are most certainly major details.

Do you want to debate one-on-one? We can then explore these notions on both sides in a much more rigorous and serious way than what is possible here.

It is not reasonable to have to answer multiple posters (who can interject at any time) in a debate and that is why I prefer the one-on-one situation. It will not take up any more of your time than what you spend here, as there will be ample time to answer. What do you say?

What about the glaring obvious flaws in your analysis of the work done by others?

Change the fire dynamic, and collapse is assured, in all three case studies.

Your analysis have not proven even one of the collapse studies impossible.

Unlikely perhaps, not impossible, the fact you even use the word is very telling Tony,
an honest researcher wouldn't use it.
 
You debate here all the time. I am just asking to do the debate one-on-one to eliminate all of the noise from other posters and allow time for more thoughtful responses.

I am trying to show you and others that the present official story explanations for the collapses of the three WTC high-rises do not withstand scrutiny and in a more serious debating situation that can be done, where on a fast paced forum with a lot of different posters arguments get drowned out.
Really? Let's see how true that is.

I will discuss the matter with you under the following rules:
  1. It's not a debate, it's a forum discussion, just in a dedicated thread where no other posters are allowed.
  2. The forum will be ISF. I don't trust the911forum. It's known for having had people banned on a whim, and for having allowed edition of messages even years after posted. ISF, on the other hand, has a history of not allowing edition of posts past 2 hours, and of reasonably fair moderation.
  3. Since you want to prove that the collapses of 1, 2 and 7 WTC were controlled demolitions (per the 2nd rule of the debate you held with tfk), the title of the thread (and the main topic) will be: Evidence for controlled demolition.
  4. There's no restriction on the topics, even though a somewhat coherent line is expected in accordance with ISF's rule 11.
  5. The post length is unlimited. The number of posts per poster is unlimited. Just like in any other forum discussion.
  6. There's no obligation to respond to any of the points raised by the other.
  7. Breaking ISF's membership agreement rules, in particular rule 0, rule 10 and rule 12, is not allowed.
  8. After 30 days without a response, the discussion is over.
These rules are designed to be pretty much like those in any other forum discussion. If what you said above is true, there should be no problem for you to agree to them.

Are you game?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom