Merged Discussion of femr's video data analysis


Thanks, but now I can see them. I think it was a Mac graphics card memory problem, as my laptop had been running Folding @ Home for a couple of weeks straight.
 
Like you did for the SG filter? Never? Googled it up, and used it. For the aircraft you have left out a lot of stuff too. Lots of flying stuff. You need to get more dirty into the flying stuff; which you have not. Not surprising since you think failed 911 fringe nut papers are technical. You can't debunk the failed papers; what does this data debunk? Which failed 911 truth claim does this lay to rest? An attack on NIST, or what? Where did the engine land?

The hard part starts at impact. The scary dynamics start at impact, and what will be done past impact? Why are you obsessed with NIST? What angle would make a difference in the impact area; where is the plane going?

We obviously need to know the arrangement of the deck chairs on the Titanic to understand the sinking.:covereyes
 
We obviously need to know the arrangement of the deck chairs on the Titanic to understand the sinking.:covereyes
If you and beachnut want that data - give femr the video footage which shows the deckchairs being moved. He can probably measure the movement of deckchairs better than NIST or D Chandler.

Personally I doubt your hypothesis that deck chairs were a critical feature but that is your call - femr only provides the measurement service. And remember that the focus of this thread is on measuring movement - not statics. See the disputation over aircraft movement in recent posts.

So it would have to be movement of deckchairs which either:
1) Caused the ship to tilt >>>keel over>>>sink; OR
2) Moving the deckchairs - en masse relocation - somehow attracts icebergs.

;)
 
Last edited:
Just taking a leaf out of your book.
It appears you agree that your assertion "that's what a 3-4° turn looks like" is baseless, not to mention the fact that the radar based ground angle change is around 1.5 degrees, not "3 to 4".

I mentioned numerous of your values, all were shoddy, none have been rectified or even admitted to be shoddy. Pfft.

Scale models are already to scale
Totally dependant upon rendering environment.

I did apply the correct dihedral and flex of a wing in flight.
How, and what angle ?

Thrown together yes
That's obvious, as I said.

it took longer to calculate the positions
You've shown repeatedly that you are incapable of accurately performing even simple measurements. You should use the satellite imagery as a plane within your rendering environment. That allows you to provide visual confirmation of absolute object placement, orientation and relative placement.

and set up models than it did to make them
Make them ? :eek: You have one stock aircraft model, and two "boxes", even though I've already provided you with these models...
936648138.png


You may think your efforts are far superior
I know they are ;)

they're not far superior if they consistently show the wrong angle
I'm quite happy with the accuracy of my values.

Are you going to get even one measurement done accurately any time soon ?

If you wish to verify my angles all you have to do is create your own scale model. You have all the information you need to do so.
Grow up.

Oh, but I am.
The satellite imagery is not a part of your scene.

There are only three to remember. With a tube passing through the length of the fuselage the model can be placed over a rod protruding from the scale building. That rod can be accurately positioned to achieve the specified pitch and yaw angles and the model can then be rotated on the rod to get the desired roll angle. Unlike your "superior model" mine is actually at 12° when I set it to 12°. If the plan views you provided are anything to go by your models are at least 2° over the specified values.
As I said, ... oh dear.

When you don't understand something, stop and ask.

You are clearly clueless about the difference between object and world coordinate systems.

My plan views were provided to you so you didn't make such stupid mistakes.

On a plan view the horizontal angle between aircraft and tower is ABSOLUTELY not the same as the horizontal angle applied to the aircraft model, as the aircraft model has modifiers applied to all thee axes.

Just STOP until you get that simplest of factoids into your head.

They're not renders, they're real world models
The ONLY way you can't be wrong is if you've made cardboard models, which would be hilarious...especially getting the camera the right distance away.

If you haven't "made my day" by getting sticky tape out, no, they are renders.

Please, please say the towers are cardboard boxes :)

Secondary buildings are only needed to accurately locate the camera position.
Incorrect. Secondary buildings are required to verify numerous factors which include lens FOV, camera elevation relative to tower and aircraft, ...

When you don't know what you are talking about, don't make it up.

Since we know that position it's not essential that they're there.
Incorrect. See above.

I haven't attempted rotoscoping yet. Figured I'd do a quick physical model to double check first.
Please, please say you've made that out of cardboard...

I have no reason to fabricate results
You've clearly had an open and blatant agenta of attempt (and fail) to "prove femr2 wrong version the umpteenth".

You've stumbled from one "gotcha", been proven wrong, stumbled to the next, been proved wrong, ... many times.

This is no different.

I'm merely checking the alternative values against reality. It's not my fault that your values don't match.
ROFL. You'll get there eventually, once you actually get to grips with what you are trying to do.

IF (and it's a big if in my book)... IF you're actually trying to do "this thing" properly and accurately...you'll end up clearly showing the NIST impact orientation is out of whack.

Nothing has been adjusted to make NIST correct and you wrong. Positions are worked out, the camera is set and the chips fall where they may. As I said, if you want to check you're more than welcome to do your own model to verify.
ROFL. Again, grow up. You've seen the results of me "doing my own model" many times.

Tada...

938786605.gif


Actually you haven't explained it, merely asserted it.
Incorrect. Re-read our discussion. You bore me. When you deny such again, I'll spend the extra 30s it takes to refute you.

Seems fairly straightforward to me. Two images of the same aircraft in the same orientation, one with the camera at ground level, one with the camera at the same level as the aircraft. Building width is matched and the aircraft length matches. You can check this yourself by raising the camera and doing a render in your 3d environment if you want. Viewer elevation makes no difference, that's why the 2d check works.
It does not work. Deary me.

You cannot treat features on separate planes as if they are coincident.

Your method is fatally flawed, as I have previously explained to you.


To "others": Can you "imagine" the number of "laughing dogs" that would emerge if I started making such dumb-derrier assertions about basic three dimensional geometry ?

You first.
Please, please tell me you made your "physical models" out of cardboard.

:blush:
 
Oh, and before I forget...

Could you please explain to me WHY this image has the overlaid "model" with an angled section "missing" at the top, and this image does not ?

Says a lot to me tha' :(
 
Thanks pgimeno - I had forgotten that SanderO had bravely entered these portals in recent months.

Also IIRC Achimspok and possibly enik have been subjected to the same sort of misapplied attention further back in history.

However can you find an example where anyone presumed to be on the "debunker" side has been subject to the same sort of nonsense?
 
However can you find an example where anyone presumed to be on the "debunker" side has been subject to the same sort of nonsense?
I'm actually having a hard time finding a technical thread opened by someone presumed to be on that side, and dedicated to something not related to any conspiracy theory. The one opened by JSanderO wasn't related to any, as I noted.

I am of the opinion that this one is in the correct forum, by the way, even if very marginally.
 
I'm actually having a hard time finding a technical thread opened by someone presumed to be on that side, and dedicated to something not related to any conspiracy theory. The one opened by JSanderO wasn't related to any, as I noted....
Yes you were correct on that example - My apology for giving the generic response without explaining what I was doing or addressing your correct specific example.

Posting "off topic" was a feature of many of Sander's posts - he gets away with lack of "on topic" discipline on another forum as we probably are both aware. It isn't tolerated to the same degree here. In fact I cautioned him several times in open posts and PMs to try to stick to "on topic". Most of his claims fall into "middle ground" and genuine scepticism which, like femrs comments in this thread, is no protection against some counter claims based on a presumption of "truther".
...I am of the opinion that this one is in the correct forum, by the way, even if very marginally.
My view is based on a more absolute attitude towards forum policy...but we are in agreement on "it belongs here".
 
Oh, and before I forget...

Could you please explain to me WHY this image has the overlaid "model" with an angled section "missing" at the top, and this image does not ?

Says a lot to me tha' :(

Because the background was removed for clarity and the image rotated to match the scene resulting in the front layer having a missing top. Since it doesn't have any impact on the scene there was no point filling it in.

Totally dependant upon rendering environment.


How about reality


How, and what angle ?


Glue and weights during construction to match the NIST diagram.




So it's ok for you to demand exact recreation of your work in order to check it but it's childish if I ask the same of you?


When you don't understand something, stop and ask.

You are clearly clueless about the difference between object and world coordinate systems.

My plan views were provided to you so you didn't make such stupid mistakes.

On a plan view the horizontal angle between aircraft and tower is ABSOLUTELY not the same as the horizontal angle applied to the aircraft model, as the aircraft model has modifiers applied to all thee axes.

Just STOP until you get that simplest of factoids into your head.


The trouble with factoids is they're not always correct. Your assertion that adjusting the pitch angle of the fuselage centreline affects the yaw angle (and vice versa) is incorrect. If you can't adjust one without affecting the other you may need to adjust your methods or labeling. Saying the aircraft inpact angle is 13° and then using 15° could be seen as dishonesty.


The ONLY way you can't be wrong is if you've made cardboard models, which would be hilarious...especially getting the camera the right distance away.

If you haven't "made my day" by getting sticky tape out, no, they are renders.

Please, please say the towers are cardboard boxes :)


Glad to know I'm not wrong, they were plywood actually. What part of physical model don't you understand?


You've clearly had an open and blatant agenta of attempt (and fail) to "prove femr2 wrong version the umpteenth".



Why would I need you to be wrong. You presented data that was grossly different to all other studies which piqued my curiosity. Upon checking, your figures seem to be incorrect. It's like if someone said there was a pod under the plane, you'd want to make them aware of their mistake.

IF (and it's a big if in my book)... IF you're actually trying to do "this thing" properly and accurately...you'll end up clearly showing the NIST impact orientation is out of whack.


From what I've seen so far I seriously doubt that.



It does not work. Deary me.

You cannot treat features on separate planes as if they are coincident.

Your method is fatally flawed, as I have previously explained to you.


As you have previously asserted you mean.
 
Last edited:
Just for completeness, here's what's probably going on with the virtual model. With the WTC buildings aligned at around 31° and positioning of the aircraft effectively giving them about 2° more angle than specified when Femr2 is comparing a 13° orientation to a 3.5° orientation he's effectively comparing a 17° with a 7.5° orientation. A quick check against his render shows,

femr17vs75overlay_zps0473bc15.jpg


a fairly close match to those values.
 
The trouble with factoids is they're not always correct. Your assertion that adjusting the pitch angle of the fuselage centreline affects the yaw angle (and vice versa) is incorrect. If you can't adjust one without affecting the other you may need to adjust your methods or labeling.

Not sure I'm following all the back and forth, but here's my take.

Point a pen at your computer screen so that the tip touches at column x2, and the back of the pen appears to be at column x1 < x2.

Using the pen's frame of reference, change the pitch. The back of the pen no longer appears to be at x1.

Return to the original orientation, then change the yaw. The back of the pen no longer appears to be at x1.

So, you can change the pitch without changing the yaw, or vice versa, but to move the back of the pen "vertically," you need to change both simultaneously.
 
:jaw-dropp

On down the rabbit hole we go...

Because the background was removed for clarity
Why is the cropping for NIST different to that for femr2 ?

The camera should be in exactly the same place.

Was the camera in exactly the same place for both ?

and the image rotated to match the scene
:jaw-dropp

There should be no manipulation of the "through camera" view required to match the "real world". That's the bleedin' point.

Since it doesn't have any impact on the scene there was no point filling it in.
You clearly haven't oriented your camera correctly.

How about reality
Oh my days. You have gotten the sticky-tape out.

:jaw-dropp

Glue and weights during construction to match the NIST diagram.
None of your aircraft images look "real". Please provide an image of your aircraft kit model, and explain how you oriented it accurately.

So it's ok for you to demand exact recreation of your work in order to check it but it's childish if I ask the same of you?
I haven't demanded any such thing.

If you say "X" is wrong using a fatally flawed method, I'll suggest you use a better method.

By far the easiest route is to use a 3D modeling environment.

Your physical model cannot be independently verified, for a start.

I have built the full scene. As I said, I'll get around to digging the box it's on out of the piling system.

You are being exceedingly childish.

The trouble with factoids is they're not always correct.
Deary me. Your problem is simply that you don't understand.

Your assertion that adjusting the pitch angle of the fuselage centreline affects the yaw angle (and vice versa) is incorrect.
Jebus. I made no such assertion. What I'm trying to get into your skull is that you clearly don't understand the difference between "world space" and "object space"...nor the effect of local coordinate systems.

The simplest of examples...

1) Bank an aicraft model 90 degrees "left".
2) Increase vertical aircraft fuselage orientation.

In what direction does the tail of the aircraft move from your perspective ?

Up, down, left or right ? :(

Your answer really should make something "sink in". If it doesn't, or you get it wrong... :eye-poppi

If you can't adjust one without affecting the other you may need to adjust your methods or labeling.
That you have such a basic lack of understanding is ridiculous.

Saying the aircraft inpact angle is 13° and then using 15° could be seen as dishonesty.
When you don't understand...ask.

Otherwise you end up making a complete phallus of yourself, repeatedly.

Glad to know I'm not wrong
You have made my day. Hilarious.

they were plywood actually
Wonderful :D

What is the actual physical width of one of your tower boxes ?

What part of physical model don't you understand?
I understand completely, I simply cannot believe that you've actually chosen to do such. Mind boggling.

Why would I need you to be wrong.
Because you want NIST to be right.

You presented data that was grossly different to all other studies
Incorrect.

Upon checking, your figures seem to be incorrect.
You have shown repeatedly that you are incapable of presenting valide critique. Your wandering and varying assertions are getting more and more ludicrous.

From what I've seen so far I seriously doubt that.
Nevertheless, when you finally sort your act out, you'll get there.

As you have previously asserted you mean.
No, as I have explained. It appears you simply are incapable of understanding.

Hint: Project a point on the tail of the aircraft onto the plane of the South face of WTC2. Use the Hezarkhani footage. Basic 3D geometry.

Your method is severely flawed.

"Stop digging the hole deeper" is my suggestion to you.
 
Just for completeness
You mean... just to add additional random numbers to the other random numers I (Reactor Drone) have asserted before, which is hilarious, as if I had any competency I'd have only ever had one set of numbers, not wandering and varying sets of numbers... :)

here's what's probably going on with the virtual model
You mean... I, Reactor Drone, don't have a clue what I'm talking about, so I'll cover my arse with a "probably". If fact, as I've already been told about the orientation of the towers in femr2's model many times, I already know what I'm about to say is utter nonsense... :)

With the WTC buildings aligned at around 31°
You mean... I (Reactor Drone) already know that femr2's tower models are not set to 31 degrees, but I'm a blatantly dishonest so-and-so, so who cares... :)

giving them about 2° more angle than specified when Femr2 is comparing a 13° orientation to a 3.5° orientation he's effectively comparing a 17° with a 7.5° orientation
You mean... I (Reactor Drone) wonder what happens if I try some sums...13+2=17, tick. 3.5+2=7.5, tick. Oh what a clever boy I am, especially as I have already been told many times about how femr2's tower models were oriented and how that affects my silly assertions.

A quick check against his render shows
Need a face-palm image.

Your method is fatally flawed.

You also still don't understand object coordinate systems.

You can post as many of these ridiculous images as you please, each with a different set of numbers on them. You achieve ZERO.

There are a small handful of folk participating within this thread, and you're not bathing in sunshine I'm afraid.

I suggest you have a long think about it. A summary of your performance over the last few weeks is likely to emerge if you don't start learning.
 
You bore me.
femr2, as of this writing, has 1104 posts in this thread. I'd love to see the output if he wasn't so bored he could barely stay awake.




Or as someone else noted earlier:

It doesn't seem femr2 is bored.
It sounds like he's sitting on a hot stove while typing.


Need a face-palm image.
Google search is usually good for stuff like this.

facepalmkitty.gif
 
Not sure I'm following all the back and forth, but here's my take.

Point a pen at your computer screen so that the tip touches at column x2, and the back of the pen appears to be at column x1 < x2.

Using the pen's frame of reference, change the pitch. The back of the pen no longer appears to be at x1.

Return to the original orientation, then change the yaw. The back of the pen no longer appears to be at x1.

So, you can change the pitch without changing the yaw, or vice versa, but to move the back of the pen "vertically," you need to change both simultaneously.

Femr is using a 13° yaw figure for his NIST orientation. If you place the centreline of the aircraft at the impact point and rotate the fuselage in the x plane until you hit 13° and then move the centreline of the fuselage up in the y plane to get the 6° pitch angle the yaw angle doesnt change when viewed from above (unless you place your camera close and still have perspective view on which you obviously wouldn't to get a true plan view). As can be clearly seen the top of the fuselage (which is parallel to the aircraft centreline) should match a 13° line. Rotation of the fuselage will similarly have no effect on on perceived yaw angle when viewed from directly above.

orientationplanview_zpsff97b988.jpg
 
Last edited:
:jaw-dropp

Why is the cropping for NIST different to that for femr2 ?

Because they're different images

The camera should be in exactly the same place.


Was the camera in exactly the same place for both ?


Within an inch (or 5 scale metres) which, as you say in your draft, has little effect on the scene.



:jaw-dropp

There should be no manipulation of the "through camera" view required to match the "real world". That's the bleedin' point.


You clearly haven't oriented your camera correctly.


You think rotation of the camera body changes the scene?




Oh my days. You have gotten the sticky-tape out.

:jaw-dropp



None of your aircraft images look "real". Please provide an image of your aircraft kit model, and explain how you oriented it accurately.


They are real so you already have images of the model from several angles. I have already explained how it was oriented accurately


I haven't demanded any such thing.

If you say "X" is wrong using a fatally flawed method, I'll suggest you use a better method.

By far the easiest route is to use a 3D modeling environment.


As a sculptor and modeller it's actually far easier for me to make a physical mock up of the scene.

Your physical model cannot be independently verified, for a start.


Sure it can, the same way your virtual model can be. You know the layout and scale, it's easily done. At 1/200 th scale the towers are 317mm wide.
 
Femr is using a 13° yaw figure for his NIST orientation...
Correct.

The rest of your post is simply further demonstration that you don't understand.

I asked you a very simple question to try and help you without mocking you too much (which you chose to ignore in your continuing cherry-picking in responses)...

The simplest of examples...

1) Bank an aicraft model 90 degrees "left".
2) Increase vertical aircraft fuselage orientation.

In what direction does the tail of the aircraft move from your perspective ?

Up, down, left or right ?


Your answer really should make something "sink in". If it doesn't, or you get it wrong...

Answer the question, and get it right. You're going to great lengths to dig yourself a hole. I keep local copies of discussion images, so deleting them your end later doesn't erase them from existence.

Also, as you obviously don't understand, and you're completely deaf to any advice, perhaps you'd care to measure (accurately!) a pertinent angle from your revered NIST...



Have fun. Stop digging the hole deeper.
 
Because they're different images
Please provide both without overlay/transparency.

Within an inch (or 5 scale metres) which, as you say in your draft, has little effect on the scene.
Ooh, numbers.

So your camera is about 19.5ft away, yes ?

And your towers are nearly 7ft tall, yes ?

Your towers are not both exactly the same height are they ?

Your camera lens is way less than an inch from "ground", yes ?

What lens and lens settings were used ?

(It's possible to check whether photos were taken from specific distance with known lens details btw)

You think rotation of the camera body changes the scene?
About what axis ?

The view from the camera should match the real-world viewpoint without manipulation.

They are real so you already have images of the model from several angles.
It is not possible to see the model clearly in your images. It looks like a cut and paste copy of a rendered transparent virtual model.

Please provide a clear photo of your aircraft model.

I have already explained how it was oriented accurately
Where ? Quote please.

As a sculptor and modeller it's actually far easier for me to make a physical mock up of the scene.
You introduce many error sources in the process I'm afraid.

Sure it can, the same way your virtual model can be.
Given that you have "removed the background" from your images, I very much doubt you will provide images suitable for verifying your layout.

You know the layout and scale, it's easily done.
I've shown you the rendered result...a number of times.

At 1/200 th scale the towers are 317mm wide.
Slightly over, but "good enough".

So 5m : 2.5cm / 0.984251969 inches.

So your camera is about 19' 3" away (from NW corner of WTC1), yes ?

And your towers are about 6' 9.5" tall, yes ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom