Merged Discussion of femr's video data analysis

femr2:

I see there are two similar views of the WTC7 collapse from the distance, but you used just one. Is the other one of lower quality? (CBS-Net Dub5 24 and CBS-Net Dub6 48). It looks slightly higher quality to me.

Also, can you tell me what file name in the Cumulus database does the Dan Rather video you used have?
 
Ba-doing :)...
I first met that one in 2007-8 and spent many hours/words trying to explain to the model builder the related physics and the fact that the twins did not collapse from harmonic resonance effects of the initial impact etc etc....

Perhaps it would be useful to trace subsequent oscillations...
[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/_ph/2/468976343.png[/qimg]
...which can be done spectacularly acurately using the sub-pixel methods and procedures previously discussed. Indeed with a much lower noise level than even the NIST moire method, as also previously demonstrated.,,,
"Useful" to who, for what purpose - just to remind us of those unaddressed questions. :D And that you cannot claim that errors are too big until you say "for what?" :mad:
I'm joking about tracing the ba-doing, of course. You can never be too sure roun'ere :)
The prognosis would be predictable. Someone asks you for the data for whatever reasons they want it. You oblige by doing the work. Then you get accused of counting angels on the head of a pin. (No I don't want to know. ;) - 17.27 is near enough for me. ;)) I do recall commenting once that if there was interest in the angels on head of pin project:
1) it is off topic here: AND
2) there are a couple of organisations that may be interested in funding or joint venturing the research. One organisation head-quartered near Rome, the other HQ in Canterbury England.

The number of people who do not comprehend the origins and purpose of this thread is astonishing. And very revealing. 2230 hrs here so it is dark outside.
 
I see there are two similar views of the WTC7 collapse from the distance
Crikey, it didn't take long for the "topic" to migrate back over to WTC7 :eye-poppi

but you used just one
I've traced numerous.

Is the other one of lower quality? (CBS-Net Dub5 24 and CBS-Net Dub6 48). It looks slightly higher quality to me.
I'd have to dig them out, but...

Why ?

I have "been there and done that" a long time ago. I'm unlikely to be wasting much of my time performing additional traces for WTC 7. I already have multiple datasets more than accurate enough to serve my purposes.

Also, can you tell me what file name in the Cumulus database does the Dan Rather video you used have?
'Fraid not. If you grab a thumbnail db file viewer, you can download the entire thumbnail list (without downloading the entire video data) and have a peruse to find the right view.
 
Crikey, it didn't take long for the "topic" to migrate back over to WTC7 :eye-poppi

Funny thing is, I don't really think you and NIST are that far apart on the whole "trajectory" thing.

I've been reading you're work (along with achimspok's). And it looks more like confusion of terms.

I haven't got time now but, I might comment further at a later date.
 
Funny thing is, I don't really think you and NIST are that far apart on the whole "trajectory" thing.
My trajectory follows the orientation.

The NIST trajectory is 13 degrees clockwise from structure North.

My trajectory is 6 degrees clockwise from structure north.


Quite a difference.

I've been reading you're work (along with achimspok's). And it looks more like confusion of terms.
Trajectory hasn't been discussed much at all. There's never been any confusion about the NIST trajectory, nor the reasons why they set it to 13 degrees...which as I said, was not a great idea.
 
My trajectory follows the orientation.

Something I doubt is accurate. Yaw and pitch are more of a factor than you consider (IMHO).

The NIST trajectory is 13 degrees clockwise from structure North.

My trajectory is 6 degrees clockwise from structure north.


Quite a difference.

Your trajectory ignores yaw and pitch. If you disagree, your first statement can not be true.
Trajectory hasn't been discussed much at all. There's never been any confusion about the NIST trajectory, nor the reasons why they set it to 13 degrees...which as I said, was not a great idea.

If I remember they claimed a trajectory of 15 degrees +/- 2. I think they used this figure to simplify the damage and create a lower bound. Something they should do in this case.
 
Something I doubt is accurate.
Which you base upon a handwave. I've looked in detail at aircraft behaviour during impact. Unsubstantiated doubt is irrelevant. Far too much of that around here.

Yaw and pitch are more of a factor than you consider (IMHO).
Again a blank handwave. More than you (for no good reason) think I consider IMNSHO.

Your trajectory ignores yaw and pitch.
No, it doesn't.

If you disagree, your first statement can not be true.
Incorrect.

If I remember they claimed a trajectory of 15 degrees +/- 2. I think they used this figure to simplify the damage and create a lower bound.
You don't remember correctly.
 
Crikey, it didn't take long for the "topic" to migrate back over to WTC7 :eye-poppi
This is unrelated. I'm still looking into the WTC7 3D analysis. Progress is slow though; I'm still finding the videos.


I've traced numerous.
I'm asking specifically about two with a quite similar view, Dan Rather and the ones I specified (which seem to be the same video, I don't know what the difference is yet).


Is the other one of lower quality? (CBS-Net Dub5 24 and CBS-Net Dub6 48). It looks slightly higher quality to me.
I'd have to dig them out, but...

Why ?
Why what? If the question is why I am asking, the answer is because I want to have a good basis to decide which one to use.


I have "been there and done that" a long time ago. I'm unlikely to be wasting much of my time performing additional traces for WTC 7. I already have multiple datasets more than accurate enough to serve my purposes.
I haven't asked nor am I asking you to do that. Wonder where did you get that idea from.


'Fraid not. If you grab a thumbnail db file viewer, you can download the entire thumbnail list (without downloading the entire video data) and have a peruse to find the right view.
Thumbs.db is Windows-generated and doesn't work under Linux. There is an extraction tool but that's about it, it would require me to extract it directory by directory. Is the Dan Rather view you used to obtain the http://femr2.ucoz.com/load/dan_rather_basic_trace_data/1-1-0-29 trace even in the Cumulus database?
 
No, it doesn't.

So, what do you consider the pitch and yaw to be? (remember this is the difference between the planes orientation to the building and actual flight path (trajectory)?

If you claim zero (or very little, the pilot would have had to be making little to no control inputs corrections). Judging from video (and flight path data) I've seen he was pushing forward and left yoke and likely hard left rudder keeping the building in the windshield (low tech way to hit something). This produces significant yaw (more so than pitch).
 
...'Fraid not. If you grab a thumbnail db file viewer, you can download the entire thumbnail list** (without downloading the entire video data) and have a peruse to find the right view.

Thumbs.db is Windows-generated and doesn't work under Linux. There is an extraction tool but that's about it,....
Is that 'vinetto'??? Its the only one I have used and only in 'one off' situations. Currently Xubuntu 12.04 on this machine.

it would require me to extract it directory by directory.
If you could get the directory tree populated only with the thumbs.db files for brevity/bandwidth - it should be possible to simply script the extraction. (Ooops - I just tried a trial run - it is Thumbs.db :o )

It is easy for me - I have several windows Virtual Machines available on this my main workstation - which sort of defeats the need for me to Linux process the image extractions. But can I help you by acting as a bridge or step in the process???

femr -- re the flagged ** bit. How do we download the list? Would (Could?) it be in directory structure populated with Thumbs.db files? Does it need windows to do the download - if so can I do the download and forward the file to pgimeno? "How big would the file be? etc etc...
 
I first met that one in 2007-8 and spent many hours/words trying to explain to the model builder the related physics and the fact that the twins did not collapse from harmonic resonance effects of the initial impact etc etc....

You seem to be confused about the purpose of the models. The one you posted was supposed to represent the structure. Mine was merely a physical representation of the upper half of each building for the purpose of photography. In this it is no different to building the towers in a virtual environment, placing them on a virtual floor and taking a picture with a virtual camera. No structure is being modelled, just shapes and positions.
 
You seem to be confused about the purpose of the models....
I'm not in the least confused. You should not read intention or content into my posts when neither are present. I said nothing whatsoever about "purpose" of the model. This is all that I said:
You will remember this one.
Some of the members here may not be familiar with it - the builder did not last long here at JREF.
I don't see why you want to impute reference to "purpose" into my post NOR any comparison to the purpose of your model. What my posts say is nearly always what I intended them to say and what they don't say is not intended to be implied - It is very unusual for me to use intentional implication or innuendo. I may slip occasionally and, if we misunderstand each other, a simple request for clarification will solve the problem.
...The one you posted was supposed to represent the structure...
The model was made by 'psikeyhackr' who has been known for some years to both femr2 and myself from our involvements in other forums. He was briefly a member here. I posted the the model as an "old times sake" reminder for femr2. I have multiple times commended psikeyhackr for the effort he put into the model even though I believe his purpose was originally heading down a wrong track and later was subject of his extensive postings across many forums. The only parallel to your model from my perspective is that it was a commendable effort even though, IMO, ill focussed as to purpose. Your models are for a different purpose - I commend you for making them. I have neither basis not reason for judging whether your purpose is fully valid. On the surface it seems valid. Go for it and best of luck.

If you are interested in judging for yourself psikeyhackr's use of models he is still active on this forum. I occasionally post there as 'econ41' - there is a long history of my involvement which I don't need to explain at this time.
...Mine was merely a physical representation of the upper half of each building for the purpose of photography.
I understood that other than the detail of limited to upper half.
In this it is no different to building the towers in a virtual environment, placing them on a virtual floor and taking a picture with a virtual camera. No structure is being modelled, just shapes and positions.
Also understood.
 
Last edited:
So, what do you consider the pitch and yaw to be?
There is no detectable drift/slew of fuselage horizontal or vertical entry location during impact.

For example...for a 13 degree trajectory with 6 degree orientation (lateral) there would be nearly 20ft difference between nose and tail entry location.

Earlier motion cannot practically be used to determine trajectory during impact, so there's only the during impact motion to go on.
 
Last edited:
I'm asking specifically about two with a quite similar view, Dan Rather and the ones I specified.
Rotation of the camera is an issue for the latter.

If the question is why I am asking, the answer is because I want to have a good basis to decide which one to use.

I haven't asked nor am I asking you to do that. Wonder where did you get that idea from.
You're planning on performing the tracing yourself then ? With what ?

There is an extraction tool but that's about it, it would require me to extract it directory by directory.
Better than grabbing 1Tb and checking them directory by directory.

Is the Dan Rather view you used to obtain the http://femr2.ucoz.com/load/dan_rather_basic_trace_data/1-1-0-29 trace even in the Cumulus database?
Dunno.
 
femr -- re the flagged ** bit. How do we download the list? Would (Could?) it be in directory structure populated with Thumbs.db files?
Yes. Upon opening the torrent you should have a list of files (lengthy). Reorder by filename and select only thumbs.db files for download.

Does it need windows to do the download
No, but utorrent is pretty good.

"How big would the file be? etc etc...
you'd need to zip up the tree. Not too big but not sure.
 
Yes. Upon opening the torrent you should have a list of files (lengthy). Reorder by filename and select only thumbs.db files for download.
Understood - that much is architecture independent so pgimeno should be able to do it for himself.
No, but utorrent is pretty good.
(mu)torrent is only in alpha for linux but there are plenty of torrent options.
...you'd need to zip up the tree. Not too big but not sure.
Looks like pgimeno should be able to help himself - if so my involvement would be redundant. Lets see what he thinks and if he's still interested - the only reason I suggested helping was that I can readily do Windows<<>>Linux bridging if he does not have access to a Windows machine.

Thanks for the info.
 
How did you ensure your half towers were elevated correctly ?

Tape measure. Since only the just over the upper third needs to be in shot the platform with them on was placed on a sawhorse and a box. A plumb line and string lines were used to transfer alignment points on the platform to ground level. The tower height was slightly over scale height to allow the camera to be pointed up with the lens at "ground" height.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom