Merged Discussion of femr's video data analysis

Well we're all kind of up against the same barrier: there just aren't very many comparables to what happened on 9/11.

Discussion of "freefall" will not progress the "argument" much, even though it has been shown that the acceleration behaviour of WTC7 (NW corner) is constantly changing and the duration of near/over g is somewhat shorter than suggested by either NIST or Chandler...the rest being below g and therefore being "resisted".

A more "useful and productive" angle is the early motion identified for WTC 7, and the simple question...


If the WTC7 descent was initiated by an event followed immediately by descent...what caused it to be in motion minutes prior to release ?

The data provided above shows that a known implosion did not experience such early motion.
 
If I was doing a PowerPoint presentation I would readily include femr's work as of the highest accuracy I am currently aware of.
Ta. If so... You're welcome to use any resources you please. Most graphs are consistently sized and styled, but I can redo some older ones if y'like.

Hoist by my own petard :o)
Difficult not to criticise both NIST and Chandler in that context.
 
the comparison between a known CD and WTC 7 is very significant for certain commonly presented claims about WTC7 collapse mechanisms
Sure. Annoying that implosion firms don't set up a camera in a good position, on a tripod, in HD... and film the last, say, half hour of the buildings life...

"good enough" for me - :boxedin:
It's comparable to the second WTC7 early motion duration. The WTC7 trace is a bit longer, and I released the prior few minutes too, but yes, should be good enough.
 
Indeed. In MT's usual innuendo style:

​
Major_Tom's statement was a simple objective and accurate response to a question asked by ChrisMohr. It has zero relevance to the point I made and that you quoted.

There was no innuendo in M_T's statement. If there is any innuendo it is yours and I cannot discern what you are implying or what relevance it has to that statement of mine that you quoted.
 
Cue: "What is the relevance of that? I cannot see the relevance. It is of no interest to me so why should anyone else be interested? You have no gaol - unless it relates to landing on the moon you have no right to measure it."

:D


Sure I was a bit explicit with the "I cannot..." - the "I" is usually left unstated - all the better to support the usual implied false generalisation...
.... AND there are three separate parodies conflated into the last one. :rolleyes:

Why is this tread in the conspiracy section?

The OP - tfk - started it in this section and the forum policy is to keep all 9/11 matters in this sub forum.

If the suggestion is "move it elsewhere" with the implied change of policy then consistency would require that all the Millette Dust threads and the thermXte threads would also need to move. Inflicting ergo, MM, CM et al on other parts of the forum. I doubt that such is your intention.

Actually this latest post by femr offers significant data on collapse mechanisms - comparing a known CD with WTC 7 - which is more closely related to 9/11 discussion that the thermXte related threads. CD is a topic of direct relevance. ThermXte is at least two layers of reasoning remote - it is a "could have been used" support for a CD claim if ever we get a Cd claim which would have to show how thermxte was used. That ain't gunna happen.

So if your aim is to change forum policy it could be easier to make a case against the thermXte threads than against this one.
I was working off the cue:
 
it would be nice to have some empirical facts pinned down
What is not "pinned down" ?

  • WTC position is known
  • Secondary Building positions are known and 3D building models are available
  • 3D aircraft models are avaliable
  • Camera location is known
  • NIST and femr2 aircraft orientation parameters are known
  • Hezarkhani and Carman Taylor imagery is available
  • High resolution full-distance satellite imagery has been provided

What else would you need pinned down ?

even if I don't have time to learn the fine art of rotoscoping.
It's not complicated, and can be performed by anyone with reasonable understanding of placing a camera and other 3D objects in a rendering package such as 3DStudio, Blender, Maya, ...
 
To recap on this particular point, is it the case that (1) you believe the correct orientation of the towers is 29° clockwise from true north, (2) and you believe femr2's orientation is more nearly 31° clockwise from true north?

2° < 9-10°. But it would be nice to have some empirical facts pinned down, even if I don't have time to learn the fine art of rotoscoping.

What is not "pinned down" ?

I thought my meaning was clear in context.

What was the true orientation of the towers? Does your analysis agree with that, or doesn't it? Presumably the answers are "pinned down" (possibly subject to measurement error), but it's remarkable that Reactor drone would challenge it and then apparently drop the point.

I assume that rotoscoping is not akin to brain surgery, but I don't feel too bad on the whole about not having learned Blender. Also, FWIW, it took me at least seven tries to download your .3ds. So I don't really have a time frame for a replication. But I'll keep puttering, at least, because I like to know more rather than less at the end of any given discussion.
 
What was the true orientation of the towers?
Measure it from satellite imagery if you want a sub-degree accurate value, or design plans, or...

It is irrelevant for the impact orientation study, as maps were used to place scene objects, both satellite and vector.

it's remarkable that Reactor drone would challenge it and then apparently drop the point
It's a common trait for numerous members here.

But I'll keep puttering, at least, because I like to know more rather than less at the end of any given discussion.
Happy to assist where appropriate.
 
What was the true orientation of the towers? Does your analysis agree with that, or doesn't it? Presumably the answers are "pinned down" (possibly subject to measurement error), but it's remarkable that Reactor drone would challenge it and then apparently drop the point.

I asked the question and am politely waiting for an answer. People have lives, I'm in no hurry given that this is only about troubleshooting why Femr2's orientation is so far off everyone elses. I've given my estimate of the angle of Femr's WTC buildings based on his draft positions, for more accurate analysis we'll just have to wait.

I'd have to dig them out of the piling system from 3 YEARS ago.

Accurately placed over satellite imagery, with verification via vector maps.

There is no reason to doubt placement.
 
I asked the question and am politely waiting for an answer. People have lives, I'm in no hurry given that this is only about troubleshooting why Femr2's orientation is so far off everyone elses. I've given my estimate of the angle of Femr's WTC buildings based on his draft positions, for more accurate analysis we'll just have to wait.

So your estimate of his estimate, so to speak, is based on close inspection of the draft?

It's true, people have lives. On my seventh or so try, I was able to download femr2's WTC model (the provider either severely throttles bandwidth or is just plain glitchy), and in a spirit of adventure, I installed Blender and imported the model there. Of course that does me very little good without any map referents. (ETA, to finish the thought such as it was: So, I intend to continue to putter as time allows.)
 
Last edited:
I asked the question and am politely waiting for an answer.
You've been answered, several times, you simply appear too blinkered upon attempt to "prove femr2 wrong version the umpteenth" to notice.

  • My scene element placement was performed via use of satellite and vector map imagery.
  • Orientation from North/True North/Any other North you might choose...is irrelevant to me
  • If you want to know, measure it, though I suggest you check the validity of any map source you reference, and what type of North it employs.

The best on-screen protractor can be found here... http://sourceforge.net/projects/osprotractor/ ...though you might want to consider other methods too :)

this is only about troubleshooting why Femr2's orientation is so far off everyone elses
:rolleyes:
125144793.gif


Everyone elses ? Such as whom ?

What orientation, aircraft ?

I've given my estimate of the angle of Femr's WTC buildings based on his draft positions
Draft. Outline. Non final. Estimated.

You've been told repeatedly that latter element placement was completed via use of satellite imagery and vector maps.

Have a GUESS where I put the camera, secondary buildings and tower models ? :rolleyes:

for more accurate analysis we'll just have to wait.
ROFL. You have everything you require. I have no need to increase accuracy. The results speak for themselves...

938786605.gif
 
You've been answered, several times, you simply appear too blinkered upon attempt to "prove femr2 wrong version the umpteenth" to notice.

My scene element placement was performed via use of satellite and vector map imagery.


Yes, you've explained how you did it but you've only ever provided the draft version of your results which you insist are useless.

Orientation from North/True North/Any other North you might choose...is irrelevant to me


It is or course relevant to determining the orientation of the buildings and aircraft to a north oriented map or photograph.

If you want to know, measure it, though I suggest you check the validity of any map source you reference, and what type of North it employs.
[/list]


I have measured it. My initial measurements showed the buildings at 28.43°, pretty close to the 29° value. My measurements of your set up show 31°

The best on-screen protractor can be found here... http://sourceforge.net/projects/osprotractor/ ...though you might want to consider other methods too :)


I usually use trigonometry.


:rolleyes: [qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/_ph/9/2/125144793.gif[/qimg]

Everyone elses ? Such as whom ?


NIST, Eduardo Kausel from MIT, me and presumably anyone else that cares to measure/model it.

What orientation, aircraft ?


Yes, aircraft orientation.


Draft. Outline. Non final. Estimated.

You've been told repeatedly that latter element placement was completed via use of satellite imagery and vector maps.

Have a GUESS where I put the camera, secondary buildings and tower models ? :rolleyes:


ROFL. You have everything you require. I have no need to increase accuracy. The results speak for themselves...

I know you've aligned your buildings using "satellite imagery" (most high res imagery on google is actually taken from relatively low flying aircraft), that's why I asked for the specific building angle from your 3d environment, to check whether it matched the real world angle. Instead of providing that information when it was convenient for you to do so you have instead repeatedly made the non-answer of how you did it.

here's a hint- doing it myself doesn't tell me what angle you used, it only tells me what angle I'm using. Nobody needs any information from you to do this themselves.
 
Last edited:
Yes, you've explained how you did it but you've only ever provided the draft version of your results
Incorrect

I've procided you with draft methodology write-up, sure...then links to where the discussions housing progression were made, along with specific details about subsequent object placement, including camera location.

You also have the resultant render.

That you choose to cling to simplistic example overview images early in the draft shows either your intent, or your "competence".

which you insist are useless
Incorrect

The draft is exceedingly useful, containing fairly detailed write-up of methods employed, and draft results, clerly stated as draft results.

That you are incapable of using that information correctly is not my problem. In recent discussion with yourself I've repeatedly told you what "changed" since draft...relative secondary building positioning and camera positioning.

Pfft.

It is of course relevant to determining the orientation of the buildings and aircraft to a north oriented map or photograph.
Who needs to know what the angle is ? I don't.

I have measured it.
Wonderful. Now, given that my models are oriented via satellite imagery, have a ******* guess what orientation a model fit exactly over an image of the thing will be...

My initial measurements showed the buildings at 28.43°, pretty close to the 29° value.
:) If you're using Google Maps satellite imagery, your trig sucks.

You're several tenths out.

My measurements of your set up show 31°
ROFL. Yet again your level of competence requires you to ineptly choose to use a clearly stated draft overview to imply something else. It's a laughable "trick".

I usually use trigonometry.
Losing tenths somewhere. Tsk ;)

NIST, Eduardo Kausel from MIT
Excellent. Now, have you BOTHERED to research how they actually came up with the values ?

Have you bothered to cross-check with radar data to find early approach vector ?

Have you bothered to consider the effect of the last momemt manouvers ?

Perhaps you'd care to explain why you've chosen to completely ignore this rather unsubtle HINT that I provided you with a few days ago...

749689034.png


...and the angle a-curring.


You haven't bothered to fit any of these details into your thought process. Omitting such says much about competence and intent.

You don't have an orientation. All you have is random suggestion of error in mine, for wandering and varying reasons. Just do the thing man. It's not difficult. I've done the hard work for you...research. All you have to do is stick some models over a map and hit render ffs :(

Reactor Drone said:
this is only about troubleshooting why Femr2's orientation is so far off everyone elses
femr2 said:
Everyone elses ? Such as whom ?
Reactor Drone said:
presumably anyone else that cares to measure/model it.
LOL. ROFL. :eek: :jaw-dropp

I know you've aligned your buildings using "satellite imagery"
So d'ya reckon I just decided to rotate them so they don't match up ? :D

here's a hint- doing it myself doesn't tell me what angle you used, it only tells me what angle I'm using.
if your results differ from mine... ;)

Nobody needs any information from you to do this themselves.
Spot on.

Go for it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom