Merged Discussion of femr's video data analysis

... I don't care in the (non-trivial) sense that as far as I an tell, nobody has established the relevance of this analysis -- so, for me at this time, it's more like pure science. The same is true for the trajectory analysis.
It is not strictly true Mark that "nobody has established the relevance" - the relevance is implicit in the content of this thread and I have stated it explicitly several times. You have even cautioned me about my explanations :o

The relevance to 9/11 CT discussion is a direct two stage link viz:
1) femr provides data - in the case of WTC in response to members requests.
2) Those other members use the data in discussion/debate of WTC7 collapse - for example in the context of the Chandler v NIST comparisons.

How much more is needed to establish "relevance"?

Now "accuracy" could be another question...but no need to regurgitate those aspects at this stage. ;)
 
It is not strictly true Mark that "nobody has established the relevance" - the relevance is implicit in the content of this thread and I have stated it explicitly several times. You have even cautioned me about my explanations :o

The relevance to 9/11 CT discussion is a direct two stage link viz:
1) femr provides data - in the case of WTC in response to members requests.
2) Those other members use the data in discussion/debate of WTC7 collapse - for example in the context of the Chandler v NIST comparisons.

How much more is needed to establish "relevance"?

Now "accuracy" could be another question...but no need to regurgitate those aspects at this stage. ;)

Sure, let me try to be clearer.

"The relevance to 9/11 CT discussion"? But what is the relevance of 9/11 CT discussion?! Don't answer that. :) Of course you can if you want. But that certainly isn't an issue I had in mind.

For what it's worth, I don't see other forum users making much use of femr2's conclusions as inputs to other discussions. I suppose that varies over time.

The question I had in mind is the extent to which femr2's conclusions, if sustained, would alter any other conclusions that might guide our judgments and actions. It is logically possible that that could include conclusions about conspiracy theories, but e.g. new or refined safety recommendations would be great. I suppose there are some implicit recommendations about how to do video analysis. Other aspects of relevance can be conjectured or imagined.
 
femr or anyone,
Most of us seem to agree that at least some part of the perimeter wall of Building 7 came down at slighly greater than freefall. Have you or anyone else ever analyzed any other known natural building collapses and found freefall or greater than freefall in some part of the collapse? Especially if the collapsing is of part of the building's actual structure (curtain drop collapses often happen when siding peels off a building and just falls straight down but that might not count). Forgive me if that's already been posted, thought I would ask.

Only one known example at this point, not natural...


The Demolition of 1515 Flagler Dr...

44753876.jpg


larger version here


The downward displacement of this demolition is compared to the downward displacement of the northwest corner of WTC7.


898155405.png




A quick look at derived acceleration suggests very near to freefall, if indeed it is not actually reached...


657018636.jpg


larger version here
 
Last edited:
..."The relevance to 9/11 CT discussion"? But what is the relevance of 9/11 CT discussion?..
clap.gif
Neat play on words. On the alternative - 9/11 discussion is of little remaining relevance - look at the dearth of threads on this forum which are not desperate survival ploys by trolls or troll feeders. The interest is rapidly fading asymptotic to zero...emphasis on asymptotic. :)
...
For what it's worth, I don't see other forum users making much use of femr2's conclusions as inputs to other discussions. I suppose that varies over time.
the fact that some asked for the data establishes relevance as far as this thread is concerned. Even the question "Whether they used the data or not" is not an issue in deciding relevance.
...The question I had in mind is the extent to which femr2's conclusions, if sustained, would alter any other conclusions that might guide our judgments and actions. It is logically possible that that could include conclusions about conspiracy theories, but e.g. new or refined safety recommendations would be great. I suppose there are some implicit recommendations about how to do video analysis.
All three are valid proofs of relevance.
-- but the subjects of who sees them as relevant are different. And, naturally, relevance down any of those three paths establishes relevance.

The obvious over-riding issue in this thread and similar ones is that addressing CT including CD is not femr's goal. Many others have dishonestly or illogically attempted to impose the determination of CD as a goal on femr. Much to his amusement as you will be aware...
 
Not nearly similar. The mechanism there is pivoting. And that mechanism is easy to see in any building that topples, similar to the known ruler experiment.

I figured it would be misused this way. :(
Who is misusing what ? Apart from you that is.

1515 Flagler is the only other building I've traced. Simple as that.

In what specific way is there any "misuse" going on there ?

:(

If you have other footage from collapses, from a static camera in near orthogonal viewpoint...let me know and I'll trace.
 
Who is misusing what ? Apart from you that is.

1515 Flagler is the only other building I've traced. Simple as that.

In what specific way is there any "misuse" going on there ?

:(

If you have other footage from collapses, from a static camera in near orthogonal viewpoint...let me know and I'll trace.
Can anyone find such a video? And thank you femr in advance for your offer. What I am wondering is this: the freefall acceleration of Building 7 is used as evidence for controlled demolition and they claim it is unique in the destruction of this building. Maybe this is unique, maybe not, I don't know. If there is such a collapse video and femr is able to find freefall collapse of any part of any building with steel supports known to have collapsed from fire, that would be good to know. The 9/11 Truith world will say that it has to be a tall steel-framed building or it doesn't count, but I would say any structure with steel supports will add useful factual information to the discussion.
 
In what specific way is there any "misuse" going on there ?
Only one known example at this point, not natural...
Different mechanisms. I remember having been bashed in the911forum for showing a façade that fell in free fall if not quicker as a consequence of a fire, and the reason I was bashed was because the mechanism was different. Therefore it is not the "only known example at this point", except if you ignore the other one. The mechanism in the example I presented and the mechanism in the above example are both pivoting, which was not the mechanism that happened in WTC7.
 
Last edited:
Different mechanisms. I remember having been bashed in the911forum for showing a façade that fell in free fall if not quicker as a consequence of a fire, and the reason I was bashed was because the mechanism was different. Therefore it is not the "only known example at this point", except if you ignore the other one. The mechanism in the example I presented and the mechanism in the above example are both pivoting, which was not the mechanism that happened in WTC7.
pgimeno,
Who bashed you? I ask because if the argument is that there MUST be CD or else strutural resistance would prohibit freefall, then ANY kind of freefall collapse of a steel supported structure in fire would be useful to know about!
 
pgimeno,
Who bashed you? I ask because if the argument is that there MUST be CD or else strutural resistance would prohibit freefall, then ANY kind of freefall collapse of a steel supported structure in fire would be useful to know about!

This is the thread if you're interested:
http://the911forum.freeforums.org/wtc-7-tipping-brick-walls-james-baldwin-and-etc-t558.html

The ironic part is that this criticism:
What is known: You produce an example of a collapse which is verifiably dissimilar to WTC7's in virtually every way. If indeed your example (by pure dumb luck) happens to exhibit over g, it says nothing about the mechanics of WTC7's collapse.
​
applies equally well to the example above.
 
pgimeno,
Who bashed you?
Read the first few posts of the linked thread Chris. "bashed" is hardly the word. More like "Ran into a very competent debater who would not accept poor argument".

... I ask because if the argument is that there MUST be CD or else strutural resistance would prohibit freefall,...
I would be very surprised if anyone posted such an idea on 911Forum and got away without it being rigorously debunked. The forum has a different ethos to JREF. First it is truther friendly in that truthers posting their are not confronted by ridicule as they would be here. So nowhere near the trolling and counter trolling "discussions" which make up the 90% noise 10% reasoned discussion we see here. (Those percentages guessed - I've never bothered to do the full counting.)

BUT, second, the sceptics on that forum tend to give a hard time to anyone putting forward poor argument. From either "side" (OK - you know what I mean even though I deny there are two sides :))

...then ANY kind of freefall collapse of a steel supported structure in fire would be useful to know about!
And Major_Tom has given the only one he knows about and correctly identified it as not meeting your original request when he said:
Only one known example at this point, not natural...
That plus the offer from femr is probably as good as you will get for available resources to meet your request.

Plus my usual disclaimer/caution. You are risking adding credibility by even responding to the "free fall == CD" nonsense. That is exactly where the truthers want you.
 
Read the first few posts of the linked thread Chris. "bashed" is hardly the word. More like "Ran into a very competent debater who would not accept poor argument".
Ouch.

That plus the offer from femr is probably as good as you will get for available resources to meet your request.
Offer stands. It would be productive use of time, which would be somewhat refreshing :)
 
I read the thread - interesting when you are familiar with the players' debating styles.

I would think twice before taking on OWE with loose arguments :)

...Offer stands. It would be productive use of time, which would be somewhat refreshing :)
Actually I agree - despite my preference for a "purist" approach to dealing with the contemporary hard line committed truthers I respect where Chris comes from.
 
Well we're all kind of up against the same barrier: there just aren't very many comparables to what happened on 9/11. Pgimeno's link to this brick building collapse doesn't really offer up much to compare, since it looks like the near-g part of the collapse may be the side of a brick wall tipping over: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=DZ1e3ddf3RM I think we need some kind of steel structure or steel-reinforced structure descending more or less vertically to have a reasonable basis for comparison.

I have a vague memory that the Delft Building collapse rate has already been measured. femr, if I'm wrong about that, here is one of many videos: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bizr86N-4nc
I think this one is considerably less than freefall but just in case...
 
I have a vague memory that the Delft Building collapse rate has already been measured. femr, if I'm wrong about that, here is one of many videos: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bizr86N-4nc
I think this one is considerably less than freefall but just in case...
I haven't traced that one...and although the camera is fixed (good) I think there's too much smoke obscuring any tracable feature.

I'm sure something will turn up.
 
Well we're all kind of up against the same barrier: there just aren't very many comparables to what happened on 9/11.
That is the core of the problem. There are two main approaches to understanding or "proving" things related to 9/11 WTC collapses viz:
1) Comparing WTC "observables" with those from other collapses; OR
2) Applying the basic physics.

...and for varying reasons those committed to "truther claims" will resist using real physics. Sure they will also reject anything that disproves their claims but "observables" are harder to dismiss.

And the reality is that WTC collapses were unique in all the facts that matter:
a) deliberate initiation of damage and fires for WTC1 WTC2;
b) fires instantly initiated with multi floor impact and intensity way above any normal fire scenario;
c) primary fire suppression systems disabled from the outset;
d) fires therefore unfightable and unfought;
e) unconventional structural design which 20/20 hindsight shows was vulnerable
...so getting parallel examples will be hard.

And what may turn up will still only illustrate principles - not direct parallels - and that puts you (us? :o) back in the same position vis-a-vis truthers who will resist arguments based on working from principles.
 
That is the core of the problem. There are two main approaches to understanding or "proving" things related to 9/11 WTC collapses viz:
1) Comparing WTC "observables" with those from other collapses; OR
2) Applying the basic physics.
Applying observables to the physics is also an option, such as the implications of early motion...without the need to compare to other descents.

Though it may be interesting to look at several high quality demolition videos with long term footage (a few minutes at least) to look for motion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom