Merged Discussion of femr's video data analysis

Ozeco that is very well-put. The uniqueness of the 9/11 destruction is obvious, and your reasons help remind us why. The fact that an event is unique can be (falsely) used to "prove" something dark and sinister. For example: no large steel-hull cruise ship holding thousands of passengers had ever been sunk by an iceberg. Therefore, the Titanic didn't sink, it was all a giant insurance fraud and the real Titanic continued to secretly ply the seas (I don't remember the title of the book but this is a real theory out there). Ozeco is right: in a unique situation, principles of physics/chemistry/whatever can be applied to gain understanding of what happened. When the three buildings collapsed on 9/11, scientists did not have a conclusive answer as to how it happened; there were some sketches done by Eduardo Kausel and some preliminary articles, but they didn't yet have a coherent explanation. That took time, and it was the application of known principles to new event that solved the mystery.
 
Applying observables to the physics is also an option, such as the implications of early motion...without the need to compare to other descents.
True.
--- I didn't intend to imply "exclusive or" between the "two main approaches";
--- the "implications of early motion" should be bleedingly obvious; AND
--- no need logically for "compare to other descents" - however Chris needs the comparison for the no win path of persuasion he is dilligently following.
 
People may have other personal motives for wanting to prove you wrong about something
...
Seems like Reactor drone is still getting stuck on 'sanity checks' that might well precede 3D analysis. Of course, some of the sanity checks may actually be insane, but learning can come from those, too. If Reactor drone eventually trails off without really having done anything, well, learning can come from that as well.

Indeed, amongst others.

As I've said, anyone with true interest in producing their own results requires nothing more from me; it's all here and stated many times. In addition, anyone with true interest in producing their own results should not need detailed prompts from me, as they should be working through the "problem" themselves.

It becomes abundently clear a few years down the line who is interested in e.g. determining accurate UAL impact trajectory and orientation, and who is attempting to "prove femr2 wrong version the umpteenth".

Note the lack of change to results due to recent "discussion". Note the lack of valid criticism to methods employed.
 
Unfortunately you ASSUME too many things.

As I said, do you really think I'd get the bleedin' tower position and orientation wrong ? Jeez. :rolleyes:

I only assumed one thing, that your grid lines were aligned with the building faces. Was that an incorrect assumption?

And, yes, I do think you'd get the tower orientation wrong based upon the documentation you provided to back up your claim that NISTs aircraft orientation was out by 9-10°.
 
I only assumed one thing, that your grid lines were aligned with the building faces. Was that an incorrect assumption?

And, yes, I do think you'd get the tower orientation wrong based upon the documentation you provided to back up your claim that NISTs aircraft orientation was out by 9-10°.

To recap on this particular point, is it the case that (1) you believe the correct orientation of the towers is 29° clockwise from true north, (2) and you believe femr2's orientation is more nearly 31° clockwise from true north?

2° < 9-10°. But it would be nice to have some empirical facts pinned down, even if I don't have time to learn the fine art of rotoscoping.
 
As I've said, anyone with true interest in producing their own results requires nothing more from me; it's all here and stated many times. In addition, anyone with true interest in producing their own results should not need detailed prompts from me, as they should be working through the "problem" themselves.

It becomes abundently clear a few years down the line who is interested in e.g. determining accurate UAL impact trajectory and orientation, and who is attempting to "prove femr2 wrong version the umpteenth".

One problem with all that, unfortunately, is that it still isn't entirely clear why anyone should be interested in producing their own results. (ETA: I mean this to describe subjective judgments; I don't claim to know what questions are objectively important, and it wouldn't matter if I did.)

Strip away all the 9/11-ness, and these threads aren't altogether unfamiliar as a peer review process. Some reviewers are saying that they don't really see much point to the analyses. Some reviewers are raising methodological questions that, in my view, have helped to clarify your methods and findings. Some reviewers seem more interested in their own agendas than the work under review -- and some may be completely off in the Delta Quadrant. Regardless, reviewers don't have to independently replicate the work under review, and they don't even necessarily have to form an opinion on whether it is essentially correct.

At least in an actual peer review process there are some systematic guarantees that you'll get a publication decision. How much influence the work has is outside the scope of peer review.
 
Last edited:
One problem with all that, unfortunately, is that it still isn't entirely clear why anyone should be interested in producing their own results.
You suggested that members' (poor and obvious) attempts to "prove femr2 wrong version the umpteenth" were due to them actually wanting to reproduce results. I'm not sure there is a name for the kind of fence you're trying to sit upon.

Some reviewers are saying that they don't really see much point to the analyses.
If I were them, then I wouldn't waste my breath then.

I don't think there's a comment type MORE pointless than someone (likely to have little knowledge of the technical elements in play) wasting oxygen letting "everyone" know they "don't really see the point".

Some reviewers are raising methodological questions that, in my view, have helped to clarify your methods and findings.
None of what I've done is complicated. That some folk can't see how simple this stuff is is a problem for future generations.

Some reviewers seem more interested in their own agendas than the work under review -- and some may be completely off in the Delta Quadrant.
Care to name any reviewers who are not ?

Regardless, reviewers don't have to independently replicate the work under review
Again, "attempts to replicate" was your suggested "excuse" for those rather obviously attempting to "prove femr2 wrong version the umpteenth".

they don't even necessarily have to form an opinion on whether it is essentially correct
Yay. Endless pointless waffle from the peanut gallery. Splendid.
 
You suggested that members' (poor and obvious) attempts to "prove femr2 wrong version the umpteenth" were due to them actually wanting to reproduce results. I'm not sure there is a name for the kind of fence you're trying to sit upon.

They're probably hoping to falsify your results, and to the extent that they try and fail, that strengthens your case, and brings more attention to your work. But the work doesn't seem to be going anywhere, so it isn't so surprising that the criticisms aren't either. It's a pretty common dynamic.
 
They're probably hoping to falsify your results, and to the extent that they try and fail, that strengthens your case, and brings more attention to your work.
Indeed.

I respond to the criticism. Not fussed about the attention.

But the work doesn't seem to be going anywhere
It is what it is. Little has changed in the last couple of years. To those it is useful to, fine. To those the technical arena interests, fine.

Over six billion people in the world and a handful on this thread.

Most of what I've done is for me anyway. It gets shared, sure.
 
I didn't intend to imply "exclusive or" between the "two main approaches"
Aiii.

the "implications of early motion" should be bleedingly obvious
Indeed.

no need logically for "compare to other descents" - however Chris needs the comparison for the no win path of persuasion he is dilligently following.
I'm looking to trace the Palace Hotel implosion. Static camera. About a minute prior to release. Would prefer a longer timespan, but can't find any.

Should be enough to show zero early motion...
 
I'm looking to trace the Palace Hotel implosion. Static camera. About a minute prior to release. Would prefer a longer timespan, but can't find any.

Should be enough to show zero early motion...
Early trace suggests no early motion prior to implosion, with +/- 0.02 pixel variance (noise).
 
Early trace suggests no early motion prior to implosion, with +/- 0.02 pixel variance (noise).

Cue: "What is the relevance of that? I cannot see the relevance. It is of no interest to me so why should anyone else be interested? You have no gaol - unless it relates to landing on the moon you have no right to measure it."

:D


Sure I was a bit explicit with the "I cannot..." - the "I" is usually left unstated - all the better to support the usual implied false generalisation...
.... AND there are three separate parodies conflated into the last one. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Cue: "What is the relevance of that? I cannot see the relevance. It is of no interest to me so why should anyone else be interested? You have no gaol - unless it relates to landing on the moon you have no right to measure it."
We'll see after a piccy or two... makes things "simpler" :)

138854416.png


440494046.png


...or maybe three piccy's...

666377698.png


Whilst there is of course difference in building size (17 storey Palace Hotel vs WTC7), the scaling metrics are very similar (12.7px/fl vs 13.2px/fl ).

Note the 0.2 pixel peak in early motion...as opposed to the +/- 0.02 pixel variance (noise) for the Palace Hotel.

Trace duration is about 2 minutes.
 
Last edited:
Cue: "What is the relevance of that? I cannot see the relevance. It is of no interest to me so why should anyone else be interested? You have no gaol - unless it relates to landing on the moon you have no right to measure it."

:D


Sure I was a bit explicit with the "I cannot..." - the "I" is usually left unstated - all the better to support the usual implied false generalisation...
.... AND there are three separate parodies conflated into the last one. :rolleyes:

Why is this tread in the conspiracy section?
 
We'll see after a piccy or two... makes things "simpler" :)..
Take care - putting what should be bleedingly obvious into pictures anyone should be able to read....tends to attract....err...ummm..."noise". :o

That said - the comparison between a known CD and WTC 7 is very significant for certain commonly presented claims about WTC7 collapse mechanisms. ;)

...Trace duration is about 2 minutes.
"good enough" for me - :boxedin:
 
Why is this tread in the conspiracy section?
The OP - tfk - started it in this section and the forum policy is to keep all 9/11 matters in this sub forum.

If the suggestion is "move it elsewhere" with the implied change of policy then consistency would require that all the Millette Dust threads and the thermXte threads would also need to move. Inflicting ergo, MM, CM et al on other parts of the forum. I doubt that such is your intention.

Actually this latest post by femr offers significant data on collapse mechanisms - comparing a known CD with WTC 7 - which is more closely related to 9/11 discussion that the thermXte related threads. CD is a topic of direct relevance. ThermXte is at least two layers of reasoning remote - it is a "could have been used" support for a CD claim if ever we get a Cd claim which would have to show how thermxte was used. That ain't gunna happen.

So if your aim is to change forum policy it could be easier to make a case against the thermXte threads than against this one.
 
Last edited:
Background slide data for powerpoints.
If I was doing a PowerPoint presentation I would readily include femr's work as of the highest accuracy I am currently aware of.

However I have regard to the likely context in which I could be making a presentation. For me it could be the local Chapter of IE(Aust) - AKA Engineers Australia - the national professional association for engineers. Such a setting could well require exploration of the range of measurement techniques and would require reference to examples such as the NIST and Chandler arguments and supporting measurement methods. If I did present those to a group of professionals I would be obliged to describe the best measurement techniques that I am aware of. (If you are into ironic analogies that is the position of ethics I applied in discussing R Gage's professional honesty. Hoist by my own petard :o)

That said the focus of such a presentation would need to be on the engineering - experience over the years tells me that the engineers I have discussed 9/11 with have a main focus on collapse mechanisms. One-on-one that is a two minute explanation with which I am well practised. CD not a real issue - tho' conspiracy theories and terrorism could be a small part of any formal presentation to put the 9/11 in both historic and technical context...mmm... I'm half way through mapping out the presentation.

Thanks for the idea. Not a bad thought - I'll ask how full the calendar is for the monthly meetings.
thumbup.gif




;)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom