Merged Discussion of femr's video data analysis

Significant in answer to your question..."are we talking about miniscule deviations, or something serious"

Significant error.

An example...


NIST suggest Lateral Approach Angle - 15 degrees +/- 2 degrees.

If camera placement is determined within a 100ft error of margin, the NIST angle is out by over 7 degrees.

If camera placement is determined within a 10ft error of margin, the NIST angle is out by over 9 degrees.

I'm confident in the latter.

NIST out by ~9 degrees.

Significant.

Ten Foot (10ft) Lateral Change in the Camera Position:
[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/draft175-part2_files/image005.gif[/qimg]

Hundred Foot (100ft) Lateral Change in the Camera Position:
[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/draft175-part2_files/image006.gif[/qimg]

NIST in red btw.

Oh, and the above over actual footage...
[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/_ph/6/938786605.gif[/qimg]
Nearly a year on. Must get around to finalising the texts :)

Have to say, having a re-read through this thread has been the source of much entertainment. Hopefully some of the folk who participated now recognise their errors, as some of them are :jaw-dropp
 
Femr2, this serves as a summary of the information you have provided concerning the WTC2 lateral displacement...


870422238.jpg


large version here


611771450.jpg


larger version here



Link to video showing measurement and displacement:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L3mUz-5hVdg&feature=player_embedded




Here's a frame segment with the major direction of motion indicated...

380816983.png




985005859.jpg

(Full timespan)




Start of the *flat period*...frame 6850 on the graph:

240882151.png



End of the *flat period*...frame 6873 on the graph:

819819105.png



29.97fps.


Do you want to add anything or does this seem about right?
 
Last edited:
Nearly a year on. Must get around to finalising the texts :)

Did you ever triangulate this stuff by using 2 different camera angles? I only remember you attempting this using 2D tools. Can't remember if NIST did or not.
 
Nearly a year on. Must get around to finalising the texts :)

If my (new) understanding is correct, NIST underestimated the core damage based on their track.

How does this fit with the Purdue (simulation) study? In your opinion, were they off also?
 
Femr2, in addition to your small study reproduced 3 posts ago, I also did a small study of qualitative ejection features along the east face during early movement here:

78th and 75th Rows of Ejections Sharply Discontinuous


Well, your study and my study fit perfectly by noting your moment of "spring relaxation" or upper-lower section decoupling (frame 6873) is the exact same moment I identify as just before the emergence of the 75th floor row of ejections.


The following gif demonstrates what I mean. It consists of 4 images.

The first 2 images show the range of behavior while eastward displacement is increasing or stationary (tension is maintained).


78th_row21c.gif


The second image takes us to the moment of decoupling or "spring release", or frame 6873 in the video.

The first 2 images show the outward appearance as tension is maintained to the point of snapping. The second 2 images shows building behavior just after tension is released.


The last 2 images in the gif show the emergence of the distinct 75 fl ejections which forcefully appear just after the moment of "spring release".




The moment just before the first appearance of the distinct, discontinuous row of 75th floor ejections is the same moment when the tension snaps between upper and lower portions of the building.
 
Last edited:
distinct 75 fl ejections which forcefully appear

...

distinct, discontinuous row of 75th floor ejections
Stuff flew out of the building. Therefore it "appeared" yes. How something can "forcefully appear" I have no idea. Whether it's "distinct," well, anything that isn't something else can be distinct, I guess. These terms seem to be leading us to some conclusion, here in the world's longest slow-pitch softball game.

Cue the quote:

So what?
 
Stuff flew out of the building. Therefore it "appeared" yes. How something can "forcefully appear" I have no idea. Whether it's "distinct," well, anything that isn't something else can be distinct, I guess. These terms seem to be leading us to some conclusion, here in the world's longest slow-pitch softball game.

Cue the quote:

So what?
I believe he has proved the collapse did not happen in a vacuum.

:rolleyes:
 
How am I to understand how the displacement decreases after the maximum values?
Quite clear by watching the video. Upper block has fragmented and forces even out over the cross-section.

Wrong.

Classic example.
Video raw data is good.
Attempt to interpret meaning of raw data fails.
 
Last edited:
'Twas a reasonable simplified response I rekn. You could formalise, with eccentric verbosity ;), if y'like.

And a rather bizarre thing to bring up. Scraping the barrel one might say.

Perhaps I'll, what is the phrase, review the thread, to make sure none of your mistakes went unnoticed, all of which I'm sure you'd wish to either correct or recognise.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps I'll, what is the phrase, review the thread, to make sure none of your mistakes went unnoticed, all of which I'm sure you'd wish to either correct or recognise.

As soon as your counterpart corrects the errors in his "book" - sound fair?
 
As soon as your counterpart corrects the errors in his "book" - sound fair?
What MT does or does not do has nowt to do with me.

I imagine tfk will be chuffed to bits that you've decided to speak for him though. I'd allow you to respond to his list of gaffs, but do you think that's really a good idea ? ;)
 
In the unintentional irony department - Unless you're talking about fishing hooks, I think you mean gaffes. ;)
 
What MT does or does not do has nowt to do with me.

I imagine tfk will be chuffed to bits that you've decided to speak for him though. I'd allow you to respond to his list of gaffs, but do you think that's really a good idea ? ;)

Come on. You two have been joined at the hip since day one. Batman and Robin.

All you both care about, the ONLY thing you care about, is showing off how awesome you are. We get it. You're NEVER WRONG.

So what?
 
NoahFence, not everyone needs to huddle together in groups. I have used the work of a number of independent researchers. They all tend to think differently from each other.

I test Femr2 measuring techniques against other independent researchers with similar skills. You probably see yourself as a member of a group in which you trust. I would never use the work of an independent researcher who does that; trusting as opposed to verifying and fact-checking.

Groupthink is a dangerous thing when verifying information. Conformity is not a positive quality in a person who works through independent verification.

...................

In retrospect, my personal favorite independent researchers are very independent. I prefer it that way. You seem to see yourself as a member of a group. You also seem to project that same quality on those you see as "other", or outside the group. The concept of independence or verification cannot be understood under such a projection. This is not a sporting event. Not a board game.

What is being observed cannot be understood from a group or team perspective. If one sees through that lens, a simplified division into "us" and "them" and an artificial, false sense of certainty is the inevitable result.

Stanley Milgram:

"A subject who has neither ability nor expertise to make decisions, especially in a crisis, will leave decision making to the group and its hierarchy. The group is the person's behavioral model."

....

"the essence of obedience consists in the fact that a person comes to view themselves as the instrument for carrying out another person's wishes, and they therefore no longer see themselves as responsible for their actions. Once this critical shift of viewpoint has occurred in the person, all of the essential features of obedience follow"
 
Last edited:
NoahFence, not everyone needs to huddle together in groups. I have used the work of a number of independent researchers. They all tend to think differently from each other.

I test Femr2 measuring techniques against other independent researchers with similar skills. You probably see yourself as a member of a group in which you trust. I would never use the work of an independent researcher who does that; trusting as opposed to verifying and fact-checking.

Groupthink is a dangerous thing when verifying information. Conformity is not a positive quality in a person who works through independent verification.

...................

In retrospect, my personal favorite independent researchers are very independent. I prefer it that way. You seem to see yourself as a member of a group. You also seem to project that same quality on those you see as "other", or outside the group. The concept of independence or verification cannot be understood under such a projection. This is not a sporting event. Not a board game.

What is being observed cannot be understood from a group or team perspective. If one sees through that lens, division into "us" and "them" is the inevitable result.

MT - the division of "us" and "them" it totally misunderstood by you.

US (people besides you and FEMR) know full well that your observations are pretty much spot on. You seem to think that "us" are a group of people who don't agree with your observations. That's not the case. What we'd like is the answer to the question "so what".

Why? Because you're on a conspiracy theory subforum, that's why. Is it really too much to ask, that you have a point other than showing us how wonderful your observations are and how competent your methodology is? How does this tie into 9/11 conspiracies? Why are you showing us these observations?

I asked you that question in another thread, and you responded by telling me you'd give a summary of that on a subsequent post, which, unsurpsingly hasn't happend yet.

I've gone through your 'book' - and can find nothing to indicate what the point of this exercise is. It's the same question you've been asked too many times to count.

So what?
What changes?

Can you at least acknowledge that the question has been asked, and you refuse to answer it?
 
Come on. You two have been joined at the hip since day one. Batman and Robin....
I wouldn't agree with that metaphor Noah.

Sure they often walk down the same or similar paths but they are very different in four areas which I notice.
1) At the technical level I rank both of them as top-bracket researchers in their fields but they have a distinctly different focus from what I see.
2) They are nearly diametrically opposed when it comes to the "where does this research lead us" type of question.
3) They are also different in the way they interact in discussions.
4) femr2's posts nearly always have underlying good humour and fun - see the "gaffe" v "gaff' comment in recent posts. M_T does not join in that sort of fun - and that is an observation not criticism.

I agree with both of them that they are individuals. And I suggest members interacting with either of them would be better served to recognise them as individuals.
 
...US (people besides you and FEMR) know full well that your observations are pretty much spot on. You seem to think that "us" are a group of people who don't agree with your observations. That's not the case. What we'd like is the answer to the question "so what"....
My previous post "crossed in the posting" with yours. Despite my comment that femr2 and M_T are have distinctly different posting styles I fully agree that your comments...especially these:
...So what?
What changes?

Can you at least acknowledge that the question has been asked, and you refuse to answer it?
...deserve an answer - which is one reason that I have used your "So what?" question several times recently.
 
'Twas a reasonable simplified response I rekn.

There wasn't anything "reasonable" about it.

The sentence was simply wrong.

If you are now saying that it was "wrong by virtue of simplification", perhaps you'd care to elaborate on what you meant to say.

Using other words that might correctly state your assertion that I quoted.

You could formalise, with eccentric verbosity , if y'like.

Why would I formalize your opinion about this, or any, matter?

Why won't YOU formalize your opinion about this matter?

And a rather bizarre thing to bring up. Scraping the barrel one might say.

I didn't bring it up.
You brought it up.
I read it for the first time this morning.
It's wrong.
I commented that it's wrong.

Please show me the "bizarre" part.

Everything seems quite ordinary in the sequence.
It's happened a hundred times before.

Perhaps I'll, what is the phrase, review the thread, to make sure none of your mistakes went unnoticed, all of which I'm sure you'd wish to either correct or recognise.

How childish is this.

If anyone on this site writes something that someone else thinks is a mistake, the 2nd person points it out & they discuss it.

Suddenly you choose to take the tack, "If someone points out a mistake I make, I'll just point out what I think are your mistakes?"

I invite you to stop behaving like a 10 years old.

I invite you to stop threatening to throw a temper tantrum.

I invite you to address the issue like an adult.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom