The Savitzky-Golay filter is not "mine". It has been around since around 1964 and is fully understood by many, including myself. It is clear than many posters within this forum do not understand it, despite it being described numerous times, and copious links to external resources being provided.You don't understand your own filter.
And ignore your inept and derogitory assertions ? No.I would ignore the old dolt engineer
Assuming you mean Bernard Maybeck, I see no relevance to a filter invented 7 years after his passing.I was lucky to pass Maybeck's class.
Incorrect, though obviously when you ask for links to help you understand I'm going to google "Savitzky Golay", innit.Your knowledge of filters cames from google U.
No. It is more appropriate to show the failings in what you spam here. A better alternative would be for you to ignore the thread.Put me on ignore.
The purpose of them being listed there has been explained to you numerous times, namely that each contain some detail on how to perform computational aspects of descent. Their parameter selection and conclusions are irrelevant. It is a point you raise regularly, which given it's on a web page created in 2009 I find quite funny, though very interesting in terms of your motivation.It is best since your definition of technical papers is 911 truth paranoid conspiracy papers
News to me beachnut. I get mostly moronic crap from all "sides" in my experienceIt is ironic 911 truth nuts on line, on youtube, use your work to push lies about 911, they thank you.
Dear me...you asked...Did not expect an answer in engineering terms.
"When will you define the high frequency noise you are removing using SG?"
I said...
SG methods result in some smoothing of noise, but it is not "removed". Are you sure you understand ?
All smoothing affects both noise and signal.
If you prefer in W.D.Clingers words... To get a usable picture of acceleration, you have to do some smoothing somewhere.
If you like I'll add...it's not just high frequency noise that gets smoothed either, some "low" frequency noise, some high frequency signal, some "low" frequency signal. Smoothing methods are fairly indescriminate, of course.
Yawn.No goals, no conclusions, no engineering.
Yawn.Using methods googled.
Read the thread. Some of it is really funny "in hindsight". The incredible number of ludicrous errors by others...amazing. My own personal consistency and integrity...not shabby at all. Pretty much everything I've said in this thread still holds true, which most certainly can't be said for posts by numerous others who have participated.Not defending your thesis, unable to explain why.
You make no sense. Smoothing is a must. Trend is focus, so smoothing of higher frequency noise preferred over smoothing lower frequency noise, absolutely. Really not interested in the higher frequencies at all, neither noise OR signal.Hide behind other statements because you can't defend using a filter which removes high frequency noise.
Silly thing to say. Also, there's not really any practical way to separate noise from the true signal for the data under discussion. Of course, via processes such as static motion removal the inclusion of noise sources is minimised, unlike the similar data from NIST.The noise is the data
Smoothing is a must. Without appropriate smoothing you end up in tfk's shoes making inept assertions that the data indicates +/- 60ft/s velocity fluctuations, even during periods of no actual building motion. Not wise.you don't want to remove it
As raw as possible, absolutely. Which is why I utilise the Savitzky-Golay filter, enabling me to retain maximum noise and still expose the underlying trend behaviour.you want it to remain raw
That is not my problem, as I've described "my methods" is detail numerous times. Other people seem to have no problem understanding, so I can only assume the issue is with you. It's really not complicated.I don't understand your made up methods
Word salad. Untrue. Read the thread again.and your inability to defend your work with more than google references used without reason.
Certainly seems to be of issue to you beachnut. You've been writing posts like this for years, with very little change in the content. Habitual ?No big deal
I've told you numerous times, my personal details are irrelevant, and, as you say, unknown by you (and everyone else who seems interested).not sure what engineering school you went to
Read the thread.but at the my schools I had to explain in detail and present the reasons with real references. It is your work, defend making data of falling building look like music, low frequency music. It looks better than the data, but it is not the data, and study of the collapse serves no purpose, not stated goals related to 911 truth crazy claims.
I have performed a rather more rigourous full descent timing recently, and provided detail for anyone to replicate it.A stop watch and the many videos is enough to destroy the faster than free-fall nonsense.
The purposes of tracing are not limited to your singular focus.
Say what ?As for tracking objects visually with optical equipment
Correct, though within the limited arena I've refined the processes greatly.you are not and have not developed new techniques
Who are you referring to beyond NIST, Chandler, ...?and the filters you applied are not better than work already done
Say what ?and being done at grad schools in engineering and optics workshops
Yawn.like the engineers I worked with at AFWAL (yes I am old).
Again, no.Put me on ignore
Ignore the thread then.I don't want to study your work