Merged Discussion of femr's video data analysis

Hm actually, part of my interest today is to fathom that ambiguity...
Understood.
...I have no fixed target. I am happy if you respond within your frame of reference (and you do; thanks)...
Yes...but make sure that context/target/frame of reference is clear for every post or point that needs that clarity.
...Oh, I disagree: It became a valid goal in this thread the moment my separate thread to discuss any conclusions to be drawn from the analysis was merged with this thread upon the request of the OP of this thread, femr, by a moderator....
My main point should have been the "big picture" v "details" distinction. Then I missed your point "inclusion follows merger"
...So we (you and I) agree that such proof is unlikely to be forthcoming?...
Yes to unlikely but I remain open to reasoned argument plus evidence - both unlikely.
No. It became a topic when my thread was merged with this here...

Femr2 doesn't have to participate explicitly, but it was upon his request that discussion of consequences be merged into this thread, so I take it that femr2 is cool with debating that topic here. This needs not alter his stated process.

Great, thanks. I read and duly noted. You had written about this before, and I am with you or understand your point of view mostly. I'll therefore not quote and respond to all of your post from here on, just a few minor remarks:...
All agreed and or understood
Huh? :confused: Did you miss a negation here? This would appear like a major modification, even if it does not address foul play....
No - I meant what I said. NIST found that there was a reasoned explanation for initiation. There is no motive for them to review. And what difference does "core led" v "perimeter led" make to the NIST recommendations? So, if NIST was persuaded to revisit it a response along the lines of "Further professional commentary suggests that core led could be an alternate explanation to our earlier perimeter led hypothesis. Since nothing hinges on the distinction we acknowledge this further work" Naturally the "further work" would have to be of professional paper status and with political backing to be considered. Unlikely.
...As an interested non-engineer, I am frankly quite overwhelmed by all the details of both NIST's reports and femr2's analysises (is there a plural to analysis? ^^), so I am happy and thankful for all guidance and elucidation...
It is "analyses" - rest understood.
To me, lots of what is debated here looks like pieces in a large puzzle: Some are already connected and definitely placed, some are connected to some others but not yet in their final position, some are well placed but not yet connected, and some are neither connected nor placed...
Which is the situation as I see it with Major_Tom's "features" - lots of building blocks - not all the blocks in the picture - no overall plan of how the bits fit together to make a whole.
In some regions of this puzzle, I am picking up pieces at random and see if I can place them or not, with the help of the big picture printed on the box, in other regions, I am already proceding quite systematically on my own....
I have been watching with interest. :)
 
Last edited:
And that is significant ... for what and to whom?
Significant in numerous ways...

Significant as-in large. A 9 degree error is a huge error. It's not, as you suggested, a "miniscule deviation". It's a whopping great 9 degrees.

For example, does that alter the basic finding that plane impact damaged a number of load bearing columns

Significant as-in...which columns ? Obviously such a large orientation change will affect which columns are affected.

In this specific case, I'd suggest the change in orientation is more likely to affect the row of columns nearest to the east face than the incorrect NIST orientation.

blew of fireproofing
No-one knows exactly what fireproofing was affected. Is that a significant point for you ?

and started fires on several floors at once
Of course fires were started.

Are you aware of the scenarios in which the NIST model did NOT fail ?

There are some changes applied which made a big difference to the outcome.

A 9 degree change in orientation of the aircraft is not a minor change.

Given that everything that followed was dependant upon that event being correct, it should have been *perfect*. That I can show serious discrepancy, so simply, is ridiculous.

I'll say that again for emphasis...

Very significant sections (and a large proportion) of the report are dependant upon the impact orientation and trajectory of the aircraft.

plane impacts and fires caused WTC2 to collapse? Yes, no, or don't know?
The effect of the change in orientation and trajectory within the NIST simulation is not known (obviously, making it a rather leading question), and they have not peformed the simulation with the changes applied.
 
Last edited:
Significant in numerous ways...

Significant as-in large. A 9 degree error is a huge error. It's not, as you suggested, a "miniscule deviation". It's a whopping great 9 degrees.

You would have to demonstrate that your result is correct before assuming the NIST figure was so far off. The change in position of the reference buildings in this gif would suggest that you have either the wrong camera location or the wrong lens, if not both.
 
You would have to demonstrate that your result is correct before assuming the NIST figure was so far off.
No assumption going on.

The change in position of the reference buildings in this gif would suggest that you have either the wrong camera location or the wrong lens, if not both.
See here, and here.

There are pages and pages of discussion with tfk on the topic kicking around somewhere. Quite happy to drill into detail if you like.

Neither factor you mention would change the results to any significant extent.

There's a margin of error in camera placement, sure. Well <10ft imo. (Note how little the aircraft change within a 10-ft camera position change, and how much the foreground buildings DO. Parallax ;) ) Oh, and extensive discussion with Carmen Taylor wrt where she was helped (which was the same ferry as Hezarkhani)

There's limitations on lens effects via the rendering mechanism (3dsMAX) too, but if you read the linked post (and its links) you'll be in a better position to comment, rather than assume.
 
Last edited:
Significant in numerous ways...

Significant as-in large.

Demonstrating that you still don't understand the definition of the word "significant". Even after it has been explained to you repeatedly.

A 9 degree error is a huge error. It's not, as you suggested, a "miniscule deviation". It's a whopping great 9 degrees.

Except for the fact that you haven't come CLOSE to demonstrating that NIST made a 9 degree error.

Demonstrating their error requires that your nonsense go thru a competent review process. The specific process that you fear will be so humiliating that, after spending YEARS blathering in forums, claiming to have the worlds best data & to have proved NIST wrong …

… you adamantly refuse to take the final, trivial step of pulling it all together & submitting it to some tech journal for publication.

Thereby allowing the world to come genuflect at the foot of the genius, femr…

… or to suffer the humiliation of having your nonsense publicly shredded.

Shredded, as you know it will be. As usual, your ACTIONS (in this case, "inaction") speaks far, far louder than your empty words of lame excuse for choosing to not spread your Gospell according to femr.

AFTER you've had your paper published, and AFTER it has been reviewed and found valid (yeah, like that's ever going to happen…), THEN you can claim to have demonstrated that NIST made an "X degree error" in their analysis.

Till then, nothing but hot air.

Given that everything that followed was dependant upon that event being correct, it should have been *perfect*. That I can show serious discrepancy, so simply, is ridiculous.

That you think that you can show serious discrepancy with such a dodgy "analysis" is amusing.

Dodgy assumptions.
Dodgy analysis.
Dodgy conclusions.

Garbage in, garbage added liberally throughout the cycle, garbage out.

I'll say that again for emphasis...

Very significant sections (and a large proportion) of the report are dependant upon the impact orientation and trajectory of the aircraft.

And I'll say it again, for emphasis.

GIGO.

tk

PS. I find it WAY past "amusing" & well into "surreal" territory that, now that I've 98% stopped posting, you have attempted, in about a half dozen instances that I've seen (& who knows how many that I haven't seen), to use our interactions as support for your positions.

As in "There are pages and pages of discussion with tfk on the topic...". Failing to mention that I conclude that your conclusions are ludicrous.

Similarly, I've seen you quote mine several other posters who think you're both wrong & deceptive, as though they approve of one aspect or another of your nonsense.

Kinda like the Truthers quote mine all manner of sensible people, producing the willfully untruthful deception that those folks agree with their nonsense.

Must suck to be so lacking in support that you're forced to turn to such desperate tactics, eh?
 
Last edited:
So, femr2, why don't you publish your findings?

Or have you already, and we haven't heard about it?
 
So, femr2, why don't you publish your findings?
Or have you already, and we haven't heard about it?


Guys, please, let femr2 analyze his video data in peace.
If he’s right about the planes, 2 feet this-a-way 1 and a half feet that-a-way and the towers would not have collapsed.
We must be patient. Important work like this cannot be hurried.

diane_arbus_child_toy_hand.jpg
 
Last edited:
WTC2 Global Lateral Motion



I'll sync with IB progression soon.

How does it fit with the IB sequence?

For brevity, I will call the 7 symmetric ejections along the 78th fl east face the "Seven Sisters".

I consider the appearance of the Seven Sisters to be a unique and distinct event so it would be nice to see how the tilt matches with the appearance of the Seven Sisters.
.................................

Q: How am I to understand the peak values? Can you show me that moment? Can you show me the point you are tracing?

Q: How am I to understand how the displacement decreases after the maximum values? How much of the tail end data can be trusted? You are saying the displacement maxes out and then begins to return?
 
Last edited:
Are you high? Why do you feel the need to confuse everything you say with your own terminology?


It is a slightly humorous way to combat the steady stream of amnesia in this forum. (think kink! Think kink! ....like that)

You are less likely to forget the "seven sisters" than you are likely to ignore the 7 symmetric ejections right in front of everyones noses.
 
Last edited:
It is a slightly humorous way to combat the steady stream of amnesia in this forum. (think kink! Think kink! ....like that)

You are less likely to forget the "seven sisters" than you are likely to ignore the 7 symmetric ejections right in front of everyones noses.
I see. By using your own terminology you can tell if we're paying attention. You better get to the point fast, I think we're all falling asleep.

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I think you fell asleep a while ago.


If you haven't noticed that the first 2 rows of ejections along the east face are sharply discontinuous and separated by 3 floors for the last 10 years, I would say you have been fast asleep for a long time.


I don't think calling the first row of ejections the "seven sisters" or drawing little breasts on them will help, but anything seems worth a try at this late stage to draw your attention to their obvious presence.
 
Last edited:
I think you fell asleep a while ago.


If you haven't noticed that the first 2 rows of ejections along the east face are sharply discontinuous and separated by 3 floors for the last 10 years, I would say you have been fast asleep for a long time.


I don't think calling the first row of ejections the "seven sisters" or drawing little breasts on them will help, but anything seems worth a try at this late stage to draw your attention to their obvious presence.
Actually we did notice these things. We just didn't consider them noteworthy. Explain again why you think they are? Would it be because no one else did?
 
Actually we did notice these things. We just didn't consider them noteworthy. Explain again why you think they are? Would it be because no one else did?

Because he thinks giving them a sinister name gives them more weight - as something important. When in actuality, it's just silly.

Say, no word from Gage on the donation, eh? Figures.
 
Q: How am I to understand the peak values? Can you show me that moment? Can you show me the point you are tracing?

Q: How am I to understand how the displacement decreases after the maximum values? How much of the tail end data can be trusted? You are saying the displacement maxes out and then begins to return?

 
Do you feel this answers his questions?
It provides the visual information for him to answer them, absolutely. MT has watched similar videos before, and will be able to determine better answers to his questions by watching the video than it's possile to state in a few words.

How am I to understand the peak values?
Easily seen and understood by watching the video. Reaction to tipping upper section.

Can you show me that moment?
It's quite clear when watching the video, but it's ~28s.

How am I to understand how the displacement decreases after the maximum values?
Quite clear by watching the video. Upper block has fragmented and forces even out over the cross-section.

How much of the tail end data can be trusted?
All of it. Video shows the trace location at all times.

You are saying the displacement maxes out and then begins to return?
Absolutely. Can be easily seen by watching the video.


Have you watched the video DGM ? :rolleyes:


If so, is this some code?
Code ? :boggled:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom