Merged Discussion of femr's video data analysis

As soon as your counterpart corrects the errors in his "book" - sound fair?

What MT does or does not do has nowt to do with me.

I imagine tfk will be chuffed to bits that you've decided to speak for him though. I'd allow you to respond to his list of gaffs, but do you think that's really a good idea ? ;)

Sweet dripping irony...

Noah made not the slightest move to "speak for me".
His statement is his own.

In contrast, while (incorrectly) chastising him for something that he didn't do, you then choose to "imagine" (i.e., speak for) how I will react.

Your ankle biting routine has long ago gotten lame.

"... talk to tfk ..." on issues that don't pertain to me.

"... tfk will [think whatever, about whatever] ..."

I have told you, point blank, to not attempt to interpret what I think about anything. You have PROVEN yourself, with pitiable regularity, to be utterly incompetent at that task.

Several people have gotten that message (regarding your opinion about my opinions) quite clearly, and reiterated it to you.

You ignore them. You ignore me.

You seem to be the only one who doesn't seem to comprehend.

Is something about this request too difficult for you to understand?

Or is "annoying ankle biter" the sum of the contributions that you have to offer?
 
The sentence was simply wrong.
Yet you've chosen not to say why.

Why won't YOU formalize your opinion about this matter?
Won't ?

I read it for the first time this morning.
It was written 10th July 2011.

Please show me the "bizarre" part.
Re-read the context of the discussion back then (10th July 2011), then ask yourself what you're doing.

Suddenly you choose to take the tack, "If someone points out a mistake I make, I'll just point out what I think are your mistakes?"
Nah. Been re-reading the thread out of curiosity. Even more tfk gaffEs in it than I recalled. Not pretty.

I invite you to stop behaving like a 10 years old?
Well, do you, or don't you ? You don't sound too sure. If you're after my opinion then I suggest you don't. :)

I invite you to stop threatening to throw a temper tantrum?
In what way would pointing out legitimate mistakes you have made which you have not recognised be having a "temper tantrum" ?

I suggest you look at your own prose to see if you detect anything perhaps written out of emotional response.

I invite you to address the issue like an adult?
What issue would that be Tom ?
 
Noah made not the slightest move to "speak for me".
Suggesting a condition for when you should respond is fine by you then ?

I have told you, point blank, to not attempt to interpret what I think about anything. You have PROVEN yourself, with pitiable regularity, to be utterly incompetent at that task.
I suggest folk have a re-read of this thread, long though it is, with fresh eyes. It really is quite funny.

Or is "annoying ankle biter" the sum of the contributions that you have to offer?
Did you say something about "temper tantrum" recently ?

As I said, I'll, in the interests of clarity and completeness of course, track back through the thread and compile a list of unresolved issues and errors that arose during our, er, discussions. It may take a while, as you had quite a few, but I imagine that won't be a problem given that you're only just getting around to posts written a year ago.
 
1) At the technical level I rank both of them as top-bracket researchers in their fields but they have a distinctly different focus from what I see.


What are their technical fields?

So far as I can recall, they have steadfastly refused to answer that question themselves, and I haven't been able to figure it out on my own.
 
femr2

WTC1 Dan Rather from 7 seconds or more back from collapse of EPHouse- Can you provide a chart with just the raw individual displacement/time data points, no data smoothing, manipulation or curve fitting.
Also for the velocity chart and acceleration chart. Raw data points only ,no smoothing, manipulation, curve fitting.
Also what is the pixel unit dimensions in inches (width , height)

Thanks
 
femr2

WTC17 Dan Rather from 7 seconds or more back from collapse of EPHouse- Can you provide a chart with just the raw individual displacement/time data points, no data smoothing, manipulation or curve fitting.
Also for the velocity chart and acceleration chart. Raw data points only ,no smoothing, manipulation, curve fitting.
Also what is the pixel unit dimensions in inches (width , height)

Thanks
I am very unlikely to invest much more time going round in circles. No offence, but I suggest you read the thread...

14th August 2010, page 1 of the thread...
To save some time, I've uploaded a simple copy of the latest Dan Rather Data.

I imagine we'll be using totally different processing techniques on the data, so best not to pollute the given data with too much of mine...

Download

Columns:

C/D - Raw pixel data for NW corner

F/G - Raw pixel data for static building

I/J - Pixel data for normalised NW corner (Static point data subtracted)

L/M - Pixel data for de-jittered NW corner (simple two point rolling average)

S/T - De-jittered NW corner data in feet (Uses variable scaling metric source values)


The scaling metrics can be modified, but are based on the building width and the visible distance between NW corner and the building it becomes obscured by.

The vertical distance is based upon NIST values, and I'm inclined to spend some more time on it. It's simply a matter of changing the scalar so I've uploaded the data now. We can agree on refined scaling metrics shortly.

Be aware there are various additional datasets, with generally increasing fidelity.
 
Last edited:
WTC1 Dan Rather from 7 seconds or more back from collapse of EPHouse- Can you provide a chart with just the raw individual displacement/time data points, no data smoothing, manipulation or curve fitting.
Also for the velocity chart and acceleration chart. Raw data points only ,no smoothing, manipulation, curve fitting.
If you ignore the models' curves and pay attention only to the plus marks, these graphs (which I posted in May 2011) show the unsmoothed data for position and velocity:

danY2.png


danV2.png


The corresponding graph for acceleration is pretty useless, as almost all of the plus marks would be literally off the chart. To get any usable information about a usable picture of acceleration, you have to do some smoothing somewhere.
 
Last edited:
Oystein, this may be a good place to get an idea of discussions about WTC7 acceleration and the NIST concept of "stage 1" that have been going on for a long time in this forum.
 
Last edited:
Given various shifts in perception of posters in recent months, I strongly urge anyone with enough patience to run through this thread from the top.

Very informative, both about "femr2's video data analysis", and how perception affects the ability of others to make rational response. The number of mistakes, argued ferociously, by others is staggering (and somewhat amusing in hindsight).

Enjoy ;)
 
Given various shifts in perception of posters in recent months, I strongly urge anyone with enough patience to run through this thread from the top.

Very informative, both about "femr2's video data analysis", and how perception affects the ability of others to make rational response. The number of mistakes, argued ferociously, by others is staggering (and somewhat amusing in hindsight).

Enjoy ;)
When will you define the high frequency noise you are removing using SG? ... the noise you remove is the data.

How does this address the OP? ..., you miss tom. How does this debunk 911 truth, while your work has received praise from 911 truth nuts and fuels their delusions? Unable to take a side on 911? You list two 911 truth nut papers as technical papers at your web site. Because you support their failed claims? Does this analysis debunk the two papers of woo by Ross and Kuttler, or does it remain conclusion free, goal free?
 
Last edited:
When will you define the high frequency noise you are removing using SG?
Define ? Probably never.

SG methods result in some smoothing of noise, but it is not "removed". Are you sure you understand ?

... the noise you remove is the data.
See above re "remove", but, to a certain extent, absolutely. All smoothing affects both noise and signal.

If you prefer in W.D.Clingers words... To get a usable picture of acceleration, you have to do some smoothing somewhere.
 
Given various shifts in perception of posters in recent months, I strongly urge anyone with enough patience to run through this thread from the top....
Sounds like a good idea - it's a few years since I reviewed my understanding of numerical methods which is a large part of this topic. :confused:

...Very informative, both about "femr2's video data analysis", and how perception affects the ability of others to make rational response....
"Perception" is a very gentle word....;)

...The number of mistakes, argued ferociously, by others is staggering (and somewhat amusing in hindsight).
I'm tempted to categorise, summarise and give a count of the failings that are obvious to me. :rolleyes:

That may not be easy. I am apprehensive that I may have to wade through a lot of logical failings, personal biases and limited comprehensions searching for the gems of truth and clear thinking lost in the mess. Let's hope I am wrong...:(
 
Define ? Probably never.

SG methods result in some smoothing of noise, but it is not "removed". Are you sure you understand ?


See above re "remove", but, to a certain extent, absolutely. All smoothing affects both noise and signal.

If you prefer in W.D.Clingers words... To get a usable picture of acceleration, you have to do some smoothing somewhere.
You don't understand your own filter. I would ignore the old dolt engineer, I was lucky to pass Maybeck's class. Your knowledge of filters cames from google U. Put me on ignore. It is best since your definition of technical papers is 911 truth paranoid conspiracy papers. It is ironic 911 truth nuts on line, on youtube, use your work to push lies about 911, they thank you.

Did not expect an answer in engineering terms. No goals, no conclusions, no engineering. Using methods googled. Not defending your thesis, unable to explain why. Hide behind other statements because you can't defend using a filter which removes high frequency noise. The noise is the data, you don't want to remove it, you want it to remain raw. I don't understand your made up methods and your inability to defend your work with more than google references used without reason. No big deal, not sure what engineering school you went to, but at the my schools I had to explain in detail and present the reasons with real references. It is your work, defend making data of falling building look like music, low frequency music. It looks better than the data, but it is not the data, and study of the collapse serves no purpose, not stated goals related to 911 truth crazy claims. A stop watch and the many videos is enough to destroy the faster than free-fall nonsense. As for tracking objects visually with optical equipment, you are not and have not developed new techniques, and the filters you applied are not better than work already done, and being done at grad schools in engineering and optics workshops, like the engineers I worked with at AFWAL (yes I am old).

Put me on ignore, I don't want to study your work, it is nonsense you can't defend mathematically, or with engineering analysis. Label the crazy loon papers as woo instead of tech papers, it will raise your engineering stink 1,000 percent.
 
That may not be easy. I am apprehensive that I may have to wade through a lot of logical failings, personal biases and limited comprehensions searching for the gems of truth and clear thinking lost in the mess. Let's hope I am wrong...:(
From Page 14 will exceed your expectations (but not in a good way).
 
From Page 14 will exceed your expectations (but not in a good way).
I don't know what can be done about the comments by debunkers who are clearly out of their depth and cannot objectively address the current discussion.

I may (if I can be bothered) set aside the primary goal of understanding where the truth lies under the ongoing personal attacks from certain prominent members.

If I do the fall back is to identify the various common false responses fired at you by debunkers. Not sure how to classify at this stage - the two options are:
A) by technical detail of the logical error OR
B) by the "process" dimension such as "evasions" or "totally out of my depth so I'll write trivia".

Two of the standard items already obvious are:
1) 'We don't understand research driven by heuristic goals so we echo beachnut style false criticisms about "no goals" etc'
...the error in that should be obvious to any educated person but sadly it isn't - these people who do not understand goals should take time to learn about (at least) the two relevant types of goal.. *(see posts 517>>518>>558 for a typical example)

2) "If it isn't about CD it doesn't belong here" which is utter crap - this sub forum was set up to take all 9/11 related discussion. Plus it is rare to see the false claim gdirected against a person who the claque have not defined as a "Truther". So it is a sub-set of "blue sky syndrome" or more accurately a form of another allele.

3) Plus the comments by engineers which should embarrass any professional engineer. Three main subsets - 1) those who are focussed in detail and have lost the plot so their engineering comment is irrelevant; 2) Those who cannot see beyond a narrow technical focus on engineering when the issue of concern is in the bigger picture of context or logic; AND 3) Those who play the "I'm an engineer - you're not" game THEN proceed to get their engineering wrong. The test is "Is the claim true" NOT "Do I have a bigger degree than the person who made the claim." The underlying psychology of "mine's bigger than yours" should need no explanation.

I think I'll plod on but it is depressing to be reminded of the shallowness of much commentary.

Which does not mean I agree 100% with you but at least you are prepared to face relevant issues.

Cheers. ;)

meanwhle "Nil illegitimi carborundum"!!!
 
Last edited:
...
meanwhle "Nil illegitimi carborundum"!!!

Fake Latin, fake engineering. Irony? What is the high frequency noises removed by SG in the work? Simple question; too deep?

google on, google off

How does this analysis debunk 911 truth claims? Simple question, how deep do you want to go?
 
I don't know what can be done about the comments by debunkers who are clearly out of their depth and cannot objectively address the current discussion.

I may (if I can be bothered) set aside the primary goal of understanding where the truth lies under the ongoing personal attacks from certain prominent members.

If I do the fall back is to identify the various common false responses fired at you by debunkers. Not sure how to classify at this stage - the two options are:
A) by technical detail of the logical error OR
B) by the "process" dimension such as "evasions" or "totally out of my depth so I'll write trivia".

Two of the standard items already obvious are:
1) 'We don't understand research driven by heuristic goals so we echo beachnut style false criticisms about "no goals" etc'
...the error in that should be obvious to any educated person but sadly it isn't - these people who do not understand goals should take time to learn about (at least) the two relevant types of goal.. *(see posts 517>>518>>558 for a typical example)

2) "If it isn't about CD it doesn't belong here" which is utter crap - this sub forum was set up to take all 9/11 related discussion. Plus it is rare to see the false claim gdirected against a person who the claque have not defined as a "Truther". So it is a sub-set of "blue sky syndrome" or more accurately a form of another allele.

3) Plus the comments by engineers which should embarrass any professional engineer. Three main subsets - 1) those who are focussed in detail and have lost the plot so their engineering comment is irrelevant; 2) Those who cannot see beyond a narrow technical focus on engineering when the issue of concern is in the bigger picture of context or logic; AND 3) Those who play the "I'm an engineer - you're not" game THEN proceed to get their engineering wrong. The test is "Is the claim true" NOT "Do I have a bigger degree than the person who made the claim." The underlying psychology of "mine's bigger than yours" should need no explanation.

I think I'll plod on but it is depressing to be reminded of the shallowness of much commentary.

Which does not mean I agree 100% with you but at least you are prepared to face relevant issues.

Cheers. ;)

meanwhle "Nil illegitimi carborundum"!!!



Heuristic (play /hjʉˈrɪstɨk/; or /hyoo-ris-tik/; Greek: "Εὑρίσκω", "find" or "discover") refers to experience-based techniques for problem solving, learning, and discovery. Where the exhaustive search is impractical, heuristic methods are used to speed up the process of finding a satisfactory solution; mental short cuts to ease the cognitive load of making a decision. Examples of this method include using a rule of thumb, an educated guess, an intuitive judgment, or common sense.


Most engineers prefer facts and figures and maths and graphs to using a rule of thumb, an educated guess, an intuitive judgment, or common sense.


The common truther mantra "It doesn't look right" is based on 'common sense' so you're welcome to crawl into that bed if you want to but don't be surprised if you get a few fleas.
 
...
Most engineers prefer facts and figures and maths and graphs to using a rule of thumb, an educated guess, an intuitive judgment, or common sense.

The common truther mantra "It doesn't look right" is based on 'common sense' so you're welcome to crawl into that bed if you want to but don't be surprised if you get a few fleas.

Don't see how this applies to ozeco. Or femr2.

Can you explain?

Femr2 uses precisely facts and figures and maths and graphs, and receives an awful lot of flag - often from debunkers who use a rule of thumb, an educated guess, an intuitive judgment, or common sense.
Would you disagree with that assessment?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom