Merged Discussion of femr's video data analysis

Yes. That's why I asked what I did. So you expect him to interpret this video to answer the questions he asked. Why not just answer them?

As I said...
MT has watched similar videos before, and will be able to determine better answers to his questions by watching the video than it's possible to state in a few words.

I'm sure that if the video does not suffice for him, he'll say so.
 
femr2:
I've worked in tall buildings for a long time. Your graph shows that the building shifted around the time of the IB (I'll use your terms). I've been in shorter buildings that moved more in a moderate wind. Why do you think it's important to show what most people (with tall build knowledge) would consider obvious?
 
Because he thinks giving them a sinister name gives them more weight - as something important. When in actuality, it's just silly.


As to whether you consider the word "sister" to be sinister, I guess that would depend on ones own experiences with ones own sisters.
 
femr2:
I've worked in tall buildings for a long time. Your graph shows that the building shifted around the time of the IB (I'll use your terms). I've been in shorter buildings that moved more in a moderate wind. Why do you think it's important to show what most people (with tall build knowledge) would consider obvious?

You are suggesting that the motion is normal ? And emphasising your, er, point by stating your tall building experience (by being in them) ? :eye-poppi

The motion is caused by the tilting upper section.

Simple action/reaction on a very large scale.

It's a fairly obvious behaviour given the motion of the top third of the building, sure.

But likening it to wind (with your tall building occupancy experience) is really very silly.

Do you plan to post how this is significant soon, or should we just leave you two alone?
I'm simply looking at timing between IB and global motion. That you require everything to be significant to some extent of your own personal scale, or sinister in some way is rather telling.

You add nothing to the discussion, so if by *we* you mean you, and you require every post to contain sinister significance, then, yes, I'd leave the discussion if I were you.
 
You are suggesting that the motion is normal ?

Would you consider the evebts leading up yo your graph "normal"?

And emphasising your, er, point by stating your tall building experience (by being in them) ? :eye-poppi

The motion is caused by the tilting upper section.

Simple action/reaction on a very large scale.

It's a fairly obvious behaviour given the motion of the top third of the building, sure.

But likening it to wind (with your tall building occupancy experience) is really very silly.

But I did not liken it to wind. I was just using that as an example of the fact buildings move.
I'm simply looking at timing between IB and global motion. That you require everything to be significant to some extent of your own personal scale, or sinister in some way is rather telling.

Not telling at all. I'm saying buildings move and shift. Your saying "look at this building move and shift". My point is, no ****!
 
Femr, it seems pretty easy to locate a "breaking of the hinge" from your video and data, don't you think?

I use 2 distinct observables when comparing the video with the data:

1) Emergence of the Seven Sisters
2) Emergence of the 75th fl row of ejections


In the 5 stages of collapse initiation I posted earlier, I state that tilting does not begin until the emergence of the Seven Sisters. This seems to be true for displacement according to your data.

I place the release point or the "breaking of the hinge" just after the 75th fl ejections emerge. This also seems to match well with your data as the maximum value of displacement.

According to the 5 stage initiation scenario, the "hinge" is broken when the west MER perimiter is forcefully ejected from the building with beam flooring still attached.

Do you agree that the "breaking of the hinge" happens just after the emergence of the 75th fl east face row of ejections?
 
Do you agree that the "breaking of the hinge" happens just after the emergence of the 75th fl east face row of ejections?

It would make sense that the point where the lower building deflection begins returning to normal would coincide with the *breaking of the hinge*, as the mass distribution and forces upon the lower tower will clearly change drastically at that point.
 
870422238.jpg


Femr, what do you think of the shape of the displacement plot?
Ii think it is like a state transition. The maximum point shows when the upper leaning portion effectively becomes decoupled from the lower structure.

From the other info gathered it looks like the maximum shows a "breaking of the hinge", meaning the 500 row core columns fail as a unit at this moment. After this there is a clear relaxation of the westward force on the lower structure.

I think I know when that moment is from other observations. Could you please post a still image of the moment the maximum value starts to drop? I want to see the evolution of the 75th fl row of ejections at that moment.


75th_floor.jpg



This is an example of a moment in which the 75th fl ejections have emerged. The red line marks the 75th floor. The rectangle shows a MER panel section along the NW corner that is still visible.

I am guessing the moment the displacement starts to relax is during or just after this moment.
 
Last edited:
Could you please post a still image of the moment the maximum value starts to drop? I want to see the evolution of the 75th fl row of ejections at that moment.

75th_floor.jpg

Sure...

Start of the *flat period*...frame 6850 on the graph...fair bit earlier than your image above...

240882151.png



End of the *flat period*...frame 6873 on the graph...

819819105.png


Your image looks to be frame 6883.

29.97fps if you want to work out timings.
 
Last edited:
I consider the appearance of the Seven Sisters to be a unique and distinct event so it would be nice to see how the tilt matches with the appearance of the Seven Sisters.
.................................

So what's the anaomaly?

The ext columns break at their connections.

The connections are between spandrels.

So are the windows.

So the windows are broken when the connections break.

So any air being squeezed out by the descending upper block/any falling floors preferentially would go out the broken windows.
 
Femr, I will need to see the evolution of the IB and the state of the Seven Sisters during the moment when the displacement first becomes noticable.

870422238.jpg


Around frame 6770, 6780. I want to be able to sychronize a close-up of IB and the Seven Sisters with the earliest moment of noticable displacement.


yhtyj.gif


It would be nice to match moments like the gif shows with frames in your plot.
 
Last edited:
Myself, achimspok, and a few others. Why ?
Honestly, I was just curious. You have a habit of writing in the passive voice nd leaving subjects out of sentences. As you apparently did some real-world research, I compliment you on this.

Separately, your dissembling on "MIHOP" is hilarious humpty-dumpty-esque.
 
Honestly, I was just curious.
Odd.

You have a habit of writing in the passive voice nd leaving subjects out of sentences.
Incorrect.

As you apparently did some real-world research, I compliment you on this.
I do a lot of real-world research. Disguised insult noted.

Separately, your dissembling on "MIHOP" is hilarious humpty-dumpty-esque.
Rule 0.
Rule 12.
Off topic.
 
Femr, I will need to see the evolution of the IB and the state of the Seven Sisters during the moment when the displacement first becomes noticable.
Haven't got around to the video sync yet, but a closer look at the displacement behaviour might be useful...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom