Dems push back on Hilary Rosen's comments about Momney

Why does that matter to you?

My mom stayed home and raised four kids, and didn't work for a paying job outside the home again until my younger brother turned 12. That meant that my mom and dad, among other things, had to be smart with a buck, which they were. We lacked for nothing.

You got a problem with that?

If so, why?

I don´t think that´s the problem. Your mom worked - "worked" as in "in a formal job" - before raising you guys, and so did mine for that matter. Did Ann Romney do that same?

The question isn´t "is raising kids a lot of work", or "is staying home to raise your kids a respectable choice" - it is "has Ann Romney ever had the experience of having to work for a living" and "has Ann Romney ever had to decide between raising her kids and earning badly needed money"?
 
Yes, because that is what truly defines a person (to some).

Exactly.

Like Mitt Romney:

"I wanted to increase the work requirement," said Romney. "I said, for instance, that even if you have a child 2 years of age, you need to go to work. And people said, 'Well that's heartless.' And I said, 'No, no, I'm willing to spend more giving day care to allow those parents to go back to work. It'll cost the state more providing that daycare, but I want the individuals to have the dignity of work.'"

Because if you don't work, you've got no dignity, and no, being at home with your kids doesn't count.
 
That's a pretty deliberate misreading. What isn't dignified, according to that argument, is living off the government dole. You may disagree about the dignity of such welfare dependency, but that's what he's claiming. And it's not a new argument either, which is why I have a hard time believing your misreading was accidental. Conservatives have been arguing that government dependency takes away dignity for decades.

One misreading in exchange for another. Karmically it balances out :cool: .
 
That's a pretty deliberate misreading. What isn't dignified, according to that argument, is living off the government dole. You may disagree about the dignity of such welfare dependency, but that's what he's claiming. And it's not a new argument either, which is why I have a hard time believing your misreading was accidental. Conservatives have been arguing that government dependency takes away dignity for decades.

So, Mitt Romney supports not just spending government money, but spending more government money than we're spending now, just so people can feel better about themselves?

Huh.
 
Last edited:
So, Mitt Romney supports not just spending government money, but spending more government money than we're spending now, just so people can feel better about themselves?

Huh.

I really don't know how you got any cost estimates from something so vague as Romney's comments in that link, but I'm impressed that you could. Can you give us ballpark dollar figures?
 
I really don't know how you got any cost estimates from something so vague as Romney's comments in that link, but I'm impressed that you could. Can you give us ballpark dollar figures?

Hey, I'm just going by what Romney himself said. "It'll cost the state more providing that daycare."

Are you saying Romney was either ignorant or lying when he said that?
 
Why does that matter to you?

My mom stayed home and raised four kids, and didn't work for a paying job outside the home again until my younger brother turned 12. That meant that my mom and dad, among other things, had to be smart with a buck, which they were. We lacked for nothing.

You got a problem with that?

If so, why?

Nope, no problem with your mom.
With you, yes.
Is your mom AR?
Does she have magic underpants?

So, did AR ever work a day in her life?-And does she have to be smart with a buck?
 
That's a pretty deliberate misreading. What isn't dignified, according to that argument, is living off the government dole. You may disagree about the dignity of such welfare dependency, but that's what he's claiming. And it's not a new argument either, which is why I have a hard time believing your misreading was accidental. Conservatives have been arguing that government dependency takes away dignity for decades.

What you are ignoring is that he was using the same definition of "work" that Hillary Rosen was crucified for.

Besides, they are still "living off the government dole" under Romney's plan. Either way, they get money from the government, even more money according to Romney when they work because the government pays another person to provide childcare while the parent works. He says that it is more dignified to be dependent on the government as long as you "work," and staying at home and raising kids doesn't count. So, no, I don't think I misread what he said.
 
What you are ignoring is that he was using the same definition of "work" that Hillary Rosen was crucified for.

The problem with what Rosen said isn't actually what definition of "work" she used. I know the response hammered her on that point, because that's what works well in soundbites on TV, but it's not actually that relevant.

Besides, they are still "living off the government dole" under Romney's plan.

To a degree, yes. But it's still seen as a step in the right direction, because not all of your support is coming from the government.
 
The problem with what Rosen said isn't actually what definition of "work" she used. I know the response hammered her on that point, because that's what works well in soundbites on TV, but it's not actually that relevant.

So what was the problem? That she said something objectively true but mean-spirited about Romney?
 
So what was the problem? That she said something objectively true but mean-spirited about Romney?

The problem was that it was an ad hominem attack. That's already been pointed out repeatedly now in this thread.
 
Back in January, Mitt didn't think that raising kids was work, or even dignified:



Raising kids: not work, not dignified, according to Mitt.

Raising your kids while your husband works is not remotely the same thing as raising your kids on welfare. For one thing, there is a five-year lifetime limit on benefits on welfare, which means that women need to be transitioning to a job.
 
Raising your kids while your husband works is not remotely the same thing as raising your kids on welfare.
How is that responsive? Did Mitt make a distinction? If raising kids is so important then why not provide resources for women who stay at home? Or was that all just BS, as I strongly suspect? IMO: For the GOP, it is only women who can afford to stay at home that are important and who deserve a choice, right? Otherwise pick up your time card and report to work. Oh, and let's overlook the fact that Romney had domestic help at some point in her responsibilities of raising kids. Really tough choice, "good work if you can get it" is what most of us would call it. Of course Democrats can't speak the truth. Romney gets a pass on that parcel of horse ****.
 
Last edited:
I suspect that is what Hilary Rosen did for quite awhile
Rosen wasn't a hypochrite. She pointed out that never doing anything but staying home and overseeing the domestic help in between trips to aspen doesn't make you an expert on economics. Personally I think she has a point. I know that doesn't play with the outraged (outraged I tell ya) crowd but she did have a god damn point. Mrs. Romney was neither an expert in economics (and I would add, nor was she a domestic).
 
How is that responsive? Did Mitt make a distinction? If raising kids is so important then why not provide resources for women who stay at home? Or was that all just BS? Only women who can afford to stay at home are important?

Single parents generally get tons of crap, especially those on welfare. We need to cut them off and make them financially dependent to stay in their bad marriages, don'tcha know?

"Welfare" can cover a few programs, but we generally give deductions for people who pay for daycare (this varies by State). Personally, I think a public or even voucher system would be better, but that would be socialism :p .
 
How is that responsive? Did Mitt make a distinction?
In context of that quote? Yes! He was talking about getting people daycare so they can get off the dole. These are people who have no choice about going to work because they have nobody to watch their kids. If they have government daycare, then they have choices. So yes, he is making the distinction between people who choose to stay hom to raise children and people who don't have that choice.

Come on people, it doesn't actually balance out karmically to misread Mitt Romney to even out Hillary Rosen.

If raising kids is so important then why not provide resources for women who stay at home?
Because he wasn't talking about that when he made that statement. Gah! Is he supposed to have preternatural vision so he can see that twenty years form now a statement of welfare reform will be used to discern his opinion of stay-at-home moms who aren't on welfare? Must he ensure that every statement he makes contains every caveat and nuance that any issue that might ever be raised for which this statement might be used or misused?

Criminy, people. How far are we skeptics willing to go to abandon all pretense at critical thinking in the name of political grandstanding?
 
Because he wasn't talking about that when he made that statement. Gah! Is he supposed to have preternatural vision so he can see that twenty years form now a statement of welfare reform will be used to discern his opinion of stay-at-home moms who aren't on welfare? Must he ensure that every statement he makes contains every caveat and nuance that any issue that might ever be raised for which this statement might be used or misused?
You got some link to show that he does advocate for paid child care to allow moms to get a job?

Most of his lot are against day care.
 
I'm not defending Romney. I'm defending rational argument. If Hilary Rosen was taken out of context, show the context. You don't respond to that by taking someone else out of context and then, when that's pointed out, demand that they disprove the lack of context!

Are there any actual skeptics in the politics forums?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom