Dems push back on Hilary Rosen's comments about Momney

Mittens put a target on his wife's back when he identified her as a source for his positions on women's issues. It is not, therefore, wrong for anyone to assess her ability to relate to the concerns of 99% of women in the country.

If she is at all cognizant of and concerned about the plight of working women, then either she has not properly communicated those concerns to that vulture capitalist hubby of hers, or he isn't paying much attention to her. His suggestions on ecconomic matters sure do not show any appreciation of the concerns of working people, male or female. Like his idea that it would be better for everybody if the vultures were able to come in and grab all of the distressed properties and rent them back to people.

Maybe those two rich parasites think it is not that hard to come back from a financial disaster. Nobdoy who has to work for a living sees it that way.

Ann's opinions on what working families need doesn't matter much to anybody who knows what is going on out here in the real world.

She neds a thicker skin or greater annonymity, and her nutjob hubby needs to be a little more careful about exposing her to ridicule. He shouldn't have blamed any part of his stupidity on her.
 
lefftysergeant said:
Mittens put a target on his wife's back when he identified her as a source for his positions on women's issues. It is not, therefore, wrong for anyone to assess her ability to relate to the concerns of 99% of women in the country.

Okay, Romney's initial statement about looking to his wife for an issue was one of those things we are all supposed to smile and clap for. Rosen made the mistake of treating it seriously.
 
I think she was thinking about the fact that Ann's husband is richer than God rather than the fact that she is a SAHM.

That was how I took it. Or more generally, that she's always enjoyed a life of privilege and has never had to work.
_______

Somewhere in this discussion, someone (I think from Romney's campaign staff) said that stay at home moms work harder than people who work outside the home. While I don't disparage stay at home moms, I know of plenty of single, working moms who would strongly disagree with that. They're doing everything a stay-at-home mom does PLUS working outside the home.
 
Guess whose wife hated staying home with the kids and said it made her ill?

Here, have some context with that. From the preceding paragraph:
"It was a gift having my mother home every day. I want my kids to feel that way," she says. But having experienced the pleasures of work outside the home, she is reluctant to give up her independence. "Work is rewarding," she says. "I love losing myself in a set of problems that have nothing to do with my husband and children. Once you've tasted that, it's hard to walk away."

Michelle Obama enjoys working outside the home, she finds it rewarding and her job offers challenges that child-rearing can not. Staying at home when the kids were young was boring. It gave her a headache.

You are obviously trying to paint Mrs. Obama as some sort of horrible person because she wants more than just motherhood but I can't see how that is a bad thing.
 
That was how I took it. Or more generally, that she's always enjoyed a life of privilege and has never had to work.
_______

Somewhere in this discussion, someone (I think from Romney's campaign staff) said that stay at home moms work harder than people who work outside the home. While I don't disparage stay at home moms, I know of plenty of single, working moms who would strongly disagree with that. They're doing everything a stay-at-home mom does PLUS working outside the home.

Thanks, Joe. Well put.

Now, did AR ever work a day in her life, or, not?
 
Thanks, Joe. Well put.

Now, did AR ever work a day in her life, or, not?

Why does that matter to you?

My mom stayed home and raised four kids, and didn't work for a paying job outside the home again until my younger brother turned 12. That meant that my mom and dad, among other things, had to be smart with a buck, which they were. We lacked for nothing.

You got a problem with that?

If so, why?
 
Here, have some context with that. From the preceding paragraph:


Michelle Obama enjoys working outside the home, she finds it rewarding and her job offers challenges that child-rearing can not. Staying at home when the kids were young was boring. It gave her a headache.

I don't deny that kids generally are boring. They certainly aren't intellectually stimulating. So why do we spend time with them? Is there some other factor in the equation?

Oh, yes, there is the impact on them. They don't find their parents boring at all, and they do find them intellectually stimulating.

You are obviously trying to paint Mrs. Obama as some sort of horrible person because she wants more than just motherhood but I can't see how that is a bad thing.

Not a horrible person by any means. Just self-absorbed. Indeed, I got quite a chuckle out of a following paragraph:
When she mentioned it to her mother, Marian Robinson told her daughter she didn't think Michelle could handle the boredom of staying home with kids. Obama was surprised to hear that taking care of her had been boring, but now she embraces the idea of discussing it openly.
(Italics added for emphasis)

Moi? Boring? :D
 
Why does that matter to you?

My mom stayed home and raised four kids, and didn't work for a paying job outside the home again until my younger brother turned 12. That meant that my mom and dad, among other things, had to be smart with a buck, which they were. We lacked for nothing.

There was an old expression that made more sense back in the days when dads went to work and the women stayed home:

A man works from sun to sun, but a woman's work is never done.
 
That was how I took it. Or more generally, that she's always enjoyed a life of privilege and has never had to work.
_______

Somewhere in this discussion, someone (I think from Romney's campaign staff) said that stay at home moms work harder than people who work outside the home. While I don't disparage stay at home moms, I know of plenty of single, working moms who would strongly disagree with that. They're doing everything a stay-at-home mom does PLUS working outside the home.


How is this possible?

A more accurate statement might be: "single working moms can adequately perform parenting duties while also working outside the home"
 
Most working moms still have all the at-home responsibilities that nonworking moms have, with work on top of it.
 
Back in January, Mitt didn't think that raising kids was work, or even dignified:

“I wanted to increase the work requirement,” said Romney. “I said, for instance, that even if you have a child 2 years of age, you need to go to work. And people said, ‘Well that’s heartless.’ And I said, ‘No, no, I’m willing to spend more giving day care to allow those parents to go back to work. It’ll cost the state more providing that daycare, but I want the individuals to have the dignity of work.”

Raising kids: not work, not dignified, according to Mitt.
 
Back in January, Mitt didn't think that raising kids was work, or even dignified:



Raising kids: not work, not dignified, according to Mitt.

Sort of ends the thread, doesn't it? Staying at home used to be without dignity. So get your asses out there and get a real job, ladies!

Oh, and Ann Romney never worked a day in her life. Still.
 
I don't deny that kids generally are boring. They certainly aren't intellectually stimulating. So why do we spend time with them? Is there some other factor in the equation?

Oh, yes, there is the impact on them. They don't find their parents boring at all, and they do find them intellectually stimulating.



Not a horrible person by any means. Just self-absorbed. Indeed, I got quite a chuckle out of a following paragraph:

(Italics added for emphasis)

Moi? Boring? :D

If having kids means that parents are supposed to dedicate every moment to them, to have no outside interests and no job, then where does the money to raise those children come from?
 
Back in January, Mitt didn't think that raising kids was work, or even dignified:

That's a pretty deliberate misreading. What isn't dignified, according to that argument, is living off the government dole. You may disagree about the dignity of such welfare dependency, but that's what he's claiming. And it's not a new argument either, which is why I have a hard time believing your misreading was accidental. Conservatives have been arguing that government dependency takes away dignity for decades.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom