Dems push back on Hilary Rosen's comments about Momney

applecorped

Banned
Joined
Mar 8, 2008
Messages
20,145
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs...e-to-struggle/2012/04/12/gIQA9tOqCT_blog.html


"Democrats have engaged in a full-court press in pushing back on strategist Hilary Rosen’s comment on CNN Wednesday night that as a wealthy stay-at-home-mom Ann Romney “never worked a day in her life.”

“I could not disagree with Hilary Rosen any more strongly. Her comments were wrong and family should be off limits. She should apologize,” campaign manager Jim Messina said in a tweet.
Top strategist David Axelrod chimed in: “Also Disappointed in Hilary Rosen’s comments about Ann Romney. They were inappropriate and offensive.”




Yeah, Momney. I like the sound of that.:cool:
 
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs...e-to-struggle/2012/04/12/gIQA9tOqCT_blog.html


"Democrats have engaged in a full-court press in pushing back on strategist Hilary Rosen’s comment on CNN Wednesday night that as a wealthy stay-at-home-mom Ann Romney “never worked a day in her life.”

“I could not disagree with Hilary Rosen any more strongly. Her comments were wrong and family should be off limits. She should apologize,” campaign manager Jim Messina said in a tweet.
Top strategist David Axelrod chimed in: “Also Disappointed in Hilary Rosen’s comments about Ann Romney. They were inappropriate and offensive.”
After hearing what she said, I was more inclined to think the offensive sentence was more of an introduction to her main thought which followed. But politics being what it is, such a connection wasn't made by others.

Fair enough. It's good to see the apology and the Democratic leaders (and -mo) make their comments. It was especially good to hear the president say wives should be off limits.

Edit - actually thinking more, I see this not much different then Romney's "I like to fire people" comment. I didn't see (when in context) that being an issue either.
 
Last edited:
She did apologize.

But ya know, as much respect as I have for stay-at-home moms, they still have little or no experience with an employer-employee relationship, and as such, are somewhat less qualified to make meaningful commentary on the business environment. And another thing is that while SAHMs are totally deserving of respect, working moms have to do everythign SAHMs do, plus work. Which one deserves more respect?

Yeah, everybody is clamoring to apologize for Hilary's comments, but in all honesty, there is at least some truth there.
 
She did apologize.

But ya know, as much respect as I have for stay-at-home moms, they still have little or no experience with an employer-employee relationship, and as such, are somewhat less qualified to make meaningful commentary on the business environment. And another thing is that while SAHMs are totally deserving of respect, working moms have to do everythign SAHMs do, plus work. Which one deserves more respect?

Yeah, everybody is clamoring to apologize for Hilary's comments, but in all honesty, there is at least some truth there.


Mom always liked you best.:cool:
 
She did apologize.

But ya know, as much respect as I have for stay-at-home moms, they still have little or no experience with an employer-employee relationship, and as such, are somewhat less qualified to make meaningful commentary on the business environment. And another thing is that while SAHMs are totally deserving of respect, working moms have to do everythign SAHMs do, plus work. Which one deserves more respect?

Yeah, everybody is clamoring to apologize for Hilary's comments, but in all honesty, there is at least some truth there.
When considering the context, there is a ton of truth, but how would that help the Republicans?
 
Hilary was a stay at home mom herself for several years. While I think it's foolish to dismiss the opinions of stay at home mothers on economics out of hand, they certainly don't have any special insight into it either.

And while I think it's wrong to bring people's families into politics, it's also wrong to say that it was Hilary who did so. Romney was the one citing his wife's opinion as a way to blatantly dodge questions about women's rights.

Hilary was wrong in that opening, but not in the ways many people are saying she was.
 
Ann Romney isn't a "stay at home mom" in the sense that she quit her job to raise kids. She's obscenely wealthy and had a large staff of people helping her and never needed a job and never will. Pointing that out isn't an insult to stay at home moms. But comparing her lavish lifestyle riding her dressage horses to average Americans, is.
 
Meh. Mrs Romney never had to work for a living or feel the pinch of gender-based wage discrimination. She is not really a good conduit from working women to the ear of her hubby.

Republicons need to get a life.
 
Cheap shot.

Even David Axelrod called that comment "inappropriate and offensive."

"What she said was absolutely out of bounds," said DNC Executive Director Patrick Gaspard on MSNBC. "Ann Romney is someone who obviously has worked hard to raise five good boys and she's made some tough choices in her life, I'm certain. Families should be absolutely out of bounds in this discussion."He added: "Hillary Rosen is absolutely not a paid adviser to the DNC or to the Obama campaign, absolutely not."
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap...VL9OSQ?docId=024963fe8d29474dabbc005643a4d7fc
 
Last edited:
Hilary Rosen - Democratic strategist
(Ann Romney) "has actually never worked a day in her life"

Ann Romney
"I made a choice to stay home and raise five boys. Believe me, it was hard work."


I'm sure it was work to raise 5 boys, absolutely. All mothers work hard, sure. If Mitt Romney is trying to use Ann as someone who can relate to women's issues he once again shows how out of touch he is. Ann Romney was able to make the choice to stay home because her husband is wealthy. Just by having a choice to work for a paycheck or not sets her apart from most women. Being able to stay home with your children has become a privilege of the well-off that few women are in the lucky position to make.

http://www.salon.com/2012/04/12/ann_romney_should_apologize/singleton/
http://www.examiner.com/political-b...wife-to-choose-what-most-american-women-can-t
 
Let me tell you about a hardworking mother, Jammie Thomas of Minnesota. Thomas was sued by the RIAA after she downloaded 24 songs from the internet. This is what the RIAA had to say about the jury found her liable for $1.5 million in damages in 2010 (that's $62,500 per song she downloaded):

We are again thankful to the jury for its service in this matter and that they recognized the severity of the defendant's misconduct.

It can't be said of Hilary Rosen that she's never worked a day in her life. She was the president of the RIAA from 1994 to 2003 and she aggressively lobbied Congress for stricter digital copyright laws.
 
Rosen is a whacktard Communist swine.

Communist? No, she's not a communist.

She is, however, a bought and paid for shill for the recording industry, and one of the people responsible for SOPA.

iowahawkrosentweet.jpg
 
You could have addressed her comment. Heck, you could have addressed her comment by quoting her out of context. But no, you post this.
Rosen is a whacktard Communist swine.
Let me tell you about a hardworking mother, Jammie Thomas of Minnesota. Thomas was sued by the RIAA after she downloaded 24 songs from the internet. This is what the RIAA had to say about the jury found her liable for $1.5 million in damages in 2010 (that's $62,500 per song she downloaded):



It can't be said of Hilary Rosen that she's never worked a day in her life. She was the president of the RIAA from 1994 to 2003 and she aggressively lobbied Congress for stricter digital copyright laws.
Communist? No, she's not a communist.

She is, however, a bought and paid for shill for the recording industry, and one of the people responsible for SOPA.
Republicans never fail to live down to my expectations.
 
A commie who worked exceptionally hard at protecting property laws, specifically copyright? She might have missed a few meetings.

Ad hom was the mistake that Rosen made.
 
You could have addressed her comment.

What is there to address? It was cheap identity politics, and not even effective identity politics. It was, in fact, exactly what you criticize me for: an ad hominem attack against Ann Romney which avoided actually addressing the Romney campaign's criticism of Obama's economic record. So the irony of you getting upset at me for doing to Hillary what she did to Ann is hardly lost on me. Except that there's nothing wrong with being a stay at home mom, but there IS something wrong with being a shill for the RIAA and backing legislation like SOPA. Plus, this is just an internet message board, and I'm nobody, whereas Hillary was speaking on national news, as a Democratic strategist.

Republicans never fail to live down to my expectations.

Funny, I don't think I've ever stated my party affiliation here. I won't say democrats have lived down to my expectations, but I will say you have. Oh, and Hillary Rosen. She's a bitch.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom