Dems push back on Hilary Rosen's comments about Momney

One of the reasons I took a six month vacation from JREF was I was getting really burned out on the double standard that often prevails here on both sides': If my side does it it is great and OK, if the other side does it it is evil and and a outrage.

When what it should be is a group of skeptics should be able to dig through the fertilizer and look at the situation without dogmatic bias.

That doesn't seem to happen much on here when the discussion involves politics.
 
When what it should be is a group of skeptics should be able to dig through the fertilizer and look at the situation without dogmatic bias.

That doesn't seem to happen much on here when the discussion involves politics.

Welcome to the JREF Politics subforum, where critical thinking comes to die. ;)
 
Attacking a candidate's wife when she has done nothing really outrageous is just plain bad politics. A little surprised that someone as experienced in the political world as Rosen made a rookie mistake like that.

If anything, I would say that she should know better than to string words together in a way that could be used as a sound bite against her. Her comment would have come off better if she said "How would she know about economic hardship, they have so much money that she never had to work a day in her life"
 
When what it should be is a group of skeptics should be able to dig through the fertilizer and look at the situation without dogmatic bias.

That doesn't seem to happen much on here when the discussion involves politics.

Two things never to get into a conversation about, politics and religion. It is too bad that without politics and religion, there wouldn't be so much to talk about here.
 
When what it should be is a group of skeptics should be able to dig through the fertilizer and look at the situation without dogmatic bias.

That doesn't seem to happen much on here when the discussion involves politics.

Hey, it ain' t for nothing that the Politics sections of JREF have been termed "It's where rational thought goes to die on JREF".
 
But it makes the person making the shot look bad. It's bad politics and rubs a lot of people the wrong way. Dumb move.

It wasn't a "move". It was an offhand comment from someone not employed by either Obama or the DNC.

It's still true. The Romneys are a walking example of the 1% and whining about some pundit isn't going to change that.
 
One of the reasons I took a six month vacation from JREF was I was getting really burned out on the double standard that often prevails here on both sides': If my side does it it is great and OK, if the other side does it it is evil and and a outrage.

You forgot the "Foreigners laughing at the suggestion that Democrats are left wing" or "Republicans are so right wing they wouldn't be elected dog catcher in our country" options.:D
 
I'm not interested in starting a personal war with anyone so I made a choice not to quote anyone directly.

Saying i'm projecting is awfully convenient. I see this stuff happen in this forum constantly. Someone says something innocuous from a conservative perspective and gets crucified. But you can claim to wish people dead, make fun of their wives and children and as long as they are Republicans, well it's okay.

It's like people want a war or something....

One of the reasons I took a six month vacation from JREF was I was getting really burned out on the double standard that often prevails here on both sides': If my side does it it is great and OK, if the other side does it it is evil and and a outrage.

Welcome to the JREF Politics subforum, where critical thinking comes to die. ;)

Biden condemned what she said, president Obama condemned what she said, the first lady condemned what she said, several of us 'leftists' in this very thread have called out her ad-hom as being wrong, yet these accusations still fly?

Pay less attention to the conservative victim playing script and more attention to what people are actually saying. Address that and not the straw men in your heads.
 
Go back and read the first page of this thread. (not to mention this isn't the first time I have experienced these same types of reactions on here)

You may not have acted this way, and hence my post is not directed at you. There is no "victimology" afoot here, I'm calling em how I see em and I see a group of supposed skeptics becoming very dogmatic when politics are the subject at hand.

Your defensive reaction is unnecessary since you weren't involved unless you feel the others require you to defend them.
 
No one in this thread has said it's alright to make fun of wives and children. If I missed it point it out. Your entire post that I quoted was 'victimology' and straw.
 
the whole goddamn first page is one big attack on Republicans. The whole damn USA politics boards is one big attack on republicans.

Calling it victimology cuz I have the balls to stand up for myself is weak. You sir are weak. Weak, little man.
 
the whole goddamn first page is one big attack on Republicans. The whole damn USA politics boards is one big attack on republicans.

Calling it victimology cuz I have the balls to stand up for myself is weak. You sir are weak. Weak, little man.

You're the one who called it 'victimology', but if it means what I think it means, it fits. The entire first page is not one big attack on Republicans. My first post wasn't, although it did contain a criticism of Romney for dodging questions by using his wife to try to change the topic and my second post disagreed with Par. I'm sure Zig would be very surprised to learn that he was attacking Republicans by criticizing SOPA too.

Lots of people say some pretty stupid thing to attack Republicans in life and on this board, but you're taking that truth to persecution complex like levels.
 
It wasn't a "move". It was an offhand comment from someone not employed by either Obama or the DNC.

Sort of. She works for a PR firm that is/was employed by various Democratic groups and possibly for the Obama Campaign as well.
 
In the field of "two wrongs make for good entertainment":

Women who are happy raising families don’t have much “cred” with Rosen or, for that matter, President Obama, because Rosen and Obama resonate only with those who carry the flag of the disenfranchised and abused. Anyone who thrives in an American company or American home, while proud and happy with any element of traditional American values, must be a hopeless automaton or relic of the oppressive past.

Hilary Rosen vilifying women who choose to be stay-at-home wives and mothers is particularly ironic, given that she has chosen an alternative lifestyle raising twins with a female partner, meaning no father-figure is present in her home. To enjoy the benefits of her alternative lifestyle while denigrating the lifestyle of Ann Romney shows that her seemingly infinite bandwidth for alternative lifestyles flows in one direction: only alternative.

Linky.
 
You're the one who called it 'victimology', but if it means what I think it means, it fits. The entire first page is not one big attack on Republicans. My first post wasn't, although it did contain a criticism of Romney for dodging questions by using his wife to try to change the topic and my second post disagreed with Par. I'm sure Zig would be very surprised to learn that he was attacking Republicans by criticizing SOPA too.

Lots of people say some pretty stupid thing to attack Republicans in life and on this board, but you're taking that truth to persecution complex like levels.

Out of curiosity I read the entire first page again (I have 50 posts per page) and I saw one attack on republicans from lefty, the most you could say beyond that was a certain disrespect for wealthy people, but that sort of attitude seems rather apolitical.
 
Since you've decided to be pedantic, that tweet doesn't actually condone anything. It merely mentions two items for the readers to consider and possibly compare. But the value judgment you place on any comparison you make is entirely your own. Furthermore, nothing in the tweet indicates that anyone should steal, or get away with stealing. All the tweet does is mention one particular response (out of many) towards stealing. Your own response suggests that you have concluded most readers will think that the response is a poor one. But you have established a false dichotomy. The choice of response isn't between doing nothing and throwing kids in jail. Many other options are available. But since you apparently aren't willing to defend what Rosen actually did, setting up this false dichotomy and attacking the only other alternative you present is the best you can do in terms of a defense of Rosen. And that's just not persuasive.

Of course there are options in between because "throwing kids in prison" for downloading Justin Beiber songs is a strawman.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom