Dems push back on Hilary Rosen's comments about Momney

I'm not defending Romney. I'm defending rational argument. If Hilary Rosen was taken out of context, show the context. You don't respond to that by taking someone else out of context and then, when that's pointed out, demand that they disprove the lack of context!

Are there any actual skeptics in the politics forums?

I remember showing the context earlier in the thread, and after that it was stated by others again.

You know, there was a time back before they had kids. What was her job then?
 
I remember showing the context earlier in the thread, and after that it was stated by others again.
And you'll notice I didn't take issue with it. You went and found evidence for your position and posted it. i don't have counterevidence so I didn't rebut it.

You know, there was a time back before they had kids. What was her job then?
Really? Are you thinking I'm defending Hilary Rosen? I'm not. I'm not defending the Romneys or Rosen. Just the style of argument around here. Why do people find this so hard to understand... in a skeptic's forum?
 
That's a pretty deliberate misreading. What isn't dignified, according to that argument, is living off the government dole. You may disagree about the dignity of such welfare dependency, but that's what he's claiming. And it's not a new argument either, which is why I have a hard time believing your misreading was accidental. Conservatives have been arguing that government dependency takes away dignity for decades.

So then you are saying that it is dignified to stay at home to raise the kids if the husband provides support, but single moms cannot have that luxury, they need to get to work and give their kids second rate providence.

Just to be clear, I don't think staying at home is any better than both parents in a relationship working, or a single mom working. It seems to be the case though in the covering of this story.
 
And you'll notice I didn't take issue with it. You went and found evidence for your position and posted it. i don't have counterevidence so I didn't rebut it.

Just establishing that there was evidence that others were standing on, they weren't just taking things out of context all willy nilly.

Really? Are you thinking I'm defending Hilary Rosen? I'm not. I'm not defending the Romneys or Rosen. Just the style of argument around here. Why do people find this so hard to understand... in a skeptic's forum?

The first part was directed at you. Sorry, the second one was an afterthought to the thread that I should have placed elsewhere.
 
Pro Rosen here. Don't care about the politics on either side on this issue. What I do care about is this pandering by both sides to mothers it needs to stop. There has been what 5 or so billion human mothers plus the countless other mammal mothers in history most of whom do a good enough job. SAHM are for the most part the worst. I am friends with one of the few honest ones (2 sons ages 4 and 1) and she does not pretend that its some tough gig with her daily naps all the while both of her kids pretty smart for their ages.
 
For some reason, "work" seemed to refer to being employed or mashing money in the context. I don't think anyone accused Anne of being lazy, just privileged.
 
In context of that quote? Yes! He was talking about getting people daycare so they can get off the dole.

If you put your kids in day care center so that you can (perhaps) work in a day care center, aren't you defeating the purpose of various conservative values? Isn't that kind of socialistic (in loose terms) and apt to increase the size of government? How does this jibe with conservative movements to home-school kids?

This may not be a popular view but managing a household with 5 kids and a high-flying husband is work, even with domestic help. It takes managerial skill. "She's never had to work for a paycheck" might be accurate, as might be any number of statements that would make the same point about her privileged status and inexperience with the economic struggles of the working class. But to state she's never worked a day in her life is idiotic, a slap in the face to anyone whose primary economic contribution has been on the home front.
 
But to state she's never worked a day in her life is idiotic, a slap in the face to anyone whose primary economic contribution has been on the home front.
As I stated earlier, that single quote w/o context is as bad as Romney's "I like to fire people". However, each need to be evaluated in context.
 
I am friends with one of the few honest ones (2 sons ages 4 and 1) and she does not pretend that its some tough gig with her daily naps all the while both of her kids pretty smart for their ages.

Hmm. I wonder about the motives here but I'll bite this time. Do you have evidence that most stay-at-home moms are dishonest? If not I will assume this statement was intended to provoke indignant responses. I know what it's like to need attention.

You must be new here. :D

It's true that opinion on the JREF politics forum leans leftward. I for one welcome common-sense conservative arguments. The problem is, there are few being made. That doesn't mean there aren't any, just that some posters make declarations based on theory but fail to support them with evidence. It's frustrating, because I'm fairly conservative in some areas and would like to hear cogent arguments from that camp on a number of issues.
 
I'm confused about what "push back" means. I read the paragraph quoted in the OP and if it's being used correctly there I've learned something.

I didn't think it was a synonym for "moved to denounce" or "backed away from" a position held by a member of their own camp. "Push back" sounds like something you'd do when the other side shoved you. Does it have some longstanding connotation of damage control, or softening of partisan statements, that everyone knows but me?
 
Here's one answer to the 'push back'.

http://townhall.com/columnists/starparker/2012/04/23/obamas_real_hilary_rosen_problem

“…a nothing story” and predicted that it would have no effect on how women vote in this election.

But no one can accuse the Obama political machine of being dumb. Quite the opposite. So, again, how to explain the high level PR damage control barrage to clean up the perceived mess made by Rosen?

Here’s the real problem that I believe they saw.

The issue was not so much what Hilary Rosen said, but who said it. More than Rosen’s words, her persona itself is an assault on working class, traditional thinking Americans of both sexes.

Rosen, who works closely with the White House, is a high dollar lesbian “inside-the-beltway” Washington power broker. She and her now estranged partner, the former director the Human Rights Campaign – an organization championing rights of lesbians, gays, bisexuals, and transgenders – adopted two black children in 1999.

Her current lesbian partner is president of the American Federation of Teachers – the nation’s second largest teachers’ union.

At a time when it is critical for Obama to gain support and confidence of the same middle of the road white working class Americans who swung over to him in 2008, the last thing he needs is to have Hilary Rosen become a poster child for his party.
Not that anyone here would care ... other than to applaud a fellow-traveler.
 
Here's one answer to the 'push back'.

http://townhall.com/columnists/starparker/2012/04/23/obamas_real_hilary_rosen_problem


Not that anyone here would care ... other than to applaud a fellow-traveler.

I was reading your quote and I was going to ask what Rosen being a lesbian had to do with anything,
Rosen, who works closely with the White House, is a high dollar lesbian
then I came across this part,
adopted two black children
and I thought what the hell does the race of her children have to do with anything? And then I saw it was from Townhall. Townhall is just doing what any organization does, pandering to their customers. In this case they are doing it with some good old fashion homophobia and race baiting.

This is the cancer that will finally do the republican party in. If they keep being associated with this kind of trash, their days are numbered. This demographic is dwindling.

I really wonder how someone could write the linked column, and what person would think these views are worth repeating.

Daredelvis
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom