Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

Indeed, although once again I have been accused of malicious intent I felt that the universality of Conservation of Energy could be broadened out by introducing thermodynamic energy to show energy flow. As energy is a universal concept in all branches of engineering and science I didn't feel that it was a major leap or even an obfuscation. Maybe, I was wrong.

I now understand what you meant by momentum, thanks for the clarification.

I get the impression that it is not being comprehended that all of these theoretical situations can be analysed purely in terms of Conservation of Energy without using forces. Forces have uses but they are not essential unless you want to know the dynamics.

I still contend that whatever euphemism you use gradient or vertical there is an instinctively directional or vectorial nature to energy.

It was interesting to see how much underlying principle was understood on the forum though.

Oh you scientist you. Listen to all those big words!
Isn't JREF cool, learning stuff!
 
It's kind of late here now so time to leave but tomorrow night I will tackle my third debunking following on from the success of the previous two in this thread.
wha-! dijyoojes-! aryoo-! *sputter* *ack*

RANT! You've been demonstrably wrong this whole thread. Despite claiming to be one who can admit when he's wrong, you have made no such admission in this thread FULL of wrong. And you have the gall to call your two shining examples of intellectual dishonesty "successes"?!? I'll not be so patient with you in the future as I have been thus far.
 
No one said you NEED to be a Civil Engineer to understand this topic, but you CLAIMED to be a Civil Engineer, and it strains credibility that an engineer would NOT understand this topic.

To be fair on William, that was a pretty clever pun...I had to chuckle at it.
 
To be fair to killtown (woah! I need to take a shower, now), I think he was saying "Huh ? A link to a "normal" video ? Why, that's not possible." Of course. That's still a stupid thing to post, but it's not the same level of stupid, assuming I'm correct.

I would suggest that you're probably reading more into the context than is necessary.

Killtown's quote was unaccompanied by any non-verbal cue (an emoticon, for example) to suggest he was either joking or ridiculing WWGHA's post. On top of that, WWGHA had never suggested that Killtown try downloading said file from the net - the topic of linking to a "normal" video (a word which WWGHA also put inside quotation marks, IIRC) was raised by Killtown, in an interrogative statement that had no defining traits with which to recognise it as intentional sarcasm or irony.

On top of this, the posts following Killtown's nominated post give even more context - WWGHA actually picks up on what Killtown has said and questions as to how he could possibly post a link to a non-internet video (which is what he had previously defined a "normal" video as being). Killtown's response was not to explain his statement further, but to ignore this comment and simply decry that the videos are all faked anyway.

This quick changing of topic away from a mistake that has been pointed out is known behaviour for Killtown to engage in when someone has pointed out a very silly or obvious mistake he has made. What Killtown is not well known for is letting people who deliberately or unintentionally misinterpret his words get away unscathed.

In other words, the most likely interpretation of this for a person who is NOT known to the person doing the analysis is that they said something very silly by asking for a link to an internet video. That we know that this is likely behaviour for the participant in question simply strengthens this interpretation - it is not, however the basis for it.

Mobyseven
 
I guess I owe that William Rea an apology for being linked to my crazy posting.

William Rea = Bill Rea = liBeRal

Hehe...clever. You like word games and such?

I've recently been taking a look at the 'puzzles' section of this forum. I get the feeling you'd enjoy it too...
 
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2496528&postcount=79

William, you appear to have completely ignored my analysis here. Admittedly, this could be because I pointed out your complete intellectual dishonestly and requested an apology, but I suppose it is possible you just missed it on your way through.

I would like you to address this, and if you cannot, I would appreciate an apology both for the fact you deliberately tried to lie about the context of the quote and a retraction of your accusation that this is an ad hominem.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

I would then like you to answer this question:

Is gravitational potential energy a vector?

All this requires is a yes / no answer.

If your answer is yes, then you will have to explain to us all how energy can be a vector, and how you came to this discovery that will overturn most of what we know about Newtonian physics.

If your answer is no, then I would appreciate a retraction of your accusation that, "...gravitational energy, which is vertical..." is an ad hominem attack.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Then, as you claimed to have found, "...at least two..." ad hominem attacks in the March Stundie Finalists, I would appreciate it if you could please continue to point out ad hominem attacks that are present there.

I imagine that I am not the only one who would like to see these things addressed, but I thought I'd break it down into sections for you for ease of reference.

Peace Out

Mobyseven
 
I'm sorry that you felt compelled to join the detractors instead of engaging with me. I only asked you to address your comments to figure 2 and you berated me for lying about it in a baseless manner.


I did "engage" you, and you responded by misrepresenting the source you claimed supported your assertions, and then implied that I was manufacturing and/or misinterpreting the quotes I cited. The fact that you chose to cloak your insinuations in superficially polite language does not change what you did. In fact, in my opinion, that makes it worse.

And I wasn't "compelled" to join your detractors. They made good points, which I agreed with, and which confirmed my own impressions of you. And to call the accuations of you being a liar "baseless" shows you either to still be lying, or to being willfully blind to the several analyses of your claims that clearly demonstrated your lies.


Your post was extremely aggressive and with repect, I found very little honorable intent on your side in it. Since you find me so disagreeable I suggest we do not exchange any further posts.


Of coure a liar finds very little honour in others who point out his lies. That's just par for the course. Yet another example of you trying to cloak a disgusting attitude with superficial politeness. Rather than simpering about "aggressive" attitudes, why not try admitting your lies, and asking forgiveness? Why not try addressing the aforementioned analyses of your lies, and demonstrating how they might not be lies?

Why not? Because you know we're right.

And we may not "exchange" posts, but I'll be around to point out any other lies of yours I see. Because, with all due respect to Douglas Adams, when you get right down to it, the one thing I really can't stand is a liar.
 
Then, as you claimed to have found, "...at least two..." ad hominem attacks in the March Stundie Finalists, I would appreciate it if you could please continue to point out ad hominem attacks that are present there.

This is, I think, the thing I find most bizarre about this thread, notwithstanding William's attempts to defend the indefensible position that energy has a vectoral quality; the completely inappropriate use of the term ad hominem. The definition of argumentum ad hominem is an attempt to discredit someone's arguments by reference to some unrelated quality of the person making them. In the case of the Griffin quote I nominated, I made no comment whatsoever about Griffin himself, and none of the discussion since has commented on anything about Griffin that is not directly related to the five words under discussion - how could any of this be further from an argumentum ad hominem?

The nearest thing to an ad hominem in this thread, in fact, was William's initial statement of his reluctance to defend the position taken by a theologian; Griffin being a theologian is irrelevant to whether or not his statements about physics are fallacious. Although appended to an expression of support, that initial statement had much in common with an ad hominem attack on Griffin - more, in any case, than energy has in common with a vector.

Dave
 
It's kind of late here now so time to leave but tomorrow night I will tackle my third debunking following on from the success of the previous two in this thread.

What in the world are you talking about?

The only thing propping up your first "debunking" was a bald-faced lie (that you "copied" the context from the LCF). The only thing supporting your second "debunking" was a misunderstanding of basic physics that you defended to the hilt, though you were clearly mistaken.
 
Interesting, can I just clarify that the sphere is a closed system and has spontaneously shattered with no energy or work entering the system boundaries? Can the sphere also be considered to be neutral in terms of internal stresses and any pressure differences between the inside volume and outside?

Sorry, missed that post for a while. (1) isn't relevant, I'm talking about the GPE of the static system; it's not physically realistic but you can assume some mechanism that involves negligible energy if it helps. (2), yes.

Dave
 
This is, I think, the thing I find most bizarre about this thread, notwithstanding William's attempts to defend the indefensible position that energy has a vectoral quality; the completely inappropriate use of the term ad hominem. The definition of argumentum ad hominem is an attempt to discredit someone's arguments by reference to some unrelated quality of the person making them. In the case of the Griffin quote I nominated, I made no comment whatsoever about Griffin himself, and none of the discussion since has commented on anything about Griffin that is not directly related to the five words under discussion - how could any of this be further from an argumentum ad hominem?

The nearest thing to an ad hominem in this thread, in fact, was William's initial statement of his reluctance to defend the position taken by a theologian; Griffin being a theologian is irrelevant to whether or not his statements about physics are fallacious. Although appended to an expression of support, that initial statement had much in common with an ad hominem attack on Griffin - more, in any case, than energy has in common with a vector.

Dave

Dammit!!! Why did you have to give away my surprise ending??? :mad:

I'm not kidding about this actually...I've been waiting for William to make another claim just so I could spring this one on him.

See, I figured the discussions re his first two claims had been so well examined and shown to be bunk that bringing this up would just continue discussion on topics that had really reached the end of the line (I've summarised what I, and most people are expecting from you in regards to the first two accusations in a post just above this, William).

Waiting for him to bring up a new accusation, my first question was simply going to be: "And how is that an ad hominem?"

I probably should have done that right when this all started, but I so quickly got involved in debating the original grounds for inclusion in the finals that by the time he started this new thread I didn't want to have the appearance of ignoring his arguments by presenting this issue.

I suppose I can still ask that question when he has a third attempt, but it's lost its surprise value now. Dangit!

... :mad:
 
It's kind of late here now so time to leave but tomorrow night I will tackle my third debunking following on from the success of the previous two in this thread.

As this was post #160 in this thread, I thought it would be an appropriate point to take the measure of this success. Categorising these 160 posts, we have:

47 posts by William Rea.
1 post supporting a specific debunking.
8 posts either neutral, or supportive of the concept of the thread without comments on specific content.
104 posts opposing William Rea's arguments, including 24 specifically accusing him of lying, demanding an apology for lying or stating that his credibility is permanently damaged in the poster's opinion.

I also categorised attitudes of 26 posters in the first 160 posts:

1 poster is William Rea himself.
1 poster was supportive of a debunk.
4 posters were generally neutral in tone.
20 posters opposed William Rea's arguments.

I haven't done any cool looking pie charts, but based on the raw numbers it seems a little unclear to me what would constitute failure.

Dave
 
Dammit!!! Why did you have to give away my surprise ending??? :mad:

Sorry, I should have posted a spoiler warning.:o

Waiting for him to bring up a new accusation, my first question was simply going to be: "And how is that an ad hominem?"

I think he's already got his answer ready, though. Check post 72 in this thread.

I will not withdraw the ad hominem accusation because to my satisfaction it is proven so you are correct that it is open and shut.

In other words, an ad hominem is anything William Rea thinks is an ad hominem.

Dave
 
As this was post #160 in this thread, I thought it would be an appropriate point to take the measure of this success. Categorising these 160 posts, we have:

47 posts by William Rea.
1 post supporting a specific debunking.
8 posts either neutral, or supportive of the concept of the thread without comments on specific content.
104 posts opposing William Rea's arguments, including 24 specifically accusing him of lying, demanding an apology for lying or stating that his credibility is permanently damaged in the poster's opinion.

I also categorised attitudes of 26 posters in the first 160 posts:

1 poster is William Rea himself.
1 poster was supportive of a debunk.
4 posters were generally neutral in tone.
20 posters opposed William Rea's arguments.

I haven't done any cool looking pie charts, but based on the raw numbers it seems a little unclear to me what would constitute failure.

Dave

It would, however, be wrong to categorise William as wrong or a liar simply because the majority of people here think so. That right there is an appeal to popularity.

William is wrong and a liar, and this has been shown in the content of the posts. The number of posts is only so great because he has yet to admit to these things.
 
Sorry, I should have posted a spoiler warning.:o

Ah, who I am kidding. You're too informative for me to stay anggry at you for too long...

I think he's already got his answer ready, though. Check post 72 in this thread.

...​

In other words, an ad hominem is anything William Rea thinks is an ad hominem.

I sure hope he has a better argument than that in store. Otherwise he is going to be ripped to shreds. Well, his argument will be anyway.
 
I haven't done any cool looking pie charts, but based on the raw numbers it seems a little unclear to me what would constitute failure.

Dave


Every now and then, someone comes up with a line that just summarizes everything perfectly!


:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom