Debunk-liners

So you are saying that pretty much the world body of structural engineers have no common sense. ?

I agree they must have more common sense than me, obviously...
they 'keep their heads down', they don't start talking about controversial stuff like CD at 9/11. No percentage in that, eh? :)
 
I agree they must have more common sense than me, obviously...
they 'keep their heads down', they don't start talking about controversial stuff like CD at 9/11. No percentage in that, eh? :)

Question beg fallacy. Further:

NIST said:
While NIST has found no evidence of a blast or controlled demolition event, NIST would like to determine the magnitude of hypothetical blast scenarios that could have led to the structural failure of one or more critical elements.
 
Yes but, it no good just saying "it's untrue" - you OT JREFers always demand evidence from "truthers" don't you?

It certainly is in these circumstances. You are claiming, by way of your faulty argument, that every building that has ever fallen down that any reasonable person knows of just happens to be a controlled demolition. This is patently false on its face.

Look, it's not my fault that you keep making arguments from faulty logic, and it's not my fault that you keep changing your faulty arguments; I am simply demonstrating how and why your faulty arguments are faulty.

Now, read my post again - for comprehension this time - and, on the other point about the "low probability" read the post that I linked you to. For ease of reference, here is the post and the link:

No, it is not okay.

Because it is untrue in these circumstances to say "all examples of P that any reasonable person know of just happen to be Q".

Thus your poor attempt to construct a logical argument is based upon a faulty premise from the beginning. Therefore, it fails.

And on the point about "the low probability" and the fact that NIST never said that, I really wanted you to read the entire post that I linked to, not to simply take that one line out of it. You really should read it, as R. Mackey did a great job of explaining it. It isn't that long and it won't take you too long to read it, so please do. Once again, you can find it here.
 
I agree they must have more common sense than me, obviously...
they 'keep their heads down', they don't start talking about controversial stuff like CD at 9/11. No percentage in that, eh? :)

Not only do they have more common sense, they also have extensive education and experience in the relavent fields.

No percentage in inventing childish fantasy scenarios involving subjects of which you are totally ignorant? I agree.
 
When Mackey says: "If one really wants to understand, I suggest one go to the Source."

That if I go to my local electronics store, formally known as Radio Shack, I will understand?
 
Hey, it's OK... I don't pretend to have any special knowledge about fire.
Don't get upset.
( and before you mention it - no, I'm not implicating any firefighters in anything at all, ok? )

Sorry to go off on you, but you shouldn't make assumptions especially since you say "I don't pretend to have any special knowledge about fire". I have heard a lot of BS when it comes to fire. Like the guy at Ground Zero saying he could determine the heat the fire just from a picture.


Okay, you said the heat was localized. Heat is never localized and it can be transfered in 4 forms.

Method of Heat Transfer.

Direct Flame Contact, which is self explanatory fire touching an object.

Convection, which is when heat is transfered through air or liquid.

Conduction, heat transfered through one body to another by direct contact or by a medium, such as lets just say a piece of steel.

Radiation, the transfer of heat through waves (number one cause of any exposure fire...oh for those who don't know an exposure is a building, floor, or area that is close to the fire and is in danger of catching fire as well)
Quoted from my thread on Fire Behavior listed in my signature.

Not only that, the pure energy of the office contents being burned off can cause serious heat.

Approximate Power Usage/Peak Heat Release Rate

Burning cigarette: 5W

Standard “A” Light Bulbs: 15 to 200 W

Burning match: 80 W

Coffee maker, hair dryer, toaster: 500 to 1500 W or 0.5 to 1.5 kW

Burning Coffee Maker: 40 kW

Small Trash Can, Trash Bag Fires: 50 to 300 kW

Burning Upholstered Chair: 80 kW to 2.5 MW

Burning Upholstered Sofa: 3,000 kW or 3 MW

Burning Christmas Tree: 1.6 MW to 5.2 MW

Base Design Fire: 5.3 MW
Taken from my Thread between "Smoldering Fires vs Diffusion Flames" This was also sourced from James G Quintiere's "Principles of Fire Behavior"


So even IF a truss member has suffered minimum dislodging of fire proofing, it is more than likely that truss will fail from exposure from fire.

Under real world conditions, fire proofing has been proven to be unreliable. The fire department has adopted Murphy's Law "Anything that can go wrong will go wrong." That is the truth.


And I was never going to implicate that you said the firefighters had anything to do with it.
 
Yes but, it no good just saying "it's untrue" - you OT JREFers always demand evidence from "truthers" don't you?


We understand that evidence has little meaning to you, Terry, but if we depended on your elevation of "common sense" to being a substitute for thinking and evidence, we wouldn't need law, courts, juries, or even a democratic society. Whim would do just fine.

Fortunately, the majority of us still believe in critical thinking. We are skeptics of claims made by anyone, including you. We ask questions.

In just the several comments you have made in this one thread alone you have made a series of assertions without any supporting evidence. Like your claim that a fire in WTC 7 would have to weaken a whole series of structural supports fairly evenly in order for WTC 7 to collapse and to collapse symmetrically.

Is this assertion made from your "common sense" or did you bother to look for evidence which you refuse to reveal to us given your aversion to evidence?

Sorry if this offends your sensibilities and belief that you shouldn't have to answer questions as a 9/11 Truther, but if you don't want to answer inconvenient questions then it would be best for you not to venture into the real world.

Any questions?
 
It certainly is in these circumstances. You are claiming, by way of your faulty argument, that every building that has ever fallen down that any reasonable person knows of just happens to be a controlled demolition. This is patently false on its face.

Look, it's not my fault that you keep making arguments from faulty logic, and it's not my fault that you keep changing your faulty arguments; I am simply demonstrating how and why your faulty arguments are faulty.

Now, read my post again - for comprehension this time - and, on the other point about the "low probability" read the post that I linked you to. For ease of reference, here is the post and the link:

Look, I don't personally know much about CD, and I don't pretend to be a structural engineer.

I do believe that WTC7 looked like a CD and I don't believe anyone has - so far - shown any other building of [similar constuction type] collapsing like #7 did , unless it was by means of CD.
Also, the Dutch CD expert that people here have quoted is adamant that it was CD...
WTC7 is the main 'sticking point' for me in the whole 9/11 thing
 
When Mackey says: "If one really wants to understand, I suggest one go to the Source."

That if I go to my local electronics store, formally known as Radio Shack, I will understand?

Poeple do tend to make assumptions about someone else's knowledge and abilities. It's foolish
 
You don't know what you don't know, TerryUK

Look, I don't personally know much about CD, and I don't pretend to be a structural engineer.

So, do you want to learn something or continue to make unfounded assertions?

I do believe that WTC7 looked like a CD and I don't believe anyone has - so far - shown any other building of [similar constuction type] collapsing like #7 did , unless it was by means of CD.
No one has to provide evidence except YOU!. We see no evidence for CD. CD's rely on gravity. WTC 7 fell because of gravity. If you have evidence for CD that initiated the collapse from gravity, by all means, don't keep us in suspense - provide it!

Also, the Dutch CD expert that people here have quoted is adamant that it was CD...WTC7 is the main 'sticking point' for me in the whole 9/11 thing
Many MORE dispute CD. Now.... where's you evidence for CD, TerryUK... or will you revert to claiming it's just "common sense"?
 
Last edited:
We understand that evidence has little meaning to you, Terry, but if we depended on your elevation of "common sense" to being a substitute for thinking and evidence, we wouldn't need law, courts, juries, or even a democratic society. Whim would do just fine.

Fortunately, the majority of us still believe in critical thinking. We are skeptics of claims made by anyone, including you. We ask questions.

In just the several comments you have made in this one thread alone you have made a series of assertions without any supporting evidence. Like your claim that a fire in WTC 7 would have to weaken a whole series of structural supports fairly evenly in order for WTC 7 to collapse and to collapse symmetrically.

Is this assertion made from your "common sense" or did you bother to look for evidence which you refuse to reveal to us given your aversion to evidence?

Sorry if this offends your sensibilities and belief that you shouldn't have to answer questions as a 9/11 Truther, but if you don't want to answer inconvenient questions then it would be best for you not to venture into the real world.

Any questions?

No questions.

I think I can stand by anything I've written here - I don't think I have to read it back.

It might be you are reading something else into what I actually said.
If you disagree with anything, just point it out.
If I'm wrong, I'll accept that
 
Look, I don't personally know much about CD, and I don't pretend to be a structural engineer.

I do believe that WTC7 looked like a CD and I don't believe anyone has - so far - shown any other building of [similar constuction type] collapsing like #7 did , unless it was by means of CD.
You can't be serious.


Also, the Dutch CD expert that people here have quoted is adamant that it was CD...
WTC7 is the main 'sticking point' for me in the whole 9/11 thing
That same Dutch CD expert (whose entire analysis is based on a single viewing of a video that failed to show the damaged side of WTC7, by the way) also maintains that WTC1 and WTC2 were not brought down by CD. Kind of puts a big hole in the CT, doesn't it?
 
I'll give it a shot though I don't subscribe to much of this strawman NWO crap.

- If they could fake the planes in live TV feeds with almost no delay, why haven't they been able to fake a plane into Pentagon footage in 6 years?

I'm not much for the no plane theories I just don't know without the transponder code except for process of elimination how did they ID the planes that hit the towers? Plus the only multiple footage they would need to have is the 2nd WTC hit. There wouldn’t be any need for a bunch of cameras catching the first hit of anything.

- If there were no planes, why haven't we seen a single TV or amateur video, or heard an eyewitness testimony of a tower suddenly exploding without any plane approaching?

On google video I think the guys name is bregistration has two videos from the same camera or same angle but different stations at the same time with one showing the plane and the other just showing something you can barely see come in and make the second WTC hit. I don't necessarily know that fake video means no plane. Couldn't it just mean some news stations embellished the shot they had just to have an exclusive video?

- How did the NWO know beforehand, that the north tower would collapse into WTC7, so the debris could be blamed for the damage and starting fires?

How about WTC7 wasn't part of the original plan but once it was damaged it was an unsecured building that house agencies like the Secret Service thus a security breach and had to be destroyed? Or maybe it was suppose to be hit by the third plane flying around the city that the emergency responders were warned about but never came in. How about everything didn’t go exactly as planned?

- If the Pentagon FDR data is faked, why did they fake it to show a fly-over and not a hit?

I don't know what the official line is on the FDR.

- If fire does nothing to steel, why do they fireproof steel?

So fire doesn't spread or compromise the steel as fast. Some fires go for hour’s even whole days. The trade centers fell in about an hour.

- If NWO kills enemies and takes away freedom of speech, why are the truthers allowed to exist, publish books, movies and arrange events?

They can't kill everyone besides they have the Government Counter-Misinformation Team to combat that stuff.
 
I agree they must have more common sense than me, obviously...
they 'keep their heads down', they don't start talking about controversial stuff like CD at 9/11. No percentage in that, eh? :)

What is your evidence to back up that claim?
 
It fell symetrically, i.e. no separating or shearing vertically - you know like when a building falls due to some non-CD structural failure, you'll see the facade break unevenly. This WTC7 collapse was very symetric.
It means that all the supports failed ~ simultaneously
...

this can be solved very easily -just provide us a video of a building collapsing - not as a result of CD- and we can compare the massive differences.
 
Look, I don't personally know much about CD, and I don't pretend to be a structural engineer.

I do believe that WTC7 looked like a CD and I don't believe anyone has - so far - shown any other building of [similar constuction type] collapsing like #7 did , unless it was by means of CD.
Also, the Dutch CD expert that people here have quoted is adamant that it was CD...
WTC7 is the main 'sticking point' for me in the whole 9/11 thing

Show us a building of that design that has collapsed and doesn't look like a CD.

It's like you're saying you have proof of a zerba because you hear the sound of hooves. Congratulations, you have seen the result of gravity. The CD is not the building falling, that's simply gravity. A CD is simply taking out key supports and letting gravity bring the building down. You have not seen the cause of gravity bringing the building down and are making invalid assumptions as to the cause simply by looking at the result.
 
So fire doesn't spread or compromise the steel as fast. Some fires go for hour’s even whole days. The trade centers fell in about an hour.

How many of those buildings were tubed design or struck by an aircraft?
 
-why did Larry Silverstien (who was in on it) agree to LOSE millions of dollars in the whole destroying and then rebuilding the WTC complex

Is Silverstein now indebt?

- why didnt they just blame it on Saddam

Did they need to? They probably didn't have a stockpile of Iraqi patsies either.

- why do they all keep getting fired or resigning?

Or promoted to the World bank or given a medal.

- not create WMD in Iraq (why subject themselves to that blunder?)

They tried but they screwed it up. http://100777.com/node/433

- why are people all not on trial with the "evidence" they have?

When does UBL's trial start and with what evidence?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom