No, it is not okay.
Because it is untrue in these circumstances to say "all examples of P that any reasonable person know of just happen to be Q".
Thus your poor attempt to construct a logical argument is based upon a faulty premise from the beginning. Therefore, it fails.
And on the point about "the low probability" and the fact that NIST never said that, I really wanted you to read the entire post that I linked to, not to simply take that one line out of it. You really should read it, as R. Mackey did a great job of explaining it. It isn't that long and it won't take you too long to read it, so please do. Once again,
you can find it here.